Plaidoyer Pour une Turquie Européenne, LE SOIR, 13.02.08 1

Plaidoyer Pour une Turquie Européenne, LE SOIR, 13.02.08 1

Plaidoyer Pour une Turquie Européenne, LE SOIR, 13.02.08
!
"
#
#
$
%
#
&
#
#
"
'
$
$
(
)
*
+
6
7
?
8
D
:
7
]
J
7
P
=
B
:
E
N
<
B
F
C
7
F
w
C
7
:
:
7
>
:
8
7
<
=
@
:
D
=
7
D
y
?
<
D
D
I
v
X
G
D
I
8
C
;
?
<
D
P
<
G
E
B
A
:
B
D
C
E
B
E
F
G
E
;
9
=
D
=
7
<
?
G
8
8
E
8
E
@
X
X
E
D
D
<
7
F
8
:
@
<
<
<
>
8
B
G
B
D
E
=
>
=
<
<
@
=
@
G
=
8
<
@
7
B
<
;
E
G
<
C
<
M
B
B
8
E
<
<
A
?
B
r
D
@
=
y
@
8
<
G
=
E
@
<
=
<
B
F
:
B
Y
Z
<
[
8
<
?
8
<
:
:
=
7
<
=
=
B
=
9
<
=
G
H
A
B
<
ƒ
8
E
B
x
B
7
G
=
F
U
:
<
@
8
B
;
G
:
R
~
O
A
X
D
>
E
G
E
>
<
R
D
D
@
:
E
G
7
;
@
:
=
B
=
G
?
:
<
D
:
B
E
B
9
?
7
F
B
D
Q
9
E
=
:
<
O
<
C
D
G
8
<
A
<
<
;
7
<
8
@
I
=
<
<
B
:
@
:
E
<
R
=
@
@
@
E
?
9
I
O
;
<
C
D
<
>
E
<
E
<
|
:
<
G
F
=
F
A
>
<
@
u
@
r
<
I
F
@
@
E
X
<
F
O
v
E
7
7
E
@
R
<
:
D
G
:
G
<
D
F
B
<
v
:
7
;
7
<
G
=
t
8
7
<
E
B
@
F
8
r
=
I
7
<
E
=
G
8
G
G
@
s
@
=
=
:
<
;
;
G
<
B
@
y
r
S
7
=
:
M
B
E
@
:
D
@
?
E
I
@
=
<
B
E
7
<
D
<
G
A
G
;
D
G
E
;
:
I
=
8
O
>
r
=
<
F
V
E
<
I
7
B
7
=
<
C
U
7
8
<
<
E
G
?
:
M
7
:
?
:
<
C
G
C
N
9
8
M
q
M
<
:
7
F
>
8
G
7
E
L
B
I
<
<
I
B
@
E
F
<
8
@
@
A
G
8
p
7
<
M
D
@
9
F
=
G
B
L
=
;
E
=
8
7
G
@
A
<
<
@
U
:
D
:
8
<
:
G
<
{
B
E
:
C
9
G
<
<
E
@
B
G
7
L
I
P
O
<
<
=
F
=
I
B
=
B
E
9
@
7
>
D
?
7
8
E
M
M
7
D
@
<
:
G
=
=
}
G
@
8
;
^
=
N
8
O
`
<
B
<
F
E
I
8
U
h
@
<
B
E
<
=
=
7
<
M
@
:
o
>
:
B
<
I
=
B
7
a
<
<
E
@
n
<
@
r
D
U
<
=
B
?
A
;
<
=
@
=
E
D
T
D
<
7
7
B
@
v
B
r
:
8
<
F
u
E
8
A
<
m
?
H
<
>
F
O
G
F
F
E
G
G
>
:
<
l
:
=
O
=
B
F
@
>
7
M
G
?
[
@
8
H
<
Z
=
E
x
=
G
:
G
@
:
a
G
D
E
@
j
<
G
7
E
<
@
<
D
G
>
I
a
X
7
<
7
E
9
E
C
:
I
X
X
K
I
<
]
;
R
B
8
:
=
:
E
G
>
<
7
<
:
<
>
=
<
7
7
B
_
9
7
|
B
=
O
9
O
8
@
>
E
v
B
=
G
>
E
<
G
@
=
:
7
<
G
:
„
E
G
B
G
A
8
G
=
8
7
9
E
m
<
7
E
B
>
@
r
G
<
=
C
M
=
:
F
@
<
7
>
8
8
E
I
G
:
G
;
<
@
E
@
D
<
:
G
G
A
D
=
7
G
>
8
u
=
=
<
<
>
:
E
G
8
M
G
7
7
E
=
:
>
8
X
7
<
M
@
8
G
B
9
=
=
7
<
D
E
;
F
G
M
F
X
?
@
C
<
<
G
<
E
?
I
X
:
<
@
<
<
;
B
‡
I
8
<
R
E
B
B
C
8
<
=
A
F
:
:
G
:
G
M
<
G
X
O
@
=
7
B
>
G
=
=
7
@
=
=
F
:
;
<
<
9
<
:
?
:
D
C
?
;
H
;
F
B
@
@
9
E
E
?
L
D
=
7
E
E
<
:
;
?
<
7
F
G
<
B
?
@
>
F
F
@
<
7
:
=
<
8
:
D
M
8
8
7
?
<
:
>
<
I
>
G
=
7
y
?
I
F
B
I
=
;
7
G
<
V
<
:
=
<
M
U
F
>
:
B
<
E
u
G
:
7
G
7
<
r
C
M
:
B
=
F
:
B
?
B
<
<
7
7
:
=
?
F
E
…
E
@
;
B
†
<
<
=
@
E
;
<
G
=
<
D
G
B
E
<
:
@
<
=
B
A
D
|
B
=
:
E
D
G
F
<
B
„
@
<
G
P
E
=
D
B
G
I
@
?
A
?
7
:
<
<
8
B
@
8
>
F
ƒ
…
<
H
U
?
E
=
@
<
<
D
<
E
<
B
@
L
U
8
7
8
B
@
=
D
G
7
E
8
<
7
8
7
G
E
7
<
@
r
D
r
:
B
>
E
@
7
?
<
<
R
=
E
Š
<
B
@
<
8
B
7
<
F
?
E
<
O
<
>
D
=
?
D
@
<
D
<
7
>
@
G
<
8
>
@
<
@
<
<
=
9
?
<
D
O
E
7
7
E
E
:
?
?
O
<
<
G
:
<
?
„
7
D
G
E
D
:
:
<
?
7
?
D
E
8
U
>
D
M
O
O
@
G
G
8
=
8
@
=
C
8
>
<
E
O
@
G
<
>
8
u
:
B
8
<
M
E
G
<
8
F
7
8
=
‹
<
@
:
<
;
B
X
7
@
@
<
:
D
E
E
8
=
7
F
?
8
=
=
E
G
8
@
@
@
=
<
H
<
G
U
8
<
=
>
@
<
8
=
<
…
G
E
<
<
8
<
E
<
=
@
@
9
<
ƒ
H
G
E
=
?
?
<
„
G
<
7
G
7
=
:
<
=
=
=
:
8
<
G
7
@
E
F
9
<
8
C
<
B
G
E
8
I
?
<
7
@
„
<
:
E
6
E
<
:
<
R
9
<
7
@
=
B
G
<
<
;
B
z
G
<
v
?
8
9
8
@
R
u
G
<
?
8
:
6
B
I
<
‰
A
=
<
E
7
8
E
8
E
<
D
<
D
@
@
B
?
<
?
D
8
@
A
@
8
7
=
:
<
<
:
F
7
=
>
G
7
B
;
@
B
W
E
<
8
?
O
D
ˆ
7
=
<
E
<
:
8
G
B
P
<
D
E
A
@
8
G
@
D
?
<
D
@
G
<
7
E
D
G
B
7
F
8
<
=
=
F
>
A
E
G
<
<
G
8
7
…
C
G
@
=
9
r
B
D
E
B
G
A
:
=
G
…
G
<
B
<
G
7
;
>
<
@
8
>
@
B
O
=
D
:
=
8
>
B
@
<
<
<
:
I
=
?
8
B
D
G
>
<
E
@
>
I
Œ
:
B
|
<
=
<
=
@
„
<
G
A
<
<
X
=
:
D
=
R
<
G
<
F
@
B
<
@
8
@
G
E
L
G
:
A
9
7
E
>
<
<
I
<
<
F
:
<
D
:
G
;
I
@
8
M
>
:
E
=
;
:
E
G
<
@
>
E
O
=
7
:
B
G
E
<
D
>
E
<
E
H
D
ƒ
I
w
:
8
<
<
=
:
F
R
<
G
?
<
B
I
G
I
E
D
=
>
<
E
A
<
7
B
<
>
:
:
A
E
>
B
G
;
B
:
M
:
>
C
<
E
D
D
<
8
D
@
F
=
V
=
:
<
@
B
<
M
G
B
I
=
F
y
C
@
G
B
?
E
<
7
<
E
A
G
E
@
?
B
O
<
7
B
8
<
<
G
<
<
<
…
<
F
A
G
<
:
G
‡
F
r
@
D
R
<
>
=
8
9
@
=
7
@
@
8
:
?
=
E
<
E
E
V
:
<
:
F
@
@
…
;
@
8
?
<
<
?
F
D
:
@
;
E
I
<
E
D
7
a
E
:
<
Z
r
G
;
F
<
=
<
B
U
A
G
<
=
B
F
=
U
:
7
<
E
E
@
7
<
@
G
=
;
f
D
;
8
:
k
I
>
>
7
<
;
;
8
`
F
F
?
@
d
;
M
@
F
`
O
=
;
?
G
R
E
:
<
>
>
s
<
I
<
<
B
7
<
=
B
;
>
8
<
7
O
>
8
?
<
G
>
E
@
D
F
;
d
F
=
<
8
=
@
G
:
8
=
I
>
<
@
7
<
E
7
G
>
J
R
F
8
:
<
D
6
E
B
E
@
C
<
M
E
D
C
:
>
E
@
7
<
B
<
=
E
7
E
:
<
<
C
L
:
I
@
G
P
;
:
8
R
;
G
I
B
G
B
E
@
D
X
I
D
?
X
u
@
E
7
7
=
A
r
F
<
F
=
D
F
d
<
E
@
]
=
:
S
<
[
I
>
R
X
<
6
=
<
e
?
G
<
X
d
5
H
=
=
B
:
D
B
<
<
D
F
M
8
>
L
A
D
‚
=
7
>
F
:
I
;
:
G
>
D
G
;
?
G
@
M
V
F
F
X
<
E
7
?
@
<
8
:
E
7
E
I
8
E
D
>
D
B
E
R
7
a
4
@
E
;
I
>
:
<
E
:
G
E
c
4
D
<
j
D
3
E
i
u
E
<
<
7
@
<
:
@
:
<
B
G
B
7
:
D
„
<
:
E
=
:
C
<
7
D
E
F
I
X
S
7
B
V
<
<
9
@
<
8
=
G
9
;
a
8
:
?
7
@
f
F
>
G
?
;
:
h
E
U
@
=
E
D
<
^
;
M
B
B
:
G

G
<
7
>
8
B
@
X
8
I
A
<
E
D
@
B
=
D
]
8
:
D
:
B
C
2
C
7
=
g
B
<
>
E
7
B
@
E
?
'
8
<
b
@
?
B
D
X
A
@
=
G
G
E
D

A
G
a
X
7
M
=
<
>
N
<
r
G
@
:
‚
@
E
F
E
@
@
C
X
X
<
B
C
G
E
7
B
=
E
F
8
@
G
=
G
8
D
7
A
@
<
G
:
?
8
D
>
8
G
G
<
@
D
=
7
<
7
G
@
<
1
<
E
;
d
0
B
B
D
>
[
/
A
<
G
D
@
>
:
F
?
E
f
7
D
I
r
G
=
>
8
8
=
=
B
B
8
C
;
z
<
<
>
O
9
8
<
Q
e
<
B
d
>
C
<
a
E
@
:
U
E
:
<
G
E
c
=
8
E
b
G
B
<
H
a
E
A
D
<
`
:
M
<
]
<
=
I
_
E
@
G
<
^
8
B
8
.
;
7
A
:
\
X
:
L
B
W
-
9
I
P
<
,
@
:
E
X
G
<
<
@
8
<
1
Plaidoyer Pour une Turquie Européenne, LE SOIR, 13.02.08
I
D
E
H
O
A
:
G
<
r
7
X
E
:
L
7
v
7
F
<
?
G
8
I
8
G
7
?
D
7
>
@
D
;
S
E
F
<
A
?
:
<
;
A
8
C

G
I
D
G
x
r
?
C
<
<
@
7
@
?
@
B
8
@
F
<
8
7
:
<
C
:
C
<
8
r
<
F
8
<
E
:
X
7
E
D
E
@
7
B
:
>
B
=
<
v
A
B
G
r
7
<
=
=
D
G
<
?
:
X
U
?
<
B
<
>
<
8
=
7
u
=
M
?
F
7
;
E
N
<
;
8
8
B
:
X
>
=
D
E
C
B
7
7
<
F
>
I
<
<
G
:
?
?
<
<
@
:
E
@
I
B
M
<
<
H
8
A
<
E
:
@
E
8
@
@
@
:
<
L
G
=
D
B
u
D
F
P
O
N
@
<
G
<
=
E
B
:
=
<
B
<
@
<
B
B
F
8
:
=
A
B
<
=
E
G
7
=
?
G
<
:
7
G
@
X
<
B
O
@
8
>
8
C
7
D
?
G
E
G
<
>
G
=
@
8
B
7
@
<
ƒ
F
;
7
8
D
H
<
<
:
@
8
A
@
7
O
@
<
:
E
=
H
:
7
ˆ
<
=
E
B
E
@
<
G
@
C
<
@
<
@
7
=
>
B
C
B
<
7
<
<
;
@
?
=
G
G
A
I
9
F
B
E
<
:
E
<
E
G
D
;
G
D
G
G
<
B
9
9
D
8
<
A
:
:
@
@
7
@
:
<
@
A
@
E
=
D
G
<
<
7
I
<
C
<
:
A
E
@
@
@
G
=
?
=
=
:
?
<
E
G
7
<
E
7
8
M
D
@
@
9
>
F
<
E
;
=
:
F
>
F
D
D
D
>
E
:
S
7
=
v
=
=
H
B
<
C
E
:
@
<
D
D
>
<
:
B
8
8
G
<
I
B
@
@
@
<
G
8
E
<
E
:
<
7
7
@
v
D
8
G
I
<
E
8
F
?
:
=
<
E
B
@
@
<
:
=
L
7
;
D
G
<
B
>
D
E
>
I
E
G
D
X
S
X
:
@
<
C
G
7
D
>
@
O
I
?
<
?
D
>
<
<
<
8
<
8
;
<
>
@
8
E
F
=
8
?
?
@
@
I
7
B
E
@
=
H
E
<
E
B
:
=
B
G
8
<
@
<
@
O
B
:
@
D
X
:
E
r
P
=
7
<
I
=
G
;
G
M
<
<
8
<
=
X
7
7
:
X
<
=
=
:
<
8
<
G
G
7
<
P
R
:
=
@
D
G
E
?
F
u
7
X
B
:
<
D
<
C
8
=
:
=
:
>
X
B
7
<
X
G
:
E
@
D
B
=
X
<
B
<
E
S
G
I
8
C
M
p
I
G
F
:
=
<
C
<
<
=
8
7
@
<
D
<
V
:
D
I
7
7
<
@
8
<
=
m
7
?
:
>
=
@
<
<
G
=
F
8
z
>
<
:
B
B
8
>
B
G
>
E
=
8
M
G
<
<
B
s
G
F
<
I
=
<
7
7
p
=
<
;
=
:
<
E
@
8
<
:
@
<
=
y
G
:
:
L
A
G
<
?
8
>
8
:
E
I
8
C
E
E
=
P
@
8
G
7
I
B
G
9
8
G
<
>
8
7
<
8
m
<
<
:
@
?
8
?
@
D
G
†
G
s
E
D
p
<
<
F
<
=
<
M
p
F
r
=
@
E
@
:
B
@
8
<
=
@
F
<
r
<
<
B
<
V
F
:
8
B
G
:
8
=
<
:
r
H
=
<
B
F
B
O
;
X
G
=
7
D
B
=
@
G
A
<
B
=
<
D
C
<
F
@
;
A
X
O
m
<
<
?
<
=
<
8
@
D
7
=
B
8
p
B
B
G
;
:
@
<
E
p
G
=
s
@
:
M
;
=
7
F
8
<
F
7
8
B
8
7
<
I
D
@
=
<
=
@
<
D
E
L
?
:
<
B
G
I
M
<
@
A
B
I
=
L
E
>
;
@
D
@
F
7
G
8
D
7
G
D
E
>
9
:
r
B
}
<
r
r
7
E
;
7
D
8
=
=
8
=
<
8
B
<
G
<
D
=
B
B
B
F
:
F
G
@
E
D
D
H
@
F
@
A
M
E
E
G
@
<
>
D
=
G
=
D
@
7
I
<
V
:
<
F
G
?
=
B
=
:
=
:
:
:
G
<
B
@
B
B
K
>
<
@
>
8
7
;
=
?
|
<
F
<
:
O
E
B
ˆ
v
D
=
<
E
7
G
B
D
?
<
=
=
@
>
<
=
=
G
;
;
@
D
>
9
<
7
<
D
B
:
:
@
7
<
}
:
N
9
F
7
B
;
D
<
:
<
>
<
7
ˆ
E
>
I
D
D
=
B
9
7
G
<
A
<
<
E
8
U
E
E
F
E
<
B
Q
:
:
D
C
C
B
<
E
@
8
D
|
F
G
H
>
B
D
>
<
:
U
=
D
<
D
B
<
G
>
G
=
=
B
@
>
B
G
B
>
<
G
A
7
8
E
E
<
D
D
G
D
:
E
E
<
C
E
<
B
F
I
;
?
P
:
D
=
>
E
=
7
E
B
7
8
E
<
:
=
G
<
8
D
O
G
O
<
F
?
B
?
B
H
@
<
8
O
?
F
<
?
F
I
F
7
8
M
=
u
<
G
G
=
<
<
;
>
<
:
r
B
u
R
<
;
G
F
:
>
B
A
:
R
C
B
E
<
<
G
w
G
:
=
=
?
B
<
8
=
<
8
7
<
<
G
G
7
D
M
<
>
M
I
:
G
A
G
A
R
K
@
?
A
@
B
:
P
<
D
ˆ
D
G
=
{
7
8
E
G
:
@
:
?
:
<
<
S
B
Œ
B
C
R
E
@
D
@
@
:
7
@
8
<
P
E
<
E
F
7
7
V
A
@
B
=
<
:
E
F
R
7
G
D
<
@
:
7
@
<
<
=
R
7
r
P
:
?
7
8
=
E
G
E
;
B
8
:
@
G
8
=
>
7
9
<
r
I
@
G
D
<
@
<
V
7
Q
}
C
8
B
7
O
B
=
;
8
F
<
<
@
D
M
F
B
S
7
@
=
A
<
=
C
A
I
:
?
B
<
H
<
:
9
?
7
E
E
;
;
B
=
G
@
<
G
<
?
E
@
F
8
<
7
<
M
@
<
I
F
E
?
@
:
<
<
D
E
:
G
B
G
D
8
:
?
F
9
@
:
;
<
D
B
7
8
@
<
<
H
?
=
F
B
@
7
D
E
=
=
U
<
;
<
?
A
B
=
M
<
:
A
G
7
@
E
<
I
=
=
C
E
;
D
S
?
<
<
I
R
M
F
8
B
<
<
7
7
F
A
L
?
<
E
8
8
<
8
7
:
7
E
;
M
I
G
N
E
?
8
>
G
@
<
D
G
G
<
B
@
?
?
<
B
@
u
<
A
E
:
I
G
F
:
B
7
:
:
<
G
=
A
G
<
D
B
Œ
I
B
E
F
:
V
=
r
E
A
D
E
I
H
F
<
7
E
V
E
ƒ
D
@
<
<
I
?
X
B
>
G
D
=
G
<
D
I
<
=
G
=
;
7
U
u
:
G
F
F
C
B
M
<
R
E
=
8
=
>
<
E
B
G
7
J
7
7
B
<
<
>
7
O
I
@
A
D
7
<
D
I
<
=
I
B
:
A
<
:
:
W
u
:
7
A
B
<
E
<
G
=
M
@
X
8
E
=
:
<
X
@
<
<
>
7
D
;
C
:
7
F
?
G
B
;
8
@
G
<
<
7
>
@
E
=
<
B
@
<
<
M
E
9
7
E
@
<
F
M
?
I
O
:
:
G
I
<
G
8
F
D
8
=
@
:
C
B
E
8
D
7
D
=
X
B
?
<
u
>
G
E
7
H
7
D
D
<
=
=
I
B
G
;
E
:
G
8
B
G
X
C
D
E
r
=
?
S
7
E
G
8
C
:
B
@
E
@
F
@
@
A
F
@
E
<
@
<
E
E
?
<
D
A
O
<
G
M
7
<
@
<
:
@
=
>
F
D
B
F
G
:
G
G
=
J
E
E
F
<
@
=
<
@
X
<
7
@
<
:
G
G
<
B
B
@
F
R
X
=
E
9
<
D
7
D
?
?
G
D
<
M
<
E
<
8
8
I
A
?
7
=
7
<
?
I
P
:
@
7
I
<
F
:
‚
u
D
<
@
:
=
@
@
:
E
?
E
7
:
@
G
D
<
=
D
<
:
F
<
C
S
D
8
I
G
R
<
7
@
<
‰
9
8
D
8
8
=
7
E
<
<
@
G
F
>
>
@
H
G
B
E
<
C
:
?
I
B
D
G
<
F
8
:
v
;
E
;
;
R
>
F
<
>
r
w
=
@
>
>
A
E
E
7
<
<
7
G
8
;

:
@
7
=
<
?
E
@
W
<
7
@
I
:
E
I
=
G
<
<
I
C
U
<
u
=
8
8
:
:
G
<
7
=
F
G
E
G
D
|
=
G
E
>
7
=
<
<
r
G
U
G
<
7
O
B
V
G
?
<
G
r
E
G
:
B
E
@
;
<
@
<
B
F
<
=
O
?
F
7
A
7
D
8
M
>
>
:
@
@
D
>
<
F
<
=
>
O
<
8
D
7
E
?
F
8
C
w
F
G
G
B
B
G
<
6
>
G
F
B
G
:
=
G
A
@
B
<
D
G
<
X
<
X
=
G
?
@
G
>
<
8
8
8
B
<
A
=
>
B
:
<
D
v
I
D
<
@
=
@
@
<
7
B
=
=
v
<
7
F
:
C
7
7
I
r
7
<
E
E
G
8
:
G
A
=
M
B
W
<
:
8
<
<
I
=
G
>
<
:
:
D
I
>
G
D
=
E
G
F
=
<
@
:
6
<
9
I
:
<
<
?
K
M
<
r
G
G
8
<
E
@
R
2