Önsöz
Transkript
Önsöz
Önsöz 7TM6CPCV» PFCJCVVCVN»¹»PD[MDKT{PGOKXCTF»T%WPFCPFQNC[»².WTµjP» .GTuO0GMMGµFGPj\KNQNFW.CJKTG FGQMWPFWXGºUVCPDWN FC[C\»NF»³FGPOK½VKT ([RUWNVCP FCFCnQM[GVGPGMNKJCVVCVNCT»O»\[GVK½OK½VKT6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC (HGPFK6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFKXGDKT\KTXGQNCPFGXTKPKP5GKUµN JCVVjVuPKMCDWNGFKNGP+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKJCVVCVNCTMCHKNGUKPKP{PGONKn KUOKFKT%KTDKTKPFGPFG¹GTNKJCVVCVNCT»O»\.WTµjP».GTuONGT(P CONCT%WJjTuK ½GTKHNGT(E\j[»½GTKHNGT'GNjKNKJC[TjVNCTPGHKU+KN[GKUCjFGVNGT0WTCMMCCµNCT NGXJCNCTXGM»V CNCTOG[FCPCIGVKTOK½NGTFKT %KTJCVVCV»P[GVK½OGUKnQMW\WPXG[QTWEWDKTnCN»½OCIGTGMVKTKT7CNGDGGXXGNj JWTHjVOG½MKFGPGPM»U»OFCJCTHNGTKOTGMMGDjVFGPKNGPFGXTGFGFGMGNKOGNGTKP XGEONGNGTKP[C\»N»½»P»VCNKOGFGT ¼GMKNDCM»O»PFCP[C\»NCTCMNjO»UKVVGFGPKNGPUNUPGUKJOWJCMMCMTG[JCPK VGXMKKµTKMCCµCFNCT»P»CN»[QTFW%C½MCKUKONGTVC½»[CP[C\»NCTFCXCTF»+GTDKT [C\»P»PJQECU»C[T»QNFW¹WIKDKDKTMCn[C\»[»DKTFGPDKNGPXG{¹TGVGPJCVVCVNCTFC OGXEWVVW <C\»[»{¹TGPGPJCVVCVJQECU»PFCPKEj\GV[CPKFKRNQOCCN»TXGCTV»M[C\»[C\CDKNKT XG[C\F»¹»[C\»P»PCNV»PCMGVGDG[CPKKO\CMQ[CDKNKTFKºEj\GVKQNOC[CPJCVVCV [C\»P»PCNV»P»MGVDGMQ[COC\F»DWDKTIGNGPGMVKXGDWIGNGPG¹GU»M»U»M»[CDC¹N» MCN»PO»½V»TºEj\GVPCOGIGNGPG¹KDWIPFGFGXCOGVVKTKNOGMVGFKT ([RN+CVVCVNCTµP»PJC\»TNCPOCU»PFCGPnQMHC[FCNCPF»¹»OGUGTD[M7TMjNKOK 0UVCMKO\jFG6NG[OCP6CFGFFKP(HGPFK PKP7WJHGK+CVVjVuPCFN»nQMM»[OGVNK MKVCD»QNOW½VWT%{[NGDKTGUGTGNKOK\FGQNOCUC[F»²([RN+CVVCVNCT³JGTJCNFG [C\»NCOC\F»2PWPKnKPMGPFKUKPKUC[I»[NCXGTCJOGVNGCP»[QTWO0GMjP»EGPPGV QNUWP ²([RN+CVVCVNCT³CFN»MKVCD»PJC\»TNCPOCU»PFC[C\»N»DVPMC[PCMNCTVCTCPO»½XG OGXEWVMCDKTNGTVGMVGMVGUDKVGFKNGTGMTGUKONGPFKTKNOK½VKT%WPCnK\MKVCD»O»P DCU»NOCU»P»MCDWNGFGP([RUWNVCP »PVCTKJXGUCPCVUGXGT%C½MCP»6C[»P$JOGV *GPn%G[ GXGCNjMCU»P»JKnDKT\COCPGMUKMGVOG[GP%C½MCP<CTF»OE»U»2UOCP 6CM%G[µG.NVTXG7WTK\O0FT6C[»PºTHCPcCN»½CP%G[ GCNGPGPVG½GMMT GVOG[KDKTDQTnDKNKTKO 0GJOGV1GTOK+$6.$1 ([NN Eyüplü Hattatlar Neflre Haz›rlayan›n Notu ([R6WNVCP+\3G[ICODGTµKPOKJOCPFjT»+jNKFD=G[F(Dj([[DGN(PUjTuµ[KUKPGUKPFG DCT»PF»TOCU»JCUGDK[NGOKNNGVKOK\KP{\GNKNIKXGKVKPCU»PCOC\JCTQNOW½{PGONKFKPuXGJC[Tu GUGTNGTNGFQPCV»NO»½V»T<CJ[j.GOjNµKP([RUWNVCPµNCKNIKNKGP{PGONKVCXUKHK²ºUNjOEGPPGVKPKP DKTDCJnGUK³½GMNKPFGQNOW½VWT%WFWTWOFPQNFW¹WIKDKDWIPFGFGXCOGVOGMVGFKTºUNjO MNVTPPJGTVTNVG\jJTPDWTCFCI{TOGMOOMPFT ºPUCPNCT»PJC[CVNCT»PFCI{UVGTFKMNGTKCNjMC{NONGTKPFGPUQPTCFCQTC[CI{ONOG[KKUVGOGM XG[CI{ONOGM½GMNKPFGVG\jJTGVOK½VKT3CFK½CJ»PFCPRC½CU»PCOFGTTKUKPFGPXCVCPFC½»PC RGMnQMMK½KDWIPKPUCPCJW\WTXGTGPMCDTKUVCPNCT»PFCOGFHWPFWT([RUWNVCPUCPCVMjTNCT VCTCH»PFCPGPI\GNGUGTNGTNGDG\GPFK¹KIKDK([RUWNVCPMCDTKUVCPNCT»FCRGMnQMUCPCVMjT» UKPGUKPFGDCT»PF»TOCMVCF»T 0GNNKHW\WPDKTOGUjKUCTHGFGTGMCUNGP([RUWNVCPN»[CJWV([RUWNVCPµFCOGFHWPJCVVCVNCT» DKTCTC[CVQRNCOC[»DC½CTO»½V»T(UGT*N\jT»UCXjD'GXJCVµNMVVjD7WJHGKJCVVjVuP+CVXG +CVVjVjPIKDKJCVUCPCV»P»P{PGONKXGVGOGNMC[PCMNCT»P»PVCTCPOCU»KNGQNW½VWTWNOW½VWT %K\KO[CRV»¹»O»\GUGTKKMKPEKDKTGNGOG[GVCDKVWVCTCMMC[PCMXGI{TPVNOCN\GOG DCM»O»PFCPVCMXK[GGVOGMQNOW½VWT$[T»ECKHCFGXGKONjFC{PGONK{NnFGI{\FGP IGnKTKNOK½VKT0GNNKHVCTCH»PFCPI{UVGTKNGPMC[PCMNCTCVGMTCTOTCECCVNCGUGTNGTVGµMKFGFKNOK½ C[T»EC[GPKMC[PCMNCTKNCXGGFKNOK½VKT.KVCD»PUQPWPCKUVKHCFGFGMQNC[N»MUC¹NCOCU»KnKP MC[PCMnCU{\NMXGKPFGMUMQPWNOW½VWT ([RUWNVCPJCVVCVNCT»\GTKPGFCJCGXXGN1WTWNNCJ7KNIGPVCTCH»PFCPPG½TGFKNGP²([RN +CVVCVNCT³KUKONKGUGT\COCP»PFCD[MDKTDQ½NW¹WFQNFWTOW½VWT$PECM7KNIGPµKPDWGUGTK nQMOWJVCUCTQNWRU»P»TN»UC[»FCKUOKKJVKXCGVOGMVGFKT'CJCGXXGNFGKHCFGGVVK¹KOK\IKDK GNKPK\FGMKGUGT±([RN+CVVCVNCT²VGOGNMC[PCMNCT»PVCTCPOCU»[NCGNFGGFKNFK¹KPFGPFCJC ½WOWNNQNCTCMJC\»TNCPO»½V»T%K[QITCHKUKXGTKNGP½CJ»UNCKNIKNKMWNNCP»NCDKNGEGMGPI\GN {TPGMNGTNGGUGT\GPIKPNG½VKTKNOG[GnCN»½»NO»½V»T <GTKIGNOK½MGPDKTJWUWUWPJCV»TNCV»NOCU»FCXC\KHGQNOW½VWT([RUWNVCPUQP[»NNCTFC{\GNNKMNG ºUVCPDWN%[M½GJKT%GNGFK[GUKXG([R%GNGFK[GUKµPKP{\GNKNIKUKPGOC\JCTQNOW½VWT%KTnQM VCTKJuOGMjPQPCT»NO»½OG\CTN»MNCTVGOK\NGPOK½KJCVCFWXCTNCT»nGMKNOK½VKT)CMCV OG\CTVC½NCT»P»PXGGUGTNGTFGMKMKVjDGNGTKPFWTWOWHGXMCNjFG\EDKTJCNFGFKT%KNKPFK¹KIKDK OGTOGTJCXCMKTNKNK¹KPKPVGUKTKKNGMCT»PECNCPOCMVCXGFGHQTOGQNOCMVCF»T%WFWTWOW {PNGOGPKP[QNWMKVjDGNGTKPXCTCMNCPOCU»F»T6CJKRQNWPCPDWMNVTXCTN»MNCT»P»PDKTFCJC GNFGGFKNOGUKPKPOOMPQNCOC[CEC¹»P»P½WWTWPCGTKNOGUKIGTGMKT%WOG[CPFCMKVCR PG½TK[CV»XGVCTKJKMNVTGNXCTN»MNCT»PMQTWPOCU»JWUWUWPFCMKJCUUCUK[GVNGTKFQNC[»U»[NC([R %GNGFK[G%C½MCP»6C[»P$JOGV*GPnµGOVG½GMMKTK\ .GPFKNGTKPFGPXGGUGTNGTKPFGPFGXCON»HC[FCNCPF»¹»O3TQH'T0WJKVVKP6GTKPµG08¹WT 'GTOCPµCXGMKVCD»PF»½OGMjPHQVQ¹TCHNCT»P»VKVK\NKMNGnGMGPJCVVCV0GJOGFf\nC[µCMKVCD»P FKMMCVNGVCUJKJKPFGD[M[CTF»ONCT»P»I{TF¹OFG¹GTNKD[¹O¼KPCU»$ECT%G[µGGPMCNDu ½MTCPNCT»O»UWPCTMGPJC\»TNCPCPDWGUGTKPJC[»TNCTCXGUKNGQNOCU»P»&GPjD»+CMµVCPPK[C\ GFGTKO (UGTKPPG½TGJC\»TNCPOCU»GUPCU»PFCMKVCD»POGNNKHK01GTOK+CUMCP%G[GHGPFKPKP+CMMµC [TF¹PD[MDKT\PV[NG{¹TGPFKO<Q¹WPDKTOGUjKJCTEC[CTCMVGNKHGVVK¹KGUGTNGTKPKP UCFCMCKEjTK[GJMOPFGMGPFKUKPKT\KOCJ½GTFGUGXKPFKTGEG¹KOWJCMMCMV»T$NNCJµVCP TCJOGVPK[j\»[NC© 'T6NG[OCP%(5. 6WNVCPCJOGV2ECM Eyüplü Hattatlar ve Mehmet Nermi Haskan 6CPCVVCTKJK½GJKTVCTKJKXGVCTKJnKNK¹KCn»U»PFCPnQM{PGONKKMKDGNFGPKPVCTKJKPKMC[FCIGnKTGP 0GJOGV1GTOK+CUMCPUCFGEGDWKMKGUGTK[NGDKNGMNVTVCTKJKOK\FG[GTCNOC[CJCMMC\CPO»½ {PGONKDKTKUKOFKT µFC[C[»PNCF»¹»O»\([RUWNVCP7CTKJKXGCTF»PFCPgUMFCT%GNGFK[GUKµPKP[C[»PNCO»½ QNFW¹WnEKNVNKMgUMFCT7CTKJKCFN»GUGTNGTKPFGPFQNC[»DK\NGTKPºUVCPDWNNWNCTQNCTCM 0GJOGV1GTOK+CUMCPµCD[MDKT½MTCPDQTEWOW\XCT%K\([R%GNGFK[GUKQNCTCMDW DQTEWOW\W0GJOGV1GTOK+CUMCPµ»P[»NNCTEGGOGMXGTGTGMJC\»TNCF»¹»([RnCN»½OCNCT»P» PKVGNKMNKDKT½GMKNFG[C[»PNC[CTCM{FG[GEG¹KOK\KF½PFMgn[»N»C½M»PDKTUTGFKT\GTKPFG [Q¹WPNC½V»¹»O»\DWnCN»½OCNCT»DGNNKDKTRGTK[QFKnKPFG[C[»PNC[CTCMJK\OGVVGMK[»N»O»\»DW I{TMGONKGUGTNGTNGVCnNCPF»TOCMKUVGFKM %K\DW[C[»PRTQLGUKPKIGTnGMNG½VKTOGM\GTGnCN»½»TMGPDK\KFGTKPFGPOVGGUUKTGFGPDKTJCDGT CNF»M%WFG¹GTNKnCN»½OCNCT»ºUVCPDWNNWNCTµCOGEECPGPXGJCUDKDKT½GMKNFGUWPCPUQPºUVCPDWN nGNGDKUKFG¹GTNKCTC½V»TOCE»[C\CT0GJOGV1GTOK+CUMCP+CMMµ»PTCJOGVKPGMCXW½OW½VW %K\NGTW\WPOGVTCLN»PKEGRTQLG\GTKPFGnCN»½»TFWTWTMGPVCMFKTKºNCJKDK\G½WW[CT»FCDWNWPFW ²6CJKRQNFW¹WPW\M»[OGVNGTKPMCFTKPKXCMVKPFGDKNKPUQPTCIGnMCNCDKNKTUKPK\³ g\PVPPC¹»TN»¹»DKTC\JCHKHNG[KPEGFCJCHC\NCIGnMCNOCOCMKnKPDK\FGDCU»O»DGMNG[GPn FQU[C[»DGNNKDKTU»TC[NC[C[»PCJC\»TNCF»M%WUGTKPKPKNMMKVCD»([RN+CVVCVNCTQNFW'CJC {PEG1WTWNNCJ7KIGP%G[µKP[»N»PFCDCU»NO»½QNCP([RN+CVVCVNCT MKVCD»P»PF»½»PFC DC½MCDKTnCN»½OCQNOCF»¹»KnKPMKVCD»O»\»PEKFFKDKTDQ½NW¹WFQNFWTFW¹WMCPCCVKPFG[K\ ([RµVGJGT½G[DKTDKTK[NGKNKPVKNKJGT½G[DKTDVPPRCTnCNCT»IKDK%KTOG\CTVC½»PFCMKK½nKNKM VC½VCMWNNCP»NCPOGTOGTITCPKVXG[CMHGMKIKDKOCFFG\GTKPFGMKJCVXGUKVKNK\GOQVKHNGTXG DWPNCT»PDKTDKTK[NGXGnGXTG[NGQNCPW[WOW6CFGEGDWC[T»PV»NCTDKNG([RµVGMK\GPIKPNK¹KPDKT {TPG¹K(XGV([Rµ([R[CRCP\GPIKPNKMNGTKPGP{PGONKNGTKPFGPDKTKFG½RJGUK\JCV UCPCV»P»PNGVjHGVXG\CTjHGVKPKPDWTCFCMKW[IWNCOCNCT» ([RN+CVVCVNCT MKVCD»O»\NCDKTNKMVGDC½NCVV»¹»O»\±%[M0GFGPK[GV'{P¼O 3TQLGUK²PFGPDKT»½»MFCJCF½T[QTW\MNVTJC[CV»O»\C.KVCD»O»\FCKPUCP»O»\CXGDVP KPUCPN»¹CU{[NG[GEGMU{\QNCPD[MDKTOGFGPK[GVKP[C\»FCMK[CPU»OCNCT»P»I{TGEGMUKPK\ %WPNCTCKFK[GVFW[IWNCT»O»\»InNGPFKTK[QTI{¹UO\MCDCTV»[QTXGD{[NGUKPGKJVK½CON»DKT DVPPRCTnCU»QNOCMVCPFQNC[»M»XCPnFW[W[QTW\$[T»ECUQP[»NNCTFCCTVCPOGFGPK[GV FG¹GTNGTKOK\GXG{\GNNKMNGJCVUCPCV»PCKNIKPKPDK\KODWnCN»½OCO»\FCVGMCDN[GVCT\GVOGUK OGOPWPK[GVKOK\K\K[CFGNG½VKTK[QT %WCTCFC0GJOGV1GTOK+CUMCP%G[µG$NNCJµVCPOC¹HKTGVPK[C\GFK[QTWO$[T»ECDW nCN»½OCP»PIGTnGMNG½OGUKKnKPFQU[CNCT»VGUNKOGFGPCKNGUKPGFGVG½GMMTGFK[QTWO7CDKKMK MKVCD»PI{\FGPIGnKTKNGTGMDCUM»[CJC\»TNCPOCU»PFCD[MMCVM»NCT»QNCP'T6NG[OCP%GTMµG +CVVCV0GJOGVf\nC[%G[µGMKVCD»PVCUCT»O»P»XGVGMPKMJC\»TN»¹»P»DC½CT»[NCIGTnGMNG½VKTGP <C\»GXKºNGVK½KO+K\OGVNGTKnCN»½CPNCT»PCDWMNVTJK\OGVKPFGMKJG[GECP»O»RC[NC½CPOGUCK CTMCFC½NCT»OCFCVG½GMMTGFK[QTWO +K\OGVVG$NV»P<»N»O»\FC([R\GTKPGDKTDC½MCMKVCD»O»\FCDWNW½OCM\GTG6C[I»NCT»ONC $JOGV*(1c ([R%GNGFK[G%C½MCP» A Abdullah Hamdi Bey (Muhsinzâde) 0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ+COFK%G[JµFGºUVCPDWN.WTWnG½OGµFGFQ¹FW %CDCU»,,0CJOWFµWPºUVCDN»ÃOKTGOFT0GJOGF%G[µFKT 2PDKT[C½»PFC%G½KMVC½.CR»C¹CU»0GMVGDKPGDC½NCF»%WTCFC+jH»\0GJOGF (HGPFKµFGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF»'CJCUQPTCJQECU»XGDCDCU»P»P VGPUKDKKNG.C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFKµFGP[C\»[CDC½NCF» .»UCDKTUTG6CFjTGV<C\»º½NGTKµPFGnCN»½V»ºUVCPDWN%j[G\KFµVGDWNWPCP0GP½GK .VVjD»$UMGTuµ[G0GJOGF¼GXMK(HGPFKµPKPXGHCV»\GTKPGJUPKJCV JQECU»QNFW$[P»\COCPFC,,$DFNJCOKFVCTCH»PFCPMGPFKUKPG²TGuUµNJCVVjVuP³ PXCP»XGTKNFKXG.jF»,[C\µ»PJCFKUOGEOWCU»¼KHj[»¼GTuHµK [C\OCMNCI{TGXNGPFKTKNFK 15 Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi’nin sülüs-nesih bir levhas› Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs zerendûd levha Bu levhada Muhyiddin Arabî’nin Osmanl› Devleti ile ilgili tesbiti yer al›r (Y›ld›z Hamidiye Camii’nden) Eyüplü Hattatlar .C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFKµPKP{PGONKVCNGDGNGTKPFGPQNCP0WJUKP\jFGµPKP JQECU».C\CUMGTG[C\F»¹»OG\CTVC½».KVjDGUK[C\»XGKUVKH[{PPFGP{PGONK GUGTNGTKPFGPFKT6WNVCPJCOCO+CE».nM&COKKJCTKEKPFGOGTOGTGOCJMM [C\»NCT»FCRGMI\GNFKT Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi’ye ait çeflme kitabesi 16 A 5GDuWNjJKT$¹WUVQUµFC.WTWnG½OGµFGMK[CN»U»PFCXGHCVGVVK(TVGUK IP([RUWNVCPµCIGVKTKNGTGM([RUWNVCP7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPGFGHPGFKNFK0G\CTVC½» .KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 7CTKMCVK$NK[[GK.CFKTK[[G FGP5GuU NJCVVCVuP0WJUKP\jFG GU6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ%G[KPTWJ»½GTuHKnWPT»\CGPNKNNCJKHCVKJC 8\WPDQ[NWDG[C\VQRUCMCNN»OVGFG[[KPOGFFGDDKTMK½KQNFW¹W PCMNGFKNOGMVGFKT ‹bnülemin Mahmud Kemal ‹nal, Son Hattatlar, ‹stanbul, MEB, 1985, s. 20; M. U¤ur Derman, ‹slâm Kültür Mirâs›nda Hat San’at›, ‹stanbul, IRCICA, 1992, s. 216, fievket Rado, Türk Hattalar›, ‹stanbul, ts.,s. 230; Menfle-i Küttâb-› Askerî: Askerî kâtip yetifltirilmek üzere kurulan mektebin ad›d›r. (Bkz. Mehmed Zeki Pakal›n, Osmanl› Tarih Deyimleri ve Terimleri Sözlü¤ü, II, ‹stanbul, MEB, 1993, s. 476-477) 17 Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi’nin nesih hatt› ‹bnülemin Mahmud Kemal ‹nal, Son Hattatlar, ‹stanbul, MEB, 1985, s. 20; M. U¤ur Derman,‹s- lâm Kültür Mirâs›nda Hat San’at›, ‹stanbul, IRCICA, 1992, s. 216, fievket Rado, Türk Hattalar›, ‹stanbul, ts.,s. 230; Menfle-i Küttâb-› Askerî: Askerî kâtip yetifltirilmek üzere kurulan mektebin ad›d›r. (Bkz. Mehmed Zeki Pakal›n, Osmanl› Tarih Deyimleri ve Terimleri Sözlü¤ü, II, ‹stanbul, MEB, 1993, s. 476-477) Eyüplü Hattatlar Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi mezartafl› kitabesi Muhsinzade Abdullah Efendi’nin clî sülüs ile yazd›¤›, hocas› Kazasker Mustafa ‹zzet Efendi kabir kitâbesi ve son sat›r detay› 18 A Abdullah Efendi (Rodosizâde) $UNGP(FKTPGµNKFKT5QFQUK\jFGFK[GOG½JWTQNOW½VWT%CDCU»P»PCF»ºDTCJKOµFKT 7jµNKM[C\»[»<GMnG½O6NG[OCP(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»+jH»\ 2UOCP(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVVK 0GFTGUGG¹KVKOKI{TGTGMOFGTTKUQNFW6»TCU»[NC(FKTPG0QNNCU»0GMMGRj[GUK &GOC\K[GNGXXGN(MKOVCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWNRj[GUKXG&GOC\K[GNCJKT(MKO VCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFWDKTC[UQPTCC\NGFKNFK¼GXXCN¼WDCV VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(OKT%WJCTK&COKKDCPKUKXG(OKT%WJCTKµPKPFCOCF» ¼G[J0CJOWF&COKKMCDTKUVCP»PFCKFKDWIPOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT Habib, Hat ve Hattâtân, ‹stanbul, Matbaa-i Ebûzziya, 1305, s. 239 Müstakimzâde, 267, 678; Habib, 239; Rado, 118. Hayat› ile ilgili bkz. Rado, 107. Müstakimzâde, 678; Hattat Hâf›z Osman Efendi ve talebeleriyle alâkal› daha genifl bilgi için bkz. Ömer Faruk Dere, Hat San’at›nda Hâf›z Osman Efendi ve Ekolü. ‹stanbul, Marmara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü Yay›mlanmam›fl Yüksek Lisans Tezi, 2001. Mustakîmzâde, 267, 678. 19 Abdullah Efendi (Sûfizâde) 6HK\jFGNjMCD»[NCCP»NOCMVCF»T([RµVGºUMGPFGT3C½C0GMVGDKµPFGJQECKFK+jH»\ XG½G[JWµNMWTTjKFK<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFK {µFGP{¹TGPOK½VKT6WNVCP,,0CJOWFF{PGOKJCVVCVNCT»PFCPF»T 1WTWNNCJ7KNIGP([RN+CVVCVNCTºUVCPDWN$[F»PN»M%CU»OGXKU Abdullah K›r›mi .»T»OµFCPIGNFK¹KKnKP²VCVCT³NjMCD»[NCCP»NO»½V»T¼G[J+COFWNNCJµ»PVQTWPW 0WUVCHCQ¹NW'GTXK½0GJOGFµVGPCMNjO»UKVVGOG½MGVVK'CJCUQPTCUNUXG PGUKJµVG[GPKDKT[QNCTCOC[CIKTK½VKKUGFGOWXCHHCMQNCOCF»CMUKPGDW[C\»NCT» FCJCFCIGTKNGFK<CNP»\OWJCMMCM[C\»FCDW[QNCIKTOGFK¹KPFGPI\GN{TPGMNGTK IPO\GMCFCTIGNOK½VKT %KTIGEGT[CU»PFC{NOPP[CM»P QNFW¹WPWI{TFXGMGPFKOG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUKPKJC\»TNC[CTCMCNV»PCKMKFQMW\ TCMCO»P»MQ[FWgnPETCMCO»MKOKP MQ[CEC¹»P»UQTCPNCTCQPECVCNGDGUK KnKPFGPDKTKPKP[C\CDKNGEG¹KPKU{[NGFK *GTnGMVGPFGQ[»NKnGTKUKPFGXGHCVGVVK 0WUVCMuO\jFGXGHCV»PC ²+CVVjV»\uDj.»TuOK³VCTKJKPK F½TO½VT (OKT%WJjTK7TDGUKEKXCT»PC FGHPGFKNFKKUGFGFCJCUQPTC OG\CT»MCNF»T»NF»OG\CTVC½» MKVjDGUKKUGºUVCPDWN7TMXG ºUNjO(UGTNGTK0\GUKµPFG OWJCHC\CCNV»PCCN»PF» Abdullah K›rîmi mezartafl› kitabesi (T‹EM) Eyüplü Hattatlar 11. Mustafa Âli, Menâk›b-› Hünerverân, (nflr. ‹bnülemin Mahmud Kemâl), ‹stanbul, Türk Tarih Encümeni Külliyat›, 1926, s.8, 25; Müstakimzâde, 289. M. U¤ur DERMAN, ‹KMHS, ‹stanbul, IRCICA, 1992, s. 196. 12. Suyolcuzâde, 106; Derman ‹KMHS, 196. 13- Müstakimzâde, 289; Derman, ‹KMHS, 196. Abdullah K›rîmi’nin sülüs nesih k›t’as› 20 A Abdullah Re’fet Bey 6CFTC\CO5COK0GJOGF3C½CµP»PQ¹NWFWT%CDCU»([RNQNFW¹WPCI{TGMGPFKUK FG([RNFT5COK0GJOGF3C½CnKHVNK¹KPKPXGUCTC[»P»PDWNWPFW¹WUGOVDWIP 5COKCF»P»VC½»OCMVCF»T([R1K½CPECµFC1K½CPEC0WUVCHC3C½C&COKKUQN M{½GUKPFG[CRV»TF»¹»OGMVGRDWIPMVRJjPGQNCTCMMWNNCP»NOCMVCF»T $DFWNNCJ5GµHGVKNM[C\»FGTUKPKUNUXGPGUKJQNCTCMcKPKEK\jFG$DFWTTCJOCP (HGPFK{µFGPCNF»'CJCUQPTC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGP[C\»P»P KPEGNKMNGTKPK{¹TGPKRKEj\GVCNO»½V»T.»TOCVCµNuMFuXjPuXGUK[jMCV[C\»NCT»PFCFC JPGTUCJKDKKFK$[P»\COCPFC½jKTQNCP$DFWNNCJ%G[µKPOCJNCU»²5GµHGV³VKT 1GX½GJKTNK'COCVºDTCJKO3C½CµP»PQ¹NW0GJOGF3C½CµP»PFKXCPGHGPFKNK¹KPFG DWNWPOW½VWT<GPKnGTKGHGPFKUKQNFWMVCPUQPTCUTTGGOjPGVK[NGJCEECIKVVK F{P½VGXCFKKHjV»OCFGPKNGPOGXMKFGJXGHCVGVVK Hayat› ile ilgili bkz. Müstakimzâde Süleyman Sa’deddin, Tuhfe-i Hattâtîn, (Nflr. ‹bnülemin Mahmud Kemal ‹NAL), ‹stanbul, Türk Tarih Encümeni Külliyat›, 1928, 253-254; Rado, 131; Müstakimzâde, 283. Sâlim Efendi, Tezkire-i Sâlim, ‹stanbul, 1315, s. 258-260; Suyolcuzâde Mehmed Necîb, Devhatü’l-küttâb Tertip ve Tashih Eden: Kilisli Muallim R›fat) ‹stanbul, Güzel Sanatlar Akademisi, 1942, s. 88. Abdurrahman Bey 6CFTC\CO5COK0GJOGF3C½CµP»PQ¹NWFWT<C\»[»GXXGNj([RUWNVCPVTDGFCT» 0GOK½5jUKO(HGPFKFGPOG½MGVVKFCJCUQPTC(¹TKMCR»N»+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFKµFGPKEj\GVCNF»¼KHjK½GTuHK[C\O»½V»T (NNK[C½»PCWNC½OCFCP[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½XG(¹TKMCR»JCTKEKPFGVQRTC¹C XGTKNOK½VKT0G\CTVC½».KVjDGUKPKMCTFG½KJCVVCV$DFWNNCJ%G[[C\O»½V»T Suyolcuzâde, 88; Müstakimzâde, 251-252. Abdülbaki Arif Efendi .CU»ORC½CµFCFP[Cµ[CIGNFK'Q¹WOVCTKJKMGUKPQNCTCMDKNKPOGOGMNGDKTNKMVGJ VCTKJKPFGFQ¹OCU»OWJVGOGNFKT%CDCU»7GTUjPGKÃOKTG[C\»E»NCT»PFCP $OOK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFKµFKTÃNKOJCVVCVXGOWUKMuFGUVjFKFK VCTKJKPFGOGFTGUGFGPOG\WPQNFWMVCPUQPTCDKTOFFGV'CTUUCCFG $¹CNCT»PG\jTGVKPFGQNCP+CTGOG[PXCM»HNCT»MjVKRNK¹KPFGDWNWPOW½VWT0WJCTTGO 21 Eyüplü Hattatlar Abdülbaki Arif Efendi’nin ta’lik k›t’as› 22 7GOOW\µFCºUVCPDWN<CXW\6GNKO&COKKEKXCT»PFCc»TC¹u0CJCNNGUK 'GHVGTFCT<CJ[C0GFTGUGUKµPGOFGTTKUQNOW½VWT6QPTCU»TCU»[NC0CNN\jFG +UTGX.GVJFC%G½KMVC½%CTDCTQU+C[TGFFKP3C½C.W[WEW0WTCF3C½CXG gUMFCT$VKM9jNKFG6WNVCPOGFTGUGNGTKPGOFGTTKUQNOW½VWT +5GEGD7GOOW\VCTKJKPFG6GNjPKMMCF»N»¹»PCVC[KPQNFW<CR»NCP ½KMj[GV\GTKPG,90GJOGFµKPKTjFGUK[NG5GDKNGXXGN¼WDCVVCTKJKPFG OGUNGMVGPn»MCT»NF»%Q½VCMCNF»¹»DWFGXTGFGJCVVCVN»M[CRCTCMIGnKOKPKVGOKP GVOK½VKT '{TVUGPGUQPTC5GDuWNCJKT¼WDCVVCTKJKPFG%WTUCOGXNGXK[GVKPGVC[KP GFKNOK½VKT6»TCU»[NC0»U»TOQNNCU»ºUVCPDWNRj[GUKXGºUVCPDWNMCF»U»QNFW 5GDKWNGXXGN$¹WUVQUµFG$PCFQNWRj[GUK¼CDCP2ECMµFG$PCFQNW .C\CUMGTKQNWR=KNMjFG 0CTVµFG C\NGFKNFK5GDKWNCJKT $¹WUVQUµFCXG 0WJCTTGO0CTV µFCKMKFGHCFCJC 5WOGNK.C\CUMGTNK¹KµPG IGVKTKNFK¼GXXjN .CU»OµFG %WTUCµFCKMjOGVGOGEDWT GFKNFK%KTUGPGUQPTC ºUVCPDWNµCF{PO½UGMK\ C[UQPTCJCUVCNCPCTCM ¼CDCP(MKO VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT .CDTK([RUWNVCP &COKKµPKP%QUVCP ºUMGNGUKµPGCn»NCPCXNW MCR»U»P»PUQNVCTCH»PFCMK JC\KTGFG$[½G%CJTK MCF»PCn»MVTDGUKXG MW\WnG½OGEK¹KPKP JGOGP[CP»PFCF»T%W [GTÃTKH(HGPFKµPKPXCMH» QNWRG½K%GJKTG+CP»O DWCn»MVTDGPKP{PPG DKTU»TCCDFGUVOWUNW¹W [CRV»TO»½V»T%WPNCT [»N»PFCMCNF»T»NF» A ÃTKH(HGPFKµPKPXGHCV»FGTKPDKT VGGUUTW[CPF»TO»½DKTnQM½jKT XGHCV»PCVCTKJXGOGTUK[GNGT U{[NGOK½VKT%WVCTKJNGTKPGP OG½JWTWVCNGDGUKPFGP6G[[KF 9GJDKµPKPQNWRMCDKTVC½»PC JjMMGFKNOK½VKT7jµNKMKNG[C\»NCP MKVjDGOGVPK½{[NGFKT Abdülbaki Arif Efendi’nin ta’lik karalamas› &GPjD»ÃTKHKDKNNCJ$DFNDjMKK Hj\»N .KQNOW½F»OUGNNGOHCUN»IKDK JUPKCJNjM» ºMKMG\QNOW½KFK\jV»UCFT»TOC RuTj[G %TGVOK½VKFGDKTKnCTN»9CUHK[NG OGJGXTCM» 2NWRXCTGUVGKMC[F»CPjU»TIKVVK WnOC¹C +Oj[TWJ»M»NF»j½K[jPGGXEK »VNjM» 'GFKOIKT[jPIKT[jPOGXVKPKP VCTKJKPK9GJDK *KFKRÃTKH(HGPFKMCNF»KUOKFGJTG %jMK ÃTKH(HGPFKµPKPºUVCPDWNµFC/jNGNK UGOVKPFGMQPC¹»([RµVG[C\N»MM{½M XGDCJnGUKXCTF»9CUK[GVK\GTKPG XGHCV»PFCPUQPTCFCOCF»XGVCNGDGUK $DFTTCJKO)jK\(HGPFK{ VCTCH»PFCP([RUWNVCPVTDG JCOCO»P»PMNJCP»MCT½»U»PFCDKT OGFTGUG[CRV»T»NO»½V»T ÃTKH(HGPFK0GJOGF7GDTK\uµFGPVCµNuM OG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF»XGPKEGI\GN ½KKTNGTXGI\GN[C\»{TPGMNGTKXWEWFC IGVKTFKÃTKH(HGPFKµFGP[GVK½GPJCV VCNGDGNGTK½WPNCTF»T1GXµK\jFG 23 Abdülbaki Arif Efendi’nin kabir kitabesi 0GJOGF6jNKJ(HGPFK{.jVKR\jFG0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPFK{0GJOGF (HNjVWP{0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFK{6G[[KF+UG[KP9GJDu(HGPFK{ ¼G[JWNKUNjOºUJCM(HGPFK{¼G[JWNKUNjOºUOCKNÃU»O(HGPFK{ )»PF»M\jFGºDTCJKO(HGPFK{6G[[KF$DFWTTCJKO)jK\(HGPFK{6G[[KF <CJ[j(HGPFK{.C\CUMGT8DG[FWNNCJ+jOKF(HGPFK{$NK5OK{ ‹. Hakk› Uzunçarfl›l›, “De¤erli Türk Âlimi ve Güzel Sanatlar Üstâd› Abdülbâki Ârif Efendi”, Belleten, c. XXII, sy. 85 (Ocak 1958), s. 101-102. Müstakimzâde, 669; Rado, 121. Uzunçarfl›l›, a.g.m., 102-103. Uzunçarfl›l›, a.g.m., 103; Rado, 121. Abdürrahim Fâiz Efendi: Sofu Emir diye bilinen Esad Efendi’nin torunu ve Ebussuud Mehmed Efendinin o¤ludur. Fâiz Efendi, s›ras›yla Manisa, Galata, Kahire kad›s› oldu. Ayn› zamanda flâir olup divan sahibidir. Ta’lîk yaz›y› kay›npederi Abdülbâki Ârif Efendi’den ö¤rendi. H. 1138/1726 y›l›nda vefat etti. (Bkz. Müstakimzâde, 675; Rado, 131) Bkz. Mustafa Uzun, “Abdülbâki Ârif Efendi”, D‹A, I, 195-198; Mehmed Nermi Haskan, Eyüpsultan Tarihi. ‹stanbul, Eyüpsultan Vakf›, 1996, s. 304. Müstakimzâde, 669; Habib, 208; Rado, 121 Eyüplü Hattatlar Abdülbâki Efendi 24 *GNKDQNWµFCFP[C[CIGNFK0GJOGF3jTUjµP»PQ¹NWFWT0GJOGF3jTUjµP»PDCDCU» <GPKnGTK$¹CU»QNFW¹WPFCPMGPFKPG$¹C\jFGFGPOK½VKT5COC\CP([NN VCTKJKPFG*GNKDQNWµFCXGHCVGVVK $DFNDjMK(HGPFK%CJTu0GJOGF3C½CKUKONKJCVCVVCPVCµNKMJWTFGVCµNKMXG½KMGUVG VCµNKM[C\»NCT»P»OG½MGVVK0GOWTK[GVVGU»TCU»[NC[MUGNFK¹K¼CO.CF»N»¹»I{TGXKPFGP C\NGFKNKPEGºUVCPDWNµCIGNFKºUVCPDWNµFCJVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVKXG(OKT %WJCTK7GMMGUK.CDTKPGFGHPGFKNFK Müstakimzade, 671 Abdülkadir Belhi Efendi ¼G[J$DFNMjFKT(HGPFKf\MGPV+MOFCT»6G[[KF%WTJCPGFFKP.»N»n VQTWPNCT»PFCP¼G[J6NG[OCP(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWTµFC%GNJEKXCT»PFC .WPFW\FGPKNGPOCJCNFGMKVGMMGFGFQ¹FW %GNJ FG\WNOPCTVOCU»PFCPFQNC[»MCFCTOGPUWDWKNGJKETGVGFGPDCDCU»[NC F{TV[C½»PFCKMGPÉTCP,TCM.QP[CXG%WTUC\GTKPFGPºUVCPDWN CIGNFKºNM A VCJUKNKPKDCDCU»PFCPI{TF([RUWNVCP FC1K½CPE»UGOVKPFG¼G[J0WTCFGN%WJjTu 7GMMGUK PG¼G[JQNCPDCDCU»P»PXGHCV»\GTKPG[»N»PFC½G[JVC[KPQNWPFW 6QP\COCPNCTFCKnKPGMCRCPF»$KNGUK[NGXGFCNC½»R5GEGD0CTVµFG UGMUGPCNV»[C½»PFCQNFW¹WJCNFGXGOG½KJCVKPKPM»TM[GFKPEKUGPGUKPFGXGHCVGVVK .CDTKC[P»VGMMGPKPJC\KTGUKPFGQNWRVC½FKMKNOGOK½VKT7TM$TCR)CTUXG cC¹CVC[NKUCPNCT»PCXjM»HKFK7C NKMJCVNC[C\»NO»½DC\»NGXJCNCT»XCTF»T$[T»EC ½KKTNGTKFGDWNWPOCMVCF»T6WNVCP,,0CJOWF WPM»\»ÃFKNG6WNVCP »PCTCU»TCDW VGMMG[GIGNGTGM¼G[J$DFNMCFKT(HGPFKKNGUQJDGVGVVK¹KXGVGMMG[GJGFK[GNGT D»TCMV»¹»DKNKPOGMVGFKT ‹bnülemin, 491; Tilgen, 5; Refiî Cevad Ulunay, ‹stanbul Evliyalar›, Milliyet Gazetesi, 7 Nisan 1957; ‹stanbul Kültür ve Sanat Ansiklopedisi, I, 171 Abdülkadir Efendi $DFNMCFKT(HGPFKGUMKUCFTC\CONCTFCP<C¹N»Mn»\jFG0GJOGF(OKP3C½CµP»PQ¹NW 5WOGNK.C\CUMGTK(OKP%G[µKPQ¹NWFWT=KNJKEEG(MKOVCTKJKPFG FQ¹FWµFG([R0QNNCU»µFC0GMMG3j[GUKµFC $PCFQNW3j[GUKCNF»XGDWU»TCFC[CR»NCP5WU[C6WNJCPNC½OCU»PFCKMKPEK OWTCJJCUQNFW 5GDKWNGXXGN7GOOW\VCTKJKPFG$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKQNFWµFC 5WOGNK3j[GUK=KNJKEEG0CTVµFG0GENKUK9jNj0HVUQNFW %CDCU»IKDKVCµNKM[C\»FCOCJKTKFK1GHKUJKN[GNGT[C\F»¹»TKXC[GVGFKNOK½VKT%KTnQM JCVVCVCKEj\GVXGTFK¹KDKNFKTKNOGMVGFKT$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK5COC\CP([NN VCTKJPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT Sicill-i Osmâni, III/349; ‹bnülemin, 488. Abdürrahim Efendi (Edhemiyye) .jVKD\jFG0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT7CµNKM[C\»[»DCDCU»PFCP{¹TGPFKXG DCDCU»IKDKVCDKDQNFW(FJGOK[[GVCTKMKPFGP&G\j[KTNK'GTXK½$NKµ[GDC¹NCPF»XG QWPWPVCXUK[GUKKNGGXKPFG[GFKUGPGKP\KXj[CnGMKNFK<KPG½G[JKPKPK\PKKNG KP\KXjU»P»UQPCGTFKTFK [»N»PFCCPU»\»PXGHCVGVVKXG½G[JKPKPMCV»NF»¹»EGPC\GPCOC\»PFCPUQPTC (OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUKEKXCT»PCFGHPGFKNFK Müstakimzâde, 677-678 25 Abdürrahim Efendi (Tatarpazarl›) %WNICTKUVCP7CVCTRC\CTN»'TTK\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFKµPKPJKOC[GUKPFGKNKOVCJUKNGVVK )»PF»M\jFGºDTCJKO(HGPFKKUKONKDKTJCVVCVVCPVCµNKM[C\»U»P»OG½MGVVK %WTUCµFCPF{P½VG&GOj\K[GNjJKT([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPFGKFK 27- Müstakimzâde, 675 Ahmed Necib Bey 5KMµCJCVV»P»[C\OCMNCOG½JWTQNOW½VWT(XXGNj2TOCPXG0CFGPNGT0GENKUK %C½MjVKDKFCJCUQPTCDCMCPN»M[C\»K½NGTKOFTQNOW½VWT%KTnQMVCNCDG [GVK½VKTOK½QNCP$JOGF1GEKD%G[KPXGHCVVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT*O½UW[W OG\CTN»¹»PCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT 25-Tilgen, 7 %WIP%WNICTKUVCPU»P»TNCT»KnGTKUKPFGMCNO»½QNCP)KNKDGNK3NQXFKXGµFG [»N»PFCFP[C[CIGNFK(EFjF»6WNVCP0WTCF+FjXKPFKIjTKNG)KNKDGµPKPHGVJKPG Eyüplü Hattatlar Ahmed Arif Efendi (Filibeli Bakkal) fiehzade Camii Vefa kap›s› üzerinde bulunan, Bakkal Arif Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs Besmele 26 A Bakkal Arif QTFW½G[JKQNCTCMMCV»NO»½XGQTCFCMCNO»½V»T$U»NNCT» Efendi’nin imzas› %WJjTCµN»F»T%CDCU»(OKT¼G[JK6NG[OCP(HGPFKµFKT )KNKDGµFGKNKOVCJUKNGVVK)KNKDG<T[½&COKKJCVKDK+jH»\ ºUOjKN6jDKT(HGPFKµFGPKNM[C\»FGTUNGTKPKCNF»*GPn [C½»PFC+KEj\µCIKVVKF{P½VGºUVCPDWNµCIGNGTGM ECOKNGTFGMKI\GN[C\»NCT»KPEGNGOK½VKT%W\K[CTGV MGPFKUKPFG[C\»[»KNGTNGVOGMOCMUCF»[NCºUVCPDWNµCIGNOGM CT\WUWW[CPF»TO»½UCFCDWPWCPECM2UOCPN»5WUJCTDK FQNC[»U»[NC5WOGNKµFGPI{nDC½NC[»PEC[»N»PFCIGTnGMNG½VKTGDKNOK½VKT ºUVCPDWNµCIGNFK¹KPFGIGnKOKPKVGOKPGVOGMOCMUCF»[NC6CTCnJCPGµFGDCMMCN FMMCP»CnV»º½VGKUOKPFGMKDCMMCNNjMCD»DWTCFCPIGNOGMVGFKT ºNMTGUOKI{TGXKPG$TCN»MµVGgUMFCT*NHGO+CVWP.»\5½FK[GUKµPFG DC½NCF»%WOGOWTK[GVGGMQNCTCM$TCN»MFC1WTWQUOjPK[G .VRJCPGUKµPFGOCJHW\PCFKTGUGTNGTKPVCOKTKKNGXC\KHGNGPFKTKNFK([NN 27 Bakkal Arif Efendi’nin hocas›ndan ald›¤› icâzetnâme (TSMK-GY 325) Eyüplü Hattatlar [»N»PFCKUG'Q¹CPE»NCT.»\5½FK[GUKµPGUNUJQECU»QNCTCMVC[KPGFKNFK$[T»ECJ [»N»PCMCFCTFC1WTWQUOCPK[G&COKKCXNWUWPFCMKOG½MJCPGFG6CN»IPNGTK [C\»FGTUKXGTOK½VKT $JOGFÃTKH(HGPFKºUVCPDWNµCIGNFKMVGPUQPTCMC[»PDKTjFGTK3C\CTE»MN»JCVVCV 0GJOGF+WNUK(HGPFKXjU»VCU»KNG¼GXMK(HGPFKµ[GFGTUGDC½NCF»XGJ [»N»PFCUNUPGUKJDKTJKN[G[C\CTCMKEj\GVPjOGCNF» ÃTKH(HGPFKµPKPºUVCPDWNµCIGNOGUKXG¼GXMK(HGPFKµ[GFGTUGDC½NCOCU»OWJCMMCMMK UCPCV»PFC[GPKDKTF{PGOKPDC½NCOCU»PCUGDGRQNOW½VWTÃTKH(HGPFKµPKP[C\»NCT» MTQPQNQLKMQNCTCMKPEGNGPFK¹KPFGJ[»N»PFCPUQPTCMK[C\»NCT»P»PK½NGMNKM MC\CPCTCMOMGOOGNDKTVCXTCDTPF¹I{TNT0CJjTGVKPKFCJCnQMUNUXG PGUKJµVGQTVC[CMQ[OW½VWT&GNu[C\»NCT»OWCU»T»JCVVCV6jOK(HGPFKµPKP 28 Bakkal Arif Efendi’nin celî sülüsle ve sülüsle yazd›¤› Hilye (Fatih, Mesih Mehmed Pafla Camii) A OGTVGDGUKPGWNC½CDKNOK½FG¹KNFKT<KPGFGEGNuUNUNGHC\NCUC[»NCDKNGEGMOG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUK[C\O»½V»TºO\CN»OG\CTVC½».KVjDGNGTK[CP»PFCUCV»T»DKTOGEKFK[G[GMCN»R n»MCTOCFCPFQ¹TWFCPOTGMMGRNGVC½\GTKPGKO\CU»\GRG[EGOG\CTVC½».KVjDGUK [C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWT .CTCIOTM0GUKJ0GJOGF3C½C&COKKµPFGOGXEWVD[MDQ[EGNuUNUXGUNU QNCTCMJC\»TNCF»¹»JKN[GJVCTKJNKQNWRÃTKH(HGPFKµPKPUCPCV»P»DVP[NG QTVC[CMQ[FW¹WGUGTNGTFGPFKT+CTHNGTKPUCV»TCFK\KNK½KXGMGUMKP[C\»NO»½[CR»NCT» OMGOOGNFKT 6NUXGPGUKJVGJQECU»0GJOGF¼GXMK(HGPFK[QNWPFCXGVCXT»PFCGUGTXGTOK½VKT 6NUPGUKJXGT»MCCµ[C\»NCT»P»OGMVWR[C\CTIKDKUTCVNK[C\F»¹»P»MGPFKUKPK VCP»[CPNCTCPNCVO»½NCTF»T%WUGDGRNGVCUJKJNGHC\NCW¹TC½OCO»½V»T 29 Bakkal Arif Efendi’nin sülüs nesih hilyesi (Tanman Koleksiyonu) Bakkal Arif Efendi’nin celî sülüsle yazd›¤› mezartafl› kitabesi (Sultan II. Mahmud Haziresi) &GNuµFGUNUXGPGUKJVGMKDC½CT»[» I{UVGTGOGOK½VKT&GNuUNRNC½O»½ ².GVGDGJWÃTKH³KO\CNCT» cCT½CPDCN»0GJOGFÃTKH%G[µNGKNM DCM»½VCDKTDKTKPGDGP\GUGFG CTCNCT»PFCHCTMXCTF»T0GJOGF ÃTKH%G[KO\CP»PUVnGPIGNKPKT» JCTHKPFGPVCMCTMGP$JOGFÃTKH (HGPFKC[PJCTHKPKPOGFJCTHKQNCP GNKHVGPVCMO»½V»T +C[CV»P»PUQPNCT»P»HGNnNKIGnKTGP ÃTKH(HGPFK5COC\CP([NN &WOCIPXGHCVGFGTGM (FKTPGMCR»U»OG\CTN»¹»PC FGHPGFKNOK½VKT.CDKT.KVjDGUK ½{[NGFKT .WNNWOGPCNG[JjHjP $NNCJWUWDJjPGJWXGVGjNj OG½jJKTKJCVVjVuPFGP )KNKDGXKGNJjE ÃTKH(HGPFKMWNWPC TCJOGVXGOC¹HKTGVG[NG[G GN)CVKJC 5COC\CP<GXOK&WOµC .GVGDGJW0WUVCHC5jM»OKDPWµN OGTJWOXGVKNOK\KJK Hattatlar .CDKT.KVjDGUKPKQ¹NW0WUVCHC 5jM»O[C\O»½UCFC6jOK(HGPFK VCTCH»PFCPCUN»P»WPWVVWTCECM OMGOOGNK[GVVGVCUJKJGFKNOK½VKT Eyüplü 28- Bakkal Ârif Efendi’nin do¤um tarihi bütün kaynaklarda h. 1246/1830 olarak verilmifltir. (Bkkz. Eflref Edib, “Ârif”, ‹slâm Türk Ansiklopedisi, I, 491; ‹bnülemin, 54; M. U¤ur Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F”ler, 4; a.mlf. D‹A/III, 364) Ancak BOA, Sicill-i Ahvâl 59/349’da bulunan terceme-i hâlinde h. 1252/1836 y›l›nda do¤du¤u kaydedilmifltir. H. 1246 tarihi, Ârif Efendi’yle alâkal› ilk neflriyat yapan Eflref Edib Bey’in makâlesinde yay›nlanm›flt›r. Daha sonra Bakkal Arif Efendi’nin celî sülüsle yazd›¤› mezartafl› kitabesi (Fatih Nakflidil Türbesi Haziresi) 30 A yap›lan neflriyatlarda bu tarih aynen iktibas edilmifltir. Ancak do¤rusu sicill-i ahvâlde Marmara Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Arflivcilik Bölümü hocalar›ndan Sn. Talip Mert’in buldu¤u, h. 1252 tarihi olmal›d›r. (Bkz. Süleyman Berk, “Filibeli Ahmed Ârif Efendi”, AD ART DEKOR, sy. 88 (Temmuz 2000), s. 148-152. *Ordu fieyhi: Askerlerin gazâ ve cihada teflvik ve ordunun muzafferiyetine dua için bulundurulanlar hakk›nda kullan›lan tabirdir. (Bkz. Mehmed Zeki Pakal›n. Osmanl› Tarih Deyimleri ve Terimleri Sözlü¤ü, II, ‹stanbul, MEB, 1993, s. 729) ‹bnülemin, 54. BOA. Sicill-i Ahvâl, 59/349. Bu icâzetnâme bugün TSMK-GY. 335’tedir. Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F”ler, 5; a.mlf., KÖK, 14. Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F”ler, 5; a.mlf. ‹KMHS, 221. Hattat Sâmi Efendi, Ârif Efendi’nin süratli yazmas› ile alâkal›; “Ârif, topu¤unu kaidesine t›k›p “Rabbiyesir......” den bafllar, murakkaa’n›n sonuna geldi¤inde daha “Rabbiyesir”in mürekkebi kurumam›flt›r! Amma, arada vav›n gözü kapal› olmufl, herifin umurunda m›? Hac› Ârif’e yaz›da o kadar meleke gelmifltir ki, uyurken bile yazabilir. “Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F”ler, 5. ‹bnülemin, 294. Ahmed Efendi (Benlizâde) ([RNQNWR%GPNK\jFGFK[G VCP»PO»½V»T<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG 0WUVCHC([[Du{µ FGP{¹TGPFK6WNVCP,,,6GNKO FGXTKPFGXGHCVGVVK¹K U{[NGPKT Müstakimzâde, 99-100; Tilgen,5 Bakkal Arif Efendi mezartafl› kitabesi ve imza detay› 31 Ahmed Efendi (Kurfluncuzâde) .WT½WPEW\jFGQNCTCMDKNKPKT6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFKµFGP OG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T0UVCMKO\jFGµPKPDKNFKTFK¹KPGI{TG\COCP»PFC([R &COKKOKJTCD»UQNVCTCH»PFCDWNWPCPnUCV»TUNUFK¹GTNGTKPGUKJJCVNCJQECU» 6W[QNEW\jFGµPKPDC½NCF»¹»D[MDQ[.WTµCP».GTuOµKVCOCONCPO»½V»T +[»N»PFCXGHCVGFGP$JOGF(HGPFKPKPMCDTKPKP[GTKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT*\GN [\NK[KCJNjMN»G½KDWNWPOC\½GTGHKPGF½MPDKTKPUCPQNFW¹WTKXj[GV GFKNOK½VKT 37- Müstakimzâde, 99; Suyolcuzâde, 12. (Nurullah Tilgen, Eyüplü Hattatlar, s. 6’da (1950) Kur’ân-› Kerîm’in Eyüp Camii’nde bulundu¤undan bahsetmektedir.) 38- Müstakimzâde, 99; Rado, 120. Ahmed Efendi (Çivizâde) Eyüplü Hattatlar ([R VG.CU»OcCXW½0CJCNNGUK PFGFQ¹FWcKXK\jFGG½¼G[J3uT$JOGF(HGPFK NjMCD»[NCVCP»PF»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVVK Çivizade kabir kitabesi 32 A 'GXTKPFGOG½JWTDKTJCVVCVQNWRC[P»\COCPFCOCVGOCVKMXGKNOKPEO <»NF»\NCTKNOK$UVTQNQLKµNCW¹TC½V»VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK)GUJCPG &CFFGUK\GTKPFGXG=CN0CJOWF3C½C0GFTGUGUKCTMCU»PFCF»T Müstakimzâde, 100; Tilgen, 5-6; Rado, 132 Ahmed Efendi (‹mam) ºUVCPDWNNW FWT(¹TKMCR»EKXCT»PFC$XE»DG[0CJCNNGUK0GUEKFKµPKPKOCO»KFK 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»cCXW½\jFG6G[[KF$NK FGP{¹TGPOK½XG{OTP.WT jP» .GTKOXGI\GN[C\»NCTJC\»TNCOCU»PCUCTHGVOK½VKTVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK .CDTK(¹TKMCR»F»½»PFCDCDCU»ºOCO+CUCP(HGPFK PKP[CP»PFCF»T.KVjDG[K5jUKO (HGPFK[C\O»½V»T Müstakimzâde, 65 Ahmed Feridun Bey 33 'Q¹WO[GTKXGVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT'GHVGTFjTcKXK\jFG$DFWNNCJcGNGDKµPKPGXKPFG [GVK½OK½XGJ[»N»PFC6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½CµP»PJK\OGVKPGMjVKRQNCTCM Feridun Bey Türbesi IKTOK½VKTºMKFGHC1K½CPE»QNOW½VWT,,,0WTCFµ»PVCJVCn»M»½»PC²¼KO½uTK ºUNjO³VCTKJKPKF½TO½VT6NUPGUKJFKXjPuTKMµCUK[jMCVXGFK¹GT [C\»NCT».QEC1K½CPE»&GNjN\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK fPGONKGUGTK²0P½GjVµUUGNjVKP³K6WNVCP,,,0WTCFµCVCMFKOGVOK½VKT$¹WUVQU µFGUCPECMDG[KQNCTCM6GOGPFGTGµ[GI{PFGTKNOK½µGFQ¹TWFC.{UVGPFKNµG I{PFGTKNOK½VKT0WJCTTGO¼WDCVµFGOGTMG\GnC¹T»NO»½XGMGPFKUKPG 1K½CPE»N»MXC\KHGUKVGXFuGFKNOK½VKTTGDuWNGXXGN1KUCPµFG5UVGO 3C½CµP»PM»\»$[½G6WNVCPµNCGXNGPFK 'GDFGDGXGKJVK½COCF½MPN¹KNGDKNKPGP)GTKFWP%G[6CHGT0CTV VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGTGM([RUWNVCP&COKKCTMCU»PFC%G[DCDCUQMC¹»PFCMK VTDGUKPGFGHPGFKNFK 41. Müstakimzâde, 96-97; Habib, 98; J.H. Mordtmann, “Ferîdun Bey” ‹A/4, 569-570; Rado, 77; Abdülkadir Özcan, “Feridun Ahmed Bey”, D‹A, XII, 396-397. Eyüplü Hattatlar Ahmed Hamîd Efendi (Enserci) 34 ([RUWNVCP FCFP[C[CIGNFK(PUGTEKNjMCD»[NCVCP»P»TF»([RUWNVCP7TDGUK VTDGFCT»2UOCP(HGPFK PKPDKTCFGT\jFGUKFKT%CDCU»VCTKJKPFGXGHCV GFGP0WUVCHC(HGPFK FKT'GFGUK([RUWNVCPVTDGFCT»¼G[JºUOCKN(HGPFK ([RUWNVCP&COKKDC½OG\\KPK$DFNICPK*N½GPuIKDKDC½OG\\KPKMGP µFGXGHCVGVVK $JOGF+jOKF(HGPFK PKP[C\»JQECU»(¹TKMCR»N»0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFK FKTcQM UTCVNK[C\»[C\F»¹»U{[NGPKT.GPFKUKGXXGNEG5jM»OGNJCE0GJOGF3C½C P»P OJTFCT»KMGP3C½C P»P'GHVGTFCT»½»MM»GXXGN KPFGPC\NKPFGPUQPTCKP\KXC[C nGMKNOK½XGM»UCDKTOFFGVUQPTCFCVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT 42- Müstakimzâde, 90; Habib, 105; Rado, 168; Tilgen, 6 Ahmed H›fz› Efendi 0QTCµFCPºUVCPDWNµCDCDCU»KNGDKTNKMVGJKETGVGVOK½VKT<C\»[»GXXGNj+CU»TE»NCT KOCO»\NHNNGTJQECU»0WUVCHC(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVVK'CJCUQPTC0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFKµFGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVPjOGCNF» A Ahmed H›fz› Efendi’ye ait sülüs-nesih k›t’a 0G½JWTEGNuUVjF»0WUVCHC5jM»O(HGPFK{µPKPJQECU»XGC¹CDG[KºUOjKN =JFu(HGPFK{[C\»[»$JOGF+»H\»(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT ².CVKDKJUPKJCV³VCTKJKPKPFGNjNGVGVVK¹KVCTKJVGJ5GKDNCJKTKPKP *P([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGTGM(¹TKMCR»µFCJQECU»5jUKO(HGPFKµPKP [CP»PCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT Suyolcuzâde, 43; Müstakimzâde, 86; Habib, 97; Rado, 169; Derman, ‹KMHS, 203. Müstakimzâde, 86; Habib, 97; Rado, 169; Derman, ‹KMHS, 203. Suyolcuzâde, 43; Müstakimzâde, 87; Habib, 97; Rado, 169; Derman, ‹KMHS, 203. Bkz. ‹bnülemin, 476; M. U¤ur Derman, “Hattat ‹smâil Zûhdî Efendi”, Hayat, sy. 49 (27 Kas›m 1969), s. 26; a.mlf., Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, ‹stanbul, Kültür Bakanl›¤›, 1982, 42. L. ; Rado, 186; Derman, ‹KMHS, 204; a.mlf., a.g.e, 203. Müstakimzâde, 87; Habib, 97; Derman, ‹KMHS, 203. Ahmed Nailî Efendi *CNCVCN»QNCTCMDKNKPGP$JOGF1jKNK(HGPFKDC\GP²*CNCVCXu³DC\GPFG²([[Du³ QNCTCMKO\CCVO»½V»T%CDCU»ºDTCJKO=CTuHuIGOKEKQNWRQ¹NW$JOGF1jKNKKNG DGTCDGT0WUVCHC.VjJuµFGP[C\»OG½MGVOK½VKT*CNCVC7C½OGMVGRVGJQECN»M [CRO»½V»TcQMJ»\N»XGI\GN[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWT<\FGPHC\NC.WTµjP».GTuO [C\O»½V»T%WIPºUVCPDWN7TMXGºUNjO(UGTNGTK0\GUKµPFG(MTGO+CMM»$[XGTFK .QNGMUK[QPWXG6CDCPE».QNGMUK[QPWµPFC.WTµjP».GTuOµNGTKOGXEWVVWT 35 Eyüplü Hattatlar Ahmed Naili Efendi’nin nesih yaz›s› 36 [»N»PFCXGHCVGFGP$JOGF1jKNK(HGPFKµPKPOG\CT»'GHVGTFCT<jXGFF MCDTKUVCP»PFCF»T2¹NW+jH»\ºDTCJKO(HGPFKFGJCVVCVQNWRJ[»N»PFC XGHCVGVOK½VKTMCDTKDCDCU»P»PMCDTK[CP»PFCF»T Habib, 163; ‹bnülemin, 222; Rado, 187; M. U¤ur Derman, Letters In Gold, ‹stanbul, The Metropolitan Museum Of Art, 1998, s. 106. Muhuttin Serin, “Kubbealt› Akademisi Kültür ve Sanat Vakf› Ekrem Hakk› Ayverdi Hat Koleksiyonu Envanteri”, Ekrem Hakk› Ayverdi Hât›ra Kitab›, ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Fetih Cemiyeti, 1995, s. 49. Derman, Letters In Gold, 106-107. ‹bnülemin, 225; Derman, a. g. e. , 106. A Ahmed Kâmil Akdik &GOj\K[GNGXXGN .CU»OµFG)»PF»MN»µFC *\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUK ½KOFK0KOCT6KPCP gPKXGTUKVGUKMCT½»U»PFC MnMDKTGXFGFP[C[C IGNFK%WGX[CPF»¹»PFCP FCJCUQPTC)CVKJµGVC½»PF»NCT %CDCU»7GTUjPGKÃOKTG(T\CM$PDCT»%C½MjV»DK6NG[OCP(HGPFKµFKTºNM[C\»FGTUKPK =G[TGM6jNKJC6WNVCP6»D[CP0GMVGDK[C\»JQECU»6NG[OCP(HGPFKµFGPCNF» 5½FK[Gµ[KDKVKTFKMVGPUQPTC'CJKNK[G0WJCUGDGUKµPGOGOWTQNFW%WCTC6jOK (HGPFKµ[G[C\»FGTUKPGDC½NC[»RUNUPGUKJOG½MGFGTGMJ[»N»PFCDKT JKN[G[C\CTCMKEj\GVPjOGCNF»%WKEj\GVPjOG0¼GXMK(HGPFKVCTCH»PFCPFCVCUFKM GFKNOK½VKT [»N»PFC'KXCP» +Oj[WP0JKOOG .CNGOKµPGOGOWTQNCP .jOKN(HGPFKOCJNjU»P»FC JQECU»P»PKUVG¹K\GTKPG +j½KOµGnGXKTFK+ [»NNCT»CTCU»$JOGF+j½KO KO\CN»[C\»NCT»PCTCUVNCP»T 'CJCUQPTCVGMTCT.jOKN OCJNjU»PCF{PO½VT 'uXCP»+Oj[WPµFCVW¹TC nGMOGUKPKFuXjPuXGEGNu FuXjPu[C\»NCT»P»FCJQECU» 6jOK(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK 'CJCUQPTCC[P»[GTFG PjOGPXKUNK¹GIGVKTKNFK [»N»PFCJQECU»6jOK(HGPFK GOGMNKQNWPEC1K½jP» +Oj[P.CNGOK 0OG[[K\NK¹KKNG+WVV» OVGPGXXKCOWCNNKONK¹KPG IGVKTKNFK Kâmil Akdik’in, o¤lu ressam fieref Akdik taraf›ndan yap›lan resmi 37 Kâmil Akdik’in, sülüs-nesih hilyesi (Özlem-Haluk Perk Koleksiyonu) [»N»PFCCn»NCP0GFTGUGK+CVVjVKPµGUNUPGUKJ µFG*CNCVCUCTC[6WNVjPuUKµPGTKMµCJQECU»QNFW µFG%jD»jNKµPKPNC¹XGFKNOGUK\GTKPG'uXjP» +Oj[PµFCMKI{TGXKPFGPGOGMNKQNFW ¼GXXCN$¹WUVQUµVGMGPFKUKPG5GuUµN JCVVjVuPµNKMPXCP»XGTKNFK6WNVCP5G½CFµ»PCT\WUWKNG XGTKNGP5GuUNJCVVjVKPNKMDGTCV»½{[NGFKT Kâmil Akdik hat›ras›na haz›rlanan pul (Süleyman Berk arflivi) Eyüplü Hattatlar %jD»ÃNu6CFCTGVK8\Oj 'uXjP»+Oj[WP ²'uXjP»+Oj[P%G[NKMnKNK¹KPFGPjOGPXKUXGJWVWV»OVGPGXXKC OWCNNKOKTVDGKNjU»P»H»UjPuUKCUJjD»PFCP+CE».jOKN(HGPFKµPKP OGUNG¹KPFGMKOGJCTGVXGKMVKFCT»PCDKPCGPUGPGUK½GJTKTGDKWNGXXGNKPKP IPPFG½GTGHUCF»TQNCPKTjFGKUGPK[[GK+C\TGVK3CFK½jJu OCPVWM»jNuUKXGEJKNGWJFGUKPG5GuUNJCVVCVuPPXCP»VGXEKJM»N»PO»½ QNFW¹WPWOWVC\COO»P'uXjP»+Oj[PµFCPK½DWXGUKMCVCP\KOXGKµVC M»N»PF»7CJTuTGPHKµN [GXOKµNj½KTOKP½GJTK ½GXXjNKNOMGTTGONK UGPGUGNjUGXGUGNjUuPG XGUGNjUGOKGXGGNH³ +CTHKPM»NjD»PFCPUQPTC KUOK+CVVCV0GMVGDKQNCP 0GFTGUGK+CVVCVuPµFGMK JQECN»¹»PFCPUQPTCDW OGMVGDKP*\GN6CPCVNCT $MCFGOKUKµPGMCV»NOCU» KNGJC[CV»P»PUQP [»NNCT»PFCDWQMWNFC[C\» FGTUNGTKXGTFK XG[»NNCT»PFC QNOCM\GTG KMKFGHC0»U»TµCFCXGV GFKNGP.jOKN(HGPFK 0GP[GN.CUT»µPFCMK 3TGPU0GJOGF$NK3C½C 0GUEKFK[C\»NCT»P»[C\F» Kâmil Akdik’in, reîs-ül hattatîn berat› 38 A Kâmil Akdik’in, Hocas› Sami Efendi’nin kabir kitabesindeki celî sülüs yaz›s› ve Kâmil Akdik’in nesih yaz›s› (UMKUVCVNCT»P[C\»NCT»P»UCV»PCNCTCMQPNCT»FKMMCVNGKPEGNGOG[GOGTCMN»QNCP .jOKN(HGPFKµPKP\GPIKPMQNGMUK[QPWDWIP7QRMCR»6CTC[»0\GUK .VRJCPGUKµPFGFKT+CUVCN»¹»U»TCU»PFCU{[NGFK¹K²fNGEG¹KOGICO[GOK[QTWO NjMKP½W[C\»[»{¹TGPGOGFGPIKFK[QTWO³U{\nQMOCPKFCTF»T 39 Kâmil Akdik ve devrin önemli di¤er hattatlar› bir arada sol üst: Hâmid Aytaç, Halil Efendi, Halim Özyaz›c› Oturanlar soldan: Necmeddin Okyay, Kâmil Akdik, ‹smail Hakk› Altunbezer &GOj\K[GNjJKT 7GOOW\VCTKJKPFG XGHCVGFGP.jOKN (HGPFKµPKPMCDTK ([RUWNVCPµFC3K[GTNQVK [QNW\GTKPFG1GEKR)C\»N MCDTK[WMCT»U»PFCF»T2¹NW ¼GTGH$MFKMVCTCH»PFCPEGNu UNUQNCTCM[C\»NCPMCDKT .KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT Kâmil Akdik’in, kabir kitabesi (O¤lu fieref Akdik taraf›ndan yaz›lm›flt›r Eyüplü Hattatlar +WXGµN+CNNjMWµN%jMK +C\jMCDTWµNOGTJO $JOGF.jOKNGNOCµTH DKTGuUKµNJCVVjVuP TCJOGVWNNCJKCNG[J ¼GTGHDKP.jOKN 6GPG&GOj\K[GNCJKT 40 ‹bnülemin, 172; Melek Celâl, Reisülhattatin Kâmil Akdik, ‹stanbul, 1938, s. 6; A. Süheyl Ünver, Reisül Hattatin Hac› Kâmil Akdik, ‹stanbul, Elli San’at Sever Serisi-12, 1954, s.2; M. U¤ur Derman, “Reîsü’l-hattâtîn Kâmil Akdik”, Hayat Tarih Mecmuas›, sy. 7 (A¤ustos 1971), s. 34; a.mlf., Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiaheserleri 1. 49; Rado, 254; Derman, ‹KMHS, 222; a.mlf, Sabanc› Koleksiyonu, ‹stanbul, Akbank, 1995, s. 152-153; a.mlf., letters In Gold, 158-159; Muhittin Serin, Hat Sanat› ve Meflhur Hattatlar, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Akademisi Kültür ve San’at Vakf›, 1999, s. 183-185; Ali Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi, ‹stanbul, Yap› Kredi Yay›nlar›, 2000, s. 95-97. Bu icâzetname bugün TSMK-GY. 325 numaradad›r. Derman, Hayat Tarih Mecmuas›, sy. 7, 1971, s. 37; ‹bnülemin merhumun Son Hattatlar s. 133’de bahsetti¤i “Haflim” asl›nda müstakil bir flah›s de¤il, Ahmed Kâmil Akdik’tir. Bu Berat için bkz. Derman, Hayat Tarih Mecmuas›, sy. 7, 1971, s. 38. (Deri üzerine bizzât Kâmil Akdik taraf›ndan dîvânî ile yaz›lan bu belge 1921 y›l›nda Süheyl Ünver taraf›ndan tezhiplenmifltir. Belge hâlen Topkap› Saray› Müzesi’ndedir.) Bu yaz›lar için bkz. Melek Celâl, Kâmil Akdik. A Alaaddin Bey ºDTCJKO$NCCFFKP%G[VCTKJKPFGFQ¹FW0W\KMCK+Oj[WP FC(UXCD (OKPKXG6C¹MQN$¹CU»KFK<C\»[»¼GHKM%G[{µFGP{¹TGPOK½XGKEj\GV CNCTCMDKTnQMVCNGDG[GVK½VKTOK½VKT'GXTKPKP{PGONKJCVVCVNCT»PFCPF» 3GMnQMUNUPGUKJXGEGNuM»V CXGNGXJC[C\O»½V»T$PNCF»¹»OMCFCT [C\CDKNUG[FKO.C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFKMCFCT[C\CTF»OFGTOK½ 41 Alaaddin Bey’in Befliktafl Sinan Pafla Camii pencere üzerlerinde bulunan celî yaz›lar› (Bu yaz›lar Ocak 2003 tarihinde restorasyon bahanesiyle silinmifltir.) %WU{\0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ%G[K½KVKPEG<C.C\CUMGT(HGPFKCPNCF»¹»MCFCT [C\UCKFKCECDCPCU»N[C\CTF»FGOK½QNFW¹WPW%G½KMVC½N»+CVVCV1WTK(HGPFK PCMNGFGTOK½ $NCGFFKP%G[µFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([R VG¼CJ6WNVCP7GMMGUK MCT½»U»PFCMKMCDTKUVCPFCKFK2TJCPK[G.»½NCU»&COKK PFGMK[C\»NCTXGNGXJCNCT %G½KMVC½ VC6KPCP3C½C&COKKµPKPRGPEGTGNGTKUVPFGMKGNGUOjµNJUPjQPWP GUGTKFKT+GTDKTKPGnKHVKUKO[C\CTCMJC\»TNCF»¹»RCTnCN»M(UOCK+UPj{PGONK GUGTNGTKPFGPFKT¼GHKM%G[µKPVCNGDGUKQNOCU»PCTC¹OGP[C\»UNDW5jM»O (HGPFKµ[GFCJC[CM»PF»T Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹bnülemin, 39; Rado, 226; Ali Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi. ‹stanbul, Yap› Kredi Yay›nlar›, 2000, s. 86 Alaaddin Bey’in Cihangir Camii’nde bulunan celî sülüs levhas› 42 A Ali Efendi (Ketânizâde) ºUVCPDWNNW FWT%CDCU».GVjPE»NCT.GVJFCU»KFK%WUGDGRVGP.GVjPK\jFGNjMCD»[NC VCP»PO»½V»T'Q¹WO[GTK$½»M3C½C0CJCNNGUKQNWR.CTK[G&COKKEKXCT»PFCMKGXKPFG QVWTWTFW +UG[KP+CDNu(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGFGTGM VCTKJKPFGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFK PKPQ¹NW0WUVCHC'GFG PKP [C\»NCT»P»DG¹GPFK¹KKnKPQPWPK\KPFGPIKVOK½XGQPWVCMNKFGVOK½VKTgn.WTµjP» .GTuO[KTOKMCFCTFGNjKNGPCOXGGXTjF[C\O»½V»T.GPFKUKC[P»\COCPFC VW¹TCMG½MGOCPMG½XGOWUKMK½KPCUKFK¼G[J7CVCT$JOGF(HGPFK [GDC¹NCPCTCM 1CM½KDGPFKVCTKMCVKPGIKTOK½VKT 5GDKNCJKT0C[»UVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC3GTVGX3C½C 7TDGUKKNG)GTKFWP3C½C7TDGUKCTCU»PFCF»T Müstakimzâde, 326; Rado, 174 Ali Efendi 43 +C[CV»JCMM»PFCMC[PCMNCTFCDKNIK[QMVWT +CO\CXuOG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK[MUGMQNWR \GTKPFG²+CVVCV$NK(HGPFK³[C\»N»F»T0G\CT VC½»MKVCDGUK+jH»\KO\CN»F»T0G\CTVC½» MKVCDGUKPFGP5COC\CP¼WDCV VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT0G\CTVC½»MKVCDGUK /CµNKcG½OGUKKNG(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹» 0GUEKFKMCT½»U»PFC[QNWPJGOGP[CP»PFC DWNWPOCMVCF»T Gezi notu, M. Nermi Haskan Ali Efendi mezartafl› kitabesi Ali Efendi (Samanizâde) 6COCPK\jFGNCMCD»[NCCP»NOCMVCF»T0WJVGOGNGP,,,6GNKOXG,90WUVCHC FGXTKPFGKMKFGHC½G[JNKUNjOQNCP6COCPK\jFGfOGT+WNUK(HGPFK VQTWPNCT»PFCPF»T$NK(HGPFK([RUWNVCPVTDGFjT»¼CON»5j½KF(HGPFKµFGPXG¼GHKM %G[µFGP[C\»OG½MGVOK½VKT[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 7; Daniflmend, IV, 546-547 Ali R›za Efendi %CDCU»D[M½G[J5j½KF(HGPFKQNCTCMDKNKPGP¼G[J$NK(HGPFK([RgOOK6KPCP 7GMMGUK½G[JKKFK1GUKJUNUXGEGNuUNU[C\OCMVCOjJKTFKº[KNCµN.»TO»\» OTGMMGR[CRCTF»2¹NW1CUJK.CTI»%G[ FKT FGXGHCVGVVK.CDTKC[P» VGMMGPKPJC\KTGUKPFGFKT Tilgen, 7 Eyüplü Hattatlar Ârifi Ahmed Pafla 44 ÃTKHu$JOGF3C½C(DG\jFG0WUVCHC%G[ KP +C\KPGFCT»1WTK%G[KPQ¹NW +CTKEK[G1j\»T»0GJOGF¼GMKD3C½C P»P Q¹NWFWTµFCºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FWf\GN JQECNCTFCPCTCRnCHCTUnCHTCPU»\EC GMQPQOKRQNKVKMCFGXNGVNGTJWMWMWXGLGQNQLK QMWFW2PDG½[C½»PFCKMGPµFG'KXCP» +Oj[P.CNGOK PGIKTFK %CDCU»9K[CPCUGHKTKKMGPQP[GFK[C½»PFC MWTW½OCC½NCUGHjTGVDKTKPEKMjVKDNK¹KPGCVCPF»ºMK UGPGUQPTCºUVCPDWN CF{PF%jDKjNKVGTEOGQFCU»XG jOGFuMCNGOKJWNGHjU»PFCPQNFW9K[CPC.QPITGUKDKTKPEKOTCJJCU»$NK3C½C P»P [CP»PFC9K[CPC [CXG3C½CµP»P3CTKU.QPITGUKOTCJJCUN»¹»PFCFC3CTKU IKVVK %KTVCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWMVCPUQPTC FG9K[CPC6GHKTKQNFW6WNVCP A $DFNC\K\GFGDXG VGTDK[GUKPKXGNKUCP MjDKNK[GVKPKVCMFKT GVVK¹KPFGPDKTUGPG UQPTC'KXCP»+Oj[P VGTEOCPN»¹»PCIGVKTFK FG0CCTKH1j\»T» C[P»UGPGKnKPFG$FNK[G 1j\»T»XGKMKPEKFGHC 9K[CPC6GHKTKQNFW<KPG DKTVCM»O[MUGM OGOWTK[GVNGTFG DWNWPFWMVCPUQPTC ¼CDCV7GOOW\ VCTKJKPFGUCFTC\CO QNFW)CMCVnC[KnKPFG C\NGFKNFK¼WTC[»'GXNGV 5GKUKQNFW'G¹K½KM VCTKJNGTFGDWI{TGXGn FGHCIGVKTKNFK &GOC\K[GNjJKT $TCN»MVCTKJKPFG &C¹CNQ¹NW PFCMK MQPC¹»PFCXG[C½»PFC QNFW¹WJCNFGXGTGOFGP XGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC%QUVCPºUMGNGUK6QMC¹»\GTKFGXG0KJTK½CJ6WNVCP OG\CTN»¹»PFC5GDKWNCJKT$TCN»MµFGXGHCVGFGPDCDCU»0GJOGF¼GMKD 3C½C P»P[CP»PFCF»T.KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT ²(HjJKOKXMj[»6CNVCPCV»6GPK[[GFGPOGENKUKOCJUWU»XMGNj[COG OWT KMGPKTVKJCNKFjT»DGMjGFGP6CFT»GUDCMOGTJWOXGOC¹HWTEGPPGVOGMjP $JOGFÃTKHu3C½CºDPK0GJOGF¼GMKD3C½C P»PTWJKnPT»\CGP/KNNjJK7C jNGµN HjVKJC EWOCFGNjJKT[GXOK3GT½GODG³ 5KM CJCVV»P»K[K[C\CPNCTFCPF»ºVKPCKNG[C\CTXGTGUKO[CRCTIKDKKO\CCVCTF» ‹bnülemin, 661; Mehmed Süreyya. Sicill-i Osmânî. III, ‹stanbul, 1281, s. 279-280; Mehmed Zeki Pakal›n. Son Sadrazamlar ve Baflvekiller. (I-IV), ‹stanbul, Ahmet Sait Matbaas›, 1944, c. III, s. 378- 417; M. Tayyib Gökbilgin, “Ârifî Pafla”, ‹A, c. I, 568-570; ‹smail Hami Daniflmend, ‹zahl› Osmanl› Tarihi Kronolojisi (I-IV), ‹stanbul, Türkiye Yay›nevi, 1971, c. IV, s. 217-316; ‹bnülemin, Son Sadrazamlar, 961 Ârifi Ahmed Pafla mezartafl› kitabesi 45 Aziz Azmi Efendi ([RµPUQPCU»TFCVCP»PO»½JCVVCVNCT»PFCPF»T0KJTK½CJ0GMVGDKµPFGÃMKH (HGPFKµFGPQMWOW½XGJjH»\QNOW½VWT$[P»OGMVGRVGUNUPGUKJJQECU»=GMjK 'GFG(HGPFKµFGP[C\»OG½MGVOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T<C\»NCT»P»PQNFWMnCI\GN QNFW¹WPCMNGFKNOK½VKT5GUOKDKTOCVDCCFCXC\KHGNKKFK2\COCPNCT([RµGDC¹N»M{[ QNCP.C¹»VJjPGµFGGVOK½VKT C. Server Revnako¤lu, Eyüplü Hattatlar. Dosya, Divan Edebiyat› Müzesi C. Server Revnako¤lu Arflivi. Bâyezid Efendi 'CJC{PEG6CFT»$PCFQNWQNCP.»T»Ou0GJOGF(HGPFKµPKPMGVJFCU»+CE»<WUWH (HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNCP%j[G\KF(HGPFK([RNFT .jVKR\jFG0GJOGF5GHK(HGPFKµFGPVCµNuMOG½MGVVK¼jKTNK¹KFGQNCP%j[G\KF(HGPFK 6WNVCP,0CJOWFFGXTKPKPK[KJCVVCVNCT»FCPF»T+[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Suyolcuzâde 24; Müstakimzâde, 654; Tilgen, 8; Rado, 147. Eyüplü Hattatlar Cafer Çelebi (Kirli) 46 ([RNQNCP&CHGTcGNGDK²MKTNK³NjMCD»[NCOG½JWTFWT+CVJQECU»6W[QNEW\jFG 0WUVCHC(HGPFKFKT5COC\CP(MKOVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK'GXTKPKP VCP»PPCPJCVVCVNCT»PFCPF»T Müstakimzâde, 150; Rado, 102; Tilgen, 8 C Celâleddin Efendi ([RN FT<C\»[»%CMMCNÃTKH(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK$[P»\COCPFCOEGNNKF O\GJJKDXGOWUKMK½KPCUQNCP&GNCNGFFKP(HGPFK([RUWNVCP&COKKJCVKRNGTKPFGPFK FCXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([R VG.KTRCUK7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT)CMCVVC½»OGXEWV FG¹KNFKT Tilgen, 8 Cemal Günter (Bektâfli Cemal) %GMVj½K&GOCN%CDCNjMCD»[NCCP»N»T[»N»PFC([R VGFQ¹OW½VWT7CJUKNKPK ([R.CNGPFGTJCPG0GMVGDK PFGXG0GFTGUGV NJCVVCVKP FG[CRCTCMOGTJWO+CE» .jOKN$MFKM VGPKEj\GVCNO»½V»T([R+GMKO.WVDGFFKP0GMVGDK PFG[C\»JQECN»¹» [CRO»½QNCP&GOCN*PVGT([R&COKKµPFGMC[[»ON»MFC [CRO»½V»T Tilgen, 8; Cemal Günter’in vefat y›l› ile alâkal› olarak, Eyüplü hattat Râflid Efendi’nin torunu A. Cenap Yazansoy, kendisinin Cemal Bey’i tan›makla birlikte ölüm y›l›n› tam olarak hat›rlamad›¤›n›, Cemal Bey’in mânevî evlâd›n›n o¤lunun da vefat tarihini tam olarak hat›rlamad›¤›n› ancak, 1968-1970 y›llar› aras› vefat etmifl olabilece¤ini kendisine söyledi¤ini bize beyan etmifllerdir. M. U¤ur Derman Bey de vâki sualimiz üzerine, kendisinin de vefat tarihini tam hat›rlayamad›¤›n› ancak, 1963 y›l›nda hayatta oldu¤unu bildi¤ini belirtmifllerdir. (S. Berk) Cemil Efendi ([RNQNWR.CRVCP»'GT[j+CUCP+UP3C½C P»P CT\WUW\GTKPGUNUJCVNCDKT.WTµjP».GTuO[C\O»½V»T $[P»\COCPFC%CJTK[G0CVDCCU»JCVVCVNCT»PFCPQNCP 0GJOGF&GOKN(HGPFK PKPºUVCPDWNµWPnG½KVNK JC\KTGNGTKPFGEGNuUNUXGEGNuVCµNuMKNG[C\F»¹» OG\CTVC½».KVjDGNGTKPKI{TOGMOOMPFT&GOKN (HGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK Tilgen, 8 Hattat Cemil Efendi taraf›ndan yaz›lm›fl celî sülüs mezartafl› kitabesi 47 Dervifl ‹brahim Efendi (Mezarc›zâde) 0G\CTE»\jFGFK[GOG½JWTFWT<C\»[»(¹TKMCR»N»5jUKO(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFK ([RUWNVCP&COKK[CP»PFCMKCMVCTFMMCP»PFC.WTµjP».GTKO[C\CTF»%W[\FGP $MVCT+QECCF»[NCVCP»PO»½V»T FGXGHCVGVVK.CDTKPKP[GTKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT 0UVCMKO\jFGµPKPKHCFGUK[NG'GTXK½ºDTCJKODKP+CUCP([RUWNVCP&COKK [CP»PFCDKTCVVCTFMMCP»PFCQVWTWTXGOGUjJKHK½GTKHGXGFGNjKNKOPKHG .KVjDGVKPGUC [\GTGFKTºDVKFC.jFKTK[[Gµ[GUjNKMUQPTC¼G[J$DFWNNCJf\DGMu .C½IjTu7GMMGUK½G[JKFGPPKUDGVK1CM½KDGPFK[G [GOjNKMQNWD\COCP»P»P+QEC $VVCT »F»T Müstakimzâde, 31; Tilgen, 9; Rado, 172 Eyüplü Hattatlar Dervifl Mustafa Efendi 0GXjNKµFGPMCF»NCTFCP.CTCcGNGDK0GJOGF(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNCP'GTXK½0WUVCHC (HGPFKOGFTGUGVCJUKNKI{TO½OFGTTKUQNOW½UQPTC+CNGRXG%WTUC MCF»N»MNCT»PFCDWNWPOW½VWT'Q¹WO[GTKQNCP([RUWNVCP CF{PFMVGPUQPTC 5GDKNGXXGN(MKOµFCXGHCVGVVK.GPFKUKC[P»\COCPFC½jKTFK 'GTXK½OG½TGDCMTCP»PCUVPjNKEGPjDDKT\jVKFK0WUKMuFGFCJKUVjFQNFW¹W (UCF(HGPFKVG\MKTGUKPFG[C\»N»F»T 7C NKM[C\»[»'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK{ FGP{¹TGPOK½XG.jVKD\jFG .C\CUMGT0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPFK FGPFGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T6WNVCP,0CJOWF CDKTnQM MKVCR[C\O»½V»T Suyolcuzâde 51; Müstakimzâde, 743-744; Tilgen, 9; Rado, 164 Ebubekir A¤a ºUVCPDWN(¹TKMCR»µFC[GVK½OK½VKT<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK{ FGP{¹TGPFKfOTP.WTµjP».GTuO[C\OCMNCIGnKTOK½XG6WNVCP,,, $JOGFUCNVCPCV»P»PKNM[»NNCT»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Suyolcuzade, 14; Tilgen, 9 48 E Ebubekir Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWQNWR$JOGF(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT6NUXGPGUKJJCVV»6W[QNEW\jFG 0WUVCHC([[WDu FGP{¹TGPFKFCJCUQPTCVC NKMFGOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF»<C½» [GVOK½GXCTF»¹»PFC[GVOK½.WTµCP».GTKO[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWTµFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTK(¹TKMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T Müstakimzâde, 134-135; Rado, 133 Ebubekir Vâhid Efendi 0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKPFG²7CTuMK1CM½»DGPFK[[GFGPJCVVCV(DDGMKT(HGPFK³QNCTCM MC[FGFKNOK½VKT.KVjDG[GI{TG[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT .C[PCMNCTFCKUOKIGnOGOGMVGFKT.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFC½jKT%jMKMCDTK KNGTKUKPFGFKT Gezi Notu:, M. Nermi Haskan 49 Ebubekir Vâhid Efendi’nin mezartafl› kitabesi Esma ‹bret Han›m Eyüplü Hattatlar µFGFQ¹FW¹WVCJOKPGFKNOGMVGFKT0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKPµFGPJCVFGTUKCNF» +QECU»PFCPKEj\GVCNF»¹»PFCMGPFKUKPG²ºDTGV³U»HCV»XGTKNFK%WU»HCVMGPFKUKPG [C\»FCI{UVGTFK¹KUVPDC½CT»FCPFQNC[»XGTKNFK<C\»UNRNCT»0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP KNGC[P»F»TXG[C\»FCMWFTGVNKDKTGNGUCJKRVKT+QECU»0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKPKNG GXNGPFK Hattat Esma ‹bret’e ait sülüs-nesih Hilye (T‹EM) 50 E Hattat Esma ‹bret’e ait sülüs-nesih k›t’a +VCTKJNKJKN[GUKMCHVCPE»0GJOGF6CNKO $¹CVCTCH»PFCP,,,6GNKOµGVCMFKOGFKNOK½VKT (½KPKP[C\»NCT»P»DC½CT»N»DKT½GMKNFGVCMNKF GVVK¹KTKXj[GVQNWPWT fNOVCTKJKDGNNKQNOC[CP(UOCºDTGV+CP»O ([R1K½CPE»¼G[J0WTCF'GIjJ»µPFC OGFHWPQNWROG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK[QMVWT Topkap› Saray› Müzesi’nde bulunan ve kendisinin yazd›¤› bir hilye arkas›nda, hilyeyi yazd›¤› tarihte onbefl yafl›nda oldu¤u kay›tl›d›r. Hilye h. 1209 tarihli oldu¤una göre tahminen h. 1194 senesinde do¤du¤u ileri sürülmektedir. (Bkz. ‹bnülemin, 87; Derman, ‹KMHS, 205) Mahmud Tâhir, ‹kdam Gazetesi, 10 Ekim 1907. Habib, 166; ‹bnülemin, 87-88; Derman, ‹KMHS, 205-206; Rado, 200-201. Esma ‹bret’e ait nesih yaz› 51 Fatma Mevhibe fierîfe Han›m Fatma Mevhibe Han›m mezartafl› kitabesi +CUKD3C½CµP»PM»\»F»T<C\»[»JCMMjM\jFG0WUVCHC 9CUHK(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVVK%CDCU»+CUKD3C½C 0CNK[GXG(XMjH%CMCPN»MNCT»PFCDWNWPOW½VWT .CDTKgUMFCT6GNKOK[G&COKK+C\KTGUKµPFGFKT )CVOC0GXJKDG+CP»OVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK0KJTK½CJ6WNVCP7TDGUK+C\KTGUKµPFGFKT OG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT (HjJKOKXMGNj[ºUCNVCPCVºUGPK[[GFGP (XMjHº+Oj[WP1j\ºTº'GXNGVN (N+jE0GJOGF+CUKD3C¼CJC\TGVNGTKPKP .GTuOGKOWJVGTGOGNGTKXG+C\uPGKOG\DTG 7CJUKNCVOFT¹\\GVNKGN+jE0GJOGF(OKP %G[GHGPFKPKPJCNuNGNGTKOGTJOGXGOC¸HTWPNGJC +CVVjVG»GTuHG)jVºOC0GXJKDGJCPºOGHGPFKPKP 5JW¼GTuHKnWPGN)CVKJC 6GPG .GVGDGJW0GJOGF=GMKGN0GXNGXK Eyüplü Hattatlar Tezhibli bir hilyesi Topkap› Saray› Müzesi’nde bulunmaktad›r. Esmâ ‹bret’ten sonra önemli bir hattatt›r. Sicill-i Osmâni, II, 180-181; ‹bnülemin, 639; Mehmet Zeki Pakal›n. Maliye Teflkilât› Tarihi, Ankara, 1977, s. 117-136; Rado, 212. Eyüp Mihriflah Sultan Türbesi Haziresi’nde Fatma Mevhibe Han›m lahdi 52 F Ferhad Pafla )GTJCF3C½CVCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW$U»NKUOK0GJOGFQNWR)GTJCF NjMCD»KNGCP»NO»½V»T%CDCU».»DT»UHCVKJK/CNC0WUVCHC3C½C F»T(PFGTWP FC [GVK½OK½KMKPEKMCR»E»DC½»XGµFG<GPKnGTK$¹CU»XGµFG.CUVCOQPW 6CPEC¹»KNG%G[NGTDG[KQNFWµFG.jPPK6WNVCP6NG[OCP »PQ¹NW¼GJ\jFG 0GJOGF KPM»\»+Oj½jJ6WNVCP NCGXNGPFKTKNFK$[P»UGPG3CFK½CJ NCDGTCDGT =KIGVXCTUGHGTK PGMCV»NF»'¹PJGFK[GUKQNCTCMMGPFKUKPG%j[G\KF&COKKJCTGOKPG PC\»TDKTUCTC[KP½CGFKNFK¼GXXCN¼WDCVVCTKJKPFGDCDCU»PFCPCNV» UGPGGXXGNXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKKEKXCT»PFCXG%G[DCDC6QMC¹» P»PUQN M{½GUKPG[CM»PDKT[GTFGFKT/CJFKOGXEWVVWT 53 Ferhad Pafla’n›n nesih yaz›s› (T‹EM) Ferhad Pafla lahdi kitâbesi Eyüplü Hattatlar )GTJCF3C½C P»P+Oj½jJ6WNVCP FCP0WUVCHC$¹C+CE»3C½C+CUCP%G[{ 2UOCP%G[{ºDTCJKO3C½C{XG+UP%G[CFN»Q¹WNNCT»KNG)CVOC +CP»O6WNVCPCFN»DKTM»\»QNOW½VWT)CVOC+CP»O6WNVCPµFGXGHCVGVVK 7TDGUK¼GJ\jFGDC½»&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT$PPGUK+Oj½jJ6WNVCPKUGDCDCU» ¼GJ\jFG0GJOGF7TDGUK PFGXGQPWPUQNVCTCH»PFCOGFHWPFWT )GTJCF3C½C P»P{NOPGECJKNDKTFQMVQTWPUGDGRQNFW¹WKFFKCQNWPOW½VWT 6GNjPKMNK0WUVCHC(HGPFKDWQNC[»VCTKJKPFG½{[NGCPNCV»T 54 (TMjPºFGXNGVXGC[jPºUCjFGVGTMGPFGPFKXjPºFC¸ºVºREGPC\GUKPGJC\ºT QNFWNCT9\GTj[º³K\COJC\TGVNGTKKnKPFGD{[NGJQ¼PXKUGJNKMCNGOX\GTj IGNOGOK¼VKTFK[GPCMNQNWPWT (TVGUK'KXjPºjNK´[GHTGPMVGPOUNOCPQNOC[CNCPEºVCDKDMºUOºPFCPDKT ¼CJºU)GTJCF3C¼C PºPCFCONCTº[NCIGNKRFCXCEºQNWR(HGPFKOK\GICFTW JC[HQNFW.QEC»EC JGMKOC[jPºUCjFGVJCVºTNCTºKnKPCPCMº[Fº OGUKTFKMQUXGTFKFGFK (NDGVVGFCXCI{TNUPFG[W6C jFGVN3CFK¼CJ+C\TGVNGTK PFGPFCJK VG\MGTGK¼GTKHIGNFK 5GKU KGVºDDjQNCP*CTUFFKP\jFGXGUKVjPGKUC jFGVGJK\OGVGFGPWNGOjXG »EC VCDKDKNGEONGVGP'KXjP CnC¸TºNºRX\GTCXGMC\CUMGTNGTJW\WTWPFC FCXCQNWPFW5GKUKJMGOjXGGVºDDCKVVKHCMKNGFGFKNGTMK¹MK[ºNFCPHC\NC )GTJCF3C¼COGUjPGJCUVCNº¸ºPCORVGNjKFK9GJGTDKTKOK\PKEGMGTG HC[FCNºKNCnNCTKNGJK\OGVGVVKM+CUVCNº¸ºPºDKNK[QTFWMDVPJKMOGV F Ferhad Pafla’n›n kabrinin bulundu¤u mezarl›¤›n genel görünümü MKVCRNCTºPFC0GUKTFKMQUDWJCUVCNº¸CK[KFKTFK[G[C\ºNOº¼VºT6Q¸WMMº¼ IPNGTKPFGQN\CJOGFGNDGVVGJCTGMGVGFGT.CPWPXG»KHj FC[C\ºNFº¸º\GTG »G[J»EC OGUKTKPFGP[GUGOTCJCVQNWTWOFK[GJQ¼PWVQNWR¼MTCP I{UVGTKTFK 6QPTCDWECJKNJGMKOKIGVKTOK¼NGT6QPTC.QEC»WEC [ºFCXGVGVOK¼NGTIKVOGM KUVGOGOK¼+CUVCFºTGNDGVVGIGNOGPK\NC\ºOFºTFK[GºUTCTGFKNKPEGXCTºR I{TO¼NGTPCD\ºPC[CRº¼VºMVCRGJTK\KDQ\OW¼UWP[KPG0GUKTFKMQU[GOGM HC[FCNºFºTFGOK¼+KMOGV\GTGUCJKJU{[NGOK¼DWPCICFTQNFWFGOGM ICTC\FºTFGFKNGT)CMCVDWPCTC¸OGP»G[J»WEC*\GN0GJOGFPCOnCXW¼ GNKPGJCRUGXGTKNFK»GXXCN 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»NCT»P»OG½JWTJCVVCV.CTCJKUCTK FGP{¹TGPOK½XGDKTnQM.WT jP» .GTKO[C\O»½V»T&GPC\GOCUTCHNCT»P»P[C\F»¹»DW.WTµjP».GTKONGTµFGPMC\CPF»¹» RCTCKNGMCT½»NCPOCU»P»XCUK[GVGVOK½VKT Habib, 129; Gültekin Oransay, Osmanl› Devleti'nde Kim Kimdi. Ankara, Kü¤ Yay›nlar›, 1969, c. I, s. 172-189; Sicill-i Osmânî, c. I, 87-88, c. IV, 16; Selânikî Mustafa Efendi, Tarih-i Selânki, Haz. Mehmed ‹pflirli, ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yay›nlar›, 1989, c. I-II, s. 15, 27, 36, 55, 110, 111, 171, 454; Ayvansarâyî (Hâf›z Hüseyin b. ‹smâil). Hadîkat'ül-cevâmi’ ‹stanbul, 1281, c. I, s.15; Müstakimzâde , 355; Ayvansarâyî, Vefeyât-› Selâtîn ve Meflâhir-i Ricâl (Haz. Fahri Ç. Derin) ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yay›nlar›, 1978, s. 25; Reflad Ekrem Koçu “Ferhad Pafla Cami'” ‹stanbul Ansiklopedisi, (‹st. A.), c. X, 5670; M. Tayyib Gökbilgin, Edirne ve Pafla livas›, ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yay›nlar›, 1952, s. 431-432, 499; Mehmed Nermi Haskan, Eyüp Tarihi, 190; Kemal Ç›¤, “Hattat Vezirler”, Tarih Dünyas›, 1950, c. 2 sy. 10, s. 429; Rado, 76; fiule Aksoy, “ Hezarfen bir Hattat Necmeddin Okyay: Hayat› ve Türk ve ‹slâm Eserleri Müzesinde Bulunan Kitaplar›”, M.U¤ur Derman, 65.Yafl Arma¤an›, ‹stanbul, Sabanc› Üniversitesi Yay›n›, 2000, s.90 55 Feyhaman Duran Eyüplü Hattatlar ºDTCJKO)G[JCOCP'WTCP1GX½GJKTNK'COCV ºDTCJKO3C½CµP»PM»\»P»PCJHjF»PFCP5UOjV (OjPGVKOWCXKP[CTF»OE»U»(PFGTPK6NG[OCP +C[TK%G[{µKPQ¹NWFWT0WJCTTGO ([NNµFC.CF»M{[µFGFQ¹FW *CNCVCUCTC[/KUGUKµPFGQMW[WROG\WPQNFWMVCP UQPTCDG½UGPGMCFCTDWNKUGFG{¹TGVOGPNKM[CRV» 5GUKOFGMKMjDKNK[GVK3TGPU$DDCU+CNKO3C½C VCTCH»PFCPVCMFKTGFKNGTGMTGUKOVCJUKNGVOGMKnKP $XTWRCµ[CI{PFGTKNFK3CTKU6CPC[KK1GHuUG Feyhaman Duran’a ait bir levha 56 F QMWNWPFC.QTOQPXG-CPRQN /QTCPUµ»PCV{N[GNGTKFGnCN»½V» ºUVCPDWNµCF{P½PFG.»\6CPC[KK 1GHuUG2MWNWµPFCTGUKOJQECN»¹»PC CVCPF»µFG*\GN6CPCVNCT CV{N[G{¹TGVOGPNK¹KPGCVCPF» +CVVCV6jOK(HGPFKµFGP *CNCVCUCTC[6WNVjPuUK[C\»JQECU» º\\GV(HGPFKµFGPXG0CJOWF%G[ 0CVDCCU»JCVVCV»7CJUKP (HGPFKµFGP[C\»OG½MGVOK½VKT *\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUKTGUKO JQECU»KMGP[C½JCFFKPFGPGOGMNK QNFW (XKPFGTGUKO[CROCM[C\» [C\OCMKNGOG½IWNKMGP0C[»U VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK (FKTPGMCR»6CM»\C¹CE»¼GJKVNK¹K $FC,DNQMVCF»T<CP»PFC [»N»PFCXGHCVGFGPFG¹GTNK CTMCFC½»$6JG[NgPXGTµKPMCDTK XCTF»T ‹bnülemin, 95; Feyhaman, ‹stanbul, Devlet Güzel Sanatlar Akademisi Yüksek Resim Bölümü 1970 Yay›nlar›, 1970, 26 s. Feyhaman Duran’›n celî sülüs yaz›s› Feyhaman Duran’›n Edirnekap› fiehitli¤i’ndeki kabri 57 Feyzi ‹brahim Efendi ([RN FT<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFK([R&G\GTu.jU»O 3C½C&COKKKOCO»QNFW¹WKnKPcGNGDKºOCONjMCD»[NCFCVCP»PO»½V»T1GUKJ[C\»KNG DKTnQM.WTµjP».GTuOXGTKM CXGVjµNKM[C\»KNGDKTnQMNGXJC[C\F».WT jP».GTKO K QPFG¹K½KMWUWNKNGQMWFW¹WKnKP¼G[J NMWTTjQNOW½VWT+CVVCVN»¹»[CP»U»TC½jKTNK¹K FGXCTF»7CTKJF½TOGFGOjJKTQNFW¹WTKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKTVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTKPKP[GTKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT Suyolcuzâde, 102; Müstakimzâde, 53-54; Tilgen, 10; Rado, 138-139 Gafuri Efendi ([RNQNWR([RUWNVCPVTDGFCT»KFK<C\»[»(OKT(HGPFK\jFG6G[[KF$DFNJCNKO (HGPFK{µFGP{¹TGPFK9GHCVVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT Tilgen, 10 Habibe Hatun Eyüplü Hattatlar .C[PCMNCTFCJC[CV»KNGKNIKNKDKTDKNIKOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT6CFGEGOG\CTVC½» MKVCDGUKPFGMKMC[»VVCPJCVVCVQNFW¹WCPNC½»NOCMVCF»TVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVOK½VKT+CO\CXK½GMNKPFGMKOG\CTVC½»MKVCDGUK([RUWNVCP&COKKM»DNG[{PPFG 'WMjMK0GJOGF3C½C7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT/CJFKDGVQPNCVCOKTGFKNOK½QNWR UCFGEGDC½VC½»OGXEWVVWT0G\CTVC½»MKVCDGUK½{[NGFKT +WXG´N+CNNjMW´N%jMK $NNCJWUDJjPGJXGVGjNj 0GTJOGXGOC¸HTG &GPPGVOGMjPºHKTFGXUK ¼K[jPJCVVjVG +CDuDG+CPºOTWJWPC 9GEGOuKO´OKPuPXGOOKPjVC 5CJOGVG[NG[G (N)jVKJC Gezi Notu, M. Nermi Haskan Habibe Hatun mezartafl› kitabesi 58 H Habibe Han›m .C[PCMNCTFCJC[CV»KNGKNIKNKDKTDKNIK[QMVWT'QNC[»U»[NCMKOFGPFGTUXGKEj\GV CNF»¹»DGNNKFG¹KNFKT.CDTK)GUJjPGECFFGUKKNG.»\»NFG¹KTOGP6QMC¹»µP»PDKTNG½VK¹K [GTFG0QNNCcGNGDKCF»KNGCP»NCP0GJOGF9WUNK(HGPFK7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPFGXG +WDDK+CVWP7TDGUKµPKPUQNVCTCH»PFCF»TVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT %C½VC½»P»P\GTKPFGOGTOGTDKTNCJCPC½GMNKDWNWPOCMVCF»T%WVC½VCPFQNC[»FC %8JCP»O»P0GT\KHQPNWQNFW¹WCPNC½»NOCMVCF»TcPMGUMKFGPCVN»URQTKMKIWTWR CTCU»PFC[CR»N»T$U[CN»NCTFCPQNW½CPCVN»D{N¹G²%CO[CE»NCT³0GT\KHQPNWNCTFCP QNW½CPD{N¹GFG²/CJCPCE»NCT³FGPKNKTFK$[CMVC½»PFCDWNWPCPMKVCDGFG½WPNCT [C\»N»F»T gUMDNOCJCNNGUKKOCOº (U6G[[KFG¼»G[J+jHº\0WUVCHC 0WJ[KFFKP(HGPFK´PKPXjNKFGUK +CVVCVG+CDKDGJCPºO 5WJWPCTº\jGPNKNNjJK´NHjVKJC At›f Kahraman, Osmanl› Devletinde Spor, s. 445 59 Eyüp’te Habibe Han›m mezartafl› kitabesi Hâf›z Mehmed Pafla (Küçük Çavufl) 6G[[KF¼GTKH0CJOWF3C½CFK[GDKNKPKT .nMcCXW½NjMCRN»F»T.GPFKUK'GTIjJ» jNKcCXW½NCT» PFCPKMGPKNGTNG[GTGM 'GHVGTFjT»¼»MM»6jPKXG FG <GPKnGTK$¹CU»QNFW$[P»UGPGPKP$TCN»M C[»P»PUQPWPFCXG\KTXG0»U»T9CNKUKQNFW ½CDCP»PFC$¹WUVQUµFCC\NGFKNFK ºUVCPDWN CIGNKRVGXMKHQNWPFWKUGFGUQPTC CHHQNWPFW.»UCDKTOFFGVUQPTCXGHCV GVVK .GPFKUKJjH»\XGJCVVCVV».CDTK([R VG 6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK&COKK JC\KTGUKPFGFKT7WJHGKJjVVjVuP FGMC[»VN» FG¹KNFKT.CDKT.KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 0GTJWOJCVVCV +jHº\0GJOGF3C¼C 5JKnWPHjVKJC Eyüplü Hattatlar Sicill-i Osmânî IV, 164 60 Haf›z Yahya Vehbi Efendi +CVVCV/C\fOGT(HGPFK PKPVCNGDGUKQNWR µFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(¹TKMCR» OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T)CMCVVC½»[QMVWT%[M DQ[.GNjO».CFKO NGTKnQMVWT.»UCDQ[NW NjVKHDKT\jVQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPWT ‹bnülemin; 458 Haf›z Mehmed Pafla kabir kitabesi H Hakk› Bey +jH»\ºUOCKN+CMM»%G[QNCTCMCP»N»TF»+QEC1CKO(HGPFKCF»PFCDKT\jV»PQ¹NWFWT <C\»[»)KNKDGNK%CMMCN$JOGFÃTKH(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT6QPTCNCT»%CM»TM{[ %[M&COKKKOCO»XGFCJCUQPTCFCQD{NIGPKPOHVUQNOW½VW[»N»PFC XGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 10 Hâlid Efendi VCTKJKPFG([RUWNVCPµFCFQ¹FW %CDCU»+\+jNKFVTDGFCTNCT»PFCPJCVVCV ¼CON»+jH»\0WJCOOCF5j½KF(HGPFKµFKT 0GMVGDKV»DDK[GK½jJjPGµFGPOG\WP QNOW½XGONj\KOKGXXGNQNOW½VWT%W CTCFCDCDCU»PFCPJCVFGTUNGTKCNF» 5GDKWNGXXGN.CU»O cCT½CODCIP[KTOK[GFK[C½»PFCXGHCV GVVK.CDTK.C½IjTK7GMMGUK[CM»P»PFCUQN VCTCHVCMKUGV\GTKPFGOWUKMK½KPCU=GMjK 'GFG(HGPFKCKNGUQHCU»P»PJGOGP [CP»PFCF»T 61 Gezi Notu, M. Nermi Haskan Hattat Halid Efendi’nin mezartafl› kitabesi Hasan Bin Abdüssamed 6COUWPNW FWT%CDCU»$EGOFK[CT»PFCPIGNOK½VKT6NUXGPGUKJK$NKD<CJ[C 6Hu FGP[C\F»6QPTCºUVCPDWNMCF»U»QNFW)CVKJ6WNVCP0GJOGF+CPQPWUVjF MCDNGVOK½VKT3CFK½CJCDKT6KJCJ»&GXJGTu[C\O»½V»TMK&GXJGTK PKPDW$TCRnC U{\N¹PPG½KGOUjNKQNOCF»¹»7GOuOK7CTKJK PFG[C\»N»F»T %WU{\NMFCJCUQPTC9CPMWNW0GJOGF(HGPFK{VCTCH»PFCPVGTEOG GFKNOK½XGºDTCJKO0VGHGTTKMC P»P FCMWTOW½QNFW¹WOCVDCCFCKNMGUGT QNCTCMDCU»NO»½V»T .GPFKUKPKP0WMCFFGOjV»GTDCCKVGETKF GJC½K[GUKXG6G[[KF¼GTKH KPOWJVCUCT JC½K[GUKPGVC NKMCV»XCTF»TVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP7TDGUK JC\KTGUKPFGQNWRUG[[KFKVC½»OGXEWVVWT Sicill-i Osmânî, II, 118; Müstakimzâde, 159; Hadîka, 248; Habib, 107-108; E. Hakk› Ayverdi, Fatih Devri Hattatlar› ve Hat Sanat›. ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Fethi Cemiyeti, 1953, s. 40; Rado, 47 Hasan Haflimi Çelebi (Seyyid) +CNGDNKQNCPDKTJjH»\+CUCP+j½KOKºUVCPDWN CIGNGTGMFGXTKPUVjF»5COC\CP (HGPFK{µFGPJUPKJCVOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T%WCTCFC(D ºUJCMºUOCKN(HGPFK FGPHGPFGTUNGTKCNO»½XG<GFKMWNGEKXCT»PFCMK0KTjJWT ºOTCJQT&COKKµPGKOCOQNOW½VWT%KTnQM.WTµjP».GTuO[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWT ¼CJ6WNVCPVGMMGUK½G[JK0KHVCJK\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK\COCP»PFCVCTKMCVGIKTOK½ $JOGF(HGPFKµPKPCOECQ¹NW5GUN(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWºUOCKN(HGFKµ[GFCOCVQNOW½VWT 5COC\CP7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK$[P»VGMMGFGVQRTC¹CXGTKNOK½VKT <GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKDW\jV»PQ¹NWUG[[KF$DFNJCNKOKUGVQTWPWFWT Müstakimzâde, 165; Habib, 107; Rado, 104-105; Derman, ‹KMHS, 20 Eyüplü Hattatlar Hasan Pafla 62 +CVVCV+CUCP3C½CQNCTCMDKNKPKT7QTQOCP+CUCP$¹Cµ[»MCVNGVOGUK\GTKPG (PFGTPK+Oj[WPµFC½{JTGVQNWR0uTjJWT»GXXGNQNOW½VWT7QTQOCP+CUCP $¹C,0WUVCHCFGXTKPFG%jDWµUUCCFG$¹CU»KMGPQU»TCFC½GJ\jFGQNCP,,2UOCP ,90WTCF.jU»O%j[G\KF,ºDTjJKOµG,0WUVCHCVCTCHVCTNCT»PECKUVGPGPUWKMCUVK JC\»TNCO»½HCMCVJCVVCV+CUCP3C½C'KNK3uTKXG6CT»9GNKKNGDKTNG½GTGM7QTQOCP +CUCP$¹Cµ[»{NFTO½NGTFKT +CUCP3C½C5GEGR¼WDCVVCTKJKPFG,90WTCF\COCP»PFC<GPKnGTK$¹CU» QNOW½HCMCVM»UCOFFGVUQPTCC\NGFKNOK½VKT$[P»UGPG¼CDCP0CTV VCTKJKPFG%QUPCXCNKUKQNFWVCTKJPFGRCFK½CJVCTCH»PFCPMCVNGFKNOGUK GOTGFKNFK¹KPFG%QUPCµFCUCMNCPF»'CJCUQPTCUGUUK\EGºUVCPDWNµCIGNGTGMKP\KXj[C nGMKNFKMKOUGPKPIGNFK¹KPFGPJCDGTKQNOCF»DWJCNFGKMGPXGHCVGVVK +CUCP3C½CµP»P[C½CF»¹»FGXKT2UOCPN»FGXNGVKPKPGPU»M»PV»N»F{PGOKFKT <GPKnGTKNGTKU[CPGVOK½XGFG¹GTNKDKTXG\KTQNCP+jH»\$JOGF3C½CMCVNGFKNOK½VKT .CDTK2VCME»NCTµFC$DFWTTCJOCP¼GTGH%G[&CFFGUK\GTKPFGXGDWIP[GTKPFG H CRCTVOCPNCTDWNWPCP¼G[J$\K\0CJOWF+FjK+COCO»U»TCU»PFCF»T'GHPGFKNFK¹K JC\KTGOGXEWVHCMCVVC½»OGXEWVFG¹KNFKT Ayvansarâyi, Vefeyat, 30; a. mlf. Mecmua-i Tevârih, 356; Sicill-i Osmâni, II/133; Daniflmend, III/271; Müstakimzâde, 165-166 Hasan Tahsin Hilmi Efendi +jH»\ºUOjKN(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNWRJ µFG7QRJCPGcWMWTEWOCµFC FP[C[CIGNFKcWDWMnWNCT6»D[CP 0GMVGDKµPFGQMW[WRJjH»\QNFW 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»¼GHKM%G[µFGP VCµNuM[C\»[»KUG6jOK(HGPFKµFGP OG½MGVVK*CNCVCUCTC[6WNVjPKUK[C\» JQECU»0GJOGFº\\GV(HGPFKµFGPKUG TKMµCOG½MGVOK½VKT'CTWNOWCNNKOjV *CNCVCUCTC[6WNVjPKUKXG 'CTW½½CHCMCµFC[C\»JQECN»¹» [CRO»½V»TgnF{TV.WTµjP».GTuO Mahmud Nedim Pafla Türbesi 63 Mahmud Nedim Pafla Türbesi üzerinde Hasan Tahsin Hilmi Efendi’nin celî sülüs yaz›s› Hasan Tahsin Hilmi Efendi’nin celî sülüs ve sülüs levhas› (Mehmet Çebi Koleksiyonu) [C\F»¹»TKXj[GVGFKNGP+CUCP7CJUKP(HGPFK&C¹CNQ¹NW&G\GTu.CU»O3C½C&COKK MCT½»U»PFCDWNWPCP0CJOWF1GFKO3C½C7TDGUK[C\»NCT»P»[C\O»½V»T 6CHGT¼WDCVVCTKJKPFGcWMWTEWOCµFCXGHCVGVVK([RµVG.»TM 0GTFKXGPOG\CTN»¹»PCFGHPGFKNFK0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKXCUK[GVKIGTG¹K[CR»NOCO»½V»T ‹bnülemin, 425-427; Rado, 241. Hattatlar Hulusi Mehmed Efendi Eyüplü +C[CV»JCMM»PFCMC[PCMNCTFCDKTDKNIK OGXEWVFG¹KNFKT¼jJKFGUKPFGJCVVCV QNFW¹WMC[»VN»F»T9GHCVVCTKJKMKVCDGFG OGXEWVFG¹KNFKT.CDTK6QMWNNW0GJOGF 3C½C0GFTGUGUKJC\KTGUKPFGMCR»FCP CXNW[CIKTKNFK¹KPFGUQNVCTCHVCF»T 6VWP½GMNKPFGMKMKVCDGUK½{[NGFKT $\OKFRDGMjG[NGFKM 5ºJNGVK+CMKFGMCDTKPK 5CX\CKEGPPGV»GTDGVEKDC¼ºGNJjE +CVVCV+WNUK0GJOGFGHGPFKOK\KP TWJWPCHjVKJC Hulusi Mehmed Efendi’nin mezartafl› kitabesi 64 H Hulusi Efendi ([R VG'¹OGEKNGT&COKKKOCO»JCVVCV0WJ[KFFKP(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT<C\»[» DCDCU»PFCP{¹TGPOK½QNWRUNUJCVV»P»[C\F»¹»XGI\GN.WTµjP».GTuOQMWFW¹W TKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 10 Hüseyin Efendi +jH»\+UG[KP(HGPFKQNCTCMCP»N»T[»N»PFCFQ¹OW½VWT<C\»[»+QEC2UOCP (HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT+UG[KP(HGPFKCFNK[GFGPGOGMNK[GC[T»NO»½QNWRDKTCTC ([R VG(UMK<GPK&COKK%jNK+QEC0GUEKFKKOCON»¹»P»FC[CRO»½V»T1WTWNNCJ 7KNIGPVCTCH»PFCPDK[QITCHKUKXGTKNGPDW\jV»PMKVCD»P[C\»NF»¹»VCTKJVG JC[CVVCQNFW¹WMC[F»UF½NO½VT Tilgen, 11 Hüseyin Efendi (Attarzâde) $VVCT\jFGQNCTCMVCP»PO»½V»TºUVCPDWNNWQNWR+CUCP$¹CµP»PQ¹NWFWT&jDK\jFG $DFKC¹CµP»P[CP»PFCDWNWPOW½UNUPGUKJFGTUNGTKCNO»½V»T+»TMCK¼GHTKH EKXCT»PFCºUMGPFGT3C½C0CJCNNGUKPFGDCDCU»PFCPKPVKMCNGFGPDKTGXFG QVWTOW½VWT 6CHGT$¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFG%GPVNGTFGDKTOGUKTG[GTKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT 1COC\»([RUWNVCPµFCM»N»PO»½(FKTPGMCR»U»/CµNKcG½OGUKMCT½»U»PCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 171 Hüseyin Hüsnü Efendi +UG[KP+UPK(HGPFKµFGFP[C[CIGNFK0CNK[G FGP[GVK½OK½ µFG0WMCVCCV=KOOGVK=KNJKEEG0CTVµFG0CNK[G0UVG½CT»QNFW ºMKUGPGUQPTCC\NQNWPFW%KTVCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWMVCPUQPTC=KNJKEEG .CU»OµFG0GENKUKXjNjC\CN»¹»PCCVCPF»6QPTCcKHNKMjV»+Oj[WP1j\»T» )CDTKMCNCT1C\»T»XG5GDKNGXXGN¼WDCVµFC0CNK[G1j\»T»QNFW 65 2UGPG5COC\CP7GOOW\CM½CO»6CFTC\CO 0WUVCHC5G½KF3C½C P»PMQPC¹»PFCXGTKNGPKHVCT [GOG¹KPFGPUQPTCF{PF¹GXKPFGjPKFGPXGHCVGVVK 9CM CPXKU/VHK(HGPFKVCTKJKPFG7GPMKJKOCC[K½K WOOK[G[GIGnKORCTCNCT»P»PMCNF»T»NOCU»FCKTVCP\KO XGVCMFKOGVOGM\GTGDWNWPFW¹WFGHVGTRGMnQM OGOWTuPXGCEG\GPKPOC¹FWTK[GVKPKOWEKDQNCEC¹»PFCP D{[NGDKTFGPDKTGXGHCV»<»TV»E»MW½WP{OTC\QNWT U{\PPU{[NGPOGUKPGXGUKNGQNOW½VWT +UPK(HGPFK PKP$JNjM)KJTKUVKCF»PFCDKTTKUjNGUKXCTF»T 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»U»I\GNFKT+jH»\2UOCPVCT\»PFC [C\F»¹»DKT.WTµjP».GTuOKVCOCONC[COCO»½V»T .CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKKM»DNGUKVCTCH»PFC%G[DCDC6QMC¹» \GTKPFGXG.nM(OKT(HGPFKCn»MVTDGUKPKPUQNVCTCH»PFCF»T ‹bnülemin, 142; Sicill-i Osmânî II/176-177; M. Zeki Pakal›n, Maliye Naz›rlar›, ‹stanbul, Kanaat Kitâbevi, ts. I, 117- 123) Eyüplü Hattatlar Hüsni Efendi 66 +UG[KP+UPK(HGPFK¼GJ\jFG&COKKVTDGFCTNCT»PFCP+CE»6jNKJ(HGPFK PKP Q¹NWFWTµFGºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW.»UCDKTG¹KVKOFGPUQPTCDC\» OGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFW FCOGOWTK[GVTVDGUKDKTKPEKFGTGEG[G [MUGNVKNGTGMCNV»PNK[jMCVOCFCN[CU»XGTKNFKºMKPEK0G½TWVK[GVKPKNjP»PFCPUQPTC GOGMNKQNFW FGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC.C½IjTK7GMMGUK[CP»PFC .»TM0GTFKXGPNGTFGPKNGP[GTFGMKCKNGOG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T +UPK(HGPFK PKPMKONGTFGPJCVFGTUKCNF»¹»DGNNKFG¹KNFKT ‹bnülemin, 145-146. ‹brahim Cevri Efendi ºDTCJKO&GXTKºUVCPDWNNWµFWTº[KDKTG¹KVKOFGPUQPTC<GPKMCR»0GXNGXKJCPGUKµPFG JETGPK½uPQNWRVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGP'GTXK½$NK'GFGµFGPVCµNKMFGTUNGTK CNO»½XGDWXCFKFGK[KDKTJCVVCVQNOW½VWT%WU»TCFC0GXNGXu7CTKMCVKµPGIKTOK½UG FGMGPFKUKPKP0GNjOuK%C[TCOu[GµFGPQNFW¹WDKNKPOGMVGFKTµFGXGHCV GVVK Hüseyin Hüsnü Efendi’nin mezartafl› kitabesi ‹ .CDTK(¹TKMCR»F»½»PFCKFK(XKMCDTKPG[CM»PDKT[GTFGKFK ºDTCJKO&GXTu(HGPFKDKTnQMGUGTKKUVKPUCJGVOK½VKTMKOGXEWVNCT» MVRJjPGNGTKOK\FGFKT%WPNCTCTCU»PFC[KTOKKMKOGUPGXuUKDWNWPFW¹WTKXj[GV GFKNKT%WPNCTFCPDKTK6WNVCP,,,6GNKOVCTCH»PFCP*CNCVC0GXNGXKJCPGUK½G[JK*CNKR 'GFGµ[GJGFK[GGFKNOK½VKT$[T»ECUQJDGVNGTKPFGDWNWPFW¹W6CT»$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK {µPKPGUGTNGTKPKFGKUVKPUCJGVOK½VKT.GPFKUKPKPOMGOOGNDKTFKXjP» 6GNKOPjOG+KN[GKEKJjT[jT»I\uPµK+CNNKJCMuMCV$[PµNH[\XG0GNJCOGIKDK GUGTNGTKXCTF»T *j[GVUGTK[C\CTXGDWUC[GFGMC\CPF»¹»RCTCKNGIGnKPKTFK*PFGDKPDG[V[C\»R DKPCMnG[GUCVCDKNFK¹KPKU{[NGOGMVGFKT Abdülbaki Gölp›narl›, Melâmilik ve Melâmiler, ‹stanbul, Gri Yay›n, 1992, s. 148; Müstakimzâde, 639; Hüseyin Ayan, Cevrî, Erzurum, Atatürk Üniversitesi Yay›n›, 1981, 399 s. ; Sa’deddin Nüshet Ergun, Türk fiâirleri III, 67-68; Ali Enver, Semâhâne-i Edeb, ‹stanbul, 1309, 32-33; ‹smail Beli¤, Nuhbetü’l-Âsâr, (Haz. Abdülkerim Abdülkadiro¤lu, 79 ve devam›; Sicill-i Osmânî, II, 91; Nâimâ Tarihi, (Haz. Zuhuri Dan›flman), ‹stanbul, 1969, VI, 2619; Müstakimzâde, Melâmiye-i fiattâriye, 106; fieyhî Mehmed Efendi, Vekayiü’l-Fudalâ. Haz. A. Özcan, III,663 ‹brahim Efendi (Kafll›) ºDTCJKO(HGPFK([RN FT.C½N»NjMCDC[NCVCP»P»TF»6WNVCP,90GJOGF KPM»\» +CVKEG6WNVCP »P[CP»PFCDWNWPFW¹WPFCP+jEGIjP»'KXjP»+Oj[WP CFCJKN +CUNCT.CNGOKJQECU»XG+CPMCRWMGVJFCU»QNOW½VWT 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»NCT»P»6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD([[Du FGPOG½MGVOK½VKT 7CMTKDGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK Müstakimzâde, 53; Tilgen, 11. ‹brahim Efendi (Hatipzâde) +CVKR\jFGQNCTCMVCP»PO½V»T.QP[C(TG¹NKµFGFQ¹OW½FCJCUQPTCºUVCPDWNµC IGNOK½VKT&KDCNKµFG$½»MRC½C0GFTGUGUKµPGIKTOK½XG[C\»[».GVjPK\jFG$NK (HGPFKµFGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T 67 ºDTCJKO(HGPFK$½»MRC½C0GFTGUGUKµPFGPUQPTC)CVKJ)GVJK[G0HVu(UCF(HGPFK 0GFTGUGUKµPGIKTOK½XGDWTCFCQMWTMGPXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»F»½»PFC (OKTDWJjTK&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGKFK Müstakimzâde, 55; Ayvansarâyi, Mecmua-i Tevârih, 355 ‹brahim Efendi (Devlet Silâhflörü) ([RUWNVCP&COKKJCVuDK0WUVCHC(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT$¹CDG[K<CJ[C3C½CµP»P VCTKJKPFG0»U»TXCNKNK¹KGUPCU»PFCQTC[CIKFKR6G[[KF0GJOGF0»UTu FGPOG½M GFGTGMKEj\GVCO»½V»T(UGTNGTKPFG'GXNGV¼KNCJ½{TKO\CU»P»CVCTF» Gezi Notu, M. Nermi Haskan Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹brahim Hanif Efendi ºDTCJKO+CPKH(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWµFWT$VCNCT»ºDTCJKO3C½C5WOGNKXCNKUK D[MDCDCU»0KT$JOGFgUMRC[jP»KFK%CDCU»gUMRN0WUVCHC(HGPFKMKDjT» TKEjNKJjEGIjPFCPKMGP%C¹FCFFGHVGTFjT»QNWRF{P½PFG6WNVCP,,,$JOGF UCNVCPCV»P»PDC½NCT»PFCVCTKJKPFG7QMCV FCXGHCVGVVK (XXGNjºUOCKN(HGPFK\jFG$DFK(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJFGTUNGTKCNF»%KTCTC &jDK\jFG$DFK$¹C FCP[C\»RUQPTC\COCP»P[C\»UVjF»0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFK FGP OG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF»7C NKMJCVV»P».CVKD\jFG0GJOGF5GHK (HGPFK FGP OG½MGFGTGMM»UC\COCPFC{¹TGPOK½VKT7W¹TCXGUK[jMCV[C\»U»KNGFGW¹TC½O»½V»T %KTCTC*CNCVCXG%WTUCMCF»N»MNCT»PFCDWNWPFW½GXXCN.CU»OµFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK.nM([RFGPKNGP<CXGFF0CJCNNGUK PFGc»PCTN».CTCMQN W CTMCU»PFC¼G[J9CJ[u(HGPFK{ PKPMCDTKMCT½»U»PFCXG'C[G+CVWP 7TDGUKµPFGOGFHWPFW%WIPJKnDKTKOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT +CPKH(HGPFKC[P»\COCPFC½jKTQNWRFKXCP»XCTF»T(POG½JWTGUGTK.CF»,[C\ »P ¼KHjCFN»GUGTKPG[CRV»¹»½GTJFKTMKDW[\FGP¼jTKMK¼KHjNjMCD»[NCCP»N»T Müstakimzâde, 43; Habib, 205; Türk Dili ve Edebiyat› Ansiklopedisi IV/100; Haskan, I/174 68 ‹ ‹brahim Sükûti Efendi (UOC6WNVCP6CTC[» P»PDGMnKUKKFK%WUCTC['GHVGTFCTUCJKNKPFGKFK*C[GVC¹»TXG nQM[C½N»KMGPµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFC/j NKcG½OGUK EKXCT»PFCQNWROG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT +WXG´N+C[[W´N%jMu .WFXGVW´NJCVVjVuPXG´TTCMºOuP 9GWOFGVW´NGUjVu\K´NjNGOuP ÂNKOW´NGUTjTKUCJKDW´NjUjT 5CJOGVWN´NNCJKVGjNjCNG[JK´NICHHjT +CVVCVGU6G[[KF¹DTCJKOW´UUWMVu (HGPFKTWJKnWP)CVKJC 6GPGMGVGDGJWFCOCFG´NOGTJWO .CDKTVC½».KVjDGUKPK[C\CPFCOCF»0WUVCHC+KNOK(HGPFKFGFG¹GTNKDKTJCVVCV QNFW¹WJCNFGJC[CV»JCMM»PFCDKTDKNIK[QMVWT 69 ‹brahim Sükûti Efendi’ye ait sülüs-nesih hilye ‹brahim Sükûti’nin kabir kitabesi .CTCIOTM FG(UMK$NK3C½C&CFFGUK\GTKPFG6WNVCP,90WUVCHC P»PCPPGUK$[½G 6KPGRGTXGT9CNKFG6WNVCP{µCCKVJCTCRnG½OGPKPJVCTKJNK MKVjDGUKFGºDTCJKO6MVK(HGPFK PKPFKT Habib, 168; ‹bnûlemin, 147; Rado, 203; Hakani Mehmed Bey’in Hilye-i fierifesi, Haz›rlayan. Abdülkadir Karahan, ‹stanbul, 1992. Ölüm tarihini, Habib, 168’de yanl›fll›kla h. 1253 olarak vermifltir. Halbuki ‹bnülemin’in kitab›ndaki kabir kitâbesinde ölüm tarihi, h. 1250/1834’dür. ‹brahim Vahdi Efendi %WNICTKUVCPµFC+CE»Q¹NW3C\CT»FGPKNGP[GTFGFQ¹FW0FGTTKUQNFW¹WKnKP+CNGR .CF»U»KMGP5GDKWNCJKT1KUCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK([RUWNVCP7TDGUK +C\KTGUKPGFGHPGFKNFKgnNKUCPDKNFK¹KPCMNGFKNOK½VKT ºDTCJKO9CJFK(HGPFK7CµNKM[C\»[»6K[jJK$JOGF(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT6NUXG PGUKJ[C\»[»$MDCDCD&COKKKOCO»0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPOK½VKT6CFTC\CO ¼GJKV$NK3C½C.VRJCPGUKµPFGDC\»GUGTNGTKMGPKFJCVV»KNG[C\O»½V»T$[T»EC7GHUuTK %G[\jXKµ[K½GTJGVOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 637 Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹hsan Bey 70 +jH»\0WUVCHCºJUCP%G[VGNITCHXGRQUVCOWJCUGDG MCNGOKOGOWTNCT»PFCPºUVCPDWNNW0GJOGF&GNjN %G[ KPQ¹NWFWTµFG6WNVCPCJOGF VG .CR»C¹CU»0CJCNNGUK PFGFQ¹FW*PI{TOG\ 0CJCNNGUK PFGMKºUMGPFGT3C½C6»D[CP0GMVGDKµPFG QMWFWMVCPUQPTC*NJCPG$UMGTK2MWNW PCIKTFK%W U»TCFC.WTµjP».GTuOKG\DGTNK[GTGMJjH»\QNFW6QPTC DKTVCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWµFG GOGMNKQNFWXG$UMGTK0CVDCCJCVVCVN»¹»PCCN»PF» ºNM{PEG+CTDK[G0GMVGDKJCVVCV»MC[OCMCO9CJFGVK %G[{µFGPUNUJCVV»P»OG½MGVVK%W\jV»P [C½N»QNOCU»PFCPFQNC[»5GKU NJCVVCV»P.jOKN$MFKMµG FGXCONCKEj\GVCNF» 6NUEGNuUKµPK(TMjP»+CTDK[G'CKTGUKJCVVV»1C\KH{ (HGPFK FGPTKM C[»*CNCVCUCTC[»6WNVCPKUK[C\»{¹TGVOGPK0GJOGFº\\GV(HGPFK{ FGPOG½MGVVK6NUXGPGUKJKI\GN[C\CTF» ‹ 6WNVCP,,$DFNJCOKF KPOG\\KPNGTKPFGP+jH»\7GXHKM%G[{5COC\CP .CU»OµFGPOWUKMuFGTUNGTKCNF»7VPE+jH»\<WUWH%G[ FGPºNjJKXG+CE» )jKMXG%QNjJGPM1WTK%G[NGT FGPDKTMCnDGUVGXGCMTCDCU»PFCPOWUKMK{¹TVOGPK ºUOCKN+CMM»%G[ FGP[GFKUGMK\HCU»NIGnVK .CU»O FGHGNnVGPOW\FCTKRQNCTCMXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U» OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T.KVjDGUK[QMVWT.GPFKUKPKPM»UCDQ[NWI\GNXGINGT[\NM»T UCMCNN»FKPKPGDC¹N»XGJQ½UGFjDKT\jVQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPWT*\GN½CTM»NCT» XCTF»TºDPNGOKP0CJOWF.GOCNºPCNµ»PIHVGNGTKPFGPKMKUKPKDGUVGNGOK½VKTMK ½WPNCTF»T +KVjDºNVHWPW[jTKPKVjDGDGP\GFKTKO 6CHj[ºjNGOKC¼MºC\jDCDGP\GFKTKO %KTPKIjJGVFKTCMKDGEjPjP 1GEKJCPMCNFºI{\OFGPGFGEjP ºDPNGOKP ¼CTMºNCTºJCMKMCVGPFKNTDjFºT%WPNCTºNjJPKJC\KPKNGQMWFWMEC FKPNG[GPNGTFKNJPQNWTNCTFº2PWPNCXGFK¸GTMº[OGVNKGJKDDCOº\NCVGTVºR GVVK¸KOK\OWUWMKCNGONGTKPKJCVºTNCFºMEC *GnFKQFGONGTMKDVP\GXMKFK 7WJHGK¼jOUGJGTKT\IjT DG[VKPKVGMTCTGVOGOGMMCDKNFG¸KNFKT²FGOGMVGFKT ‹bnülemin, 148; Y›lmaz Öztuna, Türk Musikisi Ansiklopedisi, I, 295; Mustafa Rona, Yirminci Yüzy›l Türk Musikisi, s. 89-93, 98; Sadun K. Aksüt, 500 Y›ll›k Türk Musikisi Antolojisi, s. 77-78; ‹smail Efendi (Taflc›zâde) ºUOCKN(HGPFK([RN FT7C½E»\jFGFK[GVCP»PO»½V»T.jVKD\jFG0GJOGF5GHKµ (HGPFK FGPVC NKMOG½MGVVK%WCTCFCDC\»OG\CTVC½NCT»P»PMKVjDGNGTKPK[C\CTCM GMOG¹KPKVC½VCPn»MCT»TQNFWcKnGMNGTGQNCPOGTCM»FQNCU»[NC%G½KT$¹Cµ[C KPVKUCRGFGTGMQPWPDCJnGK½NGTKPGDCMV» )CMCV%G½KT$¹C P»PVCTKJKPFGMKKFCO»PFCPM»UCUTGUQPTCXGHCVGVVK Müstakimzâde, 652; Tilgen, 11-12. 71 Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹smail Zühdî taraf›ndan celî sülüsle yaz›lan Hatice Han›m mezartafl› kitabesi (Fatih, Niflanc› Camii haziresi) Ayn› tafl›n ketebe k›sm› 72 ‹ ‹smail Zühdî Efendi 2TFWµ[CDC¹N»gP[GMC\CU»PFC FP[C[CIGNFK'Q¹WOVCTKJKDGNNK FG¹KNFKT*GPn[C½»PFCDCDCU» 0GJOGF.CRVCPVCTCH»PFCP ºUVCPDWNµCIGVKTKNFKºNKOVCJUKNK [CP»PFC$JOGF+»H\»(HGPFKµFGP UNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVVK%WCTCFC 0GJOGF(OKPKUKONKDKTDC½MC JCVVCVCPFCKUVKHCFGGFGTGM KEj\GVKPKXG²=JFK³OCJNCU»P»CNF» 6WNVCP,,,0WUVCHCFGXTKPFG (PFGTPK+Oj[WPµC[C\»JQECU» QNFWXGHCV»PCMCFCTDWI{TGXFG MCNF».»TM0WUJCHDKTnQMJKN[GK UCCFGVOWTCMMCCM»VµCXGNGXJC [C\F»%WIPO\GXG{\GN MQNGMUK[QPNCTFCMKGUGTNGTKPFGP DC½MC([R'GHVGTFCTµFC¼CJ6WNVCP7TDGUKµPFGMKEGNu[C\»NCT2TVCM{[U»TVNCT»PFC VCNGDGUKPFGP¼jPK\jFG$VjWNNCJ(HGPFKµPKP[CRV»TF»¹»nG½OGPKPJVCTKJNK EGNuMKVjDGUKKNG)CVKJ1K½CPE»&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGJVCTKJNK+CVKEG+CP»O OG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKºUOCKN=JFu´PKP{PGONKGUGTNGTKPFGPFKT &GNuµFGGUMKVCT\CDC¹N»QNCP=JFK(HGPFKUNUXGPGUKJ[C\»NCT»PFC¼G[J +COFWNNCJXG+jH»\2UOCPµFCPUQPTCJCTHXGMGNKOGNGTG\CTKHDKTI{TP½ ‹smail Zühdî’nin mezartafl› kitabesi bafltafl› (Kardefli Hattat Mustafa Râk›m Efendi taraf›ndan yaz›lm›flt›r) 73 ‹smail Zühdî kabri genel görünümü MC\CPF»TO»½V»T6NUXGPGUKJVG+jH»\2UOCP[QNWPWGPI\GN½GMKNFGºUOjKN=JFK IGNK½VKTOK½VKT ºUOjKN=JFKKNGCNjMCN»QNCTCMOGTJWO1GEOGFFKP2M[C[XGOGTJWO0jEKF$[TCN DKTNKMVG08¹WT'GTOCP%G[µG½WVGURKVVGDWNWPOW½NCTF»T²7CUJKJUK\QNCTCM GNKPFGPI\GNJCTHn»MCTVOCMVCºUOjKN=JFK(HGPFKµPKPIGnOK½UVCVNCTKnKPFG DGP\GTKIGNOGOK½VKT ¼GXXCN$TCN»MVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGPºUOjKN=JFu(FKTPGMCR» OG\CTN»¹»PCFGHPGFKNFK.CDKTMKVjDGUKVCNGDGUKXGMCTFG½K0WUVCHC5jM»O VCTCH»PFCPPC\OGFKNKR[C\»NF».CDTKJCVOGTCMN»NCT»PECJjNj\K[CTGV GFKNOGMVGFKT.CDKTMKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT %C½VC½» 5CJKOGJW´NNCJKVGjNj .jVKDKUCTC[K´UUWNVjPK XG+j\KPKMGNjOW´TTCDDjPu 5GKU´NJCVVjVuPOGTJWO ¹UOjKNG\=JFu (HGPFK5JunWP)jVKJC .GVGDGJW5jMºOGNOC´TH DKGJK´NOGTJWO Eyüplü Hattatlar $[CMVC½»MKVjDGUPKPKDjTGUK½{[NGFKT 74 5JunWPNKNNCJK´NHCVKJC 'GTuIjJQ¼PXuUjPº\COjPºP =JFuKUVjFº 9GHCVGVVKMuOCUjTK[NG\G[P QNOW¼FWJGTOCJHKN .CNGOFFKFKNKPMºNFºOTGMMGD [C\FºVCTuJKP .WDTuG[NGFK+CVVCV=JFujJMKO OGP\KN Hu[GXOK´NuF .GVGDGJW5jMºOGNOFGTTKU ¸WHKTGNGJW XGNKGJuJK´NOGTJO ‹bnülemin, 476; A. Süheyl Ünver, “Hattat ‹smail Zühdü Efendi”. ‹stanbul, 50 San’at Sever Serisi1, 1953, s. 1; Derman, Hayat Mecmuas›, 26; a.mlf., ‹KMHS, 204. Ahmed Cevdet, Târih-i Cevdet. c.XII, ‹stanbul, ‹smail Zühdî kabri ayaktafl› (Kardefli Hattat Mustafa Râk›m Efendi taraf›ndan yaz›lm›flt›r) L 1309, s. 141; Derman, ‹KMHS, 204. Derman, Hayat Mecmuas›, 26. ‹bnülemin, 476. Derman, ‹KMHS, 204. Ünver, Hattat ‹smail Zühdü Efendi, 1; Derman, Hayat Mecmuas›, 26. Derman, ‹KMHS, 204 Kabir Kitâbesi ile ilgili bkz. Süleyman BERK, Hattat Mustafa Râk›m Efendi. ‹stanbul, Kaynak Yay›nlar›, 2003, s. 94-95, 147; a.mlf. “Eyüpsultan S›n›rlar› ‹çerisinde Hattat Mustafa Râk›m’a Ait Mezartafl› Kitâbeleri”, Tarihi Kültürü ve Sanat›yla III. Eyüpsultan Sempozyumu, Tebli¤ler, ‹stanbul, Eyüp Belediyesi, 2000, s. 244-245; a. mlf., “Celî Sülüs’ün fiâheserleri”, AD ART DEKOR, sy. 87 (Haziran 2000), s. 148-154. Lâ'li Mustafa Efendi 0WUVCHC(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWµFWT/jTGPFGNK0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGPJCVFGTUNGTKCNO»½V»T ¼jKTK[KDKTMjVKRXGJCVVCVV»6NUPGUKJTKM CVC NuMXGFKXCPu[C\»FCOjJKTFK 0WUVCHC(HGPFKnQMK[KM»TO»\»OTGMMGD[CRV»¹»KnKP/j NKNjMCD»[NCCP»NCIGNOK½VKT 5W\PCOnGK(XXGNXG+CEGIjP»'KXjP» +Oj[WP FCPF»6WNVCP,90GJOGF KP M»\»+CVKEG6WNVCP »PMGVJFCU»KMGP VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK (FKTPGMCR»U»OG\CTN»¹»PFC/j NK cG½OGUKKNG¼jKT%jMK(HGPFKUQHCU» CTCU»PFCF»T(VTCH»FGOKTRCTOCMN»MKNG nGXTKNOK½QNCPJC\KPGPKPGPGUMKVCTKJNK VC½»/j NK0WUVCHC(HGPFK PKPG½K)CVOC +CP»O CCKVVKT)CVOC+CP»O FGXGHCVGVOK½VKT 75 Suyolcuzâde, 114-115; Müstakimzâde, 554; Haskan, Eyüpsultan Tarihi, 260-261 La’li Mustafa Efendi kabir kitabesi La'lîzâde Seyyid Abdülbâki Efendi 'GFGNGTK/C Nu$NK(HGPFK6WNVCP,$JOGF+CP\COCP»PFC5GuUµNMVVjD'»½K½NGTK %CMCP»QNOW½VWTMK7QRMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFCOGFHWPOG½j[KJFGP½jTKJKOGUPGXu 6G[[KF6CT»$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK PKPFCOCF»KFK%CDCU»/C NK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK/C Nu $NK(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWºDTCJKO(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT0GJOGF(HGPFKOFGTTKUXGOQNNC QNWROWJCTTGOKPFG7GOOW\0GMMGMCF»U»QNWRºUVCPDWNRj[GUK XGTKNOK½VKTµFGºUVCPDWNMCF»U»QNWRDKTUGPGUQPTCC\NGFKNFK=KNJKEEG 0CTVVCTKJKPFG.»DT»U CUTNF%G½C[UQPTCVCTKJKPFGQTCFCXGHCV GVVK.CDTK0CIQUC FC)C\N»ºNjJK7TDGUKJCTKEKPFGFKT'K¹GTQ¹NW6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ (HGPFK FKT /C Nu$DFNDjMK(HGPFKMnM[C½VCDCDCU»PFCP[GVKOMCNF»¹»KnKP½KKTNGTKPFG ²<GVKO²OCJNjU»P»MWNNCPO»½V»T0GOWTK[GVVGMCFGOGMCFGOGKNGTNG[GTGMºUVCPDWN MCF»U»QNOW½UCFCM»UCDKTOFFGVUQPTCKUVKHCGVVKXG([RUWNVCP FCMKGXKPG nGMKNFKµFCXGHCVGVVK 7C NKM[C\»[».C\CUMGT$DFNDjMuÃTKH(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT6CFT»C\CO¼GJKF$NK 3C½CKNG0QTCXG9CTCFKPUGHGTNGTKPGK½VKTCMGVOK½XG$NK3C½C P»P½GJjFGVKPFG [CP»PFCDWNWPOW½VWT .CDKTNGTKPKPRGPEGTGUK\GTGTGUOKMCNGOKQNCPEGNKJCVV»VC NKMKKNGOGXEWFQNWD ºUVCPDWN FCPPCMKNNGTKKnKPG[NGFKMNGTKVCTKJKXGHCVUGPGUKVCTKJKFKT\CPP»[NG [CP»N»TNCTMKDWKMKDG[KVVKT Eyüplü Hattatlar .CNDKOG¹DPKTK[j\ NEGPPGKNJCOGVVK+CMM +WDDº\jVºFC XGVKVFKTWJWDG\OKXWUNCVC 'GTNGTGTDjDºOWJCDDGVPCMNKOKPVjTKJKPK /C NK=jFG6G[[KF$DFNDjMKIKTFKEGPPGVG 76 La’lizade Abdülbâki Efendi Türbesi (Sa¤da görülen bina mektebidir) M 5CMCOGDEGFJGUCD»[NCDWNWPOCMVCF»T$[T»EC[C\»N»FG¹KNFKT0UVCMKO\jFGµ[G I{TGDWVCTKJVGMMGPKPDKPCGFKNFK¹KVCTKJVKT$DFNDjMK(HGPFK¼GXXCN .CU»OµFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Haskan, Eyüpsultan Tarihi I/217; Rado, 146; Müstakimzâde, 670-671; Gölp›narl›, Melâmilik s. 153-155, 166, 170,173; Mehmet Tâhir, Osmanl› Müellifleri, Meral Yay›nlar›, I, 147; Sicill-i Osmânî, III/298; Ayvansarayî (Hâf›z Hüseyin b. ‹smâil), (Haz.. Fahri Ç. DER‹N- Vâhid ÇABUK). Mecmua-i Tevârih, s. 268-269, 406; a. mlf. Hadîka, I, 276-278; Koçu, ‹st. A., I, 76; ‹stanbul Kültür ve Sanat Ansiklopedisi, ‹stanbul, Tercüman Kültür Yay›nlar›, 1982, I, 120; Türk Dili ve Edebiyat› Ansiklopedisi, I/18 Mahmud Baba R›zâi %WIP%WNICTKUVCPU»P»TNCT»KnGTKUKPFGMCNO»½QNCP3NQXFKX)KNKDGNKQNWR+QEC 0CJOWF%CDCQNCTCMDKNKPOGMVGFKT0CJOWF%CDCjNKOHj\»N½jKTQNCTCM DKNKPOK½VKT 2UOCPN»JCVOGMVGDKPKPMWTWEWUW¼G[J+COFWNNCJGHGPFKµFGPUNUPGUKJ[C\»[» {¹TGPOK½VKT7GHUuTK(DWµUUWWFµW[C\F»¹»PCMNGFKNOK½VKT ¼jKT%jMK(HGPFKQPWPKnKP½WF{TVN¹U{[NGOK½VKT %KT[G¼KNICTTjK\GTGH¼jPMC¸ºFQNOW¼VWTnGOGP <CTC¼WT[C\ºNUCIGTOGFJGFKDKPMVGFjP +jEGKjNKPC\CTUGTnG¼OGKHC\NWJPGT +C\TGVK%CDC(HGPFKMjDCJ¼WMjOTjP 77 0UVCMKO\jFGXG$VjKµFG[\[C½»PC[CM»P 5GEGD$¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK¹KMC[»VNCF»T)CMCV+CUCP+UP 3C½CXG&CPCP+CP»OVTDGNGTKCTMCU»PFC OG\CTN»MFWXCT»P»PJCOCP[CP»PFC DWNWPCPOG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKPFG &GOj\K[GNCJKTVCTKJKDWNWPOCMVCF»T 6NG[OCPK[G&COKKEKXCT»PFC0KOCT 6KPCPµC%CDCcGNGDK0GFTGUGUKCF»KNG CP»NCPDKTOGFTGUG[CRV»TO»½XGGXMjHKNG FGKJ[CGVOK½VKTDWIP[GTKFCJKDGNNK FG¹KNFKT$TCRnCXG7TMnG½KKTNGTK OCP\WOXGF\[C\»TKUjNGNGTKOGXEWVVWT Müstakimzâde, 509-510; Sicill-i Osmâni, IV/313; Cahit Baltac›. Osmanl› Medreseleri. S. 118; Melul Meriç. Mimar Sinan, 35; Atâi, 356, 357; Türk Dili ve Edebiyat› Ansiklopedisi, VII/330. Mahmud Baba R›zâi’nin kabir kitabesi Mahmud Celâleddin Eyüplü Hattatlar $UNGP'C¹»UVCPµN»QNCP0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFKDCDCU»¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFKKNG DKTNKMVGºUVCPDWNµCIGNOK½VKT'Q¹WOVCTKJuDGNNKFG¹KNFKT ºNM[C\»FGTUNGTKPK$M0QNNCfOGT(HGPFKXG+QEC5jUKO(HGPFKVCNGDGNGTKPFGP $DFNNCVKH(HGPFKµFGPCNO»½V»T<COCM\jFG6jNKJ(HGPFKXG(DWDGMKT5j½KF(HGPFKµ[G [C\»FGTUKCNOCMKnKP[CRV»¹»OTCECCVNCTKUGFKMDC½N»N»¹»UGDGDK[NG TGFFGFKNOK½VKT%WPWP\GTKPG+jH»\2UOCP(HGPFKµPKPGUGTNGTKPG DCMCTCMMGPFKMGPFKPK[GVK½VKTOK½VKT Mahmud Celâleddin hatt› ile celî sülüs levha (Eyüp Sultan Türbesi) 78 M 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»FCMGPFKPGJCUI\GNDKTVCXTCUCJKRQNOW½XGnQMMWXXGVNKXG MWFTGVNKGUGTNGTQTVC[CMQ[OW½VWT&GNu6NUµVGKUGC[P»DC½CT»[»I{UVGTGOGOK½VKT JCTHNGTKnQMFQPWMXGMVMCNO»½V»T&GNuµPKPKUVKHKPFGFGJCTHNGTDKTDKTKPFGP DC¹»OU»\IKDKMCNO»½JCTGMGXGVG\[KPCVK½CTGVNGTKPKFGDC½CT»N»DKT½GMKNFG FC¹»VCOCO»½V»T$[P»CU»TFC[C½»[CPEGNuUVjF»JCVVCV0WUVCHC5CM»Oµ»PEGNuFG [CRV»¹»CV»N»OXGFG¹K½KOKP[CP»PFC0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKPµKPEGNuCPNC[»½» VWVWPCOCO»½V»T 79 Mahmud Celâleddin’in sülüs nesih hilyesi (Mehmet Çebi Koleksiyonu) Mahmud Celâleddin hatt› ile celî sülüs-sülüs levha Eyüplü Hattatlar 6WNVCP$DFNOGEKFµKP0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKPµKPVCNGDGUK0GJOGF7jJKT(HGPFK" µPKPVCNGDGUKQNOCU»UGDGDK[NGDKTCTCDVPJCVVCVNCTRCFK½CJUGXMK[NG &GNjNGFFKP(HGPFK[QNWPFCGUGTNGTXGTOK½UGNGTFGRCFK½CJ»P{NOKNGDW[QN VGTMGFKNOK½VKT 0WUJCHXGFWCMKVCRNCT»[CP»PFCJKN[GXGM»VµC½GMNKPFGFGGUGTNGTKOGXEWVVWT ([R0KJTK½CJ6WNVCP7TDGUKEGNuUNUKnMW½CM[C\»U»0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP (HGPFKµ[GCKVVKT+[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½XG1K½CPE»¼G[J0WTCF'GTIjJ»µPC FGHPGFKNOK½VKT0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 80 Mahmud Celâleddin’in celî sülüs, sülüs ve nesih hatt› ile yazd›¤› farkl› bir hilye M Mahmud Celâleddin hatt› ile sülüs-nesih k›t’a +WXG´N+C[[W´N%jMu 0G¼j[JKJCVVjVuPFGP &GPPGVOGMjPOGTJWOXGOC¸HWT 0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFKPKP 5WJKnWPGN)CVKJC 6GPG ‹bnülemin, 187. Do¤um tarihi kesin olarak bilinmeyen Mahmud Celâleddin Efendi’nin, do¤um tarihi ile ilgili olarak, M. U¤ur Derman, Sabanc› Koleksiyonu, s. 104’de flöyle bir bilgi mevcuttur: “Do¤um y›l› belli olmamakla birlikte gördü¤ümüz 1188/1774 senesinde yaz›lm›fl mükemmel bir murakkaas›ndan 1163/1750 tarihi civar›nda do¤du¤u neticesini ç›kar›yoruz.” Habib, 166; ‹bnülemin, 187; M. U¤ur Derman, “Mahmud Celâleddin” Kültürde ve Sanatta Kök, c. 1, sy. 20-22 (Ekim-Kas›m-Aral›k 1982), s. 14; a. mlf. ‹KMHS, 205 ‹bnülemin, 188; Derman, KÖK, 14; a.mlf., ‹KMHS, 206; Süleyman Berk, Hattat Mustafa Râk›m’da Celî Sülüs ve Tu¤ra Esteti¤i, s. 94-95. Mahmud Celâleddin Efendi mezartafl› kitabesi 81 82 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mahmud Celâleddin hatt› ile sülüs-nesih k›t’a Mahmud Celâleddin hatt› ile celî sülüs levha M 83 Mahmud Dede ºUVCPDWNNWµFWT%CDCU».WOMCR»µFC1K½CPE»3C½C&COKKµPKPKOCO»KFK.GPFKUK gUMFjTK+CE»'GFG{µ[GDC¹NCPO»½VCTKMCVGJNKQNOW½XG¼GMGTEK\jFG {µFGPFGEGNu[C\»FGTUNGTKCNCTCMOG\WPQNOW½VWTVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVOK½XG([RUWNVCP7TDGUKEKXCT»PCI{ONO½VT Müstakimzâde, 513-514 Mahmud Efendi (Nazl› Mahmud Çelebi) Eyüplü Hattatlar 1C\N»0CJOWFcGNGDKFK[GFGDKNKPKTºUVCPDWNNWµFWT([RUWNVCPµFC'GHVGTFCT UGOVKXGKUMGNGUKCF»P»DW\jV»POGUNG¹KPFGPFQNC[»CNO»½V»T'GHVGTFCT0CJOWF (HGPFKDWTCFCDWIPFGOGXEWVQNCPDKTECOKOGMVGRXGnG½OG[CRV»TO»½V»T 0CJOWF(HGPFKTGKUNJCVVjuP¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPOG\WPQNOW½VWT VCTKJKPFG[CRV»TF»¹»ECOKKPOKPCTGUKCNGOKPGDKTJQMMCXGMCNGO MQ[FWTOW½UCFC\COCPNCMCNGO[QMQNOW½VWTUGPGUKD[M 84 Hattat Mahmud Efendi hatt› ile Eyüp Defterdar Nazl› Mahmud Çelebi Camii celî sülüs kitabesi M FGRTGOKPFGPUQPTCVCOKT QNWPWTMGPJQMMC[C[KPGMCNGO Nazl› Mahmud Çelebi kabir kitabesi MQPOW½VWT)CMCVPG[C\»MMK DWIPKMKUKFGOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT 0CJOWF(HGPFK VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ECOKKPOKJTCD»[{PPFG MWDDGNKVTDGUKPKPKnKPFGFKT 0GTOGTNCJFKPKP\GTKPFGM»T»M DKT½CJKFGXCTF»Tg\GTKPFGMK .KVjDG½WFWT 0GTJWOXGOC¸HWT 6jJKD´NJC[TjVXG´NJCUGPjV 'GHVGTFCT0CJOWFcGNGDK (HGPFKTJKnWPHjVKJC 85 0CJOWF(HGPFK.CPPu6WNVCP 6NG[OCPFGXTKPFG µFGXGVCTKJKPFG QNOCM\GTGVQRNCO[GFKUGPG OFFGVNG'GHVGTFCT[CPK 0CNK[G%CMCP»QNOW½XGDW I{TGXFGKMGPXGHCVGVOK½VKT Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 311; Hadîka I, 286; Müstakimzâde, 510-511; ‹smâil Hami Daniflmend. ‹zâhl› ‹slâm Tarihi Kronolojisi, II, ‹stanbul, Bâb-› Âli Yay›nevi, 1960, s. 444-445; M. U¤ur Derman, “Eski Mürekkepçili¤imiz”, ‹slâm Düflüncesi, Y›l, 1, sy.2, s. 17; Rado, 65; Muhittin Serin, Hattat fieyh Hamdullah, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Akademisi Kültür ve San’at Vakf›, 1992, s. 67. Nazl› Mahmud Çelebi türbesi Mehmed Ârif Bey (Çarflambal›) Eyüplü Hattatlar ºUOKPFGMK²cCT½CODCN»³PKUDGUKPK)CVKJµKP cCT½CODCUGOVKPFGQVWTFW¹WKnKPCNCP0GJOGF ÃTKH%G[µKPFQ¹WOVCTKJKDKNKPOGOGMVGFKT.nM [C½VC0CNK[G1G\jTGVK<C\»º½NGTKPGOGOWTQNFW 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»EGNuUNUPD[MUVjF» 0WUVCHC5jM»OVCNGDGUK+j½KO(HGPFK{ µFGPOG½MGVVK7CµNuM[C\»[»KUG6jOK(HGPFKKNG DKTNKMVG.»DT»Uu\jFGºUOjKN+CMM»(HGPFKµFGPDC½NCTFCJC UQPTCKUG0GNGM3C½C7QTWPW$NK+C[FCT%G[µGFGXCOGFGT%WMQPWKNGCNjMCN» 6jOK(HGPFK²%GPJQECO»VGTMGVOGFKOÃTKHD»TCMV»)GXMCNjFGDKTJCVVCVQNFW¹W JCNFG[C\»FCPQPRCTCMC\CPCOCF»%GPKOKUGDCDCOFCPKPVKMCNGFGPRGMnQM DQTnWOXCTF»QPNCT»JGR[C\»FCPMC\CPF»MNCT»ONC{FGFKOºPUCPJQECU»P»VGTM GFGTUGHG[\KMCNOC\MGUKNKT³ 86 Çarflambal› Mehmed Arif’in celî sülüs levhas› (Hattat Osman Özçay taraf›ndan takliden yaz›lm›flt›r) M Çarflambal› Mehmed Arif’in celî sülüs levhas› .GPFKUKPK{\GNNKMNGEGNu[C\»[CXGTGPÃTKH%G[OUGPPj[C\»FCI\GN{TPGMNGT XGTOK½VKTºO\CU»\[C\»NCT»PJCVVCVNCT»P»VCP»OCFCOjJKTQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPWT gUMFCTf\DGMNGT7GMMGUK¼G[JK+G\CTHGP(FJGO(HGPFK+WNUK(HGPFKXGJC[CV» JCMM»PFCJGTJCPIKDKTDKNIKDWNWPOC[CP+C[TGFFKPKUKONKJCVVCVcCT½CPDCN»µP»PGP {PGONKVCNGDGNGTKPFGPFKT Çarflambal› Mehmed Arif Bey hatt› ile zerendûd celî sülüs levha (Üsküdar Çiçekçi Camii) 87 Eyüplü Hattatlar Çarflambal›’n›n zerendûd celî sülüs levhas› 88 +VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGPÃTKH%G[<jXGFF.CDTKUVCP»µPCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT 7CµNKMJCVNC[C\»NCPXGDWIPOCCNGUGHOGXEWVQNOC[CPMKVjDGPKPOGVPK½{[NGFKT +WXGN%jMu $NNCJWUDJCPGJWXGVGjNjOGMVWDuKOCNK[[GOWMCDGNGEKUKOG¼jJKTK JCVVjVuPFGPOGMjTKOKCJNjMKNGOGXUHOWJKDDKjNKCDjGNJjEÂTKH%G[ MWNWPCXGDK´NEONGOOKPuPXGOOKPjVCTCJOGVG[NG[GjOuP6GPG M. U¤ur Derman, Hattat HACI ÂR‹F’ler, ‹stanbul, 50 San’at Sever Serisi-21, 1965, s.1; a.mlf., “Çarflanbal› Hac› Ârif Bey”, Kültür ve Sanatta KÖK, c.2, s.13 (Mart 1982), s.14; a.mlf., ‹KMHS, 220; a.mlf, Sabanc› Koleksiyonu, 148; Rado, 227. Bu müellifler haricinde Eflref Edib, ‹TA, 194, s. 496 ve ‹bnülemin, Son Hattatlar, s. 50’de Mehmed Ârif Bey’in Kazasker Mustafa ‹zzet Efendi’den meflketti¤ini yazm›fllard›r ki, do¤rusu Hâflim Efendi’den meflketti¤idir. Çünkü Mehmed Ârif Bey’in yaz›s›n›n Kazasker üslûbu ile alâkas› yoktur. Ayr›ca M Çarflambal› Mehmed Arif Bey hatt› ile zerendûd celî sülüs müsennâ levha 89 Necmeddin Okyay (1883-1976), Eyüplü Hattat R›fat Efendi’den, Ârif Bey’in, Hâflim Efendi’den meflketti¤ini iflitmifltir. (bkz. Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F’ler, 2,3) Eflref Edib, “Çarflambal› Hattat Hac› Ârif Bey” ‹TA, 496; ‹bnülemin, 50; Dermân, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F’ler, 3. Derman, a.g.e., 3; a.mlf., KÖK, 14. Eflref Edib, a.g.m., 496; ‹bnülemin, 52; Derman, Hattat “HACI ÂR‹F’ler, 3. Hezârfen Edhem Efendi’nin hayat› için bkz. M. U¤ur Derman, Türk Sanat›nda Ebrû, ‹stanbul, Akbank, 1977, s. 32-40. Hayat› hakk›nda bkz. M. U¤ur Derman, Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, L.55; a.mlf. ‹KMHS, 222; Muhittin Serin, Hulûsi Efendi’nin Ta’lik Meflk Murakka›, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Akademisi Kültür ve San’at Vakf›, 1999. ‹bnülemin, 52. Mehmed Ataullah Vahyi Efendi (Tefsîrizâde) ºUVCPDWNNWµFWT.CF»0HGUUKT0GJOGF(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNFW¹WKnKP7GHUKTu\jFGFK[G VCP»PF»%CDCU»IKDK1CM½KDGPFK7CTKMCVKµPGDC¹N»KFK6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»'GTXK½ $NK(HGPFK{µFGP[C\F»7CJUKNKPKVCOCONCF»MVCPUQPTC.WFU¼CO 0GMMGK0MGTTGOGXGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFW<C½»UGMUGPGXCTO»½KMGP¼CDCP $¹WUVQUXGHCVGVVK([RUWNVCP7TDGUKEKXCT»PCI{ONF¼KKTNGTKXCTF»T Müstakimzâde, 446; Sicill-i Osmanî III/476 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Aziz Efendi $\K\(HGPFKJVCTKJKPFG7TCD\QPµWP 0CnKP0CnMCKNnGUKPFGFQ¹FW%CDCU»5K\G 6CNjJCFGTGUKG½TjH»PFCP0QNNC0GJOGF $DFNJCOKF(HGPFKCPPGUK(UOj +CP»OµF»T +GP\DG½[C½»PFCKMGPJµFGMK 2UOCPN»5WUJCTDKFQNC[»U»[NCDCDCU» KNGDKTNKMVGºUVCPDWNµCIGNFKNGT([R ¼CJ6WNVCP6»D[CP0GMVGDK U»TCNCT»PFC[C\»[CQNCPKNIKUKPFGP FQNC[»)KNKDGNK%CMMCN$JOGFÃTKH (HGPFKµFGPUNUPGUKJOG½MGVOG[G DC½NCF».nM[C½»PFCJCHVCFCKMK IPÃTKH(HGPFKµ[GDKTIPGXKPGDKT IPFG1WTWQUOCPK[GµFGMK OG½MJjPG[GFGTUGFGXCOGFGTGM 5GEGR$TCN»MµFCUNU PGUKJKEj\GVPjOGUKPKCNF»0WJUKP\jFG $DFWNNCJ+COFK%G[µFGDWKEj\GVKVCUFKM GVOK½VKT7CµNKM[C\»[».CT»PjDjFN»+CUCP +UP(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGFGTGMJ [»N»PFCKEj\GVCNF» Mehmed Aziz (Aktu¤) Efendi 90 M 91 Mehmed Aziz Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs levha Eyüplü Hattatlar 0GENKUKKFCTGKG[VjO<GVKOOCNNCT»KFCTGUK[C\»K½NGTKPFGUGMK\[»NOGOWTK[GVVGP UQPTC[»N»PFCC[P»FCKTGPKP0GMVDu0G½uJCV»8N[j.CNGOK.GVGDGUKPG OGOWTQNFW[»N»PFC[KPGC[P»FCKTGPKP0CµTW\jV»0JKOOG.KVjDGVKµPGVGTHK GFGTGMIO½NK[jMCVOCFCN[CU»XGTKNFK 0»U»T.TCN»)WCFµC.WTµjP».GTuO[C\OCM\GTGµFG0»U»TµCCNV»C[N»¹»PCFCXGV GFKNFK7G\JKDKµPKPFGMGPFKUKPFGP[CR»NOCU»KUVGPKPEGCNV»C[FCJCQTFCMCNF»%W CTCFCºUVCPDWNµFCMKOGOWTK[GVKMCNF»T»N»PEC0»U»TµFCMCNCTCM.TCN)WCFµ»PKUVG¹K \GTKPG+CNKN$¹CXG¼G[J6jNKJOGFTGUGNGTKPFGQPDKT[»NJCVXGVG\JKRFGTUKXGTFK 0»U»Tµ»PKMNKOKC¹»TIGNFK¹KPFGPTCJCVU»\N»¹»PFCPGOGMNKNK¹KPKKUVG[GTGMºUVCPDWNµC F{PF&GOC\K[GNGXXGN$¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFG)CVKJcCT½CPDCµFCMK GXKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T.CDKTMKVjDGUK[GPK JCTHNGTNGFKTXG½{[NGFKT Mehmed Aziz Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs ve celî dîvâni levha 92 M Aziz Efendi kabir kitabesi +CVVCVº¼GJKT »G[J$\K\GT5WHjK (HGPFKPKP 5WJWPC)jVKJC $¸WUVQU $\K\(HGPFKgOO.GPjP 'GTIjJ»RQUVPu½KPK.GPjP 5KHjKµ[GKPVKUjD» FQNC[»U»[NCDC\GP[C\»NCT»PC ²G½¼G[J$DFNC\K\GT5»HjK³ ½GMNKPFGKO\CCVO»½V»T Mehmed Aziz Efendi’nin do¤um tarihi (‹bnülemin, 68; Derman; Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, L.53) h. 1288/1871 olarak gösterilmifl ise de Muhittin SER‹N taraf›ndan fieriyye Sicilleri’nde yap›lan araflt›rmalarda do¤um tarihin h. 1289/1872 oldu¤u tespit edilmifltir. (Bkz. Muhittin SER‹N, Hattat Aziz Efendi, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Akademisi Kültür ve San’at Vakf›, 1988, s.13) 128- ‹bnülemin, 68; Cemâlettin Server Revnako¤lu, “Hattat Aziz Efendi” Divan Edebiyat› Müzesi, Dosya, B.41; Serin, a.g.e., 13. ‹bnülemin, 68; Derman, Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, L.53; Serin, a.g.e., 13. *Bu icâzetnâme bugün Kubbealt› Kültür ve San’at Vakf› Ekrem Hakk› Ayverdi Hat Koleksiyonunu Semâhâne (Tevhîdhâne) k›sm› 40 no’da bulunmaktad›r. (Bkz. Serin, Aziz Efendi, 15; a.mlf., Ayverdi Hat Koleksiyonu, 52) Hayat› ile ilgili bkz. ‹bnülemin, 550-551. Bu icâzetname için bkz. Serin, Aziz Efendi, 14. ‹bnülemin, 68; Serin, Aziz Efendi, 18. ‹bnülemin, 71-72; serin, a.g.e., 24-35. Serin, a.g.e. , 19. 93 Aziz Efendi’nin imzas› Mehmed Bâhir Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar VCTKJKPFGFQ¹FW<C\»[»<C¹N»ME»\jFG6CFTC\CO0GJOGF(OKP3C½C P»P VQTWPW.C\CUMGT$DFNMCFKT%G[{µFGP{¹TGPFKXGKEj\GVCNF» 6QPTC(PFGTP»+Oj[WP CVC NuMJCVJQECU»QNFW0QNNC*TjPKEKXCT»PFC +CN»E»NCT.{½M PFG0QNNC¼GTGH0CJCNNGUK PFGMKGXKPFGKUVG[GPNGTGRGT½GODG IPNGTKVC NuMOG½MGFGTFK3C\CTVGUKIPNGTKFG(PFGTWP FCMKXC\KHGUKPGIKFGTFK 5KXj[GVGFKNFK¹KPGI{TGKMKVCTCHVCMK{¹TGPEKUC[»U»KMK[\DWNWPWTFW6»TCKNG VCNKOGFGTMGPDQ½QNCPVCNGDGPKPGNKPGOTGMMGR½K½GUKPKXGTGTGMnCNMCNCV»T OTGMMGDKVGTDK[GGFGTFK0GXNGXuVCTKMCVKPGOGPUWRVW Mehmed Bâhir Efendi hatt› ile talik levha 94 M Mehmed Bâhir Efendi kabir kitabesi 5GDKNGXXGN$¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK .CDTK([RUWNVCP FC.C½ICTK7GMMGUK{PPFGMK JC\KTGFGFKT0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT <j+C\TGVK0GXNCPj »G[JNJCVVCVKP (PFGTWPºJOj[PVC NKMJQECUºOGTJWO XGOC¸HWTGNOWJVCEKNCTCJOGVK TCDDKJK´NICHTGU6G[[KF 0GJOGF%jJKT(HGPFK PKP XGEGOK KGJNKKOjPºP (TXjJºPCHjVKJC5C ‹bnülemin,516; Rado, 210 95 Mehmed Bâhir Efendi hatt› ile talik levha (Cenap Yazansoy Koleksiyonu) Mehmed Efendi (Sultan Kethüdâs›) 6WNVCP,,,$JOGF KPM»\»)CVOC6WNVCP C[KTOKUGPGFGPHC\NCMGVJFjN»M [CRV»¹»PFCP6WNVCP.GVJFjU»FK[GVCP»PO»½V»T<C\»[».WT½WPEW\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK {KNGºUOCKN(HGPFK FGPOG½MGVOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T7GTUjPGXG0CVDCJ (OKPKQNOW½XGVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK([R VG=CN0CJOWF3C½C &COKKUVMCR»U»MCT½»U»PFCMKOG\CTN»MVCF»TXGVC½»OGXEWVVWT Suyolcuzade, 129; Tilgen, 13. Mehmed Efendi (K›z Alizâde) ([RUWNVCPVTDGFCT».»\$NK(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT1K½CPE»VCTCH»PFC'CXWF$¹C &COKKOG\\KPNK¹KPK[CRO»½V»T+UPKJCVV»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC([[DK(HGPFK PKP {¹TGPEKNGTKPFGP5GEGD+CNKHG FGP{¹TGPFKXGKEj\GVCNCTCMCMTCPNCT»P»IGnVK 0WUKMu[GOGTCMN»MjDKNK[GVNKDKT\jVV»VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 432; Tilgen, 13 Mehmed Efendi (Kad›zâde) ([[RN FT.CF»\jFGFK[GVCP»P»TF»%GNFGUKPFGOCJMGOGMjVKDKDC½MCPN»¹»PFC M»TM[»NC[CM»PJK\OGVGVVK+UPKJCVV»$¹CMCR»N»ºUOCKN(HGPFK\jFG0WUVCHC (HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFKXGKEj\GVCNF»([RcCT½»U» PFCGXKPGDKVK½KMQFCNCTKnKPFGDKT nG½OG[CRV»TCTCM{\GNXCM»HOG[FCPCIGVKTOK½XGnG½OGPKP.KVjDGUKPKFGºDTCJKO 7jJKT(HGPFK [G[C\F»TO»½V»T0GJOGF(HGPFK¼GXXCN1KUCPVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK Suyolcuzâde, 108; Müstakimzâde, 495-496; Tilgen, 13; Rado, 159-166; Haskan, Eyüp Tarihi, II/115-116; 96 M Mehmed Efendi (Eyyüpzâde) ºUVCPDWNNWQNWR([[R\jFGFK[GVCP»PO»½V»T6NUXGPGUKJJCVV»1GHGU\jFG6G[[KF ºUOCKN(HGPFK{µFGP{¹TGPOK½VKT7CµNKM[C\»[»FCOG½MGFGP0GJOGF (HGPFK.GOCPMG½NKMVGFCJKVC½FKMOK½MCD\CCNO»½DKTRGJNKXCPKFK .GPFKUK¼G[J6G[[KF0GJOGF9CJ[K(HGPFK{µPKPFCOCF»KFK ¼G[JNKUNjO6G[[KF)G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK{µPKPVGHVK½JK\OGVKPFGDWNWPFW¹W KnKP½GJjFGVKPFG6NG[OCPK[G0GFTGUGUKµPFGMKTVDGUKKPFKTKNFKHCMCVUQPTCKCFG GFKNFK1KUCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCF»T Müstakimzâde: 394-395 Mehmed Efendi (Rizeli) 97 5K\GNKµFKT7CµNKMJCVV»<GMnG½O6NG[OCP(HGPFK{FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT 0FGTTKUKMGP6WNVCP,0CJOWFµWPEWNUUGPGUKQNCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 733. Mehmed Efendi (Yeniflehir Fenerli) <GPK½GJKT)GPKTNKµFKT.C\CUMGT.WFUu\jFG¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFKµPKPVG\MKTGEKUK QNCTCMDKNKPKT7CµNKMJCVV»6K[jJK$JOGF(HGPFK{FGP{¹TGPOK½XG 7QRJCPGNK0CJOWF(HGPFK{FGPFGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T 7CTKMCVGIGTK½KOG½JWT0GNjOK½G[JKXGMWVDW%WTUCN»6G[[KF0GJOGF+j½KO (HGPFK{[GDC¹NCPOCU»KNGQNOW½VWT0GUNG¹KPFGKNGTNG[GTGM 5GDKNGXXGN0C[»UVCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFWXGDKTUGPGUQPTC C\NQNWPFW%KTOFFGVUQPTC½WWTWPCJCNGNIGNFKXGDWJCNnUGPGFGXCOGVVKMVGP UQPTC5COC\CP7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»F»½»PFC 6»TV7GMMGEKXCT»PFC(OKT%WJjTKOG\CTN»¹»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 728-729; Sicill-i Osmanî IV/187 Mehmed Efendi (Karc›bafl›) ([RUWNVCPN»QNWRUCTC[»PMCTE»DC½»U»KFK6NUXGPGUKJJCVV»'GFGºDTCJKODKP$NK (HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T2¹NW6CFGFFKP(HGPFKFGJCVVCVV» UGPGUKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTKPKP[GTKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT Müstakimzâde, 495 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Efendi (Berberzâde) 98 0GJOGF(HGPFK<WUWH0WJNKU 3C½C&CFFGUK\GTKPFG.CR»E» cG½OGUKFK[GDKNKPGP.CR»C¹CU» 0WUVCHC$¹CcG½OGUKEKXCT»PFC DGTGDGT+UG[KP$¹CµP»PQ¹NWFWT .C[PCMNCTFCCF»IGnOGOGMVGFKT .KOFGPFGTUCNF»¹»VGURKV GFKNGOGOK½VKT5GEGD 0CTVcCT½CODCIPXGHCV GVVK6KMMGNK½jJKFGUK3K[GTNQVK .CJXGUKEKXCT»PFCºFTKUM{½M &CFFGUKKNG*O½c»MOC\»µP»P DKTNG½VK¹K[GTFGn»MOC\UQMC¹»PUQN M{½GUKPFGFKT+GOGP[CP»DC½»PFC µFGXGHCVGFGP 'Q¹CPE»DC½»CJOGF3C½CµP»P µFGXGHCVGFGP Berberzâde Mehmed Efendi’nin mezartafl› M 0CJOWF3C½CµP»PµFGXGHCVGFGPDWIPM3K[GTNQVKMCJXGUK[GTKPFGM{½M DWNWPCP5CDKC.CF»Pµ»PXGµFGXGHCVGFGP5CDKC+CP»Oµ»PDCDCU»0FGTTKU 0GJOGF7CJKT(HGPFKµPKPMCDKTNGTKDWNWPOCMVCF»T Gezi notu, M. Nermi Haskan Mehmed Efendi (Çörekcizâde) ºUVCPDWNNWQNWR%CN»MRC\CT».CR»U»KnKPFGc{TGMEK+UG[KP$¹CµP»PQ¹NWFWT%W UGDGDVGPc{TGMEK\jFGFK[GDKNKPOGMVGFKT6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»+UG[KP+CDNuµFGP OG½MGVVK.GPFKUKDKTnQM'GNjKNKJC[TjV[C\O»½V»T6CHGT(MKOVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK2VCME»NCT&COKK{PPFG7QMOCMVGRG0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK Müstakimzade, 407; Habib, 137 Mehmed Efendi (Nakkaflzâde) VCTKJKPFG2VCME»NCT FCFQ¹FW1CMMC½\jFGNjMCD»[NCVCP»PO»½V»T<C\»[».jVKR 0GJOGF(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFKgUVjF»P»PXGHCV»\GTKPG.jVKDK6CTC[»6WNVCPu QNOW½VWT0UVCMKO\jFGµPKPKHjFGUKPGI{TGMCDTK2VCMn»NCT7QMOCVGRG OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»TVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 478; Tilgen s. 13 Mehmed Efendi (Laz Mehmed) /C\0GJOGFNjMCD»[NCVCP»PO»½V»T([R FG$MCTnG½OG FGFQ¹OW½VWT+C\KPGK +jUUCOGOWTNCT»PFCPKFK5KMµC[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPOW½VWT[»N»PFCXGHCV GVOK½VKT Tilgen, 13 99 Mehmed Emin Ât›f Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWQNWRDCDCU»)CVKJ&COKKEKXCT»PFCMK.GRGMEKNGT&COKKºOCO»0GJOGF (HGPFKXGMGPFKUKFG5WOGNK.CNGOKMCF»NCT»PFCPKFK%CDCU»P»PM»\MCTFG½K+QEC 0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKKNGGXNKDWNWPW[QTFW%WOPjUGDGVNGUNUXGPGUKJK QPFCPVCJUKNXGVGMOKNGFKRKEj\GVCNO»½V»T 2VW\[C½»P»JGP\VCOCONCO»½MGPVCTJKPFGXGDCJCUVCN»¹»PFCPXGHCVGVVK .CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹» PFCF»T 0GFGFJGOPjOº3G[ICODGT(OKPj$VºHJQ¼I ¹FDTºJNGVMCNGOMCNFºQFGOC NCOGJKDDj[C 'VCTKJKPDWDG[VG[C\FºQNFGMMKTGXjPQNFW &KPjPGEjPCVWDMºNFºVGXEKJU[º0GXNj [C %GMj[ºDKP[\GNNKCNVºUjNKPFGQNWDUjKT ¹PjPTJº$VºH FºTOKPjUDºWMDj[C Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 446-447; Habib, 141 Emin Bey hatt› ile talik k›t’alar 100 M Mehmed Emin Bey (UMKUCFTC\CO<C¹N»ME»\jFG0GJOGF(OKP3C½CµP»PQ¹NWFWT5COC\CP +C\KTCPVCTKJKPFG.CFKT*GEGUKµPFGFQ¹FW%WPWPKnKPQ¹NWPC$DFNMCFKT CF»P»XGTFKcQMK[KDKTG¹KVKOCNCTCM[GVK½VK+QECNCT»$NjK[GNK.CF»\jFG0GJOGF (HGPFK.CTCOCPN»ÃDKF(HGPFKcGVGNK$JOGF(HGPFK*GNGPDGXuºUOCKN(HGPFK 7CVCTE»M\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK1WTK(HGPFK+jH»\(FKD(HGPFK1KOGV(HGPFK\jFGXG %GPNK\jFGIKDKFGXTKPCNKONGTNGTKKFK%WPNCTFCPIGPGNMNVTJWMWMWUNMGNjO JGUCRJGPFGUGXGGFGDK[CVFGTUNGTKCNO»½V»T7CµNKMJCVV»P»<GUjTu0GJOGF(UµCF (HGPFK{µFGP[C\F»XG²ºMKPEK<GUjTu³FK[GCP»NOC[CDC½NCPF» (OKP%G[JµFG*CNCVC0QNNCU»µFG(FKTPG3j[GUKµFG0GMMG 3j[GUKµFGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»DKTUGPGUQPTC$PCFQNW3j[GUKµFG KMKPEKFGHCºUVCPDWN.CF»U»µFG$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKµFG5WOGNK 3j[GUKQNOW½XG5GDK[NGXXGNKPKPUGMK\KPFG1KUCPµFGXGHCVGVVK ([RUWNVCP&COKKMCT½»U»PFCMKJC\KTGFGCPPGUK+CHK\G+CP»Oµ»P[CP»PCFGHPGFKNFK (OKP%G[FKPFCTXGnQMDKNIKNKDKT\jVKFKºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFW¹WU»TCFCKPUCHU»\ GUPCHCnQMUGTVFCXTCPOCU»KNGVCP»PO»½V»T Sicill-i Osmânî, I, 419; ‹bnülemin, 530. 101 Mehmed Emin Dede (Yaz›c›) fOGT9CUHu(HGPFKµPKPMCTFG½KQNCP0GJOGF (OKP'GFG(HGPFK&GOC\K[GNGXXGN 0CTVVCTKJKPFG7QRJCPGµFG 'GHVGTFCT0CJCNNGUKµPFGFP[C[CIGNFK 5½FK[GVCJUKNKPFGPUQPTC[C\» OG½MGVOG[GDC½NCF»'\GPNKDKT[C\» G¹KVKOKCNOCF»CPECMMjDKNK[GVK[NGI\GN GUGTNGTXGTFK$¹CDG[KfOGT9CUHu(HGPFK JCVVCV6jOK(HGPFKµ[GFGTUGIKVVKMnGQFC [CP»PFCIKVVK6jOK(HGPFKµFGPnQMnCKUVKHCFG GVVK Sultanhamam Birinci Vak›f Han› üzerindeki çeflme üzerinde Mehmed Emin Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs kitabe Eyüplü Hattatlar +WMWMVCJUKNKU»TCU»PFC3QUVCºFCTGUKPGIKTFK'CJCUQPTC*GPGNMWTOC[JCVVCVN»¹»PC VC[KPQNFW0WUKMKFGFGOCJjTGVKQNFW¹WPFCP*CNCVC0GXNGXKJCPGUK 1G[\GPDC½»N»¹»PCIGVKTKNFK (OKP(HGPFKCTMCFC½»1GEOGFFKP2M[C[µ»PVG½XKMK[NGHGXMCNjFGOMGOOGNDKT ½GMKNFG[C\»VCMNKFGVOK½VKT¼G[J+COFWNNCJ+jH»\2UOCP5jM»O0CJOWF &GNjNGFFKPXG¼GXMKGHGPFKNGTKP[C\»NCT»P»DC½CT»N»DKT½GMKNFGVCMNKFGVOK½VKT (OGMNKQNFWMVCPUQPTCFCJCVXGOWUKMuKNGOG½IWNK[GVKPKUTFTF6Q[CF» MCPWPWPFCPUQPTC²<C\»E»³UQ[CF»P»CNF»6CHGT¼WDCVVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK([RµVG.jOKN$MFKMOG\CT»[CM»P»PCC¹CDG[KPKP[CP»PCFGHPGFKNFK Mehmed Emin Efendi’ye ait talik ve celî sülüs yaz›lar 102 M 6WNVCPJCOCO%KTKPEK9CM»H+CP»{PPFGnG½OG\GTKPFGMKEGNuUNU[C\»U»KNG 6KTMGEK+D[jT0GUEKFK\GTKVC½COCJMMEGNu[C\»U»{PGONKGUGTNGTKPFGPFKT ‹bnülemin, 80-85; Emin Dede, Yeni Adam Dergisi, 22 fiubat 1945; M. U¤ur Derman. “Kardefl ‹ki Hattat›m›z”, ‹stanbul, 50 San’at Sever Serisi 22, 1966, 9 s.; Rado, 255-257 ; Derman; ‹KMHS, 228. Mehmed Emin Efendi (Edirneli) 0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK(FKTPGNKQNWRVCTKJKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK0GXNGXK[GV Rj[GUKPGWNC½O»½jNKONGTFGP0GJOGF5JK(HGPFKµPKPCMTCDCU»PFCPF»T6NUXG PGUKJJCVVCnCN»½»R(FKTPGNKJCVVCV\jFGOWUKMK½KPCUXG*N½GPK[[GµFGPQNCP +UG[KP(HGPFKµFGPQPn[C½»PFCKMGPKOVKJCPGFKNOGUKPKKUVGOK½XGKEj\GV CNO»½V»T¼jKTºDTCJKO(HGPFKµPKPDWOPCUGDGVNGF½TF¹VCTKJ½WFWT 1C\KTjDKT\K[jFGQNFWJCVVjV =GJuJCVVºFKNjTC%jTGMCNNjJ Edirneli Mehmed Emin Efendi’ye ait Emirgan Çeflmesi üzerindeki celî sülüs kitabe 103 104 Eyüplü Hattatlar Edirneli Mehmed Emin Efendi’ye ait Emirgan Çeflmesi üzerindeki celî sülüs yaz› ve imza k›s›mlar› M 'CJCUQPTCºUVCPDWNµCIGNOK½XG*OTMnºUJCM$¹C{P»P[CTF»O»[NC 7GDGTFCT2EC¹»µPCIKTOK½VKT%KTOFFGVUQPTC'CTUUCjFG$¹CU»¼GJKF(DWXWMWH $JOGF$¹C{µP»PMCJXGEKUKQNFW%WTCFCHC\NCMCNO»[CTCM+jEGIjP U»P»H»PCIGnOK½VKT (OKP(HGPFKºUJCM$¹CµP»P%G[MQ\µFCMKnG½OGNGTKKNG.KTGnDWTPWµPFCMKnG½OGPKP .KVjDGUKPKEGNKJCVKNG[C\O»½V»T$TCR&COKK*CNCVCEKJGVKPFG²6GNCOPCNG[MO DKOjUCDGTVO³j[GVKMGTuOGUKXG(FKTPG6CTC[»µP»PDVPEGNu[C\»NCT»gUMFCT $[C\OC&COKKEGNuJCVNCT»(OKTIjPcG½OGUK.KVjDGUKKNG(OKP{P+COuFK(XXGN VTDGUKKnKPFGVTDG[KH»TFQNC[»nGXKTGPMW½CMQPWPFWT(OKTIjcG½OGUKXG+COuF K(XXGNVTDGUKPFGMK[C\»NCT»PFC KO\CU»XCTF»T (OKP(HGPFKVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR» 0G\CTN»¹»µPFCF»THCMCVOG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUK[QMVWT Sicill-i Osmânî, c. I,327, c. IV/666; Müstakimzâde, 170, 409-410; Habib, 136137; Koçu, “Emin Efendi (Edirneli Mehmed)”, ‹st. A. , IX, 4560-4561; Muhittin Serin, “Emin Efendi, Edirneli”, D‹A, XI, 114-115 105 Edirneli Mehmed Emin Efendi’nin 1. Abdülhamid Türbesi’nde bulunan kuflak yaz›s› ve imza k›sm› Mehmed Emin Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar ([RN FT%jNK+QEC&COKK MCT½»U»PFCMK.CR»E»%CMMCN 5½FK[GUKXG7C½OGMVGRIKDKDC\» QMWNNCTC[C\»JQECU»QNFW6QP FGXKTFGDC\»JCVVCVNCT»PJQECU» KFK(FKTPGMCR»[QNW\GTKPFG OGFHWP(DWDGMKT5C½KF(HGPFK OG\CT.KVjDGUKQPWPFWT%WIP +CNKn.{RTUC[C¹»FKDKPFG Yaz›lar› Mehmed Emin Efendi’ye ait olan Pertevniyal Valide Sultan Çeflmesi 106 Pertevniyal Valide Sultan Çeflmesi celî sülüs yaz›s› ve Emin Efendi imzas› M DWNWPCP3GTVGXPK[CN9CNKFG 6WNVCPcG½OGUK PKP.KVjDGUKQPWP JCVV»KNG[C\»NO»½XG KO\CNCPO»½V»T+ VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK0CCNGUGH MCDTKPKP[GTKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT ([RUWNVCPµFCDKTnQM½CJKFGFG KO\CU»DWNWPOCMVCF»T Emin Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs mezartafl› kitabesi Tilgen, 13; Rado, 229; Aç›kgözo¤lu, Eyüpsultan Civar›nda ‹mzal› Mezartafl› Kitâbeleri, (Yüksek Lisans Tezi), s. 125. Mehmed Emin Kâflif Efendi (fiat›rzâde) .j½KH(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWµFWT6NU XGPGUKJ[C\»[»(OKTGHGPFK\jFG +CNKO(HGPFK{µFGP {¹TGPFK%jD»jNKµFG5GKU.CNGOK TKECNKPFGPQNFW¹WKnKP'uXjPK TKMµCXGFK¹GT[C\»nG½KVNGTKPFGFG GJNK[GVKXCTF» &GOC\K[GNGXXGN2ECM VCTKJKPFGKNMFGHC=KNMCFG +C\KTCPµFCKMKPEKFGHCQNOCM\GTGKMKFGHC5GKUµNMVVjD'»½K½NGTK%CMCP» QNFW%WI{TGXNGTFGF{TVUGPGDWNWPFW5GEGD2ECMµFG%C½'GHVGTFCT 0CNK[G%CMCP»QNFW %WCTCFC²0GMVDuK6CFT»jNK³XG².GVJFj[»6CFT»jNK³IKDKD[MI{TGXNGT UVNGPFK+CNMCTCU»PFC²(OKP.GVJFj³NjMCD»[NCOG½JWTQNFW&GOC\K[GNCJKT .CU»OVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPµFC.nM(OKT(HGPFKCn»M VTDGUKPKPUQNVCTCH»PFCXGJC\KTG[GCn»NCPKMKPEKMCR»P»PCTMCU»PFCF»T.KVjDGUK ½{[NGFKT 107 +WXG´N+C[[W´N%jMu 0GTJWOXGOC¸HTW´N OWJVjE ¹NjTCJOGVKTCDDKJK´NICHT .GVJWFj[ºUCFTºjNuKMGP 9GFjºjNGOKHjPuXGC\OK *NKUVjPºDjMuGFGP .j¼KH0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK 5WJKnWP GN)CVKJC Mehmed Emin Kâflif Efendi’nin flahidesi .j½KH0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK jNKOGFKDXCMWTDKTKPUCPF» .GPFKUKC[P»\COCPFC½jKTQNWR ½KKTNGTKPFGMKOCJNCU»².j½KH³KFK Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 471; Sicill-i Osmânî IV, 66; Daniflmend, ‹slâm Tarihi Kronolojisi IV, 613, 635; Türk Dili ve Edebiyat› Ansiklopedisi, V, 218; fiem’dânîzâde Süleyman Efendi. Mür’i’t-tevârih, (Haz. Münir Aktepe) ‹stanbul, ‹stanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Yay›n›, 1976, II. s. 17, 33, 42, 56, 63, 74, 107; Haskan, 280 108 Mehmed Es’ad Bey &KJCP\jFG0GJOGF(UµCF%G[ FK[GDKNKPOGMVGFKT%CJCTK[G 1G\jTGVK0GMVDK2FCU»0FT 0WJKD(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT (FKTPGµFGFQ¹OW½VWT 6»D[CP0GMVGDKµPFGPUQPTC{\GN Mehmed Es’ad Bey’e ait mezartafl› kitabesi M JQECNCTFCP$TCRnCXG)CTUnCQMWFWµFCOFGTTKUQNFW%CJCTK[G0GMVDK 2FCU»PCOGOWTQNCTCMIKTFK5GEGR+C\KTCPVCTKJKPFG OFGTTKUNKMVGPJjEGIjPN»MU»P»H»PCIGnVK VCTKJKPFG+CTKEK[G1G\jTGVK0GMVDK.CNGOKµPGPCMNGFKNFK VCTKJKPFG[KTOKDG½ºPIKNK\CNV»P»OCC½NC/QPFTC6GHCTGVK%C½.jVKRNK¹KµPGVC[KP GFKNFK¼GXXCN+C\KTCPVCTKJKPFGDWI{TGXKPFGPC[T»NF»7GMTCT+CTKEK[G 0GMVDK.CNGOKµPGF{PF &GOC\K[GNGXXGN2ECMVCTKJKPFGKMKDKPDG½[\MWTW½OCC½NCCUCNGVGP ÃOGFKK'uXjP»+Oj[WP.CNGOKµPGVC[KPQNWPFW%WI{TGXFG[KTOK[GFKUGPG MCNF» ¼GXXCN7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGDG½DKPMWTW½OCC½NC¼Tj[»'GXNGV $\CN»¹»µPCKNjXGVGP%jD»jNK7CJUKNjV6CPF»¹»5K[jUGVKµPGVC[KPGFKNFK 5COC\CP(MKOVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP7TDGUK EKXCT»PFCF»T ‹bnülemin, 695 Mehmed H›fz› Efendi 109 0GJOGF+»H\»(HGPFK6NG[OCP(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNWRºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW *CNCVCUCTC[»µPFCVCJUKNI{TGTGMJjH»\QNFW2TCFCDWNWPCP+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF» +»H\»(HGPFKDKT.WTµjP».GTuO[C\CTCMW¹WTQNOCU»FKNG¹KKNGDGUOGNGUKPK [C\OCU»P»JQECU»PFCPTKECGVOK½XGUQPTCI{VTR6WNVCP,,,$JOGF GVCMFKO GVOK½VK%W[\FGP(PFGTP»+Oj[WP CJQECQNCTCMVC[KPQNWPOW½VWT +»H\»(HGPFK(PFGTWP FCMK0KTjJWT&COKKKOCO»QNWR(OKT(HGPFKFK[GDKNKPGP $DFWNNCJ(HGPFK FGPVGMTCT[C\»OG½MGFGTGM[GPKFGPKEj\GVCNO»½V»T =COCPNC6WNVCP,0CJOWFUCNVCPCV»P»PDC½NCT»PFC6»T.jV»DKXG*OTM%C½ .CV»DKQNFW+CEE»P»GFjGVVKMVGPUQPTC&GOC\K[GNGXXGN2ECMµFCPUQPTC Mehmed H›fz› Efendi hatt› ile Eyüp Sultan Türbesi’nde bulunan kitâbe XGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKKEKXCT»PFCXGCPPGUKPKP[CP»FCF»T $[XCPUCTC[U»TVNCT»PFCDWNWPCP(OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUK½G[JKOG½j[KJFGP7CVCT+QEC $JOGF(HGPFKXCU»VCU»[NCVCTKMCVGIKTFK¹KKnKP[C\F»¹»DKT.WTµjP».GTuO KQTC[C JGFK[GGVVK 6WNVCP,0CJOWF WP([RUWNVCP7TDGUKIKTK½KPG[GTNG½VKTFK¹K+C\TGVK 0WJCOOGF KPC[CM½GMNKPKPDWNWPFW¹WFQNCD»PUVPFGMKMKVjDGFGDW\jV»PF»T gnU»TCJCNKPFGJC\»TNCPO»½QNCPQPO»UTCN»MKVjDGPKPQMWPW½W½{[NGFKT =K[jTGVIjJºOOGVQNOC¸C6WNVCP0CJOWF+CP 0CMjOºCMFGUGXC\ G[NGFKDKTMGP\KNj[PUj »GTGH[jDºMCFGOQNUWPFG[([[DKGPUjTu 0NMK¼GJGKVFKVTDG[G\XXjTKnPKJFj 1QNCIGTJKUUGOGPFKPCM¼ºRj[KOEVGDjQNC $NGOFjTº5GUNK.KDTK[j FºTQNEKJjFjTj 8UjVºOOGVKnPMQ[FWDKTjUjTºKUVK¼Hj 2NjNKRTJFGJºTOjPº¼GHjjVOKQNCJC¼j '¼TFOD{[NGDKTOW EK\POj[GKJWVC[jVjTKJ 0CMjOºPDWNFWTGUOKRj[º6WNVCPº5WUNJCMMC Eyüplü Hattatlar Sicill-i Osmânî II/234; Müstakimzâde, 412; Habib, 137; Recep Akakufl, Eyyûb Sultan ve Mukaddes Emanetler. ‹stanbul, 1973, s. 120-121; Rado, 16; Haskan, I, 185 110 Mehmed Hulusi Efendi <C\»JQECU»5CI»DRC½C.VRJCPGUKJjH»\»MVD0CJOWF5jEK(HGPFKKFK6WNVCP $DFNOGEKFFGXTKPFG%G\OKjNGO9CNKFG6WNVCPVCTCH»PFCP6WNVCP,,0CJOWF 7TDGUKEKXCT»PFC[CRV»T»NCP'jT NOCjTKHQMWNWPFC[C\»JQECN»¹»[CRV»*\GN MQPW½VW¹WMNVTNXGCJNjMN»DKT\jVQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPWTµFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U»0G\CTN»¹»µPFC+CNGDKcGNGDKEKXCT»PFCKFK0G\CTVC½» .KVjDGUKDWIPOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT Habib, 171 M Mehmed Hulusi Efendi (Yazgan) VCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWNµFC FP[C[CIGNFK$U»NCF»0GJOGFQNWR +WNUKOCJNCU»F»T6WNVCP6GNKO 0GMVGDKµPFGMKVCJUKNKPFGPUQPTC DCDCU»PFCPECOKFGTUNGTKPGFGXCO GVVKVCTKJKPFGKNOK[GKEj\GVK CNF»ºNM[C\»FGTUNGTKPKKRVKFCK OGMVGDKPFG2UOCP1WTK(HGPFKµFGPCNF» 'CJCUQPTC0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ (HGPFKµFGPUNUXGPGUKJFGTUNGTKCNF»7CµNKM [C\»[C.CTKPCDCFN»+CUCP+UPu(HGPFKµFGP DC½NCO»½cCT½CPDCN»0GJOGFÃTKH%G[µFGPVCOCONCO»½V»T6COK(HGPFKµFGPVCµNuM [C\»P»PKPEGNKMNGTKPK{¹TGPFK 'CT½½CHCMCµ[C[C\»JQECU»QNFW0GFTGUGK+CVVCVuPµKPMWTWNW½WPFCVCµNuMXG EGNuVCµNuMJQECU»QNCTCMVC[KPGFKNFK+CTHKPMKNjD»PFCOGFTGUGNGTMCRCV»N»PEC 7TDGNGT%C½DGMnKNK¹KI{TGXKPGIGVKTKNFKXG'CT½½CHCMCµFC[GPKJCTHNGTNG[C\» FGTUNGTKXGTFK$[T»EC{NOPGMCFCT6WNVCP6GNKO&COKKOG\\KPNK¹KI{TGXKPK[CRV» +WNUK(HGPFKCU»NOCJjTGVKPKVCµNuMXGEGNuVCµNuM[C\»FCQTVC[CMQ[OW½VWT °[»NNCT»CTCU»UCPCV»P»PGPRCTNCMF{PGOKFKT*{TGX[CRV»¹»6WNVCP6GNKO Hulusi Efendi’nin Fatih, Sultan Selim Camii’inde bulunan zerendûd celî talik levhas› 111 112 Eyüplü Hattatlar Hulusi Efendi hatt› ile zerendûd celî talik levha (Merkez Efendi Camii) Hulusi Efendi’nin celî sülüsle yazd›¤› ve tafla mahkuk kitabe (Fatih, Sultan Abdülmecid Türbesi kap› üzeri) M 113 Hulusi Efendi’nin celî sülüsle yazd›¤› zerendûd levha (Fatih, Sultan Selim Camii) &COKKµPFGEGNuUNUXGEGNuVCµNuMNGXJCU»OGXEWVVWT&GNuUNUµNG[C\F»¹»NGXJC $¹WUVQUFGRTGOKUQPTCU»[CR»NCPVGOK\NKMGUPCU»PFCnCNF»T»NO»½HCMCVFCJC UQPTCDWNWPCTCM[GTKPGCU»NO»½V»T6WNVCPCJOGF&COKK6WNVCP6GNKO7TDGUK %j[G\KFXG0GTMG\GHGPFK&COKNGTKPFGPGHKUNGXJCNCT»OGXEWVVWT$PMCTCµFC%KTKPEK 0GENKUDKPCU»PFCMK²+CMKOK[GV0KNNGVKPFKT³NGXJCU»FC+WNUK(HGPFKµPKPFKT+KN[G OG\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKXGNGXJCQNCTCMnQMHC\NCGUGTKXCTF»T +C[CV»P»PUQP\COCPNCT»PFCHGNnIGnKTGP+WNUK(HGPFK2ECMVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK(FKTPGMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PCFGHPGFKNFKMKVjDGUK[QMVWT Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹bnülemin, 551-552; A. Süheyl Ünver, Hattat Hulûsi Efendi, ‹stanbul, 1938 ; M. U¤ur Derman, “Hattat Hulûsi Efendi”, Kubbealt› Akademi Mecmuas›, IX, Ocak 1980, s.32-54; Derman, Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, 26, 55, 64, L. ; Rado, 252; Derman, “Hattat Hulûsi Efendi”, Lâle Mecmuas›, VII, Aral›k 1990 s. 15-20; a. mlf. ‹KMHS, 222; Muhittin Serin, Hulûsi Efendi’nin Ta’lîk Meflk Murakka›, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Neflriyat›, 1999; a. mlf. Hat Sanat› ve Meflhur Hattatlar, 261-266. Hulusi Efendi hatt› ile celî talik bir levha 114 M Mehmed ‹zzet Efendi ([RUWNVCPµFCQVWTFW¹WKnKP([RNQNCTCMCP»NO»½V»T<C\»[»5jM»O(HGPFKµPKP VCNGDGUK0GJOGF+j½KO(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT$[T»ECHQVQ¹TCHUCPCV»KNG OG½IWNQNOW½VWT2MXG[C[KOCNKKNGW¹TC½O»½MKO[CKNOKPGFGXjM»HDKT\jVKFK 6WNVCP$DFNOGEKFµKPQMnWDC½»N»¹»P»FC[CRO»½V»T7CJOKPGPVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK Tilgen, 12; ‹smail Faz›l Ayano¤lu, Ok Meydan› ve Okçuluk Tarihi, Vak›flar Genel Müdürlü¤ü, ts. , 127-128; Derman, ‹KMHS, 212; Okçu ‹zzet Efendi’nin farkl› bir besmele denemesi için bkz. D‹A, V, 539. Mehmed Kâz›m Efendi ([RN FT%CDCU»0WUjJKD0WUVCHC3C½C{µP»PCFCONCT»PFCPcQTNWNW QNCTCMDKNKPFK¹KPFGPQPCFCcQTNWNW\jFGXG[C.j\»O([[DuFGPKNOK½VKT6NUXG PGUKJKKNM{PEG.WT½WPEW\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFK6QPTCJCVVCV+QEC 0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFK FGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF».»TM[C½»PCXCTOCFCP VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK1C\KMW[UCNJW[NWXG½jKTQNFW¹WTKXC[GVGFKNOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 457; Tilgen, 14; Rado, 132; Türk Dili ve Edebiyat› Ansiklopedisi V, 259; Salim Tezkiresi, 421 Mehmed Levni Efendi ([RN FT.nM[C½VC[C\»[C\OC¹CXG.WT CPJ»H\»PCnCN»½O»½V»T+UG[KP+CDNu (HGPFKUC[GUKPFG6WNVCP,90GJOGF KPM»\»+CVKEG6WNVCP »PVGDGTFCTNCT»PFCPQNFW XGUQPTCGOGMNKGFKNFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([R VGºFTKUM{½M EKXCT»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 496-497; Tilgen, 14. Teberderân: Saray hizmetkârlar›ndan olan teberdarlar hakk›nda kullan›l›r bir tabirdir. Teber denilen ay fleklindeki bir nevi küçük balta tafl›d›klar› için bu ad› alm›fllard›r. Bunun yerine “Baltac›lar” da denilirdi. (Pakal›n, Osmanl› Tarih Deyimleri ve Terimleri Sözlü¤ü, III, 429) 115 Mehmed Mecid Efendi (Molla Dilsiz) 7CµNuM[C\»[»'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFKXG(PFGTP»+Oj[WPµCn»TCM QNFW.GPFKUKFKNUK\FKDWUGDGDNG²0QNNCFKNUK\³FGPKTFK+VCTKJKPFGXGHCV GFGTGM/jµNucG½OGUKMCT½»U»PCDCDCU»XGMCTFG½KPKP[CP»PCFGHPGFKNFK.CDKT MKVjDGUK[QMVWT Müstakimzâde, 706-707. Mehmed Nâfi Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar 1jHKµ(HGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGPXG7QRMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPCFGHPGFKNGP'GTXK½ 0WUVCHC(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT0WUVCHC(HGPFK0GXNjPj&GNjNGFFKPK5OK GXNjF»PFCP<CJ[CcGNGDKµPKPQ¹NWFWT'uXjP»+Oj[WP%G[NKMnKNK¹KMGUGFjT»KFK µFGºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW%jD»jNKµFG[GVK½GTGM+jEGIjPµFCPXGUQPTCKNGTNG[GTGM %G[NKMEK.GUGFCT»QNFW Mehmed Nâfi Efendi’nin 1273 senesinde kendi hatt›yla yazd›¤› bir k›t’a 116 M 0GJOGF1jHKµ(HGPFKºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FWµFGJjEGIjPQNFW*\GNJCVV»KNG [C\F»¹»VG\MKTGXGOC\DCVCNCT6WNVCP,,0CJOWFµWPFKMMCVKPKnGMVK2PW0CDG[P .jVKRNK¹KµPGCNF»3CFK½CJ»PD[MIXGPKPGOC\JCTQNFW +C\KTCPµFG6GTCUMGT0UVG½CT»F{TVC[UQPTC0GENKUKXjNjC\CU»0CTV VCTKJKPFG%CJTK[G0UVG½CT»µFG$FNK[G1j\»T»XGQUGPGPKP$TCN»MC[»PFC3CTKU 6GHKTKQNFW%KTVCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGPUQPTC0GENKUK9jNjC\CU»KMGP5GDKWNCJKT .CU»OVCTKJKPFGJCUVCNCPCTCMXGHCVGVVK([RµVGCPPGUKPKP[CP»PC FGHPGFKNFK)CMCVOG\CTVC½»MKVCDGUKOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT 7GFDKTNKnCN»½MCPXGFGXNGVK½NGTKPGXCM»HDKT\CVKFK+CVVCV[C\CTXG½CKTKFK%[M Q¹NW0CJOWFÃMKH(HGPFK$HKHG+CVWP7GMMGUKKMKPEK½G[JKQNOW½VWT Sicill-i Osmani, IV/537-538; ‹bnülemin, 591; ‹bnülemin, Son As›r Türk fiâirleri, 1062. Mehmed Nergisî Efendi %QUPCN»QNWRºUVCPDWN CIGNFK$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTK{.CH\jFG)G[\WNNCJ (HGPFKFjKTGUKPGKPVKUCDGVVK6NUPGUKJVC NKMXGFK¹GT[C\»nG½KVNGTKPFG f\GNNKMNGJWTFGUKMG½VG[C\»[CPCPUXGTGPDKTVCT\FGGOUjNUK\FK6G[[KF +UG[KP9GJDuQPWPJCMM»PFCUGPGNGTUQPTC½WDG[VKU{[NGOK½VKT 'GXjVºnG¼OK¼JKMKNMKOLIjPºPKFDFGTIjT 2NWTKH¼j[ºTj\KVOGMFGC[Pº1GTIKUK\jFG $[T»ECFuXjP»XG+COUGµUK0GUPGXK½GMNKPFG[C\»NO»½DG½MKVCRVCPKDCTGVDKTGUGT UKXCTF»TcQMUTCVNK[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWTVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC¼GMGTRjTG7TDGUKEKXCT»PFCKFK 1GTIKUu PKPKNMVCJUKNK%QUPC FCQNWROFGTTKUNK¹GMCFCT[MUGNOK½VKT%CDCU» 1GTIKUu$JOGF(HGPFK%QUPCMCF»U»PCKDKKFKºUVCPDWN CIGNFKMVGPUQPTC5WOGNK .C\CUMGTKQNOW½VWT2TFW[»+Oj[WP6WNVCP,90WTCFMWOCPFCU»PFC5GXCP 6GHGTK PGn»MCTMGPXCM CPXKUVC[KPGFKNOK½VKT6GHGTF{P½[QNFCIKFGTMGP *GD\G FGCV»PFCPF½GTGMXGHCVGVVK1j½»P»PQTCFCPIGVKTKNGTGM([RUWNVCP C FGHPGFKNFK¹KCPNC½»NOCMVCF»T Suyolcuzâde, 134; Müstakimzâde, 701; ; Habib, 241; Riyâzî Tezkiresi, 102; Osmanl› Müellifleri, II/254; Faik Reflat Eslâf, 1001 Temel Eser, Tercüman Yay›nlar›, ts. s. 203; Rado, 93 117 Mehmed Râsim Efendi (E¤rikap›l›) Eyüplü Hattatlar (¹TKMCR»N»0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKJVCTKJKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK%CDCU» (¹TKMCR»0QNNC$½MKOCJCNNGUKKOCO»<WUWH(HGPFKµFKT=COCP»PFC(¹TKMCR»N»cGNGDK (HGPFKcGNGDK(HGPFK5jUKO(HGPFKXG+QEC0GJOGF5jUKOFGPKNFK¹KIKDK (DWTTG½KFMP[GUKKNGFGCP»NO»½V»T Azapkap› Saliha Sultan Çeflmesi üzerinde Mehmed Râsim Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs yaz›lar 118 M ºNM[C\»FGTUKPKJCVVCVQNCPDCDCU»<WUWH(HGPFKµFGPCNF»'CJCUQPTC6CTC[JQECU» <GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGFGTGMCMNjO»UKVVGFGPJ VCTKJKPFGKEj\GVCNF»0G\WPQNFWMVCPUGMK\[»NUQPTCJ[»N»PFC'COCF ¼GJKF$NK3C½CVCTCH»PFCP*CNCVCUCTC[µCOG½MJQECU»VC[KPGFKNFK+ [»N»PFCVCµNuMJCVJQECU»0WUVCHC(HGPFK[GTKPG<GPK6CTC[JCVJQECN»¹»PCIGVKTKNFK 5jUKO(HGPFK,,,$JOGF,0CJOWF1GX½GJKTNK'COCVºDTCJKO3C½C+GMKOQ¹NW $NK3C½CXG'jTWµUUCjFG$¹CU»+CE»%G½KT$¹C{IKDKKPUCPNCT»PVCMFKTKPK MC\CPO»½V»T 'COCVºDTCJKO3C½CµP»PQ¹NW0GJOGF3C½C6CFTC\CON»¹»PFC<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF $DFWNNCJ(HGPFK[GIWDjTKJCVKNGDKT.WTµCP».GTuOUKRCTK½GFGT<GFKMWNGNK5jUKO (HGPFKµ[GIKFGTGMUKRCTK½CNF»¹».WTµCP»MGPFKUKPKP[C\OCU»P»KUVGT5jUKO(HGPFK nC[KnGTKUKPFG.WTµCP»VCOCONCTXGUQPWPCFCUVjF»P»PKUOKPK[C\CT 5jUKO(HGPFKCNVO»½.WTµjP».GTuODKPMCFCT(PµCO'GNjKNK+C[TCV(XTjF 9CMHK[G[CP»PFC$\CRMCR»6jNKJC6WNVCPcG½OGUK[C\»NCT»P»FC[C\O»½V»T([RµVG (OKT(HGPFKVTDGUKEKXCT»PFC+C[CVK\jFG5GKUµNGVKDC0WUVCHC(HGPFKOG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUKKNG$TRC(OKPK&COKKµPGDKVK½KMnG½OGPKPMKVjDGUKFG5jUKO(HGPFKµ[G CKVVKT6QPWPEWGUGTOCCNGUGH[GTKPFG[QMVWT $[P»\COCPFCK[KDKT½jKTQNCP5jUKO(HGPFKµPKP½KKTNGTKVCNGDGUKºDTCJKO7jJKT (HGPFKVCTCH»PFCPVQRNCPO»½V»T5jUKO(HGPFKµPKP'KXCPnGµUKPFGMKVCTKJM»VµCNCT» VCTKJMC[PC¹»DCM»O»PFCPnQM{PGONKFKT¼CµDCP0C[»UVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGFGTGM(¹TKMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT0G\CTMKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 119 Saliha Sultan Çeflmesi celî sülüs yaz›lar› 120 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Râsim Efendi’ye ait sülüs nesih k›t’a M E¤rikap› Mezarl›¤›’nda Nakkaflbafl› Seyyid ‹brahim A¤a’n›n flahidesi. (Mehmed Râsim Efendi’nin yazd›¤› Kur’an-› Kerimleri tezhib etti¤i san›lmaktad›r.) +WXG´N+C[[W´N%jMK $NNCJ´W6WDJjPGJWXGVGjNj 0GTJWOXGOC¸HTW´NOWJVjE ¹NjTCJOGVKTCDDKJK´NIjHT +CVVCV5jUKO0GJOGF(HGPFK .WNWPCXGEGOKKO´OKPuPXGO´OKPjVC 5CJOGVG[NG[GGN)CVKJC Suyolcuzâde, 52-53; Müstakimzâde, 465-470; Tilgen, 14-15; Cavid Baysun, “E¤rikap›l› Râsim Efendi”, ‹stanbul Üniversitesi Edebiyat Fakültesi Tarih Dergisi, c. VII, sy. 10 (Eylül 1954), s.1; Rado, 155-156; Serin, Hat Sanat› ve Meflhur Hattatlar, 127-132; Tevfik Kalp. “Hoca Mehmed Râsim Efendi ve Hakk›nda Yaz›lm›fl Bir Risâlenin ‹ncelenmesi”. ‹stanbul, Marmara Üniversitesi Güzel Sanatlar Enstitüsü, 2002, 117 s. Mehmed Râsim Efendi kabir kitabesi, E¤rikap› 121 Mehmed Râflid Efendi (Bursal›) 0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFKVGUVGTGEKGUPCH»PFCP%WTUCN»+CE»$NK$¹CµP»PQ¹NWFWT µFC%WTUCµFCFQ¹FW0GFTGUGFGQMWFWºUVCPDWNµFCP%WTUCµ[CJKETGVGFGP JCVVCVNCTFCP6NG[OCP(HGPFKµPKP{¹TGPEKUKºDTCJKO6MVK(HGPFK{XG %WTUCN»JCVVCVNCTFCP6CFGFFKP(HGPFKµFGP[C\F» µFCºUVCPDWNµCIGNKR¼GHKM%G[{µFGPDKTUGPGFGTUCNF»%WTUCµ[C F{PF+GTUGPGºUVCPDWNµCIGNKT¼GHKM%G[µFGP[C\CTF»µFG(TMjP»+CTDK[G 'jKTGUKJCVVCVN»¹»PCVC[KPQNWPFW5COC\CP1KUCPµFGXGHCVGVVK ([RUWNVCP0G\CTN»¹»µPCFGHPGFKNFK 0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFKUNUPGUKJXGTKMCCµJCVNCT»P»OCJjTGVNG[C\O»½V»T Eyüplü Hattatlar ‹bnülemin, 311; Y›lmaz Özcan, “Eyüpsultanl› Bir Hattat›m›z Mehmed Raflid Efendi”, III. Eyüpsultan Sempozyumu/Tebli¤ler, ‹stanbul, Eyüp Belediyesi, 2000, s. 478-489 Bursal› Mehmed Râflid Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs levha (Hüsnü K›l›ç koleksiyonu) 122 M Bursal› Mehmed Râflid Efendi’ye ait sülüs, nesih ve r›ka’ yaz›s› Bursal› Mehmed Râflid Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs levha (Mehmet fievket Eygi Koleksiyonu) 123 Mehmed Raflid Efendi (Eyüplü) Mehmed Râflid Efendi’nin vefat tarihi, Habib’in Hat ve Hattâtân isimli eserinde h. 1292/1875 olarak verilmifltir. Ancak Râflid Efendi’nin torunu Cenap Yazansoy’un yak›n dostu fievket Rado ise eserinde h. 1297/1879 olarak vermifltir. ‹bnûlemin, ise vefat tarihini kaydetmemifltir. 11 Haziran 2000 tarihinde Cenap Yazansoy’la Feneryolu’daki evinde yapt›¤›m görüflmede büyükbabas›n›n ölüm tarihinin kesin olarak bilinmedi¤ini fakat, yaz›lar›n›n en son h. 1297 tarihini tafl›d›¤›ndan, kuvvetle muhtemel h. 1297 tarihinin sonlar›nda vefat etmifl olabilece¤ini söylemifllerdir. (S. Berk) Habib, 177, ‹bnülemin, 304; Rado; 220. Eyüplü Hattatlar VCTKJKPFG([RUWNVCP FC&COKK.GDKT0CJCNNGUK PFG7NDGPVEK0WJKFFKP 6QMC¹» PFCMKDKTGXFGFQ¹FW+CVVCV+UG[KP¼jMKT(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT =COCP»P»P[C\»UVCVNCT»PFCP.GDGEK\jFG0GJOGF9CUHu(HGPFK{µFGP UNUXGPGUKJ[C\»OG½MGVOK½XGDW\jVVCPVCTKJKPFGQPQPDKT [C½NCT»PFCQNFW¹WJCNFGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»nQMI\GN [C\CPNCTFCPF»T2VW\[GFK.WTµjP».GTuODKTnQMFGNjKNXG¼KHj[»¼GTKH[C\O»½ QNWR6WNVCP,,0CJOWF7TDGUKµPG[C\F»¹»D[MM»VµCFCMKDKT.WTµjP».GTuO DWIP,$JOGF7TDGUKµPFGFGRQFCF»T <C\O»½QNFW¹W.WTµjP».GTuONGT KPUUNGOGNGTKO\GJJKD+UG[KP+UPKXGUCTC[ DC½OEGNNKFK6jNKJGHGPFKNGTVCTCH»PFCP[CR»NO»½V»TXGJGRUKFGnQMI\GNFKT ([RUWNVCP7TDGUKDC½VTDGFjT»KMGPQ¹NWKnKPDC½NCF»¹»D[MM»V CFCDKT .WT CP »PDKTE\ P[C\O»½VCOCONC[COCFCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT .CDTK+C\TGVK+jNKF7TDGUKCTMCU»PFCF»T 0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFK6WNVCP,,0CJOWFµWPCPPGUK1CM½KFKN9jNKFG6WNVCP 0GMVGDK[C\»JQECU»+CMMjM\jFG0WUVCHC+KNOK(HGPFKµPKPXGHCV»PFCPUQPTCDW OGMVGDGJQECVC[KPQNWPOW½VWT+C[CV»PFCQVW\[GFK0WUJCHKMK%WJjTuDG½¼KHC[» ¼GTuHXGDKTnQMFGNjKNµNJC[TjV[C\O»½V»T 0\GJJKD6jNKJ(HGPFK5j½KF(HGPFKµPKPQPKMK.WTµjP».GTuOµKPKVG\JKDGVOK½VKT%W UUNGOGK½KPGµFGDC½NCO»½KMKUGPGUQPTCDKVKTOK½VKT Eyüplü Mehmed Râflid Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs levha (Cenap Yazansoy koleksiyonu) 124 M Mehmed Receb Efendi +jH»\0GJOGF5GEGD(HGPFKQNCTCMCP»N»TF»<C\»[»JCVVCV6jNKJ(HGPFK FGP {¹TGPOK½VKT¼G[J N.WTTjKFK.CNGPFGTJjPG0GMVGDKµPFGJQECN»MXG([R &COKKµPFGOG\\KPNKM[CRO»½V»T[»N»PFCXGHCVGFGP5GEGD(HGPFK([R &COKK[CP»PFCMKOG\CTN»¹CI{ONO½VT Tilgen, 15 Mehmed Reflid Efendi (¹TKMCR»N»+QEC5jUKO(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNWRVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK (¹TKMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFCXGDCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCF»T%KTnQM.WTµjP».GTuOM»V CXG OWTCMMCC[C\O»½V»T<C\»JQECU»$DFWTTCJOCP+KNOK(HGPFK{KFK 0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT GNHjVKJC $NNCJ6DJjPGJWXG7GjNj +CVVCV0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFK\jFG0GJOGF 5G¼uF(HGPFK .WNWPCXGEGOuKGJNK KOjPC 5CJOGVG[NG[GÂOKP 6GPG )u=C 125 Habib, 163 ( Habib, ölüm tarihini h. 1227 olarak vermifltir ki do¤rusu 1228’ dir.); ‹bnülemin, 329 Mehmed Râflid Efendi kabir kitâbesi Mehmed Sadullah Efendi 0JGPFKU0GJOGF6CFWNNCJ(HGPFK+CN»E»Q¹NWµPFCMK0JGPFKUJjPG .VRJCPGUKµPKPJjH»\»MVD)GVJK(HGPFKµPKPD[MQ¹NWFWT 0KTµjV»0JGPFKUJjPGCFN»GUGTFGDW\jVJCMM»PFC½WDKNIKXCTF»T²*GPnNK¹KPFG 0JGPFKUJjPGµ[GIKTOK½XGJUPKJCVVCMKOCJjTGVKPGOGDPKKMKPEKU»P»H VCNGDGUKPFGPKMGPMWTW½OCC½NCVCNGDG[G[C\»VCNKOKPGOGOWTGFKNOK½XGRGM nQMVCNGDG[GVK½VKTOK½VKT.GPFKUKW\WPDQ[NWOCXKI{\NDKT\jVKFK'CJC[KTOKDG½ [C½»PFCKMGP[C\»NCT»KNG½{JTGVQNOW½VWT³ 6CFWNNCJ(HGPFKJVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([R1K½CPECU»µPFC¼G[J 0WTCF(HGPFK7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPFGCXNWMCR»U»PFCPIKTKNFK¹KPFGUQNVCTCHVCMK UQHCFCF»T.KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT +WXG´N%jMu 0¼CTWPKNG[J»G[J6CKF(HGPFK +CHuFK0JGPFKUJCPGKDGTTuK JOj[WP +CVVjVuPKPFGPOGTJWOXGOC¸HWTWP NGJ 6CFWNNCJ(HGPFKPKP 5WJKnWPGN)CVKJC 6GPGJ Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Es’ad, Mir’at-› Mühendishâne-i Berri-i Hümâyûn, ‹stanbul, 1312, s 89; ‹bnülemin, 349. Mehmed Sadüddin Kaflif Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWµFWT'GFGUK$PMCTCN»1CMuDµNG½TjH(UµCF(HGPFKµFKT%CDCU»0GJOGF 6CµuF(HGPFKKMKMGTGPCMKDQNOW½VWT+UPKJCVV»+UG[KP)G[\KXG6K[jJK$JOGF (HGPFK{µFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT ¼KKTXGPGUKTFGOjJKTQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPOW½VWT2VW\DG½[C½»PFC6NG[OCPK[G OFGTTKUKKMGP¼GXXCN0CTVVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR» F»½»PFC(OKT%WJjTK7GMMGUK0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 714; Sicill-i Osmani IV/66 126 Mehmed Sadullah Efendi’nin flahidesi M Mehmed Said Efendi =KNJKEEG$¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW*GTGMNKVCJUKNKI{TFMVGP UQPTC%jD»jNKµPKPnG½KVNKMCFGOGNGTKPFGI{TGXNGTFGDWNWPFW%G[NKMEKÃOGFEK 6CFCTGV0UVG½CT»XGMKNK0GENKUK$JMjO»CFNK[GC\CU»XG+CTKEK[G0UVG½CT» QNOW½VWT%KTOFFGV6CFCTGV0½VG½CT»QNFWMVCPUQPTC¼Tj[»'GXNGV$\CU»XG VCTKJKPFGKMKPEKFGHC'CJKNK[G1C\»T»CNV»C[UQPTC=KTCCV1j\»T»QNOW½VWT 0GJOGF6CKF(HGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPµFC6CnN» $DFNMCFKT(HGPFK&COKKJC\KTGUKPFKG.CNGPFGTJCPG&CFFGUKµPGCn»NCPJC\KTG MCR»U»P»PUC¹VCTCH»PFCMKUGV\GTKPFGXGECFFG[GDCMCPJCEGVRGPEGTGUKPKP CTMCU»PFCDWNWPOCMVCF»T+CVVCV+CE».jOKN$MFKMµKPPGHKUEGNuUNUJCVV»KNG [C\»NO»½MKVCDG½{[NGFKT .CD\ºOCNGNJjE+UG[KPGHGPFKPKPOCJFWOW .WFGOj[ºXMGNj[ºFGXNGVKCNK[[GFGP 8OTºFCJKNK[G1C\ºTºGUDCM 0GJOGF6CKF(HGPFK´PKPTWJKnWPGNHjVKJC 7CTKJKKXGNjFGV7CTKJKXGHCVº MGVGDGJW.jOKN 127 6WNVCP$DFNC\K\XG,,$DFNJCOKFµKPKNM UCNVCPCV[»NNCT»PFC'CJKNK[G1C\»TN»¹» [CRO»½QNCP0GJOGF6CKF(HGPFK FTUVN¹KNGOG½JWTQNOW½VW$¹»T DC½N»PC\KMXGJGTMGUGJTOGVVGNMKP GFGPFG¹GTNKDKT½CJUK[GVVK*\GN[C\»U» KNGFGOG½JWTQNWRI\GNUNUXGPGUKJ [C\CTF».KONGTFGP[C\»nCN»½V»¹»DGNNK FG¹KNFKT 0GJOGF6CKF(HGPFKµPKP+CTKEK[G 1G\CTGVK\COCP»PFC+GTUGMKU[CP»%WNICT KU[CP»6GNjPKMXCMCU»XG6WNVCP$\K\µKP JCNNKIKDKQNC[NCTOG[FCPCIGNOK½VKT ‹bnülemin, Son Sadrazamlar, 40, 126, 473, 487, 613, 775; Tarih-i Lütfi, Ankara, 1990, XII/25, 66, 106, XIII/23,29; Semih Mümtaz. Tarihimizde Hayal Olmufl Hakikatler. ‹stanbul, 1948, s. 221; Mehmet Galip. Sa’dullah Pafla Yahut Mezardan Nida. ‹stanbul, 1327, s. 113-116; ‹brahim Alaattin. Meflhur Adamlar, ‹stanbul, 1933-1936, IV/1404-1405. Mehmed Said Efendi’nin flahidesi Mehmed Salih Efendi (Nev’izâde) ºUVCPDWNNWQNWR1GXµK{µPKPQ¹NWFWT=G[NK¼CMjKM[C\CT»$VjK(HGPFK{ UNjNGUKPFGPFKT7CµNKMJCVV»$DFNDjMKÃTKH(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK (¹KVKOKPKVCOCONCF»MVCPUQPTC(FKTPG.CF»U»QNFW%WI{TGXKPFGPC[T»NF»MVCP UQPTCTCOC\CP»PFC(MKOµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»F»½»PFC(OKT %WJjTK7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPFGXGDCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 731 Mehmed Salih Efendi ([R'GHVGTFCTµFCFQ¹OW½VWT0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKPµKPVCNGDGUK0GJOGF7jJKT (HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT0GENKUK0jNK[GC\CU»PFCPQNCP0GJOGF6jNKJ(HGPFKJ VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 15; ‹bnulemin, 358. Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Salih fiem’i Efendi (Çavuflzâde) 128 0GJOGF6jNKJ¼GO K(HGPFKcCXW½\jFGQNCTCMDKNKPKTFKºUVCPDWNNWQNWRDCDCU» 0WUVCHC(HGPFK FKT¼GJKF$NK3C½C0QTC<CT»OCFCU» P»PHGVJKPFG6jNKJ(HGPFK [K JWODCTCE»TGKUK[CRO»½V»T %CDCU»6GT+PMjT»'KXjP»+Oj[WP FCPQNFW¹WKnKP6jNKJ(HGPFKUCFTC\CO UCTC[»PFC5GKU.CNGOKMGVGDGNGTKPFGPXG7CJXKNQFCU»JWNGHjU»PFCPQNFW¹WPFCP ¼GO KOCJNCU»P»CNO»½V»T 6NUXGPGUKJK+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFK FGPOG½MKNGJC[NKI\GN[C\»NCT [C\O»½V»T'uXjPKTKM CXGTG[JjPKJCVNCT»PFCMK[C\»NCT»DG¹GPKNOK½XG+jEGIjP \OTGUKPKPUGnMKPKQNOW½VWT *GPnFGPGEGMDKT[C½VC=KNMCFG7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK&GPC\G PCOC\»([RUWNVCP&COKKµPFGM»N»PF»MVCPUQPTC(¹TKMCR»F»½»PFC.»TuOK(HGPFK cG½OGUKMCT½»U»PCI{ONF7C½»OGXEWFFG¹KNFKT Müstakimzâde, 458; Habib, 144; Rado, 159 M Mehmed Salih Efendi (Kayy›mzâde) =G[TGM&COKKMC[[»O»P»PQ¹NWQNFW¹WKnKP.C[[»O\jFGQNCTCMDKNKPKTFK FC{NF.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»F»½»PFC%jJKT0WUVCHC3C½C7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPFGKFK +CDKD(HGPFKµ[GI{TGGMUGTuUKECOKDQ[W[\MCFCT.WTµjP».GTuO[C\O»½V»T Habib, 177 Mehmed fiâkir Recâi Efendi 0CTVµVGºUVCPDWNµWP6VNEGUGOVKPFG FP[C[CIGNFK2Pn[C½»PFC$OOGUTGUKPK [C\CTCMJQECU»)KNKDGNK0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGP KEj\GVCNF»KEj\GVKKNGDKTNKMVG²5GEjK³OCJNCU» XGTKNFK%WCTCFCJjH»\QNFWECOKFGTUNGTKPGXG 'uXjP»JOj[WPCFGXCOGVVK+CVVCV0WUVCHC 5CM»OµFCPEGNuUNU{¹TGPFK (FGDK[CV»O»\»POG½JWTNCT»PFCP²5GEjK\jFG (MTGO%G[³KPDCDCU»QNCP0GJOGF ¼jMKT(HGPFK7CMXKOK9GMC[KOWJCTTKTNK¹K XCMµCPXKUNKMVCMXKOJCPGPC\»TN»¹»OGENKUK OCÃTKHC\CN»¹»IKDKI{TGXNGTFGDWNWPOW½VWT 129 Recâi Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs mezartafl› kitabesi ve imza k›sm› (Aksaray Valide Camii haziresi) 6NUPGUKJEGNuUNUXGVCµNuM[C\»FCOjJKTQNCP5GEju(HGPFK{\GNNKMNGEGNu UNUVG5jM»O[QNWPFCXG½KXGUKPFGGUGTXGTOK½VKT>TCJRC½C&COKK+C\KTGUKµPFG JCP»O»KnKP[C\F»¹»OG\CTVC½»KNG$MUCTC[9CNKFG&COKK+C\KTGUKµPFGJVCTKJNK ÃK½G+CP»OEGNuUNUOG\CTVC½».KVjDGNGTK5jM»O[QNWPFC[C\»NO»½{PGONK GUGTNGTKPFGPFKT 0EGNNKVNKMXGOJTENMUCPCVNCT»P»DKNGPOWUKMu[NGKNIKNGPGPJQ½UQJDGVDKT jNKOQNCP5GEjK(HGPFKµPKPUQPQP[»N»VTNU»M»PV»XG\PVNGTNGIGnOK½VKT ¼GXXCN.CU»OVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGTGM([RUWNVCPKOCTGVKMCT½»U»PFC DCDCU»P»P[CP»PCFGHPGFKNOK½VKT Sicill-i Osmânî, II, 370; Habib, 176; ‹bnülemin, 313-317; M. U¤ur Derman, “Mezar Kitâbelerinde Yaz› Sanat›m›z” TUR‹NG Bellteni, 49 (328), 1975, s.42; M. U¤ur Derman, Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, ‹stanbul, Kültür Bakanl›¤›, 1982, L. 40; Rado, 215, Ismay›l Hakk› Baltac›o¤lu, Türklerde Yaz› Sanat›, Mersin, Kültür Bakanl›¤›, 1993, s. 51,53; M. U¤ur Derman, Sabanc› Koleksiyonu, ‹stanbul, Akbank, 1995, s. 122. Kaynaklarda Mehmed fiâkir Recâi Efendi’nin defnedildi¤i yer ve kitabesi kay›tl›d›r. Ancak tüm aramalar›m›za ra¤men kitâbe bulunamam›flt›r. Mezarl›klarla ilgili çal›flmalar› ve genifl arflivi ile tan›nan Say›n M. Necdet ‹flli’ye müracaat›m›zda flu bilgiyi vermifllerdir: “Arflivimde bulunan ve Fâz›l Ayano¤lu’nun haz›rlad›¤› katalo¤a göre 1900 y›l›ndan beri, belirtilen hazirede Recâi Efendi mezartafl› görülmemifltir. Necdet Bey kendi yapt›¤› araflt›rmalarda da Recâi Efendi mezar tafl› kitâbesine rastlamad›¤›n› belirtmifllerdir. Buna göre mezartafl› kitâbesi ya tafla geçirilmemifl yahut 1900 y›l›ndan önce yok edilmifltir. (S. Berk) Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed fievket Vahdeti Efendi 130 ¼GXMGV9CJFGVK(HGPFK7GMKTFC¹µFC OWVCUCTT»HKMGPXGHCVGFGP+jEGIjP» 'uXjP»+Oj[WP FCP1WTK(HGPFK PKP Q¹NWFWT=KNJKEEG1KUCPVCTKJKPFG ºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW2Pn[C½»PFCKMGP DCDCU»XGHCVGVVK ºNM{PEG([[DK5j½KF(HGPFK FGPUCPTC6jNKJ (HGPFK FGP[C\»FGTUNGTKCNF»µFC KEj\GVUCJKDKQNFW6QPTC.C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV (HGPFK FGP[C\»nCN»½V» 2PF{TV[C½»PFC'KXjP»+Oj[WPUQPTC0JKOOG .CNGONGTK PGMCDWNQNWPFW%WGUPCFC(DWUUWWF(HGPFK{ CJHCF»PFCPXGMCF»NCT»PFCPºUj\jFG6CFGFFKP(HGPFK{M»\» ¼GTKHG$NK[[G+CP»OKNGGXNGPFK $[CUQH[C&COKKIGPGNMNVTJQECNCT»PFCPDKTKQNCP2UOCP5GEjK(HGPFK PKP FGTUNGTKPGFGXCOKNGVCTKJKPFGKEj\GVCNF» M 0JKOOG.CNGOK PFG 0GP½WTPXKUNKMFGPKNGPXG\jTGV TVDGUKXGTKNGPNGTG[C\»NCP HGTOCPNCT»MGPFKPGJCUDKT UNWRNCMCNGOGCN»TF»6NG[OCP 3C½C P»PXG\jTGVOGP½WTWPWQ XCMVGMCFCT[C\»NCPOGP½WTNCTC DGP\GOG[GPDKTVCT\FCXGJGT UCV»T»P»DC½MCDKTTGPMCNV»PFC [C\CTCMEGNuFuXjPuFGMK MjDKNK[GVKPKI{UVGTFK ºNMFGHC/QPFTC [CXG3CTKU G I{PFGTKNGTGMRQUVCRWNNCT»P»P DCPMPQVNCT»PXGVCJXKNNGTKP DCU»NOCU»PCPG\jTGVGVVK3CTKU VG DWNWPFW¹WGUPCFC,,, 1CRQN[QP C/WK1CRQN[QPXG ºORCTCVQTKnGfLGPK KUKONGTKPFGMK½KHTGJCVKNGMQN F¹OGNGTK[C\»RVCMFKOGVOK½XG nQMDG¹GPKNGTGMKNVKHCVCOC\JCT QNOW½VWT 0WJCTTGO1KUCP VCTKJKPFGXGQVW\UGMK\[C½»PFC QNFW¹WJCNFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC(DWUUWWF(HGPFK 0GMVGDK PKPJC\KTGUKPFGFKT 0G\CTVC½»PFCDC\»Ã[GVKEGNuNG KNG½WU{\NGT[C\»N»F»T (XNjFº(D U6W WF FCPXG OGXjNuKK\jOFCP ¹Uj\jFG6C FFFKP(HGPFK OGTJWOWP 'jOjFº7G¼TKHjVuK'uXjPº +Oj[WP.CNGOK +WNGHjUºPFCPXGGTDjDº OCjTKHFGPJCVVCVOGTJWO XGOC¸HTWPNGJ0GJOGF 9CJFGVu(HGPFKTJKnPHjVKJC HuUGPG Eyüp, Ebussuud Haziresi’nde Vahdetî’nin hatt› ile celî sülüs bir mezartafl› kitâbesi 131 Eyüp, Ebussuud Haziresi’nde hattat Vahdeti kabri 1WTWQUOCPK[G&COKKµPFG XG%jD»jNK FGMK1CNN» 0GUEKF FG%KNCNK+CDG½K NGXJCNCT»%WTUC FC 8NWECOK FGD[MDKT NGXJC0GTMG\(HGPFK 7TDGUK PFGMWDDGKnKPFGMK [C\»MC[»PDCDCU» 6CFGFFKP(HGPFK PKP ½jJKFGUKXG>TCJRC½C FC .CTI»6QMC¹» PFC .GnGEK\jFG OCMDGTGUKPFGMKnG½OGPKP MKVjDGUKQPWPFWT$[T»EC FK¹GTDC\»[GTNGTFGFG MKVjDGNGTKXCTF»T6WNVCP $DFNC\K\ KPVW¹TCU»P»FC DW\jVVCP\KOGVOK½XG MCT½»N»MQNCTCMCNV»P NKTCCVK[[GCNO»½V»T 9CJFGVu(HGPFK PKP OWUKMKFGFGOjJKTQNFW¹W XGMjPWPnCNOCFCUVjF» fOGT(HGPFK [KIGnVK¹K U{[NGPKT7QTWPW½jKTXG Eyüplü Hattatlar Hattat Vahdeti’nin ayaktafl› kitâbesi Hattat Vahdeti’nin han›m›n›n mezartafl› kitâbesi (Suud el-Mevlevi hatt› ile) 132 M JCVVCV6WWF%G[(D\\K[j 7GXHKM%G[ KPUVMCTFG½KXG JCNCU»P»PQ¹NWFWT 9CJFGVK(HGPFK PKPQ¹NW 0GJOGF5»\C6CHXGV%G[FG JCVVCVXG½jKTKFKµFG ºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW6CHXGV ½KKTFGMKOCJNCU»QNWR 0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ%G[ FGP UNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVVK 5GDKNGXXGN0CTV VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK DCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCF»T %W\jV»PQ¹NWXG9CJFGVK (HGPFK PKPVQTWPW0GJOGF 6WWF%G[µFG .WTWnG½OG FGFQ¹FW.GPFKUK DCDCU»IKDK½jKTQNWRµFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTK0GTMG\(HGPFK &COKKJC\KTGUKPFGXG½CF»TXCP CXNWUWPFCF»T Hattat Vahdeti’nin hatt› ile bir çeflme kitabesi 133 Habib, 172; ‹bnülemin, 438; a. mlf. , Son As›r Türk fiâirleri, 1483-1714; Rado, 212 Ebussuud Haziresi duvar›nda Vahdeti hatt› ile celî sülüs kitâbe Mehmed fievki Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar VCTKJKPFG.nM$[CUQH[C0CJCNNGUKµPFGFP[C[C[IGNFK+CTRWVNWJjH»\ 0WUVCHC(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT$TCRnC)CTUnCIGQOGVTKXGOCVGOCVKM{¹TGPFK%KT VCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWUQPI{TGXK'uXjP»0WJjUGDCVOGOWTK[GVKKFK VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDKTMKVCDGUK.nM(OKT(HGPFKCn»MVTDGUK {PPFGDWNWPOCMVCF»T8\WPECOG\GTVC½»MKVCDGUKPFGMKKDjTG½{[NGFKT ¹MK[\QPUGMK\VCTKJKPFGXGFGXTKJC\TGVK6GNKO+jPº 6jNKUVG%C¼0WJCUGDG.CNGOKPGOGOWTQNWR6WNVCP0CJOWF +jPºCNG[JK´TTCJOGVKXG´N¸WHTCPXG6WNVCP$DFNOGEKFJjPºWN[j OC¸HKTGV 5CDD´N0GPPjPCUºTNCTºPFC(XMjHºJOj[WP1G\jTGVKXGMjNGVK 9GOGHUWJ0GENKUK0WJCUGDG5K[jUGVKXG0MGTTGTGP0GENKUK9jNjC\CNº¸º 9GFGH´CKUjPK[GQNCTCM[KPG0GENKUK0WJCUGDGC\CNº¸ºIKDKOGPjUºD 9G0GUjPKFKCNK[[G XGOJKOOGFG MGOjNKUºFMXG KUVKMjOGVNGGOGMFCT +C\TGVKRjFK¼jJuFG VGMjFDW[WTWNCTCM JjPGNGTKPFG 'C´XjVºJC[TK[[GK ¼GJKP¼jJK[G OWXC\CDCVMjT QNFW¸W +CNFGVGTMW FC¸FC¸CKOGTjUKOW CNj[K¼KHGPj 9GKEjDGVKFC´XGVK VG¼TKHjVºOGPUDº DGMj ([NGOK¼QNCPGU 6G[[KF0GJOGF»GXMK (HGPFK +C\TGVNGTKPKPXG MjHHGKOOKPKPXG OOKPjV GTXjJº¼GTKHGNGTKPG GNHjVKJC Mehmed fievki Efendi mezartafl› kitâbesi (Eyüp Sultan Camii haziresi) 134 M $NF»¹»OGOWTK[GVNGT½{[NGFKT.CNGOFGP[GVK½KREG[DKJOj[WPMjVKDKXGJ µFC.nM.CNµC7G\MKTGEKNK¹KKNGJjEGIjPFCPQNFW0WJCTTGO1KUCP 3GT½GODGIP+C\KPGK+CUC0UVG½CT»QNFWXGMGPFKUKPGÐNjTVDGUKXGTKNFK VCTKJKPFG(XMjH»+Oj[WP1j\»T»XG5GDKWNGXXGN0C[»U6CN» IP7KECTGV0UVG½CT»=KNMCFG$TCN»MVCTKJKPFG0GENKUK0WJCUGDG 5GKUK&GOj\K[GNjJKT7GOOW\VCTKJKPFG0GENKUK9jNj$\CU»FCJCUQPTC 0GENKUK0jNK[G$\CU»QNFWcGODGTNKVC½µVC6WNVCP,,0CJOWF7TDGUKµPKPKP½CCV K½KPG¼GXMK(HGPFKPG\CTGVGVOK½VKT ‹bnülemin Mahmud Kemal ‹nal, “Hüseyin Hüsâmeddin, Evkâf-› Hümâyun Nezareti’nin Kurulufl Tarihi ve Naz›rlar›n›n Hal Tercümeleri” (Haz. Nazif Öztürk). Vak›flar Dergisi, sy. 16, s. 40; ‹bnülemin, 399-400; Sicill-i Osmani III/173; Mehmed Esad. Mir’at-› Mühendishâne. ‹stanbul, 1312, s. 53-54, 88. Mehmed fievki Efendi (Safranbolulu) ¼GXMK(HGPFK6CHTCPDQNWG½TjH»PFCP$JOGF(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWTFGQTCFC FQ¹FW6CHTCPDQNWU»D[CPOGMVGDKPFGQMWFW0GMVGDKPMCNHCU»JCVVCV$JOGF (HGPFK FGPUGMK\[C½»PFCFGTUCNOC[CDC½NCF»µFGºUVCPDWN CIGNFK+CVVCV +CUCP5»\C(HGPFK{DKTOWUJCH»P»I{TRVCMFKTGVVK 0PGEEKODC½»7jJKT(HGPFK{µPKPMKVjDGVKPGCN»PCTCMµFGP VCTKJKPGMCFCTDWXC\KHGFGDWNWPFW%WCTCFC.WTµjP».GTuO[C\»[QTXG%j[G\KF &COKKPFGFG7QMCVN»$JOGF(HGPFK PKPFGTUNGTKPGFGXCOGFK[QTFW 7jJKT(HGPFK PKPXGHCV»\GTKPG0PGEEKODC½»N»¹CVC[KPQNWPCP2UOCP.jOKN (HGPFK FGPK\KPCNCTCM6CHTCPDQNW [CIKVVKXGQTCFC[KTOKUGPGMCNF»*O½JCPGNK ¼G[J$JOGF=K[CGFFKP(HGPFK PKPJWNGHjU»PFCP%Q\CE»\jFG+CE»$JOGF(HGPFK FGP KNOK[GKEj\GVKCNF» µFGºUVCPDWN CIGNFK%j[G\KF FG+CMMjMNCTcCT½»U» PFCFMMCPCnCTCM KUVG[GPNGTG.WTµjP».GTuOGPµCOFGNjKN½KHj[C\F»UGPGUKPFGUC¹GNKPG VKVTGOGIGNFKXGVGFCXKUKHC[FCXGTOGFK%KTKPKPQPFK¹GTKPKP[KTOKE\ [C\»NO»½ QNCPKMK0WUJCH»UQNGNK[NG[C\CTCMVCOCONCF»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWT+C[CV»P»PUQPWPC MCFCTFCUQNGNKKNG[C\OC¹CFGXCOGVOK½VKTUGPGUKPGMCFCT.WTµjP» .GTuOn½KHjXGDKTnQM'GNCKNKJC[TjV[C\F» *{\NMU\[C\F»¹»XGVGUDKJ[CRV»¹»FCTKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT.QUMCEKXCT»PFC<CMWD $¹C&COKKKOCON»¹»PCVC[KPQNWPFW.CU»OVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVKXG([R MCDTKUVCP»PCFGHPQNWPFW ‹bnûlemin, 403-405. 135 136 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mehmed Tahir Efendi’nin celî sülüs levhas› (Mehmed Çebi Koleksiyonu) M Mehmed Tahir Efendi +jH»\+CE»0GJOGF7jJKT(HGPFK+CVVCV 0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFK PKP{PFG IGNGPVCNGDGNGTKPFGPQNFW¹WKnKP MGPFKUKPG&GNjNGFFKPK6jPuFGPOK½VKT &GNu[C\»FCC[PGPUVjF»P»PVCXT»P» VCMNKFGVOK½VKT&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFK VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½XG ([RUWNVCP FC¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK 7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPGI{ONO½VT 7jJKT(HGPFKC[P»\COCPFC6WNVCP $DFNOGEKF KP[C\»JQECU»KFK µFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC.»TMOGTFKXGPNGT OG\CTN»¹»PFCF»T0G\CTVC½».KVjDGUK DWNWPCOCO»½V»T gUMFCT+CTGOºUMGNGUK PFG'GHVGTFCT 7jJKT(HGPFK&COKKKNG*CNCVC FC.CR»KnK &COKKµPKP[C\»NCT»QPWPFWT ‹bnülemin, 205; Habib, 168; Rado, 205; Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi, 135 Mehmed Vasfi Efendi .C[PCMNCTFCJC[CV»JCMM»PFCDKTDKNIK[QMVWT.CDTK([RUWNVCP7TDGUK JC\KTGUKPFG3K[GTNQVKµ[Gn»MCP[QMW½WPXGJC\KTGFWXCT»\GTKPFGMKJCEGV RGPEGTGUKPKPCTMCU»PFCF»T5GDKWNGXXGN7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK¹KVC½»FCMC[»VN»F»T.nMOQNNCUCT»MN»MCDKTMKVCDGUKPKPKDCTGUK½{[NGFKT &GXjJKT%GFGUVGPK.GVJWFjUºOGTJWO¹UOCKN$¸C\jFG *GPnNK¸KPGFQ[COC[CPOWTCFºPCGTOG[GPEGPPGVOGMjP +jHK\W´N.WT´jPJCVVCVGU6G[[KF0GJOGF9CUHK(HGPFK´PKP 5Jº¼GTuHKPGXGMjHHGKGJNKKOCPGTXjJºPCGNHCVKJC 5GDKWNGXXGN Gezi Notu, M. Nermi Haskan Mehmed Tahir Efendi’nin celî sülüs levhas› 137 Memifl Efendi 0GOK½(HGPFK([RN FT.»\$NK\jFGFK[GPNFT([R1K½CPE»0CJCNNGUK PFG 1CM½KDGPFK[[G FGP¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFKVGMMGUKC½C¹»U»PFC'CXWF$¹C&COKKµPFG OG\\KPNKM[CRO»½V»T6QPTC6WNVCP,0CJOWFFGXTKPFG([RUWNVCP 7TDGFCT»QNFW6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFGVCNGDGNGTKPFGP5GEGR+CNKHG FGP I{TO½UQPTC6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK{FGPKEj\GVCNO»½V»T .»VµCNCT»XGDKTnQM[C\»U»XCTF»T Suyolcuzâde, 107. Mir ‹smail Bey Eyüplü Hattatlar 6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½CUNjNGUKPFGPºDTCJKO+CP\jFGNGT FGPQNWR$NK%G[ KP Q¹NWFWT([R VGFP[C[CIGNFK<C\»[»(¹TKMCR»N»+QEC5jUKO(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½ XGQPFCPUNUXGPGUKJKOG½MGVOK½VKT6QPTCVC NKM[C\»[CJGXGUGVOK½.jV»R\jFG +GMKODC½»0GJOGF5GHK (HGPFK FGPFGTUCNO»½V»T%jJKTOCJNCU»[NC[C\»NO»½½KKTNGTK XCTF»T<C½»[GVOK½G[CMNC½»TMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½CVTDGUKPFGFKT 6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½C6WNVCP,,6GNKO KPM»\»ºUOKJCP(UOCJCP6WNVCPKNG GXNGPFKTKNFK¹KKnKPMGPFKPFGPUQPTCIGNGPQ¹NWºDTCJKO%G[ GºDTCJKO+CPXGQPWP Q¹WNNCT»PCFCºDTCJKO+CP\jFGNGTFGPOK½VKT%WU»HCVDK\\jV6WNVCP,,6GNKO VCTCH»PFCPXGTKNOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 124; Habib, 101; Rado, 147; Tayyib Gökbilgin, “Mehmed Pafla, Sokullu”, ‹A, VII, 595-605. Mir ‹smail Bey Kabri’nin de bulundu¤u Sokollu Türbesi içi 138 M Mir Mustafa Bey )GTJCF3C½C P»PQ¹NWFWT0WUVCHC%G[I\GNJCVNCT»KNGOG½JWTKFK.CTFG½K0KT $JOGF%G[KNGDGTCDGTDCDCNCT»PFCP[C\»FGTUNGTKCNO»½NCTF»TVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTKCPPGUKVCTCH»PFCPD[MDCDCU»QNCP¼GJ\jFG0GJOGF&COKK ¼GJ\jFGDC½»&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT)CVOC6WNVCP7TDGUKMCR»U»{PPFGMK OWJVG½GOMCDTKPKP½CJKFGUKPFGMKKDCTG½{[NGFKT 0GTJWOGNOWJVjEKNj5CJOGVK5CDDKJK´N*jHWT 0KTKCNGO0WUVCHC$¸C¹DPK)GTJCF3C¼CTWJKnWPHCVKJC Hu¼GJTKTGEGDGNOTGEEGDUGPG Habib, 155-156; Rado, 93 Muhiddin Efendi Mir Mustafa Bey kabir kitabesi <C\»[»JCVVCV(OKP(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT0GMVGRJQECN»¹»XG'¹OGEKNGT &COKKµPFGKOCON»M[CRV»VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 15 139 Murtaza Efendi (Yekçeflm) 7GMI{\JCUCTN»QNFW¹WKnKP²<GMnG½O³FK[GCP»NCP0WTVC\C (HGPFKMCNGOFGP[GVK½KR+jEGIjPµFCPQNFW+FG 7QRJCPG1j\»T»0KNNK6CXWPOC%CMCP»&GOC\K[GNCJKT .CU»OVCTKJKPFG7GTUjPG(OKPK7GTUjPGPKPOjNKXGKFjTK K½NGTKPGDCMCPQNFWXGUQPTCC\NGFKNFKµFGKMKPEKFGHC 7GTUjPG(OKPKXGFG$PCFQNW0WJjUGDGEKUKXG 7GOOW\µFGnPEFGHC7GTUjPG(OKPKQNWRDKTUGPG UQPTCI{TGXFGPCN»PF»µFG&K\[G0WJCUGDGEKUKXG ¼GXXCN(MKOVCTKJKPFG5W\PjOGK(XXGNQNWR 5COC\CP([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK2¹WNNCT»KNG DGTCDGT[CRV»TF»¹»VGMMGPKPJC\KTGUKPFGFGHPGFKNFK0G\CTVC½» MKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT +X´GN+CNNCM´N%jMK6jJKD´NJC[TCV9G´NJCUGPCVUCDºMCP 5\PjOGKGXXGNOGTJWO(NJCE0WTVC\C(HGPFK 5JKnPGNHjVKJC6GPG5COC\CP Murtaza Efendi kabir kitabesi +UPKJCVV»(¹TKMCR»N»+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T 0WTVC\C(HGPFKJCEFCKMGP[GMFGUVVGMGNNK0GMMu¼G[J$JOGF(HGPFKµ[GKPVKUCR GFGTGM1CM½KDGPFuQNOW½VWT([RUWNVCPU»TVNCT»PFC.C½IjTK$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµ[G DKTVGMMG[CRV»TO»½V»TMKDWIPFGOGXEWVVWT Sicill-i Osmânî, II 361; Müstakimzâde, 518; Hadîka, II, 361; Hâskan, Eyüpsultan Tarihi, 65-67. Mustafa Çelebi ([RUWNVCP FC6WNVCP,0CJOWF+CP\COCP»P»PJC[»TUCJKRNGTKPFGP'CTUUCjFG $¹CU»GN+jE%G½KT$¹C{µP»P%CDC+C[FCT&COKKEKXCT»PFC[CRV»TF»¹» 'CT NJCFKU[CP»PFCMKOGMVGDKPOWCNNKOK$JOGF(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT 'GXJCV NMVVCDOGNNKHK6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFK PKPFGOjPGXKQ¹NWIKDK KFK2P[C½»PFCKMGP[C\»[CDC½NCF»(XTjFFKPuFWCNCTXGUCKTG[C\F»6QPTCDKT 0WUJCH»½GTuHGDC½NCF»<jUKPK½GTuHUWTGUKPG[CMNC½O»½V»<C\»FCPKEj\GVCNF»XGQP DG½[C½»PFCKMGPVCTKJKPFGXGDCFCPXGHCVGVVK 6W[QNEW\jFGJCMM»PFC½{[NG[C\O»½V»T$PPGXGDCDCUºPºPDGPKOXGDVP CMTCDCUºPºPI{PNNGTKJPQNFW%GPQUGPGDWGUGTKP[CTºUºPºVGOK\G nGMOK¼VKO2PWPXGHCVº[NCMCNGOKGNFGPDºTCMVºO6QPTCMGPFKOGOGVCPGV XGTGTGM[KPG[C\OC[CDC¼NCFºO² Suyolcuzâde, 124 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mustafa Efendi (Vizeli) 140 9K\GNKFKT5WOGNK.CNGOKµPFGMCF»KFK7CµNKMJCVV»ÃTKH(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK'GJC QNFW¹WU{[NGPKTFK*\GN[C\»U»KNG½{JTGV[CRO»½V»T7CJOKPGPJµFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 746. Mustafa Efendi (Kâtipzâde Talebesi) 6G[[KF$JOGF(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNWRºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW7CµNKMJCVV».jVKR\jFG 0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT0FGTTKUXGOQNNCQNWR+CNGR¼COXG 0GMMGK0MGTTGOGMCF»U»QNFW*{TGXKPFGPF{PFMVGPUQPTCVCTKJKPFG M XGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»F»½»PFC(OKT%WJjTK7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 74. Mustafa Efendi (Yusuf Efendizâde) ºUVCPDWNNWµFWT%CDCU»<WUWH(HGPFKµFKT¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF6jNKJ(HGPFK{ PKPM»\MCTFG½K$[½G+CP»ODWPWPNCGXNKKFK7CµNKMJCVV»ÃTKH(HGPFKµFGP [C\F»º[KDKTG¹KVKOI{TFXGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»XGDKTMCnUGPGUQPTCFC0FGTTKUKPK MKTCOµFCPQNFW9GHCVVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK2¹NW <WUWH(HGPFKFGJCVVCVV» Müstakimzâde, 745. Mustafa Efendi (Mühürdar) ([RN FT<C\»[»<CMWD+KPFK´FGP{¹TGPFK.CR»E»DC½»NCT» PFCPKMGPcCXW½DC½»XG UQPTC6CFT»C\CO<KTOKUGMK\cGNGDK\jFG6CKF3C½C P»POJTFjT»QNFW VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(¹TKMCR»0G\CTN»¹» PFCQNWRUKMMGNK½jJKFGUK½{[NGFKT ºOCO\jFG+CVVCV0GJOGF0WUVCHC(HGPFK=KNJKEEG$¹WUVQU Müstakimzâde, 557; Tilgen, 16 Mustafa Efendi (Ketânizâde) .GVCPK\jFGFK[GDKNKPKTºUVCPDWNNW FWT<C\»[»+UG[KP+CDNu(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFK 6NUPGUKJXGTKM CJCVNCT»PFCOjJKTFKgUVjF»FC[C\»NCT»P»DG¹GPKTFK2VW\[C½»PC XCTOCFCPµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC3GTVGX3C½C7TDGUKKNG )GTKFWP3C½C7TDGUKCTCU»PFCF»T.CTFG½K$NK(HGPFKFGJCVVCVQNWRC[P»JQECFCPFGTU I{TF%KTnQMGUGT[C\O»½OjTKHGVNKXGJPGTNKDKT\jVQNFW¹WTKXj[GVQNWPOW½VWT Müstakimzâde, 540; Suyolcuzâde, 112 141 Mustafa Efendi (Müezzin) ([RNFT%CDCU»&G\GTK.CU»O3C½C&COKKµPKPDC½OG\\KPKQNOW½2TOCP\jFG FGPOGMNGOW½JWT0GJOGF(HGPFK FKT<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD (HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFKº½NGMDKT[C\»U»QNWRDKTnQM.WTµjP».GTuO[C\O»½V»T VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK2PUC[HC[CDKT0WUJCHU»¹F»TOCMNCOG½JWTFWT Müstakimzâde, 542; Tilgen, 16; Rado, 146 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mustafa Feyzi Efendi 0WUVCHC)G[\u(HGPFK(¹TKMCR»N»µF»T6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»0QNNC$½Mu&COKKKOCO» (D5jUKO<WUWH(HGPFK{FGPOG½MGVOK½XG(PFGTPK+Oj[WP C MCTFG½K0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFKKNGDGTCDGTn»TCMQNOW½VWT0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK VCTKJKPFGOGMVGDGDC½NCO»½XG(V»DDCK+jUUC\OTGUKPGIKTOK½XG OGMVGRVGPC[T»N»R.QECOWUVCHCRC½C0GFTGUGUKOFGTTKUKQNOW½VWT%WU»TCFC fOGT(HGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½XG[GTKPG5GKU NGV»DDCK¼GJTK[jTu VC[KPQNWPOW½VWT%WOCMCOFC QPCNV»UGPGJK\OGVI{TO½XG $PCFQNW.C\CUMGTNK¹KRj[GUKPG CNO»½V»T $\NKPFGPUQPTCMCTFG½K(OKP (HGPFK5GKU NGV»RDCQNOW½ 0GMMGMC\CU»KNGJCEECIKVOK½ F{P½PFGXGDKTUGPGUQPTC XGHCVGVOK½VKT 0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP&COKKM»DNGUK [{PPFGXG.nM(OKT(HGPFK 7TDGUK PKPJGOGPUQN VCTCH»PFCF»T0WJVG½GODKT ½CJKFGUKXCTF»T 0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK PKPDCDCU» 5GKU NGV»RDC$JOGF(HGPFK VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK Mustafa Feyzi Efendi kabir kitâbesi 142 M 'GFGUK.QEC+C[jVK\jFG0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK FGVCTKJKPFG6jNKJ (HGPFK PKPXGHCV»\GTKPG5GKUµNGV»DDCQNOW½VWT Müstakimzâde, 523; Sicill-i Osmanî, IV, 426-427 Mustafa Nâili Efendi ([RUWNVCP1K½CPECµFCFP[C[CIGNFK%CDCU»6CFTC\CO+COK0GJOGF3C½CµF»T 0KT0WUVCHC%G[FK[GDKNKPGP0WUVCHC1jKNK%G[UNUXGPGUKJJCVV»(¹TKMCR»N» 0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFKXGKEj\GVCNF»¼G[JNKUNjO3KTK\jFG0GJOGF 6jJKD(HGPFKµPKPFCOCF»KFK 0WUVCHC1jKNK%G[$PCFQNW0WJCUGDGUK(OjPGVK'GHVGTK+CMjPu'GHVGTK¼»MM» (XXGNQNFWMVCPUQPTC7GXMKK'GXNGVK$NK[[Gµ[GCVCPF»0WJCTTGO$¹WUVQU VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.QECOWUVCHCRC½C7GMMGUKOG½j[KJKPFGP¼G[J6G[[KF 1WTGFFKP(HGPFKµPKPOWTKFKQNFW¹WPFCPXCUK[GVKPGI{TGJµFGXGHCV GFGP½G[JKPKPOGFHWPQNFW¹W²VTDGKEGFKFG³MCR»U»F»½»PCI{ONF Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 436-437; Müstakimzâde, 541; Daniflmend, ‹zahl› Osmanl› Tarihi Kronolojisi, IV, 613 143 Mustafa Nakflî Efendi (A¤a) ([RN FT6NUXGPGUKJJCVV»<GFKMWNGNK\jFG6G[[KF$DFNJCNKO(HGPFK FGP OG½MGVVK6QPTCVC NKM[C\»[CnCN»½V»%KTOFFGVUQPTCUCTC[»P.CJXGEKDC½»U»QNWR +CUU2FCTKECNKPFGPXGVGDFKNJCUGMKUKKMGPTGDKNGXXGNKPKPRGT½GODG IP([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTKgUMFCT FC$[C\OC&COKK JC\KTGUKPFGFKT7C½»OGXEWVVWT Müstakimzâde, 558; Tilgen, 16; Rado, 166 Mustafa Niyazi Efendi 6G[[KF0WUVCHC1K[C\K(HGPFK%Q\FQ¹CP.GOGTKEKXCT»PFCºVHjK[G&CFFGUKKNG .QXCE»NCT&CFFGUKµPKPDKTNG½VK¹K[GTFGDWNWPCP+UCO%G[&COKKKOCO»XG OGMVGDKPJQECU»KFK 7CµNKM[C\C[»%WTUCN»=GMK'GFGµFGP{¹TGPOK½XGKEC\GVCNO»½V»T6QP\COCPNCT»PC MCFCT²0GMVGDK1XXjD³JCVJQECN»¹»P»[CRO»½V»T0WJCTTGO$TCN»M VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»'TTK\jFGNGTUQHCU»[CP»PFC XG[QNWPFKTUGM[CRV»¹»[GTFGDWNWPCPºUOjKN=JFuMCDTKEKXCT»PFCF»T ‹bnütlemin, 607 Mustafa Pafla (Koca Niflanc›) 7QU[CN».CF»&GNjN KPQ¹NWFWT7CJUKNFGPUQPTC)TGPMºDTCJKO3C½C [C6»TMCV»DKXG UQPTC5GKU µNMVVjDQNFWµFG1K½CPE»QNWRVCTKJKPFG OVGHGTTKMCDC½»QNOW½VWT µFC=KIGVXCT CI{PFGTKNGTGMKMKPEKFGHC1K½CPE»QNFW7GXEKJG.jPPK 6WNVCP6NG[OCP »PXGHCV»PCVGUjFHGVVK¹KPFGP6CFTC\CO6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½C KNGQVC¹CIKTFK¹KPFGVCDWVWI{TF¹PFGMKOUG[GHCTMGVVKTOGOK½VKT 5GDKNGXXGN([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([R VGMGPFKGUGTKQNCP 1K½CPE»&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGMCTFG½K6jNKJ(HGPFK PKP[CP»PFCF»T 6VWP½GMNKPFGMK½CJKFGUKECOKKP OKJTCD»VCTCH»PFCF»T%C½VC½»P»P KDCTGUK½{[NGFKT Eyüplü Hattatlar /CKNCJGKNNCNNCJ &GNjNQ¸NW1K¼jPuMKEKJjPºP )GPjUºPI{TFC\OKVFKDGMj[C 7GPKJjMKQNWDCUNºPCTjEK .CTº¼FºTJºRjMKCUHK[j[C $[CMVC½»PFCKUG 0WJCOOGFWP5GUNWNNCJ <GTKEGPPGVQNCFG[OGNGMNGT )GNGMNGTFGPGNCnFºNCTFW j[C ¹¼KFDTJKMWFUKFGFKVjTKJ ±¹NjJKTCJOGVG[NG0WUVCHC [C² Mustafa Pafla mezar› (Eyüp, Niflanc› Camii Haziresi) 144 M 0WUVCHC3C½CUK[CUGVXGJMOGVKFCTGUKPKPJKMOGVKPGXjM»HDKT\jVKFKºNM VCJUKNKPKOGONGMGVKPWNGOjU»PFCPXG[MUGMVCJUKNKPKFGºUVCPDWNjNKONGTKPFGP VCOCON»[CTCMFGXNGVJK\OGVKPGIKTFK+jK\QNFW¹WHC\KNGVKXGºUNjOK[C\»VTNGTKPFGP FKXjPKFGMKOCJjTGVKOGUNG¹KPFG[MUGNOGUKPGUGDGDQNFW%WUC[GFG<CXW\ 6WNVCP6GNKO+CP\COCP»PFC'KXjP»+Oj[WP.CVKRNGTKCTCU»PCIKTFK .CPWPKFGXTKPFG0»U»T COGOWTQNCP9G\KTKC\COºDTCJKO3C½C P»PVCMFKTXG JKOC[GUKPGOC\JCTQNCTCMQPWPVG\MKTGEKNK¹KXC\KHGUKKNG0»U»T CIKVVKµFG F{PFXG5GKUµNMVVjD'»½K½NGTK%CMCP»VC[KPQNWPFW µFG%C¹FCFHGVJKPFGDWNWPWR1K½CPE»6G[FK%G[ KPXGHCV»\GTKPG1K½CPE»N»M VGXEKJQNWPCTCM[KTOKF{TVUGPGDWOJKOXC\KHGFGDWNWPOW½VWT%WJK\OGV FQNC[»U»[NCFGXNGVKPOJKOK½NGTKPKPGPK[K½GMKNFGF\GNVKNOGXG[TVNOGUK JWUWUWPFCRGMD[MDKTNK[CMCVXGFKTC[GVKI{TNF 7CDCMCV NOGOCNKMCFN»GUGTKVCTKJuXGCJNjMuOJKODKTGUGTFKT0GXjMKD N JCNNCOKUGI\GNCJNjM»PHC[FCNCT»PFCPXGM{VCJNjM»P\CTCTNCT»PFCP DCJUGVOK½VKT6GNKOPjOG UK<CXW\6WNVCP6GNKO KPIC\CNCT»P»KnGTOGMVGFKT$[T»EC 1K½jPKOCJNCUN»DKTFKXCP»XGFK¹GTDC\»GUGTNGTKXCTF»T %CDCU»&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFKFGQ¹WNNCT»IKDKJCVVCVV»2PNCTIKDK[C\»[»¼G[J+COFWNNCJ (HGPFK FGP{¹TGPFKXGVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK 145 Sicill-i Osmânî IV, 375; Cemaleddin, Ayine-i Zurafa, ‹stanbul. 1314, s. 25-26; Müstakimzâde, 525; Hadika I, 295; Rado, 74; Daniflmend, ‹zahl› Osmanl› Tarihi Kronolojisi, II, 451; Mehmet Tâhir, Osmanl› Müellifleri, III , 37; Uzunçarfl›l›, Tosyal› Celâlzâde Mustafa ve Sâlih Efendiler, Belleten’den ayr› bas›m s. 341-391; Haskan, I, 75; Mustafa Rak›m (Unan) Bey )KNKDGNK+CVVCV%CMMCN$JOGFÃTKH(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWTµFG )KNKDG3NQXFKX FGFQ¹FW2UOCPN»5WUJCTDKU»TCU»PFCCKNGUKKNGDKTNKMVG ºUVCPDWN CJKETGVGVVKºNMXGQTVCVCJUKNKPFGPUQPTC9GHCºFCFKUK PKDKVKTFK 8\WPOFFGVOGOWTQNCTCM<CNQXC FCDWNWPFW6QPTCgPKXGTUKVGOWJCUGDGEKUK QNFW(OGMNKQNFWMVCPUQPTC*\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUKJUPKJCVJQECN»¹»PCVC[KP QNWPFWXGHCV»PCMCFCTDWI{TGXFGMCNF»1KUCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK (FKTPGMCR»U»OG\CTN»¹»PFCXGDCDCU»PC[CM»PDKT[GTFGFKT%CDCU»P»POG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUKQPWPFWT ‹bnülemin, 294 Mustafa fieyhi Efendi $PVCM[CN»µF»T7CJUKNKPKVCOCONCF»MVCPUQPTCºUVCPDWNµCIGNFKgnFKNFG$TCRnC )CTUnCXG7TMnG½KKT[C\CDKNGPDKT\jVV»6NUPGUKJXGVCµNKM[C\»FCOjJKTQNWR .CTCM»\NjMCD»[NCVCP»PCP+QEC\jFG0GJOGF(PXGTK{FGPFGTU CNO»½V»T+GTMCNGOFGOjJKTDKTRuTKFKµFGXGHCVGVVK([RUWNVCPµFC OGFHWPFWT Müstakimzâde, 551. Mustafa Tevfik Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWQNWRJ´FGFQ¹FW'Q¹WOWPC$[XCPUCTC[FCJKNKPFG(OKT %WJjTK7GMMGUK½G[JK0GJOGF(OKP7QMCFu(HGPFKVCTKJF½TO½VT6WNVCP,,, $JOGFFGXTKPFG(PFGTWPµCCN»PCTCM6GHGTNK.Q¹W½WµPCIKTFK6QPTCn»TC¹»QNFW .CTFG½K6KNCJFCTcCXW½NCT»µPFCPGNJjE0GJOGF$¹CKNG¼G[J0GJOGF(OKP (HGPFKµ[GDC¹NCPCTCMVCTKMCVGIKTOK½NGTFKT 7CµNKM[C\»[».jVKD\jFG5GHKµ(HGPFK{µFGP{¹TGPFK6WNVCP6GNKO&COKK EKXCT»PFCºUOGV(HGPFK7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCMK(UMK1K½CPE».C\CUMGT&CµHGTcGNGDK &COKK[CM»P»PFCMKGXKPFG[C\»NCT»KNGOG½IWNQNFW¹WU»TCFCjOj$NK(HGPFKµFGPWUN FGTUNGTKCNCTCMOWUKMu½KPCUQNOW½VWT¼KKTNGTKXCTF»T +KETu0WJCTTGO$¹WUVQUHGNnKNNGVKPFGPXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR» 0G\CTN»¹»µPFCOGUEKVXG/CµNunG½OGUKMCT½»U»PFCF»T Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 740. 146 Mustafa Vâs›f Efendi (Çömez) <C\»[».GDGEK\jFG0GJOGF9CUHu(HGPFK{µFGP{¹TGPFK¹KKnKPMGPFKUKPG c{OG\NjMCD»XGTKNOK½VKT6QPTC/C\fOGT(HGPFK{0µFGPFCJK[C\» FGTUNGTKCNF».CUVCOQPW FC$MUW.{[ PFG.CF»Q¹NWFGPOGMNGOCTWHKFK ºUVCPDWN CIGNGTGMJPGTUCJKDKQNFW+COKFK[G9CMH» P»PMC[OCMCO»XGVTDGUKPKP DC½VTDGFCT»KMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKK PKP %QUVCPºUMGNGUK6QMC¹» PCCn»NCPCXNWMCR»U»P»P[CP»PFCXG$[CU3C½C7TDGUK PKP UQNVCTCH»PFCF»T &GNuUNUµNG[C\»NCPMKVjDGUKPKPKDCTGUK½{[NGFKT M 147 Mustafa Vâs›f Efendi’nin nesih yaz›s› Mustafa Vâs›f Efendi kabir kitâbesi + XGN+C[[ N%jMK &GPPGVOGMjPHKTFGXUK j¼K[CP *j\K6WNVCP$DFNJCOKF +jPVjDGUGTCJ +C\TGVNGTK PKP 9CMHº¼GTuHKMjKOOCMjO XGMKNKGUDCM 6GTNGXJCKJCVVjVuPOGTJWO XGOC¸HWTW´NOWJVjEKNj TCJOGVK TCDDKJK´N¸CHTGNJCE 0WUVCHC 9jUºH(HGPFK´PKPTWJKnP HjVKJC %KTUGPGGXXGNXGHCVGFGPM»\» (OKPG6GTXGV+CP»O »PMCDTKFG [CP»PFCF»T.C\CUMGT0WUVCHC º\\GV(HGPFK9jU»H(HGPFKµPKPGP {PFGIGNGPVCNGDGUKFKT Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 475-600; Habib, 170171; ‹bnülemin, 447-449; Rado, 210 Eyüplü Hattatlar Mustafa Vefa Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWQNCP¼G[J0WUVCHC9GHj(HGPFKD[MjNKO0UVCMKO\jFG6NG[OCP 6CFGFFKP(HGPFK PKPDCDCU»GN+CE0GJOGF(HGPFK PKPMCTFG½KXG0GJOGF 0UVCMKO(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT ¼G[J0WUVCHC9GHj P»PVCJUKNKDCDCU»PFCPQNWRUNUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»&jDK\jFG$DFK $¹C FCPVC NKM[C\»[»'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK FGPXGJWTFGVC NKMKFG 1GTIKUK\jFG FGPOG½MGVOK½VKT %CDCU»P»PXGHCV»PFCPUQPTC1CDNWUNW¼G[J$DFNICPK(HGPFK [GKPVKUCDGVOGMKnKP ¼CO CIKVOK½XGQTCFCQPKMKUGPGMCNF»MVCPUQPTCU»NCJCUTGVK[NGºUVCPDWN C F{PO½XGDKTJCHVCUQPTCFCVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U» F»½»PFC(OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUKEKXCT»PFC6»TV7GMMGCTMCU»PFCXGDCDCU»P»P EKXCT»PFCF»T Müstakimzâde, 539; Suyolcuzâde, 130 148 M Müeyyedzâde Abdurrahman Hâtemi Efendi 0G[[GF\jFG$OCU[CN»QNWR¼G[JºUJCM(HGPFKPGUNKPFGPFKT6CHGT2ECM VCTKJKPFGFQ¹OW½XG6WNVCP,,%j[G\KF KP$OCU[CXCNKNK¹KU»TCU»PFCOGENKUKPGFCJKN QNOW½XGDWU»TCFC¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFK FGP[C\»OG½MGVOK½VKT ¼GJ\jFG,,%j[G\KFKNGQNCP[CM»PN»¹»P»nGMGOG[GPNGTVCTCH»PFCP)CVKJµG ICOOC\NCPF»fNOHGTOCP»n»MO»½MGP¼GJ\jFGPKPFG[CTF»O»[NC$OCU[CµFCP MCnCTCM{PEG+CNGDµGIKVVK2TCFCKNKOVCJUKNGVVKKNOKPKKNGTNGVGMKnKPFCJCUQPTC ¼uTC\µCIKVVK%WTCFC[GFK[»NFuPKXGCMNuKNKONGT\GTKPGnCN»½V»,,%j[G\KFµKPVCJVC n»MOCU»\GTKPG{PEG$OCU[Cµ[CUQPTCºUVCPDWNµCIKVVK 3CFK½CJ »\K[CTGVVGPUQPTCWNGOjFCP+CVKD\jFG[CTF»O»[NC5COC\CP(MKO VCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWN FC9G\PGEKNGT FG.CNGPFGTJjPG0GFTGUGUKOFGTTKUNK¹KPG VC[KPQNWPOW½VWT 5GDKNGXXGN0CTVVCTKJKPFG0UNKJFFKP.CUVCNjPKµ[GFCOCVQNFW¹W IPFG)CVKJ6GOjPK[GOGFTGUGUKOFGTTKUNK¹KPGCVCPO»½V»T6QPTCDC\» OFGTTKUNKMNGTFGFGDWNWPFW5WOGNK.C\CUMGTKRj[GNKKMGP<CXW\6WNVCP6GNKO KP ENWUWPFC<GPKnGTKNGT KP7jEK\jFG&CHGTcGNGDK PKPGXKKNGDGTCDGTMQPC¹»P»[C¹OC GVOGNGTKUQPWPFCC\NQNWPOW½VWT FG5WOGNK.C\CUMGTKQNFWDKTUGPGUQPTC<CXW\6GNKO KPOCK[GVKPFGcCNF»TCP UGHGTKPFGDWNWPOW½VWTVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPVTDGUK CTMCU»PFCKMGPVC½»[QMQNOW½VWT9GHCV»PFCPUGPGUQPTC[C\»NCP+CFuMCV N &GXjOK[C\CT»½jJKFGUKPKI{TF¹PDG[CPGFK[QT.GPFKUKPKP[GFKDKPEKNVNKMRGM D[MDKTMVRJCPGUKXCTF»$[T»ECVGNKHGUGTNGTKXCTF»T Hadîka, II, 42; Müstakimzâde, 249; Ayverdi, Fatih Devri Hattatlar›, 7; Daniflmend, Osmanl› Tarihi Kronolojisi, I, 422; Mehmed Mecdî, Hadâiku’fl-flekâik (Haz. Abdülkadir Özcan), ‹stanbul, Ça¤r› Yay›nlar›, 1989, s. 308-311; Serin, fieyh Hamdullah, 55 Nasuhi Karg› ([RUWNVCPgOOK6KPCP7GMMGUK¼G[JK5j½KF(HGPFK PKPMnMQ¹NWFWT [»N»PFC([RUWNVCP FCMKDWVGMMGFGFQ¹FW9GHC/KUGUK PFGPOG\WPQNOW½XG *OTMVG½MKNCV»P»PFG¹K½KMM»U»ONCT»PFCnCN»½O»½V»T <C\»[»K[KDKTJCVVCVQNCPD[MDCDCU»P»P[C\»NCT»P»PVGUKTKCNV»PFCMCNCTCMH»VTuDKT KUVKFCVNC{¹TGPOK½VKT.CTI»PGUKJTKM CXGEGNu[C\»NCT»[C\O»½V»T<C\»VGMPK¹KPG XjM»HK[KDKTJCVVCVXGK[KDKTTGUUCOQNFW¹WTKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT Tilgen, 16 149 Nefle Bey <C\»[»6jOK(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFK%jD»jNK'KXjP»+Oj[WP.CNGOKOOG[[K\KKFK +C[CV»JCMM»PFCHC\NCECDKTOCNWOCV[QMVWT[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 16 Nizameddin Efendi 7C NKM[C\»[»nQMK[K[C\CTF»([RUWNVCP FC.»\»N0GUEKF FGQVWTWTFW+C[CV» JCMM»PFCDKTDKNIK[QMVWT[»N»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT Tilgen, 17 Osman Efendi (Suyolcuzâde Talebesi) Eyüplü Hattatlar ºUVCPDWNNW FWT2UOCP(HGPFK[C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK{ µFGP{¹TGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK<CXGFWFºUMGNGUK PFG %CNCV¼G[JK6G[[KF+CUCP1WTK(HGPFKMCDTKPKPMCT½»U»PFCKFKµG[CM»P0WUJCH [C\F»¹»TKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 300; Tilgen, 17 Osman Efendi (Mevlevî) 0GUPGXKJCP0GXNGXu2UOCP'GFGQNCTCMCP»N»T<C\»OGTCMN»U»QNFW¹WMCFCTJjH»\ ½jKTXGGFKDFKTºMKI{\jOjQNWRVCTKJNGTKPFGJC[CVVCKFK Tilgen, 17 150 O Osman Efendi (Hâf›z) +jH»\2UOCP(HGPFKNjMCD»[NCDKNKPKTFK'uXCPMCVKRNGTKPFGP$DFNDjMK%WTPC\ (HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT<C\»[»JCVVCV6jNKJ(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½VKT([RUWNVCP FC .CNGPFGTJjPG0GMVGDKJQECU»KFK[»N»PFC{NO½VT Tilgen, 17 Osman Efendi (‹smail Efendizâde) ([RNFT([RUWNVCP&COKKDC½OG\\KPKXGVTDGFCT»ºUOCKN(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»([[WDK6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPOK½XG UQPTCFC+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½VKT9GHCVVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT 1WTWNNCJ7KNIGP FGI{TNGPVCTKJK[CP»NOCUQPWEWQNUCIGTGMVKT Müstakimzâde, 298-299; Tilgen, 17 Osman Efendi (Süleyman Efendizâde) 6VNEG&COKKºOCO»6NG[OCP(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWTºUj\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGP VCµNuMOG½MGVOK½VKT.C½ICTu¼G[JK$DFWNNCJºFTuUKM»\MCTFG½KKNGGXNKKFK+KETu [»N»PFC+jE[QNWPFCXGHCVGVVK +CVVCVN»¹»[CP»PFCOWUKMu½KPCUN»¹»JjH»\N»¹»XG½jKTNK¹KFGXCTF» Müstakimzâde, 693; Tilgen, 17. Osman Efendi +C[CV»JCMM»PFCMC[PCMNCTFCDKTDKNIK[QMVWT¼CDCP¼WUCV&WOC IPXGHCVGVOK½VKT.nM½jJKFGUK(¹TKMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCJCVVCV0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFKMCDTK{PPFGJ\$DFWµUUjF»MÃOKT7TDGUKµPKP[CPVCTCH»PFCF»T.KVCDGUK ½{[NGFKT 151 +jEGK%QUVCPEK[jPJCVVCVGNJjE2UOCP(HGPFK »CDCP +CVVCV5jUKO(HGPFKMCDTK{PPFGI{ONQNOCU»QPWPVCNGDGUKQNOCKJVKOCNKPK CMNCIGVKTOGMVGFKT Ömer A¤a 0GJOGF(HGPFKKUKONKDKT\jV»PQ¹NWFWT([R VG2VCME»NCT FCFP[C[CIGNFK<C\»[» ([[Du5GEGD+CNKHG FGPFCJCUQPTC6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC([[DK(HGPFK FGPOG½M GFGTGMKEj\GVCNF» CFGV.WTµjP».GTuO[C\F»¹»Q¹NW$JOGFcGNGDKVCTCH»PFCPTKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT <GPKnGTK6GTFGPIGnVKGOGMNKNGTKPFGPKMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK (FKTPGMCR»OG\CTN»¹»PFC6»TV7GMMGE»XCT»PFCKMGPDWIPOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT Müstakimzâde, 347-348; Tilgen, 18 Eyüplü Hattatlar Ömer Efendi (Akmolla) %[MDKTKJVKOCNNG([RUWNVCPFQ¹WONWFWT%CDCU»$DFWTTCJOCP(HGPFK OFGTTKUKPFGPKFK$MOQNNCQNCTCMDKNKPGPfOGT(HGPFKOGFTGUGG¹KVKOKI{TO½ XGMCF»QNOW½VWT([R1K½CPECU»µPFC¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK{VGMMGUKPFG ½G[JQNCPXGµFCXGHCVGFGP6»TT»$NK(HGPFKµPKPOTuFKKFK Ak Molla Ömer Efendi’nin celî sülüs yaz›s› 152 Ö +CFKMCµFC²1j[\GPKDuPC\uTJCVVCV³QNCTCMIGnGP$MOQNNCUNUXGPGUKJK .jVKR\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK{FGP{¹TGPOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T+CVVCV +QEC\jFG6G[[KF$JOGF(HGPFK{µPKPGXKPKUCV»PCNO»½XGQTCFC VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT 0UVCMKO\jFGµ[GI{TG²¼G[J0WTCFFCKTGUKPG[CM»PRGFGTKMCDTKPGFGHPQNWPFW³ 6NG[OCP)jKM(HGPFK{µ[GI{TGFG²([RµVG¼G[J0WTjF»1CM½KDGPFK 7GMMGUKMCR»U»MCT½»U»PFCMKOCMDGTGFG³OGFHWPFWT+CFuMCµFC*CNCVC 0GXNGXKJCPGUKDCJUKPFG±»G[FC'GFGXG1C[\GPDC¼º$MOQNNCfOGT(HGPFKXG FK¸GT1C[\GPDC¼º+CNKN'GTXK¼0GJOGF'GFGOGFHWPNCTFºT² FK[QT ¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK7GMMGUKMCR»U»MCT½»U»PFC1C\»T$¹C6QMC¹»KNG=CJKTGEK6QMC¹» CTCU»PFCMKGUMKOG\CTN»MVCPIGTK[GMGUOGVC½FWXCTDCMK[GUKPFGPDC½MCDKT½G[ MCNOCO»½V»T$TUCU»PCDKTnQMIGEGMQPFW[CR»NO»½V»T*CNCVC0GXNGXKJCPGUK OG\CTN»¹»PFCKUG$MOQNNCµP»PVC½»PCTCUVNCPOCO»½V»T fOGT(HGPFK[C\NCT»%Q¹C\KnKµPFGºPEKTM{[µFGMK[C\N»¹»PFCQVWTWTFW+GTUCDCJ UGJGTXCMVK[CT»OUCCVPG[nCNCTXG(XE0CMCO»µPFCPG[KNG²GUUCNjV³XGTKTOK½ %KNKPFK¹KIKDKUCDCJUCNjV»FKNMG½JjXGTCPOCMCO»PFCF»TfOGT(HGPFKµPKPQTVC[C MQ[FW¹W(XKE0CMCO»µP»PDKTOW\KMJCFKUGUKQNFW¹WDWK½KPW\OCPNCT»VCTCH»PFCP U{[NGPOGMVGF»T 153 Hadîka, I, 294- II, 49; Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 593-594; Müstakimzâde, 346-347; ‹bnülemin (Mahmud Kemal ‹nal), Hofl Sadâ, ‹stanbul, Türkiye ‹fl Bankas› Kültür Yay›nlar›, 1958, s. 156. Eyüp Niflanc›’da Ak Molla Ömer Efendi’nin kabrinin bulundu¤u alanda bugün gecekondular bulunmaktad›r. Ömer Vasfi Efendi’nin Eyüp Sultan Reflad Türbesi kap› üzerinde bulunan celî sülüs müsennâ yaz›s› Eyüplü Hattatlar Ömer Vasfi Efendi +»TMCK¼GTuH&COKK+CVuDK([R6CDTK(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNCTCM&GOj\K[GNGXXGN 1KUCPVCTKJKPFG7QRJCPG'GVGTFCT0CJCNNGUK7TMIE6QMC¹»µPFC FP[C[CIGNFK ºNMVCJUKNKPFGPUQPTC7QRJCPG)G[\K[G5½FK[GUKµPGFGXCOGVVK%WTCFC[C\» JQECU»cWMWTEWOCN».CFTK(HGPFKµFGPUNUPGUKJFGTUKCNF»'CJCUQPTC$\K\ (HGPFKµFGPVCµNuMXGUNU.jOKN(HGPFKµFGPUNUXGFuXjPKOG½MGVVK1KJC[GV [»N»PFC6jOK(HGPFKµ[GOG½MGDC½NC[CTCMEGNuVCµNuMXGEGNuUNUnCN»½V» =KNMjFG2ECMVCTKJKPFGDCDCU»P»PXGHCV»\GTKPGQPWPI{TGXKQNCP +»TMCK¼GTuH&COKK+CVKRNK¹KPKfOGT(HGPFK\GTKPGCNF» Ömer Vasfi Efendi’nin celî sülüs yaz›s› 154 Ö Eyüp Sultan Reflad Türbesi giriflinde Ömer Vasfi Efendi hatt› ile besmele 7CMUKO0CMUGOKµPGDKVK½KMnG½OG\GTKj[GV.»U»MN»&COKKF»½MCR»XGOKJTCR\GTK EGNu[C\»NCT»KNGECOKK{PPFGDWNWPCPnG½OG\GTKPFGMKEGNuj[GV+»TMCK¼GTuH &COKKµPFGEGNuUNU\GTGPFFNGXJC)CVKJ7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPFGVTDGFCT$JOGF ÃOK½(HGPFKOG\CTVC½».KVjDGUK([R6WNVCP5G½CF7TDGUKF»½»PFCMKEGNuOUGPPj C[GVKNGKnGTKFGRCHVCN»MW½CMfOGT9CUHK(HGPFKµPKP{PGONKGUGTNGTKPFGPFKT &GOC\K[GNCJKT.CU»OVCTKJKPFG[C½»PFCXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK ([RUWNVCPµFC+CVVCV.jOKN(HGPFKOG\CT»EKXCT»PFCF»T.KVjDGUK[QMVWT 155 Ömer Vasfi Efendi’nin yaz›lar›n›n bulundu¤u Eyüp Sultan Reflad Türbesi Eyüplü Hattatlar Ömer Vasfi Efendi’nin Eyüp Sultan, Reflad Türbesi kap› üzerinde bulunan celî sülüs müsennâ yaz›s› ve kuflak yaz›s›n›n sonunda bulunan imza istifi ‹bnülemin, 266-271; Derman, ‹ki Kardefl Hattat›m›z, s. 1-9; a. mlf. Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, L. ; a. mlf. ‹KMHS, ; a. mlf. “Eyüpsultan Reflâdiye Nümûne Mektebi’nin Kaz›nm›fl Kitâbesine Dâir”, ‹stanbul, III. Eyüpsultan Sempozyumu Tebli¤ler, 2000, s. 170-175; Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi, 125-126 ; Serin, Hat Sanat› ve Meflhur Hattatlar, s. 169-170. Ömer Vasfi Efendi hatt› ile celî sülüs Ahmed Âmifl Efendi mezartafl› kitâbesi (Fatih Türbesi haziresi) 156 R Râflid Efendi (Hâf›z) +jH»\0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFKQNCTCMCP»N»T[»N»PFC([RUWNVCP FC 1K½CPEC FC'CXWF$¹C&COKKEKXCT»PFCMKDKTGXFGFQ¹FWºNMVCJUKNKPK2VCME»NCT FC )GVJKcGNGDK&COKK[CP»PFCKMGPDWIPJGNj[CR»NCP$DFK(HGPFKXCM»HOGMVGDKPFG +jH»\0GJOGF(HGPFK FGPQMWOW½XGJjH»\QNOW½VWT+QEC5CKM(HGPFK FGP$TCRnC ¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK7GMMGUK½G[JK$DFNMCFKT%GNJK(HGPFK FGPFG)CTUnC {¹TGPOK½VKT7C NKM[C\»[»JCVVCV%WTJCPGFFKP(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T %CDCU»¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK7GMMGUK½G[JK$DFNMCFKT%GNJKQNFW¹WPFCPQPWPXGHCV» \GTKPGDKTOFFGVXGMjNGVGP½G[JNKM[CRO»½V»T7GMMGNGTKPMCRCV»NOCU»PFCPUQPTC ([RUWNVCP&COKKKOCO»QNFWXG[»N»PFCGOGMNK[GC[T»NF» (OGMNKNK¹KPFGPUQPTCXCMVKPKQMWOCMXG[C\»[C\OCMNCIGnKTOK½VKT7TMFKNKKNGFG OG½IWNQNCP0GJOGF5j½KF(HGPFKUGMUGPUGMK\[C½»PCMCFCTJKnFWTOCFCPKNKONG OG½IWNQNOW½VWT6QPFGTGEGOVGXC\KXGCNnCMI{PNNDKT\jVKFK[»N»PFC XGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC*O½UW[W0G\CTN»¹» PFCKFK Tilgen, 18 Râflid Efendi (Dürrizâde) 157 'TTK\jFG0GJOGF5C½KF(HGPFKKMKFGHC¼G[JNKUNjO QNCP'TTK\jFG0GJOGFÃTKH(HGPFK{µPKP Q¹NWQNWROFGTTKUKFK7C NKMJCVV»P»I\GN[C\CTF» VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR» OG\CTN»¹»PFC/j NKcG½OGUKXG¼jKT.C\CUMGT%jMK (HGPFKUQHCU»P»PDKTC\KNGTKUKPFGXG[QNWPFKTUGM [CRV»¹»[GTFGMKCKNGUQHCU»PFCF»T.KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 6CDºMCP»G[JNKUNjO 'TTK\jFGÂTKH(HGPFK +C\TGVNGTK PKPOCJFWOW OFGTTKUuPKMKTjOFCPOGTJWO XGOC¸HTWPNGJ GU6G[[KF0GJOGF5j¼KF(HGPFK TWJKnWPGN)CVKJCUGPG ‹bnülemin, 608; Haskan I/309; Sicill-i Osmânî II, 351 Râflid Efendi kabir kitâbesi Rifat Yazgan %CDCU»)CVKJIGPGNMNVTJQECNCT»PFCP$NK(HGPFKQNWRVCTKJKPFG ºUVCPDWN FC6CT»I\GN FGFQ¹FW'CJCMnM[C½VCKMGP[C\»[C\OC¹CJGXGUNGPGP 5KHCV%G[OG\CTVC½NCT»P»MQR[CGVOGMUWTGVK[NGFGXTKPKP[C\»UVjFNCT»P»P GUGTNGTKPKOG½MGVOK½XG6GNKO(HGPFKPjO»PFCMKDKT\jV»PJKOC[GUKPFG[GVK½GTGM OG\CTVC½NCT»[C\OC¹CDC½NCO»½V»T%KT[CPFCPFCT½FK[G[GFGXCOGFGTGMVCJUKNKPK [CRCTMGP\COCP\COCP[C\»JQECNCT»PFCPFGTUCNO»½V»TºNMJQECU»+CE»<CJ[C +KNOK(HGPFKºMKPEKJQECU»6WNVCP+COKF KPnQEWMNCT»PC[C\»JQECN»¹»GVOK½QNCP ¼GXMK(HGPFKµFKT6QPTCDC\»OGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWXGMGPFKCT\WUWKNG FG GOGMNKQNFW %VP[C\»nG½KVNGTKPK[C\OCMVCQNCP5KHCV<C\ICPDKNJCUUCUNUEGNuUNUTKM C EGNuUKXGVC NKM KI\GN[C\CTF»(UGTNGTKPKPGMUGTKUKºUVCPDWN7TMXGºUNCO(UGTNGTK 0\GUK PFGDWNWPOCMVCF»T%KTnQMNGXJCNCT[C\F»¹»IKDKOG\CTVC½»[C\O»½V»T¼WDCV FCXGHCVGVVK.»UCDQ[NWM»TO»\»[\NXGDG[C\UCMCNN»KFK.{OTVQ\WPFCP OTGMGR»U»TICPQVWPWPUCRNCT»PFCPMCNGOXGOKF[GMCDW¹WPWJQMMC[CRCTF» (XK([RUWNVCP FC2VCME»NCTUGOVKPFGKFK%WTCFCP6WNVCPCJOGF VGMK'GHVGTK +CMjPuFCKTGUKPG[T[GTGMIKFGTXGGXKPGF{PGTFK ‹bnülemin, 333; Hattat R›fat Yazgan, Canl› Tarihler, ‹stanbul, Türkiye Yay›nevi, 1946, s. 1-8; Tilgen, 18 Eyüplü Hattatlar Rüfldi Üstek 0W\KMC[»+Oj[WPDC½CNM»½n»U»7GXHKM%G[µKPQ¹NWFWT[»N»PFC 'QNOCDCJnGµFGMK.CTCCDCN»7GMMGUKµPFGFQ¹OW½VWTºNMVCJUKNKPK([RUWNVCPµFCMK .CNGPFGTJCPG0GMVGDKµPFG[CRO»½UQPTCCUMGTuT½FK[G[GIKTOK½QTCFCPOG\WP QNFWMVCPUQPTC%G½KMVC½µVC6KPCP3C½C&COKKµPFG0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGP$TCDuXG FCJCUQPTCFC([R%CJCTK[G0GXNGXKJCPGUKµPGKPVKUCDGFGTGM¼G[J+UG[KP )CJTGFFKP(HGPFKµFGP)CTKUu{¹TGPOK½VKT [»N»PFCGXXGNC*CNCVC5WUOCV1G\jTGVKVCJTKTCVMCVKRNK¹KPGUQPTC'GHVGTJjPG MC[»VMCNGOKPFG(XMjH1G\jTGVKXCM»HMC[»VNCTXGNGXj\»OMCNGOKPFGXGPKJC[GVDW FCKTGPKPOWJVGNKHM»U»ONCT»PFC½GHQNCTCMQVW\[»NFCPHC\NCnCN»½O»½XGGOGMNK[G C[T»NO»½V»T +QECU»+UG[KP)CJTGFFKP(HGPFKµFGPI{TF¹VG½XKM\GTKPGGFGDK[CVKNGFG OG½IWNQNOW½VWT0G[FCPCIGVKTOK½QNFW¹WGUGTNGT0GXNjPC'GTIjJ»RQUVPK½KPK +CNKOcGNGDKVCTCH»PFCPVCMFKTGFKNOK½VKT ([RUWNVCPµFC)[\jV0GMVGDKµPFGJQECN»MGVOK½QNCP5½FK%G[OWJVGNKH NGXJCNCT[C\F»¹»IKDKCTW\XG\PKPFGnQMI\GN½KKTNGTKFGXCTF»T%KNJCUUCVCTKJ F½TOGMVGG½KPGC\TCUVNCP»TDKTUVjFKFK Tilgen, 19; Nurullah Tilgen kitab› neflretti¤inde (1950) hayatta oldu¤unu kaydetmifltir. 158 S Sadullah Efendi 6CFWNNCJ(HGPFK([RN FT%CDCU».CTE»DC½»0GJOGF(HGPFKµFKT%CDCU»KNG DGTCDGT+QECRC½CN»ºDTCJKO'GFG(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GV CNO»½V»TµFGXGHCVGVVK Müstakimzâde, 207; Tilgen, 19 Salih Efendi (Hâf›z ‹mam) +jH»\KOCOFK[GVCP»PO»½V»T.GPFKUKºUVCPDWNNWQNWR<WUWH(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»$DKFcGNGDK0GUEKFK PKPKOCO»XGOGMVGDKPKPOWCNNKOK &GNXGVK7CTKMCVK PKPjTKHNGTKPFGP0GJOGF=CKHK(HGPFK FGPVC NKMJCVV»FC 'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK FGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T¼G[JNKUNjO$VCWNNCJ (HGPFK PKPKOCON»¹»P»[CRV»¹»PFCP$VCuºOCO»QNCTCMFCVCP»PO»½V»T ([R1K½CPECU» PFCVGMMGUCJKDK+QEC0GJOGF0WTCF(HGPFK{µ[G DC¹NCPO»½V»T6QJDGVNGTKPKPFCKOCKNOuQNFW¹WTKXj[GVGFKNOK½VKT'KXjP»fTHuK ¼KTj\u [K½GTJGVOK½VKT$[T»ECFKXCP»XCTF»T VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FCºFTKU.{½McG½OGUK CTMCU»PFCMKOG\CTN»MVCMCTFG½KOFGTTKU0WUC(HGPFK PKPMCDTK[CM»P»PFCF»T 0OKP\jFG%WTUCN»6G[[KF+CUKD(HGPFK{XGHCV»PCDG[KVNKMDKT OGTUK[G[C\O»½V»TMKDKTMCnO»UTC»½{[NGFKT %KP[ºNFCDKTIKTGTOKGNGD{[NGDKTC\K\ +GTEjPKDKMGOCNWNNCJDWNOW¼FWK¼VKJjT +GOHC\NºJUPKUKTGVKJGOJUPKJCVVºXCT =JFUCNjJJjNKNGQNOW¼FWPjOFjT $NNCJFQUVWFGPUGUG\jXGTKFKjPC =KTC+CDKDK(MTGO Gj¼ºMKFKQ[jT 6jNKJMWNWP¹NCJKXKTDEjPUjNKMG ++FK[DEGOjNKPKnPG[NGFKI\jT Müstakimzâde, 666; Sicill-i Osmânî III, 206; Mehmed Tâhir, Osmanl› Müellifleri, II, 147- 148, 382 159 Salih Efendi (Tosyal›) Eyüplü Hattatlar 7QU[CN»&GNjN(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNWRµFG7QU[C FCFQ¹FW%CDCU»XGMCTFG½K 0WUVCHC3C½C FCPNDKTGTJCVVCVKFK$OCU[CN»¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFK FGP[C\» FGTUNGTKCNF»'CJCUQPTC¼G[JNKUNjO.GOCNRC½C\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK{ FCKTGUKPGIKTGTGMKNOKPKIGPK½NGVVKXGOFGTTKUQNFW .CPPu6WNVCP6NG[OCP »PGOTKKNGµFGUGMK\EKNVNKM)uTW\¼jJM»UUCU»P» VGTEOGGVVK%KNjJCTG0»U»T.CJKTGMCF»U»CMCDKPFG7CKHMCF»N»¹»KNGGOGMNKQNFW ¼GJ\jFG6WNVCP%j[G\KF KPKUVG¹K\GTKPG&COK NJKMj[jVCFN»OGEOWC [» )CTUnC FCP7TMnG [GVGTEOGGVVKXGOMCHCVQNCTCM([RUWNVCP0GFTGUGUK OFGTTKUNK¹KPGCVCPF»)CMCVGUMKFGPDGTKORVGNjQNFW¹WJCUVCN»MVCP MWTVWNCOC[CTCMjOjQNFW .CTFG½K0WUVCHC3C½C P»P([R1K½CPEC&COKKEKXjT»PFCDKTDCJnGVGFjTKMGVVKXG QTCFCXGHCV»PCMCFCTKDCFGVNGXCMKVIGnKTFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK .CDTKDWECOKPKPJC\KTGUKPFGQNWRVC½»OGXEWVVWT%C\»GUGTNGTK/G[NCX0GEPWP OCP\WOGUKXG½KKTNGTKXCTF»T .CDKT.KVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 'jTºFP[jOGP\KNKHjPKKOK¼ +GRIGnGT0KT9G\KT3jFK¼jJ (TUGIGTVCMFKTKNj[GOV $XPK+CMMKNGDGTjDGTGPFGTKHGTKF (VUGDKPVCJFKF+C[[KNj[GOV 6CnºNºTVQRTC¸CVCJCOOWTK\\WEjJ )C\NWKTHjPWWNOUKRCJCPC $\OKVCTCHºCJTGVMºNFºDWFGO 5CJOGVK7CCNj+CMM FCPNWVHºJjJ 5ºJNGVKUjNKPKOC NOKVOG¸G ¹UVGFK+CMM FCP1K¼jPKRTIPjJ 'KFKJjVKHDWFW jVjTKJuFKT .CDTK6jNKJEGPPGVQNC[j¹NjJ Hadîka, I, 296; Atâî, 47; Müstakimzâde, 229; Cahit Baltac›I, Osmanl› Medreseleri, 203; Muhittin Serin, fieyh Hamdullah, ‹stanbul, Kubbealt› Neflriyat›, 1992, s. 74. Salih Efendi kabir kitâbesi (Eyüp, Niflanc› Camii haziresi) 160 S Sami Bey ¼KHCJCXW\NW6jOK%G[FK[GCP»N»T%CDCU»$JOGF%G[CF»PFCDKT\jVV»T ([RUWNVCP FC¼KHCJCXW\W PFCFQ¹OW½VWT<C\»[»+CE».jOKN$MFKM VGP{¹TGPOK½VKT 7C NKM[C\»[»+WNWUK(HGPFK{FGPOG½MGVOK½VKT0GFTGUGV NJCVVCVKP G FGXCOGFGTGM FGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T([RUWNVCP FCGXXGNEGOGFHWPQNCPgn ¼GJKVNGT.CDTKUVCP» P»P.KVjDGUKQPWPFWT[»N»PFCnKnGMJCUVCN»¹»PFCPXGHCV GVVK Tilgen, 19 Seyyid Abdullah Efendi (Yedikuleli) VCTKJKPFGºUVCPDWNµWP<GFKMWNGUGOVKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK$PCXGDCDC UQ[WPFCP+\0WJCOOGFµGDC¹NCPF»¹»KnKP6G[[KFQNCTCMCP»NCP6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ (HGPFK<GFKMWNGµFGFQ¹FW¹WPFCP<GFKMWNGNKQNCTCMFCDKNKPKT 161 Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah Efendi’ye ait sülüs-nesih k›t’a Hattatlar Eyüplü Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah hatt› ile nesih Kur’an sahifeleri 162 S 163 Eyüplü Hattatlar %CDCU»<GFKMWNG0uTjJWTºOTCJQT&COKKKOCO»6G[[KF+CUCP+j½KO" Q¹NW6G[[KF$DFNJCNKO+CUKDVQTWPW6G[[KF 0GJOGF6CKFJCVVCVQNFWMNCT»PFCPCKNGF{TVPGUKNDQ[WPECDW UCPCVNCKNIKNGPOK½VKT <GFKMWNGNKDCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCJjH»\N»¹»P»VCOCONC[»R[C\»FGTUKCNO»½V»T2PUGMK\ [C½»PFCJVCTKJKPFGCMNjO»UKVVGOG½MKPGDC½NC[CTCMM»TMC[UQPTCJ VCTKJKPFGDCDCU»P»P[GTKPGºOTCJQT&COKKµPGKOCOQNFW VCTKJKPFG7QRMCR»6CTC[»µPCOG½MJQECU»QNFW3CFK½CJ,,,$JOGFµKP[CM»PCNjMC XGUC[I»U»P»I{TF +jH»\2UOCPµ»P{PFGIGNGPVCNGDGNGTKPFGPQNCP<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF $DFWNNCJ(HGPFK[KTOKF{TV.WTµCP».GTuOMCFCT(PµCOXGGXTCFKNGDKTnQM M»VµCOWTCMMCCXGJKN[G[C\F»(¹TKMCR»N»0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKKNG¼GMGT\jFG 0GJOGF(HGPFK<GFKMWNGNKµPKP{PGONKVCNGDGNGTKPFGPFKT 5GDKWNGXXGN([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGP<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ (HGPFK([RUWNVCPµFC¼CJ6WNVCP'GTIjJ»MCT½»U»PFCMKMCDTKUVCPCFGHPQNWPFW 7CNGDGUK¼G[JºDTCJKO'GFG"VCTCH»PFCP[C\»NCPMKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 164 Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah hatt› ile sülüs-nesih k›t’a S +WXG´N+C[[W´N%jMu $NNCJWUWDJjPGJWXGVGjNj 0uTjJWT&COKK¹OjOº +CVVCVGU6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ .WNWPCXGDK´NEONGO´OKPuPXG 0´OKPjVCTCJOGVG[NG[G %KJWTOGVKUTGVK´N)CVKJC 6GPGHK5GDuWNGXXGN [»N»PCMCFCT[GTKPFGFWTCPMKVjDGC[P»[»N[CR»NCP[QNnCN»½OCNCT»GUPCU»PFC QTVCFCPMCNF»T»NCTCM/CIjTu7GMMGUKJC\KTGUKPGCV»NO»½V»T Suyolcuzâde, 59; Müstakimzâde, 269-271; Habib, 118-119; Rado, 136-138; M. U¤ur Derman, “Sultan III. Ahmed’in Yazd›d›¤› Mushaf” Türkiye ‹fl Bankas› Kültür ve Sanat, Y›l.1, sy. 1 (Aral›k 1988) s. 70-74; Derman, ‹KMHS, 201; Ayd›n Ergün, Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah Efendi’nin ‹stanbul Müze ve Kütüphanelerinde Bulunan Eserleri, ‹stanbul, Marmara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, Yay›mlanmam›fl Yüksek Lisans Tezi, 1992, 91 s. ; Derman, Sabanc› Koleksiyonu, 86-87; Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi, s. 72-73;Dere, Hâf›z Osman Efendi. Yüksek Lisans Tezi. 165 Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah’›n mezartafl› kitâbesi (Bu tafl bugün Lagâri Tekkesi bahçesinde olup ortadan ikiye ayr›lm›flt›r.) Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah Efendi’nin Eyüp Lisesi karfl›s›nda bulunan kendi ad›na yaz›lm›fl ikinci bir mezartafl› kitâbesi Hattatlar Eyüplü 166 Yedikuleli Seyyid Abdullah hatt› ile nesih Fatiha suresi M 167 Yedikuleli’nin nesih hatt› ile Fatiha suresi Seyyid Abdulhalim Hasib Efendi +CVVCV<GFKMWNGNKXG0KTjJWT&COKKºOCO»6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT %CDCU»P»PXGHCV»PFCPUQPTCQPWPVCNGDGNGTKPG[C\»FGTUNGTKXGTFK%WCTCFC OFGTTKUQNCTCM6CTC[»jOKTGJK\OGVKPGVC[KPQNWPFW$MNjO»UKVVGµ[KDCDCU»PFCP OG½MGVVK$DFNJCNKO(HGPFKJGT½G[FGPDKNIKUKQNCPXGC[P»\COCPFC½KKTNG W¹TC½CPDKT\jVKFK%WJCN\GTG{OTUTGTMGPXEWFWPWP[CT»U»PCHGNnKUCDGV GVOK½XGDWFWTWOKMKUGPGFGPHC\NCUTO½VT%WCTCFCUCTC[FCMKJK\OGVKPG XGMjNGVGP0GUVEK\jFGCVCPO»½XGMGPFKFGVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT &GPC\GPCOC\».QECOWUVCHCRC½C&COKK KPFGM»N»PF»MVCPUQPTC([R VGDCDCU»PC [CM»PDKT[GTGFGHPFKNOK½VKT(¹TKMCR»N»+QEC5jUKO(HGPFKXGHCV»PC½WVCTKJK F½TO½VT ¹NOWOC jTKHFGDGPKOUVjFºOQNOW¼FWVCOjO gUVjFºUjPuK\COjPI{nFFGFKOVjTKJKVjO fiahidesi, fiah Sultan Camii karfl›s›nda iken, yolun geniflletilmesi s›ras›nda biraz ileride, Tafll›burun'da, Lagârî Tekkesi haziresine at›lm›flt›r. Burada daha pek çok tafl vard›r ki utanç duyulacak bir durumdur. Müstakimzâde, 241; Habib, 115; Rado, 157 Seyyid Ahmed Haflim Efendi 6G[[KF$NK(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNWRºUVCPDWNNW FWT.CJXGEK\jFGQNCTCMVCP»P»T 6NUXGPGUKJJCVV»P»UVjF<GFKMWNGNK(OKP(HGPFK FGPOG½MGVOK½XGKEj\GV CNO»½V»TVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FCF»T Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 74 168 Seyyid Ali Efendi (Çavuflzâde) $NK(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWQNWRDCDCU»1CMKDµN(½TjHcCXW½DC½»U»QNWRcCXW½\jFGQNCTCM VCP»PO»½V»T)CVKJcCT½CODC FC'CTµUUCjFG$¹CU»0GJOGF$¹C&COKKµPFG OG\\KPKFK6NUXGPGUKJK,'GTXK½$NK(HGPFK{µFGP{¹TGPOK½XG KEj\GVCNO»½V»T(UMKFGP[C\»NCPNCT»OMGOOGNDKTUWTGVVGVCMNKVGFGTFK0CNKM QNFW¹WM»[OGVNKGUGTNGTKUQPTCFCP.CRVCP»'GT[C.C[OCM0WUVCHC3C½C{ µ[CXGTOK½VKT VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U»F»½»PFC(OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUK S EKXCT»PFCKFK0UVCMKO\jFG6NG[OCP6CFGFFKP(HGPFKXGHCV»PC½WVCTKJK F½TO½VT &GNuNUVjFºOº\6G[[KF$NKI{nFcCXW¼\jFG Müstakimzâde, 313; Habib, 124; “Ali Yard›m Kuzaî'nin fiihabü'l-Ahbar Adl› Hadis Kitab›n›n Türk-‹slam Kültürü Üzerindeki Tesirleri”, Kubbealt› Akademi Mecmuas›, Y›l. 12, sy.1 (Ocak 1983), s. 65-76; Rado, 133; Seyyid Ali Efendi (Ruscuklu) 6G[[KF$NK(HGPFK5WUEWMNW FWT+C½KO(HGPFK PKPMCTFG½KFKT<C\»[CMCTFG½KKNG DGTCDGTDC½NCO»½XGOG½JWTJCVVCVXGºOTCJQT&COKKKOCO»<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF $DFWNNCJ(HGPFK FGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNO»½NCTF»T 'KXjP»+Oj[WP.KVjDGVKPGIKTFK7G\MKTGKGXXGNXG9GMCNGVK5K[CUGVK.GDuTIKDK XC\KHGNGTFGDWNWPFWVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK2VCME»NCTEKXCT»PFC 6CFTC\CO0WUVCHC3C½C7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCDWNWPCPOGUEKFKPOKJTCD»{PPFGKFK Müstakimzâde, 326 169 Seyyid Hasan Nuri Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWµFWT&GFFK)CVKJ6WNVCP0GJOGF7TDGUKµPFGDWNWPCPUCPEC¹»P CNGOFjT»KFK%CDCU»6G[[KF¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFKQNWR.QECOWUVCHCRC½C 7GMMGUKµPFG½G[JKMGPJCEF{P½JVCTKJKPFG0GFKPGµFGXGHCVGVVK 7GMMGPKP½G[JNK¹KFG+CUCP1WTK(HGPFKMnMQNFW¹WKnKP¼G[J0GJOGF (HGPFKµPKPM»\MCTFG½KPKPQ¹NW.GTCOGFFKP(HGPFKµ[GXGTKNFK ¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFK¼G[JµNJCTGOXGOCDGVUCJKDK<WUWH6KPCP(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NW MCF»NCTFCP$DFNMGTKO(HGPFKµFGP[C\»FGTUNGTKCNF»%KTnQM[C\»U»XCTF»T ¼G[J6G[[KF+CUCP1WTK(HGPFKJVCTKJKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK6NUXG PGUKJ[C\»[»{¹TGPFK$OEC\jFGNGTK¼G[J.GTjOGFFKP(HGPFKµFGPCJ\»VCTKMCVKNG %CNCVµVC)GTTWJ.GVJFC7GMMGUKµPG½G[JQNOW½XG0WJCTTGO.CU»O VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT.CDTK'GHVGTFCTºUMGNGUKEKXCT»PFCc»PCT.CTCMQNW CTMCU»PFC%GMVC½(HGPFK7TDGUK[CP»PFCMKUQHCFCKFK <GTKPGQ¹NW6G[[KF9CJ[K(HGPFK½G[JQNFWXG&GOC\K[GNCJKT0C[»U IPXGHCVGVVK.CDTKDCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCKFK%W\jV»PQ¹NW%CNCV¼G[JK)G[\WNNCJ (HGPFKµFGVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGFGTGMC[P»[GTGI{ONF 6G[[KF+CUCP1WTK(HGPFKµPKP²1WTK³OCJNCU»[NC[C\»NO»½½KKTNGTKXCTF»T Müstakimzâde, 161-162. Seyyid ‹brahim Efendi (Küçük Emir) Eyüplü Hattatlar .nM(OKTFGPOGMNGOG½JWTFWT%CDCU»KNGnQEWMMGP0jXGTjµPPGJTµFGP $OCU[CEKXCT»PFC<GPKEGFK[GDKNKPGPMCUCDC[CIGNOK½NGTXGDWTC[C [GTNG½OK½NGTFKT%CDCU»P»PMGTCOGVUCJKDKDKTGXNK[CQNFW¹WU{[NGPKT 6WNVCP,,%j[G\KF+CPVCTKJKPFG¼GJ\jFGQNCTCM$OCU[CµFCDWNWPFW¹WU»TCFC QPWDCDCUC[»RJGT\COCPFWCU»PFCP[CTF»OKUVGOK½VKT<CP»PFCDWNWPFW¹WU»TCFC QPCPCUKJCVGFGTXGCXFCPXC\IGnKTOG[GnCN»½»TF»%WPCUKJCVKFKPNG[GP%j[G\KFDKT FCJCCXCn»MOCO»½V»T ºDTCJKO(HGPFKQNIWPNWMnC¹»PCIKTKPEG%WTUCµ[CJKETGVGVOK½XGDWTCFCW\WP \COCPKNKOVCJUKNGVOK½VKT%WTUCµ[CIGNFK¹KU»TCFC¼CMCKMK1WµOCPK[G[C\CT»P»P CPPGUKVCTCH»PFCPFGFGUK¼G[J6KPCP(HGPFKµPKP[CP»PCXGTKNOK½XGDKTOFFGV ½G[JKP[CP»PFCMCNO»½V»T ºDTCJKO(HGPFKVCJUKNKPKVCOCONCOCMKnKP%WTUCµFCDWNWPCP6COUPu+CUCP (HGPFKµPKPXGQU»TCFCºUVCPDWNMC\CU»PFCPC[T»N»Rº\PKM0GFTGUGUKµPGOFGTTKU QNCTCMIGNGP+QEC\jFGµPKPKNOKPFGPKUVKHCFGGVVK+QEC\jFGµFGPDKNIKUKPK IGPK½NGVOGMKnKPº\PKMµGIGNGPºDTCJKO(HGPFKDWTCFC6CFTC\CO.CTCOCPK0GJOGF 3C½CµP»PGXNjF»PCUQPTC6WNVCP%j[G\KFµKP¼GJ\jFGUK6WNVCP.QTMWVµC{ JQECQNOW½VWT ºDTCJKO(HGPFKDWPFCPUQPTC0GT\KHQP0GFTGUGUKµPFG$H[QP.CTCJKUCT*GFKM $JOGF3C½CºUVCPDWNµFC.QECOWUVCHCRC½COGFTGUGNGTKPFGXG$OCU[CµFC6WNVCP ,,%j[G\KF0GFTGUGUKµPFGOFGTTKUNKM[CRV»$[P»\COCPFC$OCU[C0HVN¹FG [CRO»½V»T6QPTCDWKMKI{TGXFGPFGC[T»NF» UGPGUKPFG6WNVCP,6GNKOµKPENWUWPFC([RUWNVCPµCIGNOK½XG([RUWNVCP 7TDGUKEKXCT»PFCDKTGXUCV»PCNO»½V»T%WGXKMGPFKUKPFGPUQPTC([R0GFTGUGUK OFGTTKUNGTKPGXGTKNOGUKPK½CTVXGXCMHGVOK½VKT+VCTKJKPFGXG.CPWPu 6WNVCP6NG[OCPFGXTKPFGXGHCVGVVK Küçük Emir Efendi kabri 170 S .GPFKUKJKnGXNGPOGOK½VKT%CDCU»GXNGPOGUKKnKP»UTCTGVVK¹KDKTIGEGT[CU»PFC +C\TGVK0WJCOOGFUCXµFGP²6G[[KFºDTCJKOIKDKDKTXGNGFKGOEGFKNG MCPCCVMjTQNOC[»RCPFCPK[KDKTXGNGFFCJKOKFGFGTOKUKP³FK[GUGTVDKTU{\ K½KVOK½VKT ºDTCJKO(HGPFKGFKDXCMWTHj\»NXGMGTCOGVUCJKDKDKT\jVKFK6QP\COCPNCTFCjOj QNFW[UCFCUQPTCFCPDKTI{\Cn»NO»½V»T6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»¼G[J+COFWNNCJ (HGPFKKNGDGTCDGTVCµNKOXGVCJUKNGVOK½VKT ¼KO½KT'GFGFK[GFGDKNKPGPºDTCJKO(HGPFKµPKPCn»MVTDGUK([RUWNVCP&COKK [CP»PFC%G[DCDC6QMC¹»\GTKPFGXG3GTVGX3C½C7TDGUKµPKPMCT½»U»PFCF»T 7TDGPKPOGTOGTMGOGTNKXGU{XGNKMCR»U»\GTKPFGKMKUCV»TJCNKPFG[C\»NO»½½W MKVjDGDWNWPOCMVCF»T +j\jMCDT´NjNKOGNjOKNGNHj\ºNGNMjOKNGNJCUKD (PPCUKDGU6G[[KF¹DTCJKO´W¼¼GJT.nM(OKT(HGPFK .CPGXCNKFWJWOVCXCVVºPGPHu$OCUu[GXGMCPGOKPGXNK[CWNNCJ gNMKDjTXGUjJKD´NMGTjOGV´UUGPK[[G .nM(OKT(HGPFKMCDTKPKPDWNWPFW¹W[GTDKTC\nWMWTFCQNFW¹WPFCPKMK DCUCOCMNCKPKNKT/CJFKPKPGVTCH»PFCDKTKPUCPFQNC½CECMMCFCTDKTCn»MN»MXCTF»T <CPFWXCTNCT»MCOKNGPOGTOGTMCRN»F»T%C½½CJKFGUKVCTCH»PCFWCKnKPQVWTWNCECM DKT[GT[CR»NO»½V»T$[CMVC½»PFCMKMKVjDGUK½WFWT 171 0GTJWO.nM6G[[KF(HGPFK +C\TGVNGTK´PKPOGTMCFKGPXGTKFKT 5CJOGVWNNCJKVGjNj 6GPG %C½VC½»PCFCC[P»MKVjDG[C\»NO»½V»T7TDGDWIPM½GMNKPK½KOFKMKECOKKP[CR»O» U»TCU»PFC[CPKJVCTKJKPFGCNO»½V»T Sicill-i Osmânî, I/92; Müstakimzâde, 46-47; Mecdî Mehmed Efendi, Hadâiku’fl-flakâik, 319-323; Baltac›, 489; Haskan,183 Küçük Emir Efendi kabri girifl kitabesi Seyyid Kâs›m Gubâri Efendi Seyyid Kâs›m Gubâri hatt›, Sultanahmet Camii kap›s› üzerindeki kitabe 'K[CTDCM»TµFCPºUVCPDWNµCIGNOK½¼GTKH$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPUNUXGPGUKJ[C\»[» OG½MGVOK½VKT¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFKµPKPFCOCF»¼MTWNNCJ+CNKHGµFGP[C\» {¹TGPGPºUVCPDWNNW¼GTKH$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVOK½VKT 6G[[KF.jU»O*WDjTKF{TVj[GVXGQPDG½MGNKOGFGPQNW½CPºJNjU6TGUKPKDKT RTKPnVCPGUK\GTKPG[C\OCOCJCTGVKI{UVGTFK¹KKnKP²*WDjTK³NCMCD»P»CNO»½V»T 0GFTGUGG¹KVKOKI{TGP.jU»O(HGPFK6NG[OCPK[G0FGTTKUKKMGP&GOC\K[GNCJKT +C\KTCPµFG1CMKDNG½TCHQNOW½VWT%WI{TGXGIGVKTKNK½KFQNC[»U»[NC½jKT +j½KOK½WVCTKJKF½TO½VT Eyüplü Hattatlar ±.jUºOGHGPFK¼KOFKPCMKDQNFWK\\GVNG² 172 Seyyid Kâs›m Gubâri hatt›, Sultanahmet Camii meydan taraf›ndaki takkap› üzerindeki kelime-i tevhid S Seyyid Kâs›m Gubâri hatt›, Sultanahmet Camii flad›rvan avlusuna bakan takkap›n›n imzal› kitâbesi %WI{TGXKPFGPUQPTC0GMMGXGºUVCPDWNRj[GNGTKPKGNFGGVVK&GOj\K[GNCJKT 0CTVVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT .GPFKUKPKPjNKOXGVCVN»DKT\CVQNFW¹WPCMNGFKNOK½VKT6WNVCP,$JOGFµKP[CRV»TF»¹» 6WNVCPCJOGF&COKKµPKPEGNuUNU[C\»NCT»MGPFKUKPKPFKT 7CDKKDWECOKKPKPU»XC\GTKPFGDWNWPCP[C\»NCT»TGUVQTCU[QPWPFC [GPKNGPOK½XGDKTnQ¹W[GPKFGP[C\F»T»NO»½V»T%WUGDGRNG.jU»O*WDjTK[C\»NCT» QNCTCMUCFGEGOGTOGT\GTKPGJCMMGFKNOK½EGNuUNUJCVNCTMCNO»½V»T 173 Müstakimzâde, 285; Ayvansarâyi, 19; Sicill-i Osmâni, IV/48; Rado, 93. Seyyid Kâs›m Gubâri hatt›, Sultanahmet Camii flad›rvan avlusuna bakan takkap›n›n iç yüzeyindeki ayet Seyyid Mehmed Emin Efendi ºDTCJKO(HGPFKCFN»DKT\jV»PQ¹NWFWT<C\»[»(¹TKMCR»N»5jUKO(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½ XG.C¹»VJCPG FGVQRNCPCPJCVVCVNCTJW\WTWPFCKOVKJCPQNCTCMKEj\GVCNO»½V»T (UGTNGTKPGMGVGDGJW3uT0GJOGFKO\CU»P»CVCP(OKP(HGPFK+CNXGVK[GVCTKMKPG DC¹N»KFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKK PKP%QUVCP ºUMGNGUK PGCn»NCPCXNWMCR»U»{PPFGOG½JWT0G\\KP$DFNICPK(HGPFKMCDTKPKP MCT½»U»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 37; Tilgen, 20 Eyüplü Hattatlar Seyyid Mehmed Haflim Efendi 174 <WUWH(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWQNWR%WTUCN»µF»T.WFUK\jFG.GVJFjU»FK[GOG½JWTFWT <GMnG½O6NG[OCP(HGPFKµFGP{VCµNKMJCVV»P»{¹TGPOK½VKT+C[CV» /CµNK\jFG6G[[KF$DFNDjMK(HGPFKµPKP6KNUKNGK%C[TCOK[GTKUjNGUKPFGCPNCV»NO»½V»T %WPCI{TG/GDGPu UVn%G½KT$¹CµP»PVCTKJKPFGFQMUCP[C½»P»IGnOK½ DWNWPFW¹WDKTU»TCFC)GPGTDCJnGµFGMKHGPGTKnKPFGDQ¹WNCTCMFGPK\GCV»NOCU» \GTKPGOGNjOKNKMOCMCO»PCIGnOK½VKT +C½KO(HGPFK5COC\CP.CU»OVCTKJKPFGCPKQNCTCMXGHCVGVVK (FKTPGMCR»U»F»½»PFC(OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCOGFHWPFWTºTKTQ\GVNK NCJFKPKP.KVjDGUKDWVGMMGPKPOG½j[KJKPFGP¼G[J+CUCP)G[\K(HGPFK[C\O»½V»T ¼G[J+CUCP)G[\K(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWXGDWVGMMGPKP½G[JK0GJOGF¼G[Ju(HGPFKµFKT MK9CMj[KµNHWFCNCCFN»GUGTK[NGOG½JWTFWT +j½KO(HGPFKµPKP½KKTNGTKFGXCTF»T Müstakimzâde, 721-722; Gölp›narl›, Melamilik ve Melamiler, 161-162. Seyyid Mehmed Said Efendi %CDCU»GUMKMCF»NCTFCP3GJNKXCP\jFGFK[GDKNKPGP0WUVCHC(HGPFK FKT.GPFKUK ¼GJKF¼G[JNKUNjO)G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK PKPFCOCF»5WOGNK.C\CUMGTK6G[[KF6CKF 0GJOGF(HGPFKMKDWTCFCQVWTOCMVCKMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT M»\»P»PQ¹NWQNFW¹WKnKP'GFG\jFGQNCTCMVCP»PO»½V»T S 7C NKMJCVV»P».CVKD\jFG0GJOGF5GHK (HGPFK PKPVCNGDGNGTKPFGPºUOCKN(HGPFK FGP OG½MGVVKgnNKUCPC7TMnG$TCRnCXG)CTUnCXjM»HjTKHDKT\jVKFK &GOj\K[GNGXXGN$TCN»MVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK .CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U»F»½»PFC(OKT%WJjTK7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 718-719; Habib, 244; Rado, 164 Seyyid Mustafa fiâkir Efendi $DFWNNCJ0jJKT(HGPFKKNG.C\CUMGT8½½jMK\jFG6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµPKP M»\MCTFG½KPKPQ¹NWFWT0jJKT\jFGFK[GVCP»P»T%CDCU»0GMMG.CF»N»¹»µPFCP C[T»NF»MVCPUQPTCCTRCN»¹»QNCP$PVGRµVGXGHCVGVVK 0WUVCHC¼jMKT(HGPFKVCµNKMJCVV»P»5GUN\jFG(HGPFKµFGP[C\O»½V»T6NG[OCPK[G OFGTTKUKKMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U»0G\CTN»¹»µPFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 742-743. Seyyid Osman Efendi ([RN FT7QRJjPGNK0CJOWF(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJ6K[CJu$JOGF (HGPFK FGPVC NKMOG½MGVVKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVOK½VKT Müstakimzâde, 511-685; Tilgen, 20 S›dk› Efendi (Çelebi) $DFTTCJKO(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWFWT<C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFK{ µFGP{¹TGPFK=COCP»P»PGPK[KJCVVCVNCT»PFCPDKTKKFK<C\»NO»½MKVCRXG FuXjP»nQMVWT9GHCVVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT Suyolcuzâde, 76; Tilgen, 20 175 Sultan Bediüzzaman 7KOWTNGPIµKPPGUNKPFGPQNWR6GOGTMCPFXGGVTCH»P»PJMOFCT»+UG[KP %C[MCTCµP»PD[MQ¹NWKFK%CDCU»P»PµFGMKXGHCV»PFCMCTFG½K0W\CHHGTKNG DKTNKMVGM»UCDKTOFFGVJMOFCTN»M[CRO»½NCTF»T)CMCVf\DGM¼»DCPuVCTCH»PFCP OC¹NWDGFKNOGNGTK\GTKPG¼CJºUOCKNµGKNVKECGVOK½VKT VCTKJKPFG6WNVCP,6GNKO+CP¼CJºUOCKNKNG[CRV»¹»cCNF»TCP6CXC½»µPFCP UQPTC7GDTK\µKHGVJGVOGUK\GTKPG²'CKTGK+Oj[P³CIGNOK½VKT )CVKJ6WNVCP0GJOGFFGXTKPFGPDGTKJGTNMGFGPKNKOXGUCPCVUCJKRNGTKPK ºUVCPDWNµCIGVKTOGMCFGVCDKTCPµCPGJCNKPFGKFK<CXW\6WNVCP6GNKODW7GDTK\ =CHGTKU»TCU»PFCUWNVCP%GFK\\COCPµFCPDC½MCUGUKPKPI\GNNK¹KKNGOG½JWT ,UHCJCPN»OG\\KP+jH»\0GJOGFµKFGQ¹NW+CUCP&CPKNGDGTCDGTºUVCPDWNµC I{VTO½VT3CFK½CJ»PPGFKOKQNCP+CUCP&CPOG½JWT2UOCPN»7CTKJnKUKXG 7CEµVVGXjTKJCFN»GUGTKP[C\CT»¼G[JNKUNjO+QEC6CµFFFKP(HGPFKµPKPDCDCU»F»T 7GDTK\µFGPºUVCPDWNCIGVKTKNGPDWFG¹GTNKKNKOCFCONCT»XGUCPCVMCTNCT»PnQ¹W7TM ,TM»µPFCF»T%WPNCT¼CJºUOCKNVCTCH»PFCP+QTCUCPµFCP7GDTK\µGIGVKTKNOK½PN MK½KNGTFK 6WNVCP%GFK\\COCPVCµNKMJCVV»P»DCDCU»PFCP{¹TGPOK½DKTJCVVCVKFKcQMW\WP [C½CF»XGJFGºUVCPDWNFCXGHCVGVVK+MOFCTNCTCOCJUWUHGXMCNjFGDKT OGTjUKOKNG([RUWNVCPµCFGHPGFKNFK Müstakimzâde, 658-659; H. Beveridge, ‹A, V/1, 645-646; Daniflmend, ‹zahl› Osmanl› Tarihi Kronolojisi, II, 15,20. Eyüplü Hattatlar Suyolcuzâde Mehmed Necib Efendi 176 ([RNQNCP0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFK6W[QNEW\jFGNjMCD»KNGDKNKPOGMVGFKT 6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC([[DK(HGPFKµPKPFCOCF»fOGT(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT$¹CMCR»N» ºUOCKN(HGPFK{µFGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVOK½FCJCUQPTC .WT½WPEW\jFG$JOGF(HGPFKKNG[C\»O\CMGTGNGTKPFGDWNWPOW½VWT%KTOFFGV <GFKMWNGNK$DFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPFGFGTUI{TO½VT 0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFKµPKPJKNGJ[»NNCT»CTCU»PFC[C½CO»½ JCVVCVNCT»PM»UCDK[QITCHKNGTKPKCPNCVV»¹»²'GXJCVµNMVVjD³KUKONK{PGONKDKTGUGTK XCTF»T ¼jKTNK¹KFGQNCP1GEuD(HGPFKµPKPFKXCP»FCOGXEWVVWT+[»N»PFCXGHCV GFGP1GEuD(HGPFK([RµVGOCJMGOGUQMC¹»KNGTKUKPFGXG.»TM0GTFKXGPNGT 0G\CTN»¹»DC½»PFC6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC([[Du(HGPFKµPKP[CP»PCI{ONF Bu eser bibliyografyada da görülece¤i gibi 1942 y›l›nda Kilisli Muallim R›fat Bey taraf›ndan tertip ve tashih edilerek Güzel Sanatlar Akademisi yay›nlar› aras›nda neflredilmifltir. Müstakimzâde, 436-438; Rado, 15 S Suyolcuzâde Mustafa Eyyûbi Efendi ([RµVGVCTKJKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK([RµVGFQ¹FW¹WKnKP²([[Du³6W[QNEW fOGT$¹CµP»PQ¹NWQNFW¹WKnKPFG²6W[QNEW\jFG³NjMCD»[NCCP»NOCMVCF»T'CXJCVµN MVVjDOGNNKHK6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFKµPKPD[MDCDCU»F»T%C½NCPI»nVC 177 Suyolcuzâde’nin nesih hatt› Eyüplü Hattatlar Suyolcuzâde’nin sülüs-nesih k›t’as› 178 'GFGKUOK[NGDKNKPGPDKTJCVVCVVCPFGTUCNO»½V»T%W\jV»PXGHCV»KNG,'GTXK½ $NKµFGPCMNjO»UKVVGOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVPjOGCNO»½V»T6WNVCP,90GJOGFFGXTKPKP UGnMKPJCVVCVNCT»PFCPF»T 6W[QNEW\jFG¼G[J+COFWNNCJ0GMVGDKµPKPUQPJCNMCU»QNCTCMMCDNGFKNKT\uTC [GVK½VKTFK¹K+jH»\2UOCP[GPKDKTOGMVGDKPUCJKDKQNOW½VWT <GVK½VKT¹KGP{PGONKVCNGDGNGTK+jH»\2UOCP+QEC\jFG0GJOGF{ &jDK\jFG$DFWNNCJ{µV»T (NNKMCFCT0WUJCH[\MCFCTGPµCO[C\F»¹»TKXj[GVQNWPWTVCTKJKPFG XGHCVGFGTGM([RUWNVCPµFCVQRTC¹CXGTKNFK0G\CT»VCJTKDQNWPECOG\CTVC½» .KVjDGUKºUVCPDWN7TMXGºUNjO(UGTNGTK0\GUKµPFG OWJCHC\CCNV»PCCN»PF»0G\CTVC½»MKVjDGUKPKPKDCTGUK ½{[NGFKT +XG´N+C[[W´N%jMu $NNCJWUWDJjPGJWXGVGjNj +CVVCV6W[QNEW\jFG 0WUVCHC(HGPFKMWNWPC 9GDK´NEONGOOKPuPXGOOKPjVC 5CJOGVG[NG[GDKTJWTOGVK´N)CVKJC 6GPG Suyolcuzâde, 73; Müstakimzâde, 536-537; M. U¤ur Derman, “Hattat Suyolcuzâde Eyyûbî, Mustafa Efendi”, Yeflilay, sy. 413 (Nisan 1968) s. 18-20; Rado, 104; Alparslan, Osmanl› Hat Sanat› Tarihi, ; Dere, Hâf›z Osman Efendi, Yüksek Lisans Tezi. Suyolcuzâde’nin mezartafl› kitâbesi (T‹EM) S Suyolcuzâde hatt› ile sülüs-nesih k›t’a (Türk Petrol Vakf› Koleksiyonu) Süleyman Sâbit Bey 6NG[OCP6CDKV%G[$PMCTCXCNKUKKMGPXGHCVGFGP9G\KT0GJOGF+WT½KF3C½C{ µP»PQ¹NWFWTµFC7GMKTFC¹ FCFQ¹FW7CJUKNFGPUQPTC µFC+CTKEK[G1G\jTGVK0GMVDK.CNGOK PGIKTFKf\GNI{TGXKNGI{PFGTKNGP )WCF3C½C P»P[CP»PFCDCDCU»KNGDGTCDGT¼CO CIKVVK %CDCU»P»PIKVVK¹KDC\»OGOWTK[GVNGTFG[CP»PFCDWNWPFWµFC3CTKU UGHjTGVKKMKPEKMCVKRNK¹KPGVC[KPQNWPFWFG%MTG½6GHKTKQNFW FG.{UVGPEG FGXGHCVGVVK1j½»ºUVCPDWN CIGVKTKNGTGM([RUWNVCP FC 6CFTj\CO7WPWUNW+C[TGFFKP3C½C6QHCU»E»XCT»PCFGHPQNWPFW ºHHGVNKPCOWUNWXGNK[CMCVNKQNWRTKM C[C\»[»I\GN[C\CPNCTFCPF»*GPK½DKT MVRJCPGUKXGDC\»½KKTNGTKXCTF»MKJGRUKDKT[CPI»PFC[CPO»½V»T.»\»6CFK[G+CNKN (NFGO+CP»O F»T Sicill-i Osmâni III, 101; ‹bnülemin, 763-766; Haskan, I, 360 179 Süleyman Efendi (Damadzâde) 6NG[OCP(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNW FWT'COCF\jFGFGPOGMNGOG½JWTFWT)CVKJ&COKK KOCO»KFK6NUXGPGUKJK7Q\MQRCTCP\jFG+jH»\0GJOGF(HGPFK{µFGP {¹TGPOK½XGMGOjNFGTGEGUKPGXCTO»½V»T%KTnQM0WUJCH»¼GTKH[C\F»¼GXXCN VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPCMCR»U»OG\CTN»¹»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 218; Habib, 114 Süleyman Efendi (Berber) ºUVCPDWN FC.WOMCR»1K½CPE»&COKK[CP»PFCDGTDGTNKM[CRO»½V»T'MMCP»{PGONK MKOUGNGTKPW¹TCM[GTKKFK6NUXGPGUKJK$TCD\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK FGP{¹TGPOK½ XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T¼jKT6jOK(HGPFK PKPFuXjP»6NG[OCP(HGPFKVCTCH»PFCP VQRNCPO»½V»T .GPFKUKC[P»\COCPFC1CM½KDGPFKKFK+VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC.C½IjTK7GMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCF»T Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 220-221 Süleyman Efendi (E¤inli) 6NG[OCP(HGPFK(¹KPNK FKT%CDCU»º\OKTIOTMEU0GJOGF(HGPFK FKT.GPFKUK (PFGTPK+Oj[WP FCUQHCDGMnKUKPGHGTNGTKPFGPQNWRUQPTCDWTCFCPC[T»N»R 5GKU´NMVVjD$PDGTu0GJOGF(HGPFK PKPKOCO»QNFW0KTjJWTºOTCJQT&COKK KOCO»OG½JWTJCVVCV6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK FGPJUPKJCVOG½MGFGTGMVC NKM [C\»FCPKEj\GVCNF»¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFK [GDC¹NCPCTCMVCTKMCVGIKTOK½VKT¼GXXCN 1KUCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK Müstakimzâde, 215 180 S Süleyman Hikmetî Efendi ([RUWNVCP FC&GFKF6GOK\$NK3C½C&COKKKOCO»XG.CNGPFGTJCPG7GMMGUK [CP»PFCMK/j NK\jFG$DFNDjMK(HGPFKU»D[CPOGMVGDKPKP[C\»JQECU»KFK0WUKMu UVjF»=GMjK'GFG PKPDCDCU»F»TVCTKJNGTKPFGQ¹NWQVW\UGMK\[C½»PFC DWNWPFW¹WU»TCFCXGHCVGVVK.CDTK*O½UW[W0G\CTN»¹» PFCKFK.GPFKUK 7C½M{RTN+QECfOGT(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNFW¹WPCI{TGCKNGCUNGP.CUVCOQPW PWP 7C½M{RT.C\CU» PFCPF»T 6NG[OCP(HGPFK PKP[C\»UCPCV»PFCMKOCJNCU»P»PJKMOGVuQNFW¹WUCP»NOCMVCF»T .CTFG½KXG[CC¹CDG[K+jH»\ºDTCJKO=JFu(HGPFK FG3GRG+QECFK[GOG½JWTQNWR C[P»OGMVGDKPJQECU»KFKVCTKJKPFGFGXGHCVGVVK ‹bnûlemin, 377; Öztuna, Türk Musikisi Ansiklopedisi, II, 402. Süleyman ‹zzî Efendi º\\u(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWQNWR+CNKN(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT+CNKN(HGPFKXG[C$¹C6WNVCP ,90GJOGFµKPM»\»+CVKEG6WNVCPµ»PMGVJFj[»VGDGTFGTjP»KFK º\\u(HGPFKUNUXGPGUKJKJCVVCV+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGPOG½MGVOK½XG KEj\GVCNO»½V»T1CM½u7CTKMCVKµPGOGPUWDVW6QPTC6KRCJXG6KNCJFCT.jVKDKXG 7G½TKHjVKXGXCMCPXKUQNOW½VWT º\\u(HGPFKDKTFKXCPFCPDC½MC [»NNCT»CTCU»PFCMKQNC[NCT» CPNCVCPKMKEKNVNKM7CTKJKXGMj[KCF»[NC TGUOKDKT2UOCPN»7CTKJK[C\O»½V»T $[T»EC0GPjMKDK%CJCFFKP+QEC 1CM½KDGPFVGTEOGUKPG\GTKPFG nCN»½O»½HCMCVVCOCONC[COCFCPXGHCV GVVOK½VKT¼KKTFGMKOCJNCU»²º\\u³QNWR VCTKJF½TOGFGMKDGEGTKUK[NGPNKFK 181 1166/1753 tarihinde vefat etti. Kabri, Eyüp Niflancas›’nda, fieyh Murad Efendi Tekkesi haziresindedir. Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 467; Tezkire-i Sâlim, 474-475; Müstakimzâde, 212; Cemâleddin Mehmed, Âyine-i Zürefâ, ‹stanbul, 1314, s. 49-50; Mehmet Tâhir, Osmanl› Müellifleri, III, 76. Süleyman ‹zzî Efendi’nin kabir kitâbesi Süleyman Râci Efendi ºUVCPDWNNWQNWR<WUWH(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWTºNMVCJUKNKPKDCDCU»PFCPCNO»½XGQPWP [GTKPG0QNNC$½Mu&COKKKOCO»QNOW½VWT6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»C¹CDG[K+QEC 0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPOK½XGPKEG.WTµjP».GTuO[C\O»½V»T ¼G[J6G[[KFgUMFCTu$JOGF5CWHu(HGPFK{µ[GDC¹NCPCTCMVCTKMCVG IKTOK½VKT$¹CDG[KºDTCJKO9jU»M(HGPFKFGJCVVCVV» 8\WP\COCPJCUVC[CVV»MVCPUQPTCVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK([RµVG 2VCMn»NCTµFC.»T»OucG½OGUKMCT½»U»PFCDCDCU»P»PMCDTKPGFGHPGFKNFK Müstakimzâde, 217; Habib, 113; Rado, 154 Süleyman fievket Pafla Eyüplü Hattatlar 6NG[OCP¼GXMGV3C½CTKEjNFGP7GXMKK1K½CPE»$NK %G[µKPQ¹NWFWTºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW7CJUKNKPK VCOCONCF»MVCPUQPTC'KXjP»+Oj[WPµCIKTFKDKT VCM»OOGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFW6CFjTGV0UVG½CT» µFG0GENKUK9jNj[»$JMjO»$FNK[GC\CU»QNFW µFGXG\jTGVTVDGUK[NG7CP\KOCV0GENKUKC\CN»¹»PC VC[KPQNWPFW¼CDCP0CTVVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPµFC%QUVCPºUMGNGUK6QMC¹»\GTKPFG 0KJTK½CJ9jNKFG6WNVCP7TDGUKMCT½»U»PFCXGOG\CTN»M MCR»U»PFCPIKTKNKPEGUQNVCTCHVCMKD[MJC\KTGFGFKT 0G\CTVC½».KVjDGUK+CVVCV¼GXMGV9CJFGVu%G[µKPFKT .KVjDG½{[NGFKT 182 +XG´N+C[[ 5CJOGVWNNCJKVGCNjCNG[JKX\GTC[º³º\COº UCNVCPCVºUGPK[[G´FGPXGOGENKUKjNKK VCP\KOCVj\jUºPFCPQNWRKTVKJCNKjNGOK FjTºDGMjGFGPGU6G[[KF6NG[OCP»GXMGV 3C¼C´PºPTWJKnWPHjVKJC »CDCP/G[NGV´NEWO´C .QPC¹»ºUVCPDWNµFC0CJOWF3C½C +COCO»[CP»PFC[C\N»¹»KUG %CNVCNKOCP»CTMCU»PFCKFK 6NUPGUKJTKMµCXGFKXjPKµFG OjJKTFK 9CMµCPXKU/VHu(HGPFKGUGTKPFG Süleyman fievket Pafla mezartafl› kitâbesi fi ±»GXMGV3C¼CIC[GVJQ¼PXKUVKT5KM´CXGFKXCPuFGPDC¼MCJCVVºPGUKJ´FG FCJK[GFKVNCUºXCTFº.GPFKJCVVº[NCDKTKMK0WUJCHº»GTKH[C\Oº¼VºT +CNMINGT[\NGXKJGTMGUGCnºMIC[GVOMTKOXGOVGXj\KDKT\jVKFK² FGOGMVGFKT Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 174; ‹bnûlemin 406-408; fiekib Pafla (DG\jFG0WUVCHC%G[ KPJC\KPGFjT»1WTK$¹C P»P Q¹NWFWTºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW7CJUKNFGPUQPTC 'KXjP»+Oj[WP.CNGOK PGIKTFK6QPTCDKTVCM»O OGOWTK[GVNGTFGDWNWPFWµFC+jTKEK[G 0UVG½CTN»¹»Rj[GUK[NG/QPFTC6GHKTKQNFW µFG6CFjTGV0UVG½CT»XGQUGPGXG\KT TVDGUK[NG0GENKUK9jNj5GKUKQNFW 5GDKNCJKT$TCN»MµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC%QUVCPºUMGNGUK EKXCT»PFCXG0KJTK½CJ9CNKFG6WNVCP6GDKNK PKPUQNVCTCH»PFCXGJCEGVRGPEGTGUKPKP CTMCU»PFCF»T¼CJKFGUKPKPMKVjDGUK½{[NGFKT 183 fiekib Pafla’n›n yaz›s› +X GN*CHWT 1jOFj¼º6G[[KFjNGO»GMKD 3C¼CDWUjN 0GENKUKXjNj5GKUK [MGPKFD VGTMKEKJjP 3TMGTGOKXjNjJKOGODKT IGXJGTKKTHCPKMGP +C[HMKOIGPEKPGXG¼QNFW\GOKP KnTGPKJjP 'GJTGNKPFGPFKT\GDCPºJjNKNG JGT\GTTGKJjM %K\FGIGNFKMjNGOG[CPFºM [CMºNFºMDKT\GOjP 5GH KFDJCMMCKFFKUKVGO U{[NGFKOVjTKJKPK ([NG[GHKTFGXUKjNjFC»GMKD3C¼C OGMjP TGDuWNCJKT 1GOGMCJWJCVKDKEjOKK*N GN)CMKT0CNKM cQMFQ¹TWDKT\jVQNCP¼GMKD3C½C.KVjDGVVGXGTKM C[C\»FCOjJKTKFK'GXNGVKPG nQMK[KJK\OGVNGTKHCGVOK½VKT2¹NWUQPTCFCP6CFTC\COQNCPÃTKHK3C½C F»T ‹bnülemin, 767-770; Aç›kgözo¤lu, 85, 133. Eyüplü Hattatlar fieyh Abdürrahim Efendi 184 $OCU[CN»QNCP$DFTTCJKO(HGPFK+CE»cGNGDKFK[GOG½JWTQNOW½VWT 0G[[GF\jFG$NKcGNGDKµPKPQ¹NW.C\CUMGT0G[[GF\jFG$DFWTTCJOCP(HGPFKµPKP MCTFG½KFKT2¹NW¼G[JCDFCNMCFKT(HGPFK¼G[JNKUNjOQNOW½VWTºMKMCTFG½VCJUKNNGTK GUPCU»PFC¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFKµFGPUNUXGPGUKJOG½MGVOK½NGTFKT ¼G[JNKUNjO(DWUUWWF(HGPFKµPKPDCDCU»¼G[J0WJ[KFFKP0GJOGFºUMKNKDKµPKP FCOCF»XGOTKFKQNFW%WUC[GFGVCTKMCVGIKTFKXGUQPTCºUMKNKRNK7GMMGUKFK[G DKNKPGPVGMMG[G0WUNKJKFFKP6KTQ\uµFGPUQPTCRQUVPK½KPQNFW%WVGMMGUQPTCFCP 6KXjUK7GMMGUKCF»P»CNO»½V»T ¼G[J$DFTTCJKO(HGPFKµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPOG[FCP»PFC6CnN» CDFNMCFKT(HGPFK0GUEKFKCNV»PFCMKVTDGFGFKT%WOGUEKFXGVTDG[KQ¹NW6CnN» $DFNMjFKT(HGPFKDCDCU»P»PXGHCV»PFCPUQPTC[CRV»TO»½V»T $[XCPUCTj[K+CFuMCµFC6CnN»$DFNMCFKT0GUEKFKKNGKNIKNK½WDKNIK[KXGTOGMVGFKT fiekib Pafla’n›n flahidesi fi ²)GXMjPKFKT%jPKUK¼G[JNKUNjO$DFNMCFKT(HGPFKFKTMK¼G[Ju$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK FGPOGMNGOCTWHVWT3GFGTNGTK¼G[J$DFTTCJKO(HGPFK6KXCUK7GMMGUK¼G[JKKFK VCTKJKFGXGHCVGVVKMFGOCJFOKOMGTTGONGTK¼G[Ju(HGPFKCF»IGnGPOGUEKFKP CNV»PFCQNCPVTDG[GFGHPG[NGFKMVGPUQPTCDWOGUEKFKDKPCG[NGOK½VKT³ $DFTTCJKO(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NW$DFTTCJKO1K[C\K(HGPFKOFGTTKUKMGP5COC\CP 0C[»UVCTKPFGQVW\[C½»PFCXGHCVGVVK$DFTTCJKO(HGPFKµPKPFK¹GTQ¹NW ¼G[JNKUNjO6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFKKUG¼GXXCN7GOOW\VCTKPFGXGHCVGVVK XGDCDCU»P»P[CP»PCI{ONF $DFTTCJKO(HGPFKµPKP¼G[JQNFW¹W6KXCUK7GMMGUK)CVKJ<CXW\6GNKO&COKK EKXCT»PFC<CXW\6GNKO&CFFGUKKNG$NK1CMK6QMC¹»µP»PDKTNG½VK¹K[GTFGKFK%WIP JKnDKTK\MCNOCO»½QNWRDKTKM»UO»[QNCDKTM»UO»FC'jTW½½CHCMC/GUGUKDCJnGUKPG MCV»NO»½V»T+C\KTGPKPDKTM»UO»[QNWPQTVCU»PFCMCNO»½V»T Müstakimzâde, 256; Sicill-i Osmânî, III/256; Serin, fieyh Hamdullah, 55; Ayvansarâyi, I/269-270. fieyh Râflid Efendi .C[PCMNCTFCCF»IGnOGOGMVGFKT %CDC+C[FCTµFC¼G[JNKUNjO 0WUVCHC(HGPFK7GMMGUK¼G[JK 8½½jMK[GµFGP(NK(HGPFKµPKPD[M Q¹NWFWT%CDCU»MGPFKUKPFGPUQPTC &GOC\K[GNCJKT$TCN»M VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK¼G[J 5C½KF(HGPFKµFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTKVGMMGFGCn»M VTDGFGFKT.CDKTMKVCDGUK ½{[NGFKT »G[JNKUNjO7GMMGUK»G[JK (U6G[[KFGN+jEJjHK\W´N .WT´jP 8¼¼jMK $NK(HGPFKPKPOCJFWOºMGDuTK +CVVjVuPFGPOC¸HTGNOGTJWO &GPPGVOGMjPºJWNFKj¼K[jP KNj 5CJOGVKNNCJKVGjNCGU6G[[KF (¼»G[J5j¼KF(HGPFK´PKPTWJº »GTuHKnWPGN)CVKJC 185 fieyh Râflid Efendi’nin kabir kitâbesi fieyhülislam Abdullah Vassâf Efendi $MJKUCTµN»QNWR¼G[J0GEFFFKP(HGPFK{PGUNKPFGPFKTºUVCPDWNµCIGNOK½ $PCFQNW.C\CUMGTK.CTC+CNKN(HGPFK{FCKTGUKPGIKTOK½XGUQPTCQPWP FCOCF»QNOW½VWT<WPWU3C½C0GFTGUGUKµPFGPHG[\CNO»½XG[GVK½OK½VKT%WCTCFC 6K[CJu$JOGF(HGPFK{µFGPVCµNKM[C\OC[»{¹TGPOK½VKT VCTKJKPFGOFGTTKUQNFW6QPTCKNGTNK[GTGMµFG6GNjPKM0QNNCU» UQPTC)GVXj(OKPK5COC\CP0CTVµFG0»U»T0QNNCU»µFG0GMMG 3j[GUKXG=KNJKEEG1KUCPµFG.CTC0WUVCHC3C½CµP»PÉTCPUGHGTKPFG $PCFQNW3j[GUKCNF» µFG$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKQNWRµFGI{TGXFGPCN»PCTCM=KNJKEEG $TCN»MµFG5WOGNK3j[GUKCNF»5GEGD+C\KTCPµFG5WOGNK .C\CUMGTKXG5GDK[NGXXGN2ECMµFG¼G[JNKUNjOQNFW )CMCVDG½C[UQPTC%WTUCµ[CUTNF'{P½PFG<WUWH3C½C\jFGµPKP (OKTICPµFCMK[CN»U»PFC=KNMCFG+C\KTCPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP&COKKOKJTCD»VCTCH»PFC6K[CXW½3C½C7TDGUKEKXCT»PFC MC[»PRGFGTKPKP[CM»P»PFCF»T Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 383; Müstakimzâde, 711 Eyüplü Hattatlar fieyhülislam Mehmed Esad Efendi (Vassafzâde) 186 ¼G[JNKUNjO$DFWNNCJ9CUUCH(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWTµFGºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW 7CµNKMJCVV»5GKUµNGV»DDj.jV»R\jFG0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFKµFG OFGTTKU=KNMCFG$¹WUVQUµFG*CNCVC0QNNCU»(FKTPG0QNNCU»XG DCDCU»¼G[JNKUNjOQNFW¹WKnKPJGOGP0GMMG3j[GUKCNF»¼CDCP1KUCPµFG ºUVCPDWN3j[GUKCNF»5GDK[NGXXGN7GOOW\µFG$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKQNWR µFGC[T»NF»5COC\CP.CU»OµFG5WOGNK.C\CUMGTK¼GXXCN $TCN»MµFC¼G[JNKUNjOQNFW\&GOC\K[GNCJKT7GOOW\µFG JCUVCN»¹»UGDGDK[NGI{TGXFGPCN»PF»5GEGD7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKKM»DNGUK[{PPFG6K[CXW½3C½C7TDGUKJC\KTGUKPFG DCDCU»P»P[CP»PFCF»T Sicill-i Osmânî, I, 334; Müstakimzâde; 711; Müstakimzâde, Devhatü’l-meflâyih, 106. fi fieyhülislam Mehmed Esad Efendi ¼G[JNKUNjO+QEC6CµFFFKP (HGPFKµPKPKMKPEKQ¹NWQNWR 0WJCTTGO+C\KTCP VCTKJKPFGFP[C[CIGNFK%CDCU»P»P KJVKOCO»KNGK[KDKTG¹KVKOCNF» 6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»7jE\jFG 0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGP[C\O»½V»T (XXGNCOFGTTKUUQPTC(FKTPG 0QNNCU»QNFW=KNMCFG+C\KTCP $PCFQNW3j[GUKKNG(FKTPGµFGP C[T»NF»0WJCTTGO$¹WUVQU µFGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFW¼GXXCN 1KUCPI{TGXFGPCN»PF» 6CHGT$¹WUVQUµFG$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKQNFW%KTUGPGUQPTCC\NQNWPCTCM 5COC\CP¼WDCVµFG5WOGNK.C\CUMGTKQNFW0WJCTTGO1KUCP VCTKJKPFGI{TGXFGPCN»PF»µFGJCEECIKVVK&GOj\K[GNjJKT+C\KTCP µFGIGNKTMGP.QP[CµFCMCTFG½K0GJOGFcGNGDK(HGPFKµPKPXGHCV»KNGM»TMDG½ [C½»PFCQNFW¹WJCNFG½G[JNKUNjON»MOCMCO»PCCVCPF»¹»P»{¹TGPFK VCTKJKPFG/GJ6GHGTKµPGRCFK½CJKNGDGTCDGTIKVVK)CMCV%W¹FCPµFCJCUVCNCPCTCM ºUVCPDWNµCF{PFXGKP\KXC[CnGMKNFK=KNJKEEG([NNµFGKMKPEKFGHC ½G[JNKUNjOQNFW½CDCP»P»PQPF{TFPFG0C[»UµFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCPµFC6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK&COKK[CP»PFCMKJC\KTGFGFKT<CP»PFC DCDCU»XGFK¹GTCKNGGHTCF»OGFHWPFWT Müstakimzâde; 445; Müstakimzâde, Devhatü’l-meflâyih, 44-46; Ça¤atay Uluçay, Padiflah Kad›nlar›, Ankara, Türk Tarih Kurumu Yay›nlar›, 53-54. fieyhülislam Mehmed Sadeddin Efendi <CXW\6WNVCP6GNKO KPPNPGFuOK+CUCP&CP »PQ¹NWQNWR+QEC6CFGFFKP(HGPFK CF»[NCDKNKPKTµFCºUVCPDWN FCFQ¹FW¼G[JNKUNjO(DWUUWWF(HGPFK FGPKNKO VCJUKNGVOK½QNWRnNKUCPFC[C\»XG½KKT[C\O»½FG¹GTNKDKTMKOUGKFK$[T»ECUNU PGUKJXGVC NKMJCVNCTFCFCMGOjNFGTGEGUKPFGOjJKTFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK fieyhülislam Mehmed Es’ad Efendi’nin muhteflem lahdi 187 .CDTK([RUWNVCP FC.CNGPFGTJCPG&CFFGUK \GTKPFG[CRV»TF»¹»XGDWIP6CnN»$DFNMCFKT (HGPFK&COKKCF»KNGCP»NCPFjT NMWTTjU» JC\KTGUKPFGFKT%WFjTNMWTTj [»Q¹NW ¼G[JNKUNjO(UCF(HGPFKFGTIjJ[CRV»MK <CJ[C\jFG7GMMGUKFK[GPNFT 0G½JWT+CnQXC0G[FCP0WJCTGDGUK PKP MC\CP»NOCU»PCXGUKNGQNCP+QEC6CFGFFKP (HGPFKVCTKJKPFG½G[JNKUNjO QNOW½VWT%WPFCPGXXGN6WNVCP,,,0WTCF »P 0CPKUC FC¼GJ\jFGKMGPOWCNNKONK¹KPGVC[KP GFKNFK¹KKnKP+QEC(HGPFKFK[G½{JTGV DWNOW½VWT.GPFKUKPKPGUGTNGTKXCTF»TMKGP OG½JWTW7jE VVGXjTKJCFN»2UOCPN»VCTKJKFKT Mehmed Sadeddin Efendi mezartafl› kitâbesi Hadîka, I, 269; Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 18; Müstakimzâde, 399-400 Habib, 134-135; Tarih-i Selânikî, 823-824; fierafettin Turan, “Sadeddin Efendi”, ‹A, X, 27-32; Atâî, Zeyl-i fiakâik, ‹stanbul, 1268, s. 429; Eyüplü Hattatlar fieyhülislam Mehmed fierif Efendi 188 ¼GTKH\jFGFK[GDKNKPOGMVGFKT8NGOjFGP <GPK½GJKT)GPGTNK¼GTKH(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWXG ¼G[JNKUNjOcCVCNN»$NK(HGPFKµPKPM»\»P»P VQTWPWFWTµFGºUVCPDWNµFCFQ¹FW 0GJOGF¼GTKH(HGPFKVCTKJKPFGQP UGMK\[C½»PFCOFGTTKUQNFWµFC <GPK½GJKTµFG%WTUCXGRG½KPFGP 0GMMGOQNNCU»QNFW&GOj\K[GNCJKT0CTV µFCºUVCPDWNMCF»U»5GDKWNCJKT2ECM µFG1CMKDWNG½TCHQNFW0WJCTTGO +C\KTCPµFC$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTKQNFW 5COC\CP2ECMVCTKJPFG5WOGNK .C\CUMGTNK¹KPGCVCPF»5GDKWNCJKT 7GOOW\VCTKJKPFGKMKPEKFGHC1CMKDNG½TCH $¹WUVQUVCTKJKPFG¼G[JNKUNjOQNFW$NV» C[UQPTC¼WDCVVCTKJKPFGC\NQNWPFW =KNMCFG2ECMVCTKJKPFG6WNVCP,,, fieyhülislam Mehmed fierif Efendi’nin mezartafl› kitâbesi fi 0WUVCHCXGHCVGVVK[GTKPG,$DFNJCOKFRCFK½CJQNFW.»N»nMW½CPOCOGTCUKOKPK ¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF¼GTKH(HGPFKKFjTGGVVK)CMCVM»UCDKTOFFGVUQPTCDC\» JCNNGTKOPCUGDGVK[NGI{TGXKPFGPC\NGFKNFK¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF¼GTKH(HGPFKVCµNKM [C\»[».jVKD\jFC0GJOGF5GHKµ(HGPKFµFGPOG½MGVOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T ¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF¼GTKH(HGPFK=KNJKEEGCTCN»MVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCPµFCGUMKCF»%Q[CE»6QMC¹»QNCP½KOFK6WNVCP5G½CF&CFFGUK \GTKPFGXG%CJTK[G1C\»T»+CUCP+UP3C½C7TDGUKKNG&CPCP+CP»O7TDGUK CTCU»PFCMCNCPCKNGUQHCU»PFCF»T (Gezi notu) Sicill-i Osmânî, III, 141; fierif Efendi; Sicill-i Osmânî 4/257, Mehmed Efendi; Daniflmend Kronoloji 4/541; fiem’danizâde, (haz. Münir Aktepe), II.B, s: 24, 26, 93-114, 116, 117, 118; Müstakimzâde, Devhat’ül Meflay›h, t›pk›bas›m, 1978, s: 104; Müstakimzâde, Tuhfe, s: 705-706 /A. Alt›nsu, Osmanl› fieyhülislamlar› s: 147 fieyhülislam Seyyid Mehmed Efendi ¼GTKH\jFGQNCTCMVCP»PO»½V»T%WIP<WPCPKUVCPµFCMCNCP<GPK½GJKT)GPGTµFG µFGFP[C[CIGNFK%CDCU»+CNXGVu½G[JK0CJOWF(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NW%WTUC 0QNNCU»¼GTKH(HGPFKµFKT%W\jV¼CDCP(MKOVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCPµFCgOOu6KPCP7TDGUKEKXCT»PFCF»T %CDCU»P»PXGHCV»\GTKPGCPPGUKPK.GXCMKD\jFG.C\CUMGT9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK {KNGGXNGPFKTOK½XGMGPFKFG.GXCMKD\jFGµPKPM»\»KNGGXNGPOK½VKT 6G[[KF0GJOGF(HGPFK¼G[JNKUNjOcCVCNECN»$NK(HGPFK{µPKP VQTWPWFWTµFGOFGTTKUQNWR.GXCMKD\jFG9GNK[FFKP(HGPFKµ[GFCOCV QNFWµFC<GPK½GJKTµFG%WTUCUQPTC0GMMG0QNNCU»XG0CTV VCTKJKPFGFGºUVCPDWN.CF»U»QNFW µFG1GMKDµNG½TCHQNWRKMKUGPGUQPTCC\NGFKNFK0WJCTTGO+C\KTCP µFC$PCFQNW.C\CUMGTK5COC\CP$TCN»MµFC5WOGNK.C\CUMGTKQNFW µFG1CMKDµNG½TCHXG0WJCTTGO$¹WUVQUµFG¼G[JNKUNjO QNFW)CMCV[GPKC[»VCOCONCPOCFCPC\NGFKNFK=KNJKEEG$TCN»MµFC XGHCVGVVK([RUWNVCPµFCGUMKCF»%Q[CE»UQMCMQNCP½KOFKMK6WNVCP0GJOGF5G½CF &CFFGUK\GTKPFGMKµFGXGHCVGFGPcKXK\jFG$VCWNNCJ(HGPFKµPKPMCDTKPG FGHPGFKNFK6QMCMVCTCH»PFCMKJC\KTGFWXCT»PC½WMKVjDG[GTNG½VKTKNOK½VKT »G[J´N¹UNjOºGUDCM»GTKH\jFG 0GJOGF0QNNC(HGPFKTJKnWPGNHjVKJC Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 257-258; Müstakimzâde, 705-706; 189 Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin yaz›lar›n›n bulundu¤u Damat ‹brahim Pafla Sebili fieyhülislam Veliyyüddin Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar 2UOCPN»µP»P[GVOK½DG½KPEK½G[JNKUNjO»QNCP9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK6KNKXTKMCR»µFC <C[NCMOCJCNNGUKPFGFQ¹OW½VWT'Q¹WOVCTKJKDGNNKFG¹KNFKT%CDCU»UQNCMDC½»JCE» 0WUVCHC$¹CµF»T7CµNKM[C\»[»'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK"µFGP OG½MGVOK½VKT ºNMTGUOuI{TGXKPKDCDCU»0WUVCHC$¹CµP»P6KNKXTKMCR»$TCDCE»%j[G\KF OCJCNNGUKPFG[CRV»TF»¹»OGFTGUGFG+CTKETVDGUKKNGOFGTTKUNKM[CRCTCMCNO»½V»T 0FGTTKUNKM[»NNCT»PFCPUQPTCDKTCTC(XMjH»+CTCOG[P0HGVVK½NK¹K[CRO»½ fieyhülislam Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin Bayezid Camii yan›ndaki kütüphanesi 190 fi 191 Veliyyüddin Efendi hatt› ile talik k›t’a Eyüplü Hattatlar Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin kabrinin bulundu¤u Eyüp Niflanc› fieyh Murad Dergah› 192 [»N»PFCFC+CNGRMCF»N»¹»PCVC[KP GFKNOK½VKT0C[»UVCTKJKPFG $PCFQNW1KUCPFG5WOGNK .C\CUMGTNK¹KPGIGVKTKNFK ¼WDCVVCTKJKPFG ¼G[JNKUNjOQNCP9GNK[FFKP (HGPFKQPFQMW\C[DWI{TGXFG MCNF»MVCPUQPTC([NN VCTKJKPFGDWI{TGXKPFGP C\NGFKNOK½VKT$NV»[»NUQPTC VGMTCTKMKPEKFGHCQNCTCM1KUCP µFC¼G[JNKUNjOµN»¹CVC[KP GFKNFKXGHCV»PCMCFCTI{TGXKPK UTFTF 'GXTKPKPnKnGMOGTCMN»NCT»PFCP QNCP9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK{\GNNKMNG FG¹K½KMEKPUXGC[T»XCU»HNCTFC [GPKNjNGNGT[GVK½VKTOK½XGQPNCTC KUKONGTXGTOK½VKT%j[G\KF &COKKµPFGDKTMVRJCPGMWTCTCM DKTnQMMKVCRDC¹»½NCO»½V»T$[T»EC DWIP9GNKGHGPFKKUOKKNGCP»NCP OGUKTG[GTKPKFG9GNK[FFKP (HGPFKDC¹»½NCO»½V»T Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin kabri fi fieyhülislam Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin Zeytinburnu Veli efendi Hipodromu civar›ndaki çeflmesinin harap durumu, Temmuz 2002 $[CUQH[CµFCEGNuVCµNuMDKTNGXJCU»DWNWPCP 9GNK[FFKP(HGPFKºUVCPDWNµFC$[C\OC&COKK .KVjDGUKKNG+GMKOQ¹NW$NK3C½C6GDKNK1GX½GJKTNK 'COCVºDTCJKO3C½C6GDKNK¼GJ\jFGDC½»'jTWµN JCFKUnG½OGUKMKVjDGNGTKPKFG[C\O»½V»T.GPFK MWTFW¹W%j[G\KF&COKKµPFGMKMVRJCPGFGFGVC½C OCJMM$[CUQH[CµFCMK[C\»P»PDGP\GTKOGXEWVVWT &GOj\K[GNCJKT(MKOVCTKJKPFGXGHCV GFGP9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK([R1K½CPE»µFCMK¼G[J 0WTjF'GTIjJ»µPFCVQRTC¹CXGTKNFK.CDKTMKVjDGUK ½{[NGFKT 193 +WXG´N%jMu 6jPK[GPOGUPGFjTj[ºUCFTºHGVXjKMGP 9GFjºjNGOKHjPKGFGP»G[JWNKUNjO 0GTJWOXGOC¸HWT9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK 5WJKnWPGN)CVKJC 6GPG Suyolcuzâde, 138; Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 614; Müstakimzâde, 750-751; Habib, 247; Derman, Türk Hat Sanat›n›n fiâheserleri, 15. L.; Rado, 170-171; Recep Sadri Say›o¤ullar›, Türk Ta’lik Yaz› Ekolünün Do¤uflunda fieyhülislâm Veliyûddin Efendi. ‹stanbul, Marmara Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü, (Yay›mlanmam›fl Yüksek Lisans Tezi) 1991; Derman, ‹KMHS, 202, Haskan, 236-237 Veliyyüddin Efendi kabir kitâbesi Veliyyüddin Efendi’nin talik karalamas› fiükrü Efendi Eyüplü Hattatlar 6K[jJKNjMCD»[NCCP»N»T+QEC¼MT(HGPFK%C½OGMVGDºRNKMJCPG.CNGPFGTJjPGXG 1K½CPE»OGMVGRNGTKPFG[C\»JQECU»XGC[P»\COCPFC1K½CPE»&COKKKOCON»¹» [CRO»½V»T[»N»PFC{NO½XG([R1K½CPECµFC6KXjUKFGTIjJ»JC\KTGUKPG I{ONO½VT)CMCVVC½FKMKNOGOK½VKT 194 Tilgen, 20 Tahsin Bey +CUCP7CJUKP%G[VCTKJKPFG/GHMQ½G FGFQ¹FW6QPTCDCDCU»KNGDGTCDGT ºUVCPDWN CIGNFK7CJUKNKPGFGXCOGVVKXG/C\fOGT9CUHK(HGPFK FGPUNUXGPGUKJ OG½MGVVK %CDCU»6WTTGGOKPKQNWPECµFG+KEC\ CIKVVK+CEFCPUQPTC0GFKPG FG OG½C[KJK1CM½KDGPFK[G FGP0GJOGF&CP(HGPFK FGPCJ\»VCTKMGFGTGM.»DT»U C F{PFFCºUVCPDWN CIGNFKXGOFGTTKUQNFW µFG%C¹FCF0QNNCU»QNWRUQPTC0GMMGRj[GUKXGTKNFKºMKPEKFGHCJCEEC IKFGTGM½G[JKPFGPUNMWPWVCOCONCF»XGJKNjHGVCNF» T ºUVCPDWN CF{P½PFG µFG5WOGNKMC\CUMGT» Rj[GUKPKJCK\QNCTCMFG 1CMKDµNG½TCHQNFW 6CHGT$¹WUVQUµFG XGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC 0KJTK½CJ9CNKFG6WNVCP7TDGUK +C\KTGUKPFGFKT0GXNGXuUKMMG MCDCTVOCN»NCJFKOGXEWVVWT .GPFKUKDKNIKNKGFKDXGnQM \GPIKPKFK.KO[CIGTNK¹GJGXGUK XCTF»½KKTFG[C\CTF» .CPN»EC.{THG\K PFG[CN»U»XCTF» %W[CN»[»ICTKRDKTVGUjFH QNCTCM6WNVCP,,,6GNKO KP OCDG[KPEKUKVGMI{\M{T$JOGF 0WJVCT%G[ FGPCNO»½V»7CJUKP %G[ KPFCOCF»$JOGF%G[ KPFG DKTI{\M{TF$[XC\»P»PFCVGM I{\NQNFW¹WU{[NGPOGMVGFKT Cevdet Pafla, Tezâkir-i Cevdet, 13-20, 152153,156; Sicill-i Osmânî II/49; ‹bnülemin, 811; Haskan, I/228; Tahsin Efendi (NJCE+jH»\+CUCP7CJUKP(HGPFKFK[GDKNKPKT7QMCVµVC0G[FCP&COKKKOCO»2UOCP (HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWTµFG7QMCVµVCFQ¹FW*GPnKMGPºUVCPDWNµCIGNFKXG OGFTGUGG¹KVKOKI{TF0G½uJCV0UVG½CT».C[UGTKNK'GTXK½$NK5»\C(HGPFKµFGP %j[G\KF&COKKµPFGFGTUCNF» 5GKUµNJCVVCVKP0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ%G[{FGPUNUXGPGUKJ OG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF»+QECU»P»PJQECU».C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFK{ µFGPFGKUVKHCFGGVVK 6CFTC\COÃNK3C½CµP»P[CPO»½QNCP<CMWR$¹C&COKK[GTKPG%j[G\KFEKXCT»PFC .C\CPE»NCTµFCUGPGUKPFG[CRV»TF»¹»ECOK[GKOCOXGJCVKDVC[KPQNWPFW %WXC\KHG[GECOKKP0GTECP[CPI»P»µPCMCFCTFGXCOGVVK%j[G\KFµVGMK'GXNGV .RVJCPGUKµPKPCn»NOCU»KNGKMKPEKUQPTCDKTKPEK+jH»\».VDQNFW9GHCV»PC MCFCTDWI{TGXFGMCNF»'CJCGXXGNT½FK[GOGMVGDKPFG$TCRnCXG[C\» JQECN»¹»PFCDWNWPFW Tahsin Bey’in flahidesi 195 Eyüplü Hattatlar Tahsin Efendi’ye ait celî sülüs levha <GVK½OK½M»\»P»PXGHCV»[NC½GXMKM»T»NF»%WU»TCFC%j[G\KF0G[FCP»EKXCT»PFCMKGXK [CPF»cQMPCFKFGMKVCRNCT»XG[C\»VCM»ONCT»P»PDKTM»UO»MWTVWNCDKNFK 6WNVCPCJOGF0G[FCP»EKXCT»PFCMKDKTGXGVC½»PF»[UCFCDWTCU»FC[CPF»¹»PFCP [C\»NCT»P»PXGNGXJCNCT»P»PDKTC\»[QMQNFW9GHCV»PFCPDKTUGPGGXXGNUC¹VCTCH»PFC HGNnIGNFK+C[NK\COCP[CVV»6QPTCFCPK[KNG½VK)CMCV\PVNGTFGP\KJPKPG FWTIWPNWMIGNFK6CHGT2ECMVCTKJKPFGCPKFGPXGHCVGVVK9GHCV»PFC CNVO»½F{TV[C½»P»PKnKPFGKFK.CDTK([RUWNVCPµFCºFTKU.{½MEKXCT»PFCXGM»\»P»P [CP»PFCF»T ‹bnülemin, 428 196 Ü Ümmet H›fz› Efendi 0GJOGF(HGPFK PKPQ¹NW$DFNEGNKN(HGPFK PKPVQTWPWQNWR0QTC FCPDCDCU»KNG DGTCDGTºUVCPDWN CJKETGVGVOK½VKTºNM{PEG+CU»TE»NCTºOCO»QNCTCMDKNKPGP =NHNNGT+QECU»0WUVCHC(HGPFK FGP[C\»FGTUKCNO»½UQPTC+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO (HGPFK FGPKEj\GVCNO»½V»T 5GDKNCJKT([NNVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTKUVjF»+QEC5jUKO (HGPFK PKP[CP»PFCF»T Müstakimzâde, 86 Vesim Abbas Efendi $DFWTTCJOCP(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWVCDKD$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK PKPVQTWPWFWTºUVCPDWN FC FP[C[CIGNFK+CNXGVuXG.CFKTuVCTKMCVNGTKPGDC¹N»KFK 5GKU NGV»DDC.jV»D\jFG0GJOGF5GHK (HGPFK FGPVC NKMOG½MGVOK½XGDWCTCFCFC V»RG¹KVKOKI{TO½VT+QECNCT»%WTUCN»7CDKDK¼GJTK[jTK$NK(HGPFKXGQPWPUVjF» FC'GTXK½¼KHj[»fOGT(HGPFKKFK +CEF{P½6WNVCP6GNKOcCT½CODCU» PFCDKTFMMCPCnCTCMJCUVCNCT»PCDCMO»½V»T 7GNKHGVVK¹KGUGTNGTCTCU»PFCGPOG½JWTW'UVWTK9GUKOHu7»DDK NEGFKFXG NMCFKO CFN»MKVCD»F»TUC[HCN»MOWHCUUCNXGJCMKOCPG[C\»NO»½DKTGUGTFKT7QRNCPO»½ FKXCP»XGFK¹GTDC\»GUGTNGTKXCTF»T 2UOCPN»VCDKDNGTKPFGPºDTCJKO3C½C9GUKO$DDCU(HGPFKKnKPºMFCO*C\GVGUK PFG DKTMCnOCMCNG[C\O»½V»T2PCI{TG7CDuDK¼GJuT9GUKO$DDCU+C\TGVNGTK9GTGO JCUVCN»¹»JCMM»PFC\COCP»O»\FCMKO½CJGFGNGTGW[CPVG½JKUKXGVGFCXKWUWN QTVC[CMQ[OW½VWT ¼GXXCNKPFG0C[»UVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(FKTPGMCR»U»F»½»PFCKFK Müstakimzâde, 668; Mehmet Tâhir, Osmanl› Müellifleri, 3/237-238; Rado, 163 Yahya Fahreddin Efendi 2UOCP(HGPFK PKPQ¹NWQNWR7QRJCPG FGFQ¹FW.GVGDGUKPK<CJ[C)CJTGFFKPFK[G FGCVCTF»7QRJCPG FG.CTCDC½7GMMGUK½G[JK+UG[KP(HGPFK PKPCMTCDCU»KFK 7GMMGPKPMCR»U»[CP»PFCMKDKTJETGFGQVWTWTFW %KTIPOKJTCD»P{PVCTCH»PFCMKJCVVCV'GOKTEKMWNW<WUWH(HGPFK PKPMCDTKPK VGOK\NGTMGPVQRTCMNCTKnKPFGDKTMCO»½MCNGODWNFW%WPWMGPFKUKKnKPJC[»TN»DKT W[CT»UC[CTCMFGTJCN$NCECºOCO»$PDjTK\jFG$NK(HGPFK FGPOG½MGVOG¹G DC½NCO»½XGKNGTNGOGMVGKMGPUVjF»XGHCVGVVK¹KKnKPFCOCF»+UG[KP+CDNuµFGPIGTK 197 Eyüplü Hattatlar Yahya Fahreddin Efendi’ye ait nesih yaz› 198 VCTKJKPFG7QRnWDC½»$¹C P»PKOCO»DWNWPFW¹WKnKPC¹CP»PMQPC¹»PFC D[MDKT\K[CHGVVGTVKRGFKNGTGM.GVjPK\jFG.GDKTK0WUVCHC(HGPFKKNGDGTCDGT KEj\GVPCOGNGTKPKCNF»NCT.GVCPK\jFGDWPFCPKMKUGPGUQPTCXGHCVGVVK.CDTK ([RUWNVCP FC%G[DCDC6QMC¹»\GTKPFGXG3GTVGX3C½C7TDGUK PKPUC¹ VCTCH»PFCF»T VCTKJKPFGDKT\K[CHGVVGTVKDGFKNGTGMJCVVCV<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ (HGPFK*CNCVC+QECU»0GJOGF(HGPFK6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD(HGPFK=JFK ºUOCKN$¹CXG9GHC[K0WUVCHC(HGPFKnC¹T»NF»+CVVCV9GHj[K.»V CNCT»JQECU» [C\O»½V»TFK[GQTVC[CDKTNCHCVV»%WPWP\GTKPG<CJ[C(HGPFKUVjFNCT»P{PPFG DKTGTMGTGFCJC[C\OC[CDC½NC[»PEC<GFKMWNGNK9GHju [G%GJG[cGNGDKUVjFKNG n»TCM[C\»U»P»C[»TCOC\O»U»PFGOK½CNC[N»IN½OGNGTQNOW½VWT VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP FC1K½CPEC FC¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK VGMMGUKMCT½»U»PFCMKOG\CTN»MVCKFK%WVGMMGPKP¼G[JK$NK6jPu FGPPKUDGVCNCTCM VCTKMCVGIKTOK½VKT¼CJKFGUK[QMVWT Müstakimzâde, 580-581; M. U¤ur Derman, “Kalem”, ‹slâm Düflüncesi, Y›l. 1, sy. IV(Aral›k 1967), s. 259; a. mlf. , “Türk Yaz› Sanat›nda ‹cazetnameler ve Taklid Yaz›lar”, VII. Türk Tarih Kongresi Tebli¤leri, Ankara, TTK, 1970, s. 721-742; Rado, 156. Yahya Efendi’nin defnedildi¤i mezarl›k üzerinde bugün malesef gecekondular bulunmaktad›r. (S. Berk) Y Galata’da Yahya Pafla Çeflmesi, A¤al›¤› zaman›nda 1145 (1732) tarihinde yapt›rm›flt›r. Yahya Pafla %CDCU»([RUWNVCP&COKKJCVKDKQNFW¹WKnKP+CVKD\jFGFK[GVCP»P»T%CDCU»0WUVCHC (HGPFKVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK([RUWNVCP&COKKJC\KTGUKPFGFKT <CJ[C3C½CUNUXGPGUKJKUKMMGTGUUCO»fOGT(HGPFK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFKµFGP {¹TGPOK½XGKEj\GVCNO»½V»T5GKUµNGVKDDj1WJ(HGPFK\jFG$NK3C½CµP»PFCOCF»XG QPWPDKTKPEKUCFCTGVKPFGMGVJFCU»FCJKQNOW½VWT6QPTC0KTjJWT»GXXGNQNCP <CJ[C3C½Cº\\GV$NK3C½C P»PXGHCV»\GTKPGXG\KTQNFWf\K.CNGU»OWJjH»\»KMGP 199 GGalata’da Yahya Pafla Çeflmesi (kitabesini kendisi yazm›flt›r) VCTKJKPFGOWJKOOCVU»\N»MXG[CTF»OU»\N»M[\PFGPMCNG[K5WUNCT C VGUNKOGVOK½XGMGPFKUKFGGUKTQNOW½VWT.»UCDKTOFFGVUQPTCGUCTGVVGPMWTVWNCP 3C½CºUVCPDWN CIGNOK½XGGXXGNC1K½CPE»UQPTCFC7»TJCNC9CNKUKQNOW½VWT%WTCFC KMGPVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK <CJ[C3C½C P»P*CNCVC FC.TMEKNGT.CR»U»F»½»PFCDKTnG½OGUKXCTF»T.nM MCTFG½KºDTCJKO%G[6jNKJC6WNVCP »PM»\»)CVOC+CP»O6WNVCPKNGGXNGPFKTKNOK½VKT Suyolcuzâde, 146; Sicill-i Osmânî, IV, 640-641; Müstakimzâde, 583; Tilgen, 21. Yusuf Efendi (‹mam) <WUWH(HGPFKºUVCPDWNNWQNWR0QNNC$½Mu&COKKKOCO»KFK%VP{OTPQMWOCMNC IGnKTOK½MCPCCVMjTXGW[WONWDKT\jVKFK6NUXGPGUKJ[C\»[»6W[QNEW\jFG 0WUVCHC(HGPFKKNGDC½NCF»2PWPXGHCV»\GTKPG.CTCM»\NjMCD»[NC½{JTGVNK +QEC\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK FGPOG½MGFGTGMKEj\GVCNF» VCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK.CDTK(¹TKMCR»F»½»PFC.nM7QMOCM7GRGFGPKNGP [GTFGXG.»T»OK(HGPFKcG½OGUKMCT½»U»PFCKFK%WIPOGXEWVFG¹KNFKT 2¹WNNCT»ºDTCJKO9jU»M6NG[OCP5CEKXGOG½JWTJCVVCV+QEC0GJOGF5CUKJ (HGPFKNGT FKTºDTCJKO9jU»M(HGPFKVCTKJKPFGJCEF{P½$PVCM[C EKXCT»PFCXGHCVGVVK Eyüplü Hattatlar Müstakimzâde, 595, 638-639; Habib, 161 200 Yusuf Efendi (Yusufzâde) <WUWH(HGPFKµPKPQ¹NWFWT<WUWH\jFGQNCTCMDKNKPKT7CµNuM[C\»[»MjVKD\jFG0GJOGF 5GHuµ(HGPFKµFGP{¹TGPFKº\OKT%WTUCXGºUVCPDWNMCF»N»MNCT»PFCDWNWPFW 0GJOGF(OKP7QMCFuJC\TGVNGTKPGKPVKUCRN»KFK[C½»PFC5COC\CP ¼WDCVVCTKJKPFGXGHCVGVVK 6KEKNNK2UOjPu,90UVCMKO\jFG0UVCMKO\jFG<WUWH(HGPFKµPKP MCDTKPKP(FKTPGMCR»0G\CTN»¹»µPFC6KEKNNK2UOjPuOGNNKHKKUG(FKTPGMCR» 0G\CTN»¹»µPCFGHPGFKNFK¹KPKDGNKTVOK½NGTFKTMKKMKOG\CTN»MVCFCMKVjDGUK½WCP OGXEWVFG¹KNFKT E y ü p lü H a t t a t la r Lugatçe ve D eyim ler 202 ÂJCT *GPGNNKMNGPK½CUVC[WOWTVCCM»XGRKTKPnVGP[CR»NCPXGJCOMC¹»VNCT»P VGTDK[GUKPFGMWNNCP»NCPU»X» ÂJGPM +CTHNGTKP[CR»NCT»P»PGUVGVKM{NnNGTKPKPJGOOPHGTKFJGOFGFK¹GT JCTHNGTNGW[WOKnGTKUKPFGQNOCU»F»T%WPNCTFCVGPjURXGVGTMKRNGKHCFG QNWPOW½NCTF»T $MNjOº6KVVG 7TMnGUKCNV»MCNGO)CTUnCU»½G½MCNGOFKT6NUPGUKJ OWJCMMCMTG[JjPuVGXMuXGT»MCC [C\»NCT»PCXGTKNGPVQRNWKUKO $TK\C .nMVGPD[MOCMCOCVCMFKOQNWPCPFKNGMnGDKTK½KCT\GVOGMKnKP [C\»NCP [C\»XG[COGMVWR %CDUUCjFG$T\MCR»U»VCJVMCR»U»7QRMCR»6CTC[» P»PnPEMCR»U»QNWR (PFGTWPXG%uTWP WDKTDKTKPFGPC[»T»TF» %jDº+Oj[P7QRMCR»6CTC[» P»P$[CUQH[C [CDCMCPDKTKPEKMCR»U»PCXGTKNGP CF %jDº6GNjO7QRMCR»6CTC[» P»P%CD»+Oj[PFCPUQPTCIGNGPKMKPEKMCR»U» QNWRFCJC\K[CFG2TVCMCR»FK[GCP»N»T %CTQM;9,[\[»NQTVCU»PFCP;9,,,[\[»NQTVCU»PCMCFCT$XTWRC FC[C[I»PQNCP DKTUCPCVUNDW%CTQMUNDW,,,$JOGFFGXTKPFG7TMOKOCTKUKPFGFG I{TNOG[GDC½NCT;,;[\[»NDC½NCT»PCMCFCTGVMKUKPKUTFTT %G[\G7W¹TC P»PM»U»ONCT»PFCPQNWRUC¹FCPUQNCXG[WMCT»FQ¹TWnGMKNGPnKHV ½GMKN %G[\u<WOWTVCDKnKOKPFGQNCPQXCN &GNu6NU6NU[C\»P»P[CMNC½»MFQMW\OO FGPMCN»P[C\»NCP»PCXGTKNGPCFF»T 6NU [C\»[CI{TGDW[C\»FCJCVNCTFCJCDGNKTIKPDKTJjNCN»T &GNKN&GNu[C\»P»P$DDCUKNGTF{PGOKPFGMKCF» &KJCT[jTºI\uP+\(DW%GMKT+\fOGT+\2UOCPXG+\$NKKnKP{\GNNKMNG UPPuOUNOCPNCTVCTCH»PFCPMWNNCP»NCPDKTVCDKT 'ºXCN.CFKHG\GTKPGU»TOC[CFCIKNCRFCPNCMCDCTVOCQNCTCM[CR»NCPK¹PGK½K º½NGPGEGMFGUGPNGTOWMCXXCXG[CFGTK\GTKPGnK\KNKT%WPNCTMGUKNGTGMIGTIGHXG[C MCUPC¹CIGTKNGPMCFKHG\GTKPG[GTNG½VKTKNKT*GTIGHXG[CIKNCRVCPDWMCN»RNCT» {TVGEGM½GMKNFGK½NGPKT%KPFCNN»MCF»PGNDKUGNGTKKNGDKTNKMVGDQJnCNCTMGUGNGT {TVNGTFKXCNK½KQNCTCMDWVGMPKMNGUUNGPKT7TMGNK½NGTKCTCU»PFCFKXCNKP[GTK D[MVT (DT6W[\G[KPGUGTRKNGPVQ\DQ[CNCTCMC¹»VVCVDKMQNWPCTCM[CR»NCPDQ[COC (PXCPVGT'{MONKUVG (UNjH%KTOGOWTNWMXG[CJK\OGVVGDKTKPFGP{PEGDWNWPOW½QNCPNCT[GTNGTKPG IGnKNGP MKOUGNGTIGnOK½NGT (UOCK+UPj$NNCJ »PGPI\GNXG½GTGHNKFQMUCPFQMW\KUOKPGXGTKNGPCFF»T (UVCORCL7C½COCJMWMQNCP[C\»NCT»P\GTKPGMC¹»VMQPOCMUWTGVK[NGMCN»D»P»P CN»POCU» (UVGVKM'W[IWKNOKOCPCU»P»KHCFGGFGTUGFGDWIPUCPCVVCMKI\GNNK¹KP OCJK[GVKPFGPDCJUGFGPKNKOI\GNNKMFW[IWUWW[CPF»TCPI\GNQNCP (XjJKT6QPF{PGOWUVCN»MF{PGOK (XjKNºNMF{PGOn»TCMN»MF{PGOK (XjUºV2TVCF{PGOMCNHCN»MF{PGOK )GTUFG<»RTCPO»½GUMKOK½C½»PO»½GUMK[»TV»M +jHº\.WT jP».GTuOKVCOCOGPG\DGTNK[GPXGG\DGTKPFGVWVCPMKOUG +CPnGT7W¹TC FCDG[\GNGTKPFGXCO»QNCTCMUC¹CW\CPCPnKHMQNCXGTKNGPCF +CUCPG[P+\3G[ICODGTKPVQTWPNCT»+\+CUCPXG+\+UG[KPKnKPMWNNCP»NCP VCDKTFKT +C\KTG(VTCH»PFCFWXCTXG[CnKVDWNWPCPC¹»NOG\CTN»MXGUCKTG +GPFGUGcK\IK½GMKNXGJCE»ONCT»KPEGNG[GP{NnXGPKUDGVNGTKPKMQPWGFKPGP TK[C\K[GOCVGOCVKMMQNW +WTHWOJOGNG$TCRGNKHDCU»PFCMKPQMVCU»\JCTHNGT ¹DFC %KTUCPCVGUGTKOG[FCPCIGVKTOGMºDFC QNWPOW½DKTGUGTFGOGMJKnDKT OQFGNK QNOC[CPXGMKOUG[KVCMNKVGVOG[GTGMXWEWFCIGVKTKNGPCUNuGUGTFGOGMVKT ¹Ej\GV+CVUCPµCV»PFCOHTGFCVXGOTGMMGDCVOG½MNGTKPKDKVKTGPNGTGJQECNCT» VCTCH»PFCP[C\»NCT»P»PCNV»PCMGVGDGMQ[OCK\PKPKXGTGPFKRNQOC ¹RVKFCu%CUKVIGNK½OGOK½K½NGPOGOK½ ¹UVKH%KT½G[KDKTDKTK\GTKPGXGU»TCKNGFK\KR[»¹OCMFGOGMQNCPDWMGNKOGºUNjO [C\»U»PFCMGNKOGNGTKUCV»TPK\CO»F»½»PFCDKTDKTKPKP\GTKPGn»MCTOCM[GTKPFG MWNNCP»N»TDKTVCDKTFKT ¹OCTGV0GFTGUGVCNGDGUK[NGHCMKTNGTG[GOGMRK½KTKNKR[GFKTKNGP[GTNGTGXGTKNGPCF .CFGOK¼GTuH+\3G[ICODGTKPC[CMK\NGTK .GVGDG%KTJCVVCV»P[C\F»¹»[C\»[CKUOKPKMQ[OCU»[GTKPFGMWNNCP»N»TºO\C FGOGMVKT .KVCDG&COKKOGUEKVOGFTGUGMCNGVTDGMGTXCPUCTC[JCPJCOCOIKDKDKT OKOCTuGUGTKPMCR»U»\GTKPGXG[CW[IWPDKT[GTKPG[GTNG½VKTKNGP\GTKMCDCTVOC [C\»N»VC½NGXJC .W¼CM%KTCDKFGPKPnGXTGUKPKVCOCOGP[CJWVM»UOGPMW½CVCPXGW\CMVCP QMWPCDKNOGUKKnKPEGNu½GMNK[NG[C\»NO»½QNCP[C\»NCT .NNK[G2UOCPN»\COCP»PFC$TCRNCTFCMKDC\»OGFTGUGNGTGPKXGTUKVGMGNKOGUKPKP MCT½»N»¹»XGTKNGPDKTCF /CJKV+CTnKNG[CR»NCPOG\CT{NNGTKMQ[OC[COCJUWUUCPFWMC[GTKPFGMWNNCP»N»T DKTVCDKTFKT 0CJMM0CFGPVC½VCJVCXGUCKTG\GTKPGFGOKTMCNGONGnWMWTXG[CMCDCTVOC QNCTCM [C\»P»PQ[WNOCU» 0C MºNu+KnDKTRCTnCU»PFC[WXCTNCMN»MDWNWPOC[CPF\FKMXGM{½GNK[C\» DKnKOKFKT 0CJNCU$U»NCFFCPDC½MCMWNNCP»NCPKMKPEKCFCXGTKNGPKUKOFKT¼CKTNGT½KKTG DC½NCF»MNCT»XCMKVD{[NGKMKPEKDKTCFCN»TNCTQPW½KKTNGTKPFGMWNNCP»TNCTF»'GXNGV OGOWTK[GVKPGIKTGPNGTKPDC\»NCT»PCFCjOKTNGTKVCTCH»PFCPOCJNCUXGTKNKTFK 203 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 204 0CNCMjTu7CXCPXGFWXCTNCTCCNn»KNGC\MCDCTVOCQNCTCM[CR»NCPVG\[KPCV .CDCTVOCNCTIC[GVC\MCN»PN»MVCF»TXGGMUGTK[CDKTUCPVKOKIGnOG\%WVCT\K½G OCNCMjTuFGPKNOGUKOCNCIKDKMnMDKTCNGVNG[CR»NF»¹»KnKPFKT 0GMVGR(MQN6CPµCVVCC[P»GUCUNCTCVjDKQNCPC[P»UCPµCVRTGPUKRNGTKPKOFCHCC GFGPXGQVCT\FCnCN»½CPUCPµCVMjTNCTIWTWDWPCFGPKT 0GXjNu9KNj[GVMCF»NCT»PCXGTKNGPKUKOFKT 0GXNGXK[GVºNOK[GVCTKMCV»PFCDKT»UV»NCJQNCP²OGXNGXK[GV³MCF»N»MFGOGMVKT 0GXNGXK[GVMKDjT»OFGTTKUuPKP[QNWKFK%KTG[CNGVKPDVPJWMWMuXGMC\jK K½NGTKPGDKNHKKNDCMCPMCF» 0WJCMMCM6NU[C\»[CI{TGJCTHNGTKFCJCF\OUnCPCMNCT»IGPK½nGXGFGTKP QNOC[CP[C\»F»T.W[TW¹WQNCPJCTHNGTKPMW[TWMNCT»FCJCW\WPECF»T 0WJCTTKT7CJTKTGFGP[C\»[C\CPMjVKR[C\CTDKTOGX\W[W[C\»KNGCPNCVCP 0WTCMMC +CVVCVNCT»PC[T»C[T»MC¹»VNCTC[C\CTCMM{TMIKDKDKTEKNVVGVQRNCF»MNCT» [C\»CNDO0WTCMMC CNDONGTKnG½KVNK[C\»VTNGTKPKKnKPGCN»T 0WXCMMKVJCPG9CMKVVC[KPKPG[CT»[CPUCCVIKDKCNGVNGTKPDWNWPFW¹W[GTNGT JCMM»PFCMWNNCP»N»TDKTVCDKTFKT 0EGNNKF.KVCREKNVNG[GPEKNVEK 0FGTTKU0GFTGUGXG&COKKFGVCNGDG[GFGTUQMWVCPJQEC[GTKPFGMWNNCP»NCPDKT VCDKTFKT 0UGPPC<C\º$[P»KDCTGPKPJCTHNGTKPKPMCT½»N»MN»QNCTCM[C\»NOCU»F»T%W[C\»[C C[PCN»[C\»FCFGPOGMVGFKT 0UVGPUKJºUVKPUCJGFGPDKT[C\»P»PMQR[CU»P»UWTGVKPKn»MCTCP 0VGXGNNK9CM»HK½NGTKPKXCMHK[[G½CTVNCT»XG¼GT uJMONGTFCKTGUKPFGKFCTGKnKP VC[KPQNWPCPNCTJCMM»PFCMWNNCP»N»TDKTVCDKTFKT 1GUKJ6NU GVCDKQNWRQPWPnVGDKTKMCFCTF»T%W[C\»VGMPKMDCM»O»PFCP UNUPnVGKMKUKPKPGUJGVOK½XGnVGDKTK[NGFGQPCVCDKQNOW½VWT'CJCnQMMKVCR KUVKPUCJ»PFCMWNNCP»NO»½V»T 3j[G5VDGMCT½»N»¹»MWNNCP»N»TDKTVCDKTFKT%WVCDKT{\GNNKMNGUQP\COCPNCTFC KNOK[GTVDGNGTKJCMM»PFCMWNNCP»NO»½V»TºNOK[GRC[GNGTKPKPGPMn¹OFGTTKUNKM GPD[¹FG5WOGNKMC\CUMGTNK¹KKFK+GTJCPIKDKTOGOWTK[GVKPHKKNGPKHCGFKNOGM \GTGFG¹KNFGCF»P»PDKTTVDGQNCTCMXGTKNOGUK 3QTVCN$DKFGXuIKTK½MCR»U»D[MMCR» 3W¼KFG7TDGNGTFGOG\CTUCPFWMCNCT»\GTKPGUGTKNGPK½NGOGNKXG[C\»N»{TV 5GKU´N.VVjD.jVKRNGTKPTGKUKOCPCU»PCIGNGPTGKUµNMVVjD,,6WNVCP 0CJOWFµWPUCNVCPCV»P»PUQPNCT»PCMCFCT'uXjP»+Oj[WP MCVKRNGTKPKPjOKTKQNWR'»½K½NGTK%CMCPN» ¹»[GTKPFGMWNNCP»NO»½DKTVCDKTFKT 5G[JCPK0WJCMMCM CVCDKQNWRQPWPKPEGMCNGONG[C\»NCP»PCXGTKNGPCF 5ºMCC 7GXMK [C\»[CVCDKQNWRQPWPKPEGMCNGOK[NG[C\»NCP[C\»F»T 5QMQMQ5QMQMQUNDW;9,,,[\[»N»PQTVCNCT»PCFQ¹TW%CTQMUNDWPFCPUQPTC )TCPU»\UCTC[NCT»PFCPFQ¹CPDKTKnOKOCTN»MXGOQDKN[CUVKNKFKT;,;[\[»N DC½NCT»PFC5QMQMQUNDW$XTWRC FC[CXC½[CXC½GVMKPNK¹KPK[KVKTKTMGP 7TMK[G FGI{TNOG[GDC½NCO»½CPECM7TM5QMQMQUWCF»[NC7TM\GXMKPG W[IWP DKnKOFGFG¹K½OGNGTNGUUNGOGNGTFGW[IWNCPO»½V»T 6CFjTGVºNOK[GVCTuMKPFG¼G[JWµNKUNjOµN»MOCMCO»PFCP{PXGGNFGGFKNGP$PCFQNW XG5WOGNK.C\CUMGTNK¹KRC[GNGTKPG²6CFjTGV³FGPKTMKVCTKMOGPUWRNCT»P»PGP UQPWPEWUWQNOCMKVKDCTK[NGFKT 6CPFWMC7TDGNGTFGOG\CTNCT»P\GTKPGVCJVCFCPUCPF»M½GMNKPFG[CR»NCPXG UVPG [G½KNnWJC{TVNGP[GTKPCF»F»T 6NU+GTJCTHKPKPCNV»FCF{TVRCTnCU»F\CNV»FCKMKUKFG[WXCTNCMQNCP[C\»F»T ºUNjO[C\»NCT»KnGTKUKPFGOO NJWVVQNCTCMKUKONGPFKTKNOK½VKT8OWOK[GVNGC¹\» OOIGPK½NK¹KPFGMCNGONG[C\»N»T 6KMMGK+Oj[P5GUUCONº¸º.»[OGVKFGXNGVKPTGUOuFCOICU»[NCVGOKPCVCNV»PC CN»PCPOCFGPuRCTCNCT»PXGOCFCN[CNCT»P[C\»XGTGUKONGTKPKnK\OGTGUUCON»¹»PC XGTKNGTKUKOFKT 7CMXuOKXGMj[K7TMK[G FGKNMIC\GVGPKPCF»,,0CJOF WPGOTK[NGMWTWNOW½XG MCU»OVCTKJKPFG[C[»PCDC½NCO»½V»T 7CUJKJ+CVUCPµCV»PFCJCTHKPHC\NCXG[CRT\NM»U»ONCT»P»P[CNCOC[CJWV VTC½NCOCUWTGVK[NGIKFGTKNOGUKGMUKMM»U»ONCT»P»PKUGVCUJKJOTGMMGDKKNG FQNFWTWNOCU»UWTGVK[NG[CR»NCPK½NGO 7GTMKRºUVKHCPNCO»PFCJCVUCPCV»PFCJCTHXGMGNKOGNGTKPjJGPMNKDKTUWTGVVG VGTVKRGFKNOGUK 7G¼TKHCV<C\»FCJCTHNGTKP[GTNK[GTKPFGVCMFKOXGVGJKT[CR»NOCMU»\»P MWNNCP»NOCU» 7GXMKu6NU GVCDKQNWRQPWPKJOCNGFKNOK½½GMNKFKT$[T»ECDKVK½OG[GPJCTHNGTFG DKTDKTNGTKPGDKVK½VKTKNGTGM[C\»N»T 7G\JKD<C\OCMKVCRNCTNCOWTCMMC NCTFCDQ[CXGCNV»PVQ\WKNG[CR»NCPJGTVTN UUNGOGK½KPGXGTKNGPCF 7G\[KP6UNGOGDG\GOG 7W¸7W¹TC P»PM»U»ONCT»PFCPQNWRUGTG[GFKMKPGQNCTCM[WMCT»FQ¹TWnGMKNGPn G½KVJCVVCFGPKT%WPWP[GTKPGGNKHFGFGPKT 7W¸Tju%GTCVHGTOCPXGUCKTVW¹TCnGMKNGPMC¹»VNCTCVW¹TCnGMGP[GTKPFGMWNNCP»N»T DKTVCDKTFKT%WXC\KHG[KI{TGPOGOWTC²7W¹Tju³²1K½CPE»³²7GXMKu³FGFGPKNKTFK 7W¸TCcGMOGM%GTCVHGTOCPXGUCKTXGUKMCNCTCVW¹TCFGPKNGPCNjOGVKP[C\»NOCU» [GTKPFGMWNNCP»N»TDKTVCDKTFKT gUNR7CT\[QNDKnKOWUN gUNRNC¼VºTOC6VKNK\GGVOGDGNNKDKTDKnKOGUQMOC 9CM CPXKU7CTKJuJCFKUGNGTKPMC[FXG\CDV»KnKPVC[KPQNWPCPTGUOuOGOWTWP WPXCP»F»T 9CTCM$NVºP.C¹»VJCNKPFGIC[GVKPEGJCNGIGVKTKNOK½CNV»P 9C\\CJ1GUKJ[C\»P»PEGNuQNCTCM[C\»NO»½½GMNKPGXGTKNGPCFF»T <C\º6KNMGNGOGM+CTHMGPCTNCT»K¹PGNGPGPDKT[C\»P»P\GOKPTGPIKPGI{TGM{OT [CJWVVGDG½KTVQ\WKNG[C\»\GTKPFGPIKFKNGTGM[C\»P»PGUCU[C\»NCEC¹»\GOKPG VGURKVGFKNOGUK =GTGPFF.C¹»F»P\GTKPGU»XCOCCNV»PUTNOGUKCPNCO»PCMWNNCP»NCPDKTVCDKTFKT 205 E y ü p lü H a t t a t la r Bibliyografya 206 $c,.*f=2¸/8$JOGF6CEKV([RUWNVCP&KXCTºPFC¹O\CNº0G\CT7C¼º.KVjDGNGTK ºUVCPDWN0CTOCTCgPKXGTUKVGUK6QU[CN%KNKONGT(PUVKVU<C[»PNCPOCO»½<MUGM/KUCPU 7G\KUTGH $c,.*f=2¸/8$JOGF6CEKV±([R6WNVCP.CDTKUVCPNCTºPFC+CV6CPCVº²6CPCVUCN 0Q\CKMU[(MKOU $.$.8¼5GEGR([[D6WNVCPXG0WMCFFGU(OCPGVNGTºUVCPDWNU ¼WNG$.62<²+G\CTHGPDKT+CVVCV1GEOGFFKP2M[C[+C[CV»XG7TMXGºUNjO(UGTNGTK 0\GUKPFG%WNWPCP.KVCRNCT»³08¹WT'GTOCP<C¼$TOC¸CPººUVCPDWN6CDCPE» gPKXGTUKVGUK<C[»P»U ÃNu*GNKDQNWNW0WUVCHC0GPjMºDº+PGTXGTjPP½TºDPNGOKP0CJOWF.GOCNºUVCPDWN 7TM7CTKJ(PEOGPK.NNK[CV»U $/3$56/$1$NK2UOCPNº+CV6CPCVº7CTKJKºUVCPDWN<CR».TGFK<C[»PNCT»U $<$1+UG[KP&GXTu(T\WTWO$VCVTMgPKXGTUKVGUK<C[»PNCT»U $<$12¸/8ºUOCKN)C\»N2M0G[FCPºXG2MnWNWM7CTKJK9CM»HNCT*GPGN0FTN¹VU U $[XCPUCTj[u+jH»\+UG[KPDºUOjKNGN$[XCPUCTC[u+CFuMCV´N&GXjOKN,,,0CVDCCK ÃOKTG $[XCPUCTj[u+jH»\+UG[KPDºUOjKNGN$[XCPUCTC[u9GHG[jVº6GNjVuPXG0G¼jJKTK 5KEjNºUVCPDWNºUVCPDWNgPKXGTUKVGUK(FGDK[CV)CMNVGUK<C[»PNCT»U $[XCPUCTj[u+jH»\+UG[KPDºUOjKNGN$[XCPUCTC[u 0GEOWj,7GXjTKJP½T)CJTKc'(5º19jJKFc$%8.ºUVCPDWNºUVCPDWNgPKXGTUKVGUK (FGDK[CV)CMNVGUK<C[»PNCT»U $<9(5'º(MTGO+CMM»)CVKJ'GXTK+CVVCVNCTºXG+CV6CPCVººUVCPDWNºUVCPDWN)GVJK 'GTPG¹KU %$/7$&,2¸/8ºUOC[»N+CMM»7TMNGTFG<C\º6CPCVº0GTUKP.NVT%CMCPN»¹»U %(9(5º'*(+²+UG[KP0KT\C³¹UNjO$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹$ºUVCPDWN0KNNK(¹KVKO%CMCPN»¹» E9U ¹ONj.NCXW\W$PMCTC7TM'KN.WTWOWU %$<5$.02TJCP¹UVCPDWN´FC*{ON0G¼JWT$FCONCTºUVCPDWN7TMK[G $P»VNCT'GTPG¹KºUVCPDWN¼WDGUK<C[»P»U %$<6810&CXKF²(¹TKMCR»N»5jUKO(HGPFK³¹UVCPDWNgPKXGTUKVGUK(FGDK[CV)CMNVGUK 7CTKJ'GTIKUKE9,,U[([NNU %(5.6NG[OCP+CVVCV0WUVCHC5jMºO(HGPFKºUVCPDWN.C[PCM<C[»PNCT»U %(5.6NG[OCP²([RUWNVCP6»P»TNCT»ºnGTKUKPFG+CVVCV0WUVCHC5jM»OµC$KV0G\CTVC½» .KVjDGNGTK³ 7CTKJK.NVTXG6CPCVº[NC,,,([RUWNVCP6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¸NGTºUVCPDWN([R %GNGFK[GUKU %(5.6NG[OCP²&GNu6NUµP¼jJGUGTNGTK³$'$57'(.25U[+C\ÉTCPU %(5.6NG[OCP²)KNKDGNK$JOGFÃTKH(HGPFK³$'$57'(.25U[7GOOW\U %(5.6NG[OCP)KNKDGNK%CMMCN$JOGFÃTKH(HGPFK³7CTKJK.NVTXG6CPCVº[NC,9 ([RUWNVCP6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¸NGTºUVCPDWN([R%GNGFK[GUKU %(5.6NG[OCP²&KJCPIKT&COKUK<C\»NCT»²$'$TV'GMQTU[$¹WUVQUU %(5.6NG[OCP²+CVVCV0WUVCHC5jM»Oµ»P&GNu6NUµP(UVGVK¹KPFG2TVC[C.Q[FW¹W <GPKNKMNGT² 08¹WT'GTOCP<C¼$TOC¸CPººUVCPDWN6CDCPE»gPKXGTUKVGUKU %(5.6NG[OCP²+CVVCVºUOCKN=JFu(HGPFK³7CTKJK.NVTXG6CPCVº[NC9, ([RUWNVCP6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¸NGTºUVCPDWN([R%GNGFK[GUKU %(<$7/,<CJ[C.GOCN$\u\¹UVCPDWNºUVCPDWN0KNNK(¹KVKO%CMCPN»¹»U &$1+CNKN±(DGFKNG¼GP'GJjNCTºOº\(OKP'GFG²7TM0WUKMKUK'GTIKUKE,U[ ¼WDCVUE,U[0CTVU &GXCF5g¼'ɲcKnGMXG/jNG%CJnGNGTKPFG¼G[JWµNºUNjO9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK³¹MFjO *C\GVGUK ¼WDCVºUVCPDWN cCPVC[*{PN²5GUUCO)G[JCOCP'WTCP³7CTKJK.NVTXG6CPCVº[NC9,([RUWNVCP 6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¸NGTºUVCPDWN([R%GNGFK[GUKU c,¸.GOCN+CVVCV+jHº\2UOCP(HGPFKºUVCPDWN8\OCP/CDQTCVWCT»U '$1º¼0(1'ºUOjKN+jOK¹\CJNº¹UNjO7CTKJK.TQPQNQLKUKºUVCPDWN%jD»ÃNK<C[»PGXK '$1º¼0(1'ºUOCKN+jOK¹\CJNº2UOCPNº7CTKJK.TQPQNQLKUK,,9ºUVCPDWN7TMK[G <C[»PGXK '$1º¼0(1'º+jOK¹\CJNº¹UNjO7CTKJK.TQPQNQLKUKºUVCPDWN7TMK[G<C[»PGXK '(5(fOGT)CTWM+CV6CP´CVºPFC+jHº\2UOCP(HGPFKXG(MQN ºUVCPDWN0CTOCTCgPKXGTUKVGUK6QU[CN%KNKONGT(PUVKVU<C[»ONCPOCO»½<MUGM/KUCPU 7G\KUTGH '(50$108¹WT.CTFG¼¹MK+CVVCVºOº\ºUVCPDWN6CPµCV6GXGT6GTKUKU '(50$108¹WT².CNGO³¹UNjO'¼PEGUK<»NU[,9$TCN»MU '(50$108¹WT²5GuUµNJCVVjVuP.jOKN$MFKM³+C[CV7CTKJ0GEOWCUºU[$¹WUVQU U '(50$108¹WT+CVVCV±+$&,Â5¹)²NGTºUVCPDWN6CPµCV6GXGT6GTKUKU '(50$108¹WT²+CVVCVºUOCKN=JFu(HGPFK³+C[CV0GEOWCUºU[.CU»O U '(50$108¹WT²0G\CT.KVjDGNGTKPFG<C\»6CPCV»O»\³785¹1*%GNNGVGPKU[ U '(50$108¹WT7TM6CPCVºPFC(DTºUVCPDWN$MDCPMU '(50$108¹WT²cCT½CPDCN»+CE»ÃTKH%G[³.NVTXG6CPCVVC.f.EU[0CTV U '(50$108¹WT²ºMK.CTFG½+CVVCV»O»\³6CPCVXG.NVTFG.f.E,,U[7GOOW\ U '(50$108¹WT²6WNVCPgnPE$JOGFµKP<C\F»TF»¹»0WUJCH³7TMK[G¹¼%CPMCUº .g/7g59(6$1$7<»NU[$TCN»MU '(50$108¹WT/GVVGTU,P*QNFºUVCPDWN7JG0GVTQRQNKVCP0WUGWOQH$TV U '(50$108¹WT&CNNKITCRJKGU2VVQOCPGUºUVCPDWN0WUoG6CM»R6CDCPE»gPKXGTUKVp 6CDCPE»U )CKM5G½CV(UNjHºUVCPDWN7GTEOCP7GOGN(UGTVUU (5*g1$[F»P+CVVCV<GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK´PKP¹UVCPDWN0\GXG .VRJCPGNGTKPFG%WNWPCP(UGTNGTKºUVCPDWN0CTOCTCgPKXGTUKVGUK6QU[CN%KNKONGT (PUVKVU<C[»ONCPOCO»½<MUGM/KUCPU7G\KU 207 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 208 )G[JCOCP'WTCPºUVCPDWNºUVCPDWN'GXNGV*\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUK<MUGM5GUKO %{NO<C[»P»U *f.%º/*º107C[[KD;9;9,$UºTNCTFC(FKTPG9G3C¼C/KXCUººUVCPDWNºUVCPDWN gPKXGTUKVGUK(FGDK[CV)CMNVGUK<C[»PNCT»UTGH *f.%º/*º107C[[KD²ÃTKHu3C½C³¹UNjO$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹$E,U *f.%º/*º107C[[KD²0GJOGF3C½C6QMWNNW³¹UNjO$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹$E9,,U *f/3,1$5/,$DFNDCMK0GNjOKNKMXG0GNjOKNGTºUVCPDWN*TK<C[»PU +CDKD+CVVXG+CVVjVjPºUVCPDWN0CVDCCK(D\\K[jU +CMCPK0GJOGF%G[´KP+KN[GK»GTuHGUK+C\»TNC[CP$DFNMCFKT.CTCJCPºUVCPDWN +$6.$10GJOGF1GTOK([RUWNVCP7CTKJK([R%GNGFK[GUKºUVCPDWNU +$6.$10GJOGF1GTOK<\[ºNNCT%Q[WPECgUMFCT,,,,ºUVCPDWNgUMFCT %GNGFK[GUKgUMFCT$TC½V»TOCNCT»0GTMG\KU +CVVCV5»HCV<C\ICP&CPNº7CTKJNGTºUVCPDWN7TMK[G<C[»PGXKU º%1g/(0º10CJOWF.GOCNº1$/6QP+CVVCVNCTºUVCPDWN0(%U º%1g/(0º10CJOWF.GOCNº1$/+Q¼6CFjºUVCPDWN º%1g/(0º10CJOWF.GOKNºPCN+UG[KP+UCOGFFKP(XMjH,+Oj[P1G\jTGVK´PKP .WTWNW¼7CTKJKXG1C\ºTNCTºP+CN7GTEOGNGTK9CM»HNCT'GTIKUKUU ºUOCKN%(/º¸1WJDGV´NÂUjTNK\G[Nu=DFGVK´NG¼´jTP½T$DFNMGTKO $%'g/.$'º52¸/8$PMCTC*C\KgPKXGTUKVGUK<C[»PNCT»U ¹UVCPDWN.NVTXG6CPCV$PUKMNQRGFKUK,,,ºUVCPDWN7GTEOCP.NVT<C[»PNCT» .$/37GXHKM+QEC0GJOGF5jUKO(HGPFKXG+CMMºPFC<C\ºNOº¼%KT5KUjNGPKP ¹PEGNGPOGUK ºUVCPDWN0CTOCTCgPKXGTUKVGUK*\GN6CPCVNCT(PUVKVUU .2c85G½CF(MTGO²$DFNDCMK(HGPFK/CµNK\CFG³¹UVCPDWN$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹UV$, 9,,,ºUVCPDWN 0GJOGF(UµCF0KT´CVº0JGPFKUJjPGK%GTTK+Oj[WPºUVCPDWN 0GJOGF0GEFu+CFjKMW´¼»GMjKM+C\$DFNMCFKTf=&$1ºUVCPDWNcC¹T»<C[»PNCT» E,U 0GJOGF6jNKO7G\MKTGºUVCPDWNgPKXGTUKVGUK0GTMG\.VRJCPGUK7CTKJ<C\OCNCT» 1Q 0GJOGF6g5(<<$6KEKNNK2UOjPK,,9ºUVCPDWN 0GJOGV7jJKT(HGPFK2UOCPNº0GNNKHNGTK,,9ºUVCPDWN0GTCN<C[»PGXK 0GNGM&GNjN5GKUNJCVVCVKP.jOKN$MFKMºUVCPDWNUTGUKO 025'70$11º+²)GTuFWP%G[³¹UNjO$PUKMNQRGFKUKº$&,9ºUVCPDWN0KNNK(¹KVKO %CMCPN»¹»U 0UVCMKO\jFG6NG[OCP6CµFGFFKP7WJHGK+CVVCVuPP½TºDPNGOKP0CJOWF.GOjN ºUVCPDWN7TM7CTKJ(PEOGPK.NNK[CV»U f+025'70$11²)GTuFP%G[³¹UNCO$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹$E,9ºUVCPDWN0(%U f=&$1<»NOC\²([RUWNVCPN»%KT+CVVCV»O»\0GJOGF5C½KF(HGPFK³,,,([RUWNVCP 6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¸NGTºUVCPDWN([R%GNGFK[GUKU f=781$<»NOC\7TM%GUVGEKNGTK$PUKMNQRGFKUKºUVCPDWN+C[CV<C[»PNCT»U 3$.$/,10=GMK0CNK[G1C\ºTNCTººUVCPDWN.CPCCV.KVjDGXKVU 3$.$/,10=GMK6QP6CFTj\CONCTXG%C¼XGMKNNGT,9ºUVCPDWN$JOGV6CKV0CVDCCU» 3$.$/,10=GMK2UOCPNº7CTKJ'G[KONGTKXG7GTKONGTK6{\N¸,,,,ºUVCPDWN0KNNK (¹KVKO%CMCPN»¹» 5$'2¼GXMGV7TM+CVVCVNCTººUVCPDWNVUU 5(91$.2¸/8&GOCN6GTXGT+CVVCV.KVjDGNGTK'QU[C'KXCP(FGDK[CV»0\GUK&GOCN 6GTXGT5GXPCMQ¹NW$T½KXK$ 5(91$.2¸/8&GOCN6GTXGT([RN+CVVCVNCT'QU[C'KXCP(FGDK[CV»0\GUK&GOCN 6GTXGT5GXPCMQ¹NW$T½KXK$ 6$/º0(HGPFK7G\MKTGK6jNKO'GTUCCFGVU ¼(0µ'Ã1º=Ã'(6N[GOCP(HGPFK)»PF»MN»N»0T´KVVGXjTKJºUVCPDWNºUVCPDWNgPX (FGDK[CV)CM 6$<,2¸8//$5,5GEGR6CFTK7TM7C´NKM<C\º(MQNPP'Q¸W¼WPFC»G[JNKUNjO 9GNK[FFKP(HGPFKºUVCPDWN0CTOCTCgPKXGTUKVGUK6QU[CN%KNKONGT(PUVKVU*GNGPGMUGN 7TM(N6CPCVNCT»%{NO<C[»ONCPOCO»½<MUGM/KUCPU7G\KU 6(5º10WJKVVKP+CVVCV»G[J+COFWNNCJºUVCPDWN.WDDGCNV»$MCFGOKUK.NVTXG6CPµCV 9CMH»U 6(5º10WJKVVKP±(OKP(HGPFK(FKTPGNK²'º$&;,6 6(5º10WJKVVKP².WDDGCNV»$MCFGOKUK.NVTXG6CPµCV9CMH»(MTGO+CMM»$[XGTFK+CV .QNGMUK[QPW(PXCPVGTK³(MTGO+CMMº$[XGTFK+CVºTC.KVCDººUVCPDWNºUVCPDWN)GVKJ &GOK[GVKU 6(5º10WJKVVKP+CV6CPCVºXG0G¼JWT+CVVCVNCTºUVCPDWN.WDDGCNV»$MCFGOKUK.NVT XG6CPµCV9CMH»U 6(5º10WJKVVKP²$%'µFGMK(N<C\OC(UGTNGTXG,,$DFNJCOKF.QNGMUK[QPW³$MCFGOKM $TC¼VºTOCNCT'GTIKUK2UOCPN»f\GN6C[»U»U[¼WDCV7GOOW\U 6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEuD'GXJCV´NMVVjDºUVCPDWN*\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUK 1G½TK[CV»PFCP1QU 7º/*(11WTWNNCJ([RN+CVVCVNCTºUVCPDWN$[F»PN»M%CU»OGXKUTGH 785$1¼GTCHGFFKP²6CµFGFFKP³¹UNjO$PUKMNQRGFKUK¹$ºUVCPDWN0(%6 7TM'KNKXG(FGDK[CV$PUKMNQRGFKUK,9,,,ºUVCPDWN'GTIjJ<C[»PNCT» 81$7)CKM5G½KV +KETu7CTKJNGTK0KNjFu7CTKJGcGXKTOG.ºNCXW\W$PMCTC7TM7CTKJ.WTWOWU 8=810WUVCHC²$DFNDjMKÃTKH(HGPFK³'¹$,U 8=81c$5¼,/,ºUOCKN+CMM»±'G¸GTNK7TMÂNKOKXG*\GN6CPCVNCTgUVjFº$DFNDjMK ÂTKH(HGPFK²%GNNGVGPE;;,,U[2ECMU g19(5$6JG[N+CVVCV¹UOCKN=JF(HGPFKºUVCPDWN6CPµCV6GXGT6GTKUKU g19(5$6JG[N+CVVCV0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFKXG¹UVCPDWN)GVJKPK0LFGNK[GP +CFKU ºUVCPDWN6CPµCV6GXGT6GTKUKU g19(5$6JG[N²=jV»6jOuµNGTKPK=K[jTGV³ .NVTXG6CPCVVC.f.E,,U[1KUCPU <$5',0$NK.W\Cu´PKP±»KJjD´N$JDCT²$FNº+CFKU.KVCDºPºP7TM¹UNjO.NVT g\GTKPFGMK7GUKTNGTK².WDDGCNV»$MCFGOK0GEOWCU»<»NU[2ECMU <g&(/(TFGO±&GOCN6GTXGT5GXPCMQ¸NW´PWP([RcCNº¼OCNCTº²7CTKJK.NVTXG 6CPCV»[NC,9([RUWNVCP6GORQ\[WOW7GDNK¹NGTºUVCPDWN([R%GNGFK[GUK =(5'(&º+OG[TC2UOCPNº8NGOj%K[QITCHKNGTKPKP$T¼KX.C[PCMNCTº»GT´K[[G 6KEKNNGTK ºUVCPDWNºUVCPDWNgPKXGTUKVGUK6QU[CN%KNKONGT(PUVKVU$T½KXEKNKM$PC%KNKO'CN» <C[»ONCPOCO»½<MUGM/KUCPU7G\KU%GNIG 209 E y ü p lü H a t t a t la r ‹ndeks 210 $6JG[NgPXGT $DFK(HGPFK $DFWµU6CF»MÃOKT7TDGUK $DFWNNCJ%G[ $DFWNNCJ(HGPFK $DFWNNCJ+COFK%G[ $DFWNNCJ.»T»OK $DFWNNCJ0CJKT(HGPFK $DFWNNCJ5GµHGV%G[ $DFWTTCJOCP%G[ $DFWTTCJOCP(HGPFK $DFWTTCJOCP+KNOK(HGPFK $DFWTTCJOCP¼GTGH%G[&CFFGUK $DFNC\K\ $DFNDCMK%WTPC\(HGPFK $DFNDjMKÃTKH(HGPFK $DFNDjMK(HGPFK $DFNEGNKN(HGPFK $DFNJCOKF(HGPFK $DFNMCFKT%GNJK(HGPFK $DFNMCFKT(HGPFK $DFNMGTKO(HGPFK $DFNNjVKH(HGPFK $DFTTCJKO(HGPFK $DFTTCJKO(HGPFK(NJGOK[[G $DFTTCJKO)CK\(HGPFK $DFTTCJKO1K[C\K(HGPFK $DKFcGNGDK0GUEKFK $FKNG6WNVCP $HKHG+CVWP7GMMGUK $H[QPMCTCJKUCT*GFKM$JOGF3C½C $¹CMCR»N»ºUOCKN(HGPFK $¹CMCR»N»ºUOCKN(HGPFK\jFG0WUVCHC (HGPFK $JOGFÃOK½(HGPFK $JOGF$TKH(HGPFK $JOGFcGNGDK $JOGF(HGPFK $JOGF)GTKFWP%G[ $JOGF+COFK(HGPFK $JOGF+C½KO $JOGF+»H\»(HGPFK $JOGF.jOKN $JOGF.jOKN$MFKM $JOGF0WJVCT%G[ $JOGF1CKNK(HGPFK $JOGF1GEKD%G[ $M0QNNCfOGT $MCTnG½OG $MDCDCD&COKK $MJKUCTN» $MKH(HGPFK $MOQNNC $MVCT+QEC $NCCFFKP%G[ $NCECºOCO»$PDCTK\jFG$NK(HGPFK $NCGFFKP%G[ $NjK[GNK.CF»\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK $NKDKP<CJ[C6WHK $NK(HGPFK $NK1CMK6QMC¹» $NK3C½C $NK5»\C(HGPFK $NK5WOK $OCU[C $OCU[CN» $OCU[CN»¼G[J+COFWNNCJ(HGPFK $OOK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK $PMCTC9CNKUK $PVCM[C $PVCM[CN» $PVGR $TCR&COKK $TKH%G[ $TKH(HGPFK $TKHK$JOGF3C½C $TRC(OKPK&COKK $½»MRC½C0GFTGUGUK $VCK(HGPFK $VVCT\jFG $XE»DG[0CJCNNGUK0GUEKFK $[CU3C½C7TDGUK $[CUQH[C $[½G%CJTK.CF»P $[½G6KPGRGTXGT9CNKFG6WNVCP $[½G6WNVCP $[XCPUCTC[u $\K\$\OK(HGPFK $\K\(HGPFK %CDCcGNGDK0GFTGUGUK %CDC+C[FCT %C¹FCV %CJCTK[G0GXNGXKJCPGUK %CJKT0WUVCHC3C½C7GMMGUK %CJTK0GJOGF3C½C %CJTK[G0CVDCCU» %CJTK[G1C\»T»+CUCP+UP3C½C %CM»TM{[%[M&COKK %CMMCN$TKH(HGPFK %CNCV %CNCV¼G[JK %CNCV¼G[JK6G[[KF+CUCP1WTK %CN»MRC\CT».CR»U» %CNVCNKOCP» %C½OGMVGD %C[G\KF %C[G\KF&COKK %C[G\KF(HGPFK %C[G\KF0G[FCP» %GMVC½(HGPFK7TDGUK %GNJ %GPNK\jFG %GTDGT %GTDGT\jFG %G½KMVC½ %G½KMVC½.CR»C¹CU»0GMVGDK %G½KMVC½N»+CVVCV1WTK(HGPFK %G½KT$¹C %G[DCDC6QMC¹» %G[MQ\ %G\OK$NGO9CNKFG6WNVCP %KNjNK+CDG½K %QNCJGPM1WTK%G[NGT %QUPC %QUPCN» %QUVCPºUMGNGUK %Q[CE»6QMC¹» %Q\CE»\jFG+CE»$JOGF(HGPFK %W¹FCP %WJCTC %WNICTKUVCP %WTJCPGFFKP(HGPFK %WTUC %WTUC0QNNCU»¼GTKH(HGPFK %WTUCN» %WTUCN»+CEK$NK$¹C %WTUCN»6G[[KF0GJOGF+C½KO %WTUCN»7CDKDK¼GJTK[jTK$NK(HGPFK %WTUCN»=GMK'GFG %MTG½ &CDK\jFG$DFK$¹C &CDK\jFG$DFWNNCJ &CHGTcGNGDK &C¹CNQ¹NW &CPCP+CP»O7TDGUK &GNjNGFFKP(HGPFK >TCJRC½C &G\C[KTNK'GTXK½$NK &G\GTK.CU»O3C½C&COKK &KDCNK cCNF»TCP 211 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 212 cCT½CODCN»0GJOGF$TKH%G[ cCXW½0CJCNNGUK cCXW½\jFG6G[[KF$NK cGNGDK(HGPFK cGVGNK$JOGF(HGPFK c»PCT.CTCMQNW cKXK\jFG$DFWTTCJOCP(HGPFK cKXK\jFG cKXK\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK cKXK\jFG$VCWNNCJ(HGPFK cQTNWNW c{OG\ c{TGMnK+UG[KP$¹C c{TGMnK\jFG cWDWMnWNCT6»D[CP0GMVGDK cWMWTEWOC cWMWTEWOCN».CFTK(HGPFK 'C¹»UVCP 'COCF¼GJKF$NK3C½C 'COCF\jFG 'CTWµUUjCFG$¹CU»+CE»%G½KT$¹C 'CTW½½CHCMC/KUGUK 'CTUUjCFG$¹CU»0GJOGF$¹C 'CTUUjCFG$¹CU»¼GJKF 'CXWF$¹C&COKK 'C[G+CVWP7TDGUK 'GFGºDTCJKO%KP$NK(HGPFK 'GFG\jFG 'GHVGTFCT 'GHVGTFCTºUMGNGUK 'GHVGTFCT0CJOWF(HGPFK 'GHVGTFCT<CJ[C0GFTGUGUK 'GHVGTK+CMjPK 'GOKTEKMWNW<WUWH(HGPFK 'GTXK½$NK(HGPFK 'GTXK½0GJOGF 'GTXK½0WUVCHC(HGPFK 'GTXK½¼KHC[»fOGT(HGPFK 'GXNGV6KNjJ½{T 'KNK3KTK 'K[CTDCM»T 'Q¹CPE»DC½»$JOGF3C½C 'Q¹CPE»NCT.»\5½FK[GUK 'QNOCDCJnG 'WMCMK0GJOGF3C½C7TDGUK 'WTOW½\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK 'WTTK\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK '¹OGEKNGT&COKK 'TTK\jFG 'TTK\jFG0GJOGF$TKH(HGPFK 'TTK\jFGNGT6QHCU» (DG\jFG0WUVCHC%G[ (DWºUJCMºUMCKN(HGPFK (DW5CUKO<WUWH(HGPFK (DWDGMKT(HGPFK (DWDGMKT5C½KF(HGPFK (DWDGMKT9CJFK(HGPFK (DWTTG½KF (DW9WMWH$JOGF$¹C (D\\K[j7GXHKM%G[ (FKTPG (FKTPG.CF»U» (FKTPGMCR»U»0G\CTN»¹» (FKTPGMCR»U» (FKTPGNK (¹KPNK (¹TKMCR» (¹TKMCR»0QNNC$M½K0CJCNNGUK (¹TKMCR»N»cGNGDK(HGPFK (¹TKMCR»N»+QEC0GJOGF5CUKO(HGPFK (¹TKMCR»N»+QEC5CUKO(HGPFK (¹TKMCR»N»0GJOGF5CUKO(HGPFK (¹TKMCR»N»5CUKO(HGPFK (¹TKMCR»0G\CTN»¹» (MTGO+CMM»$[XGTFK (NJCE+jH»\+CUCP7CJUKP(HGPFK (OKP%G[ (OKP(HGPFK (OKPG6GTXGV+CP»O (OKT%WJCTK (OKT%WJCTK&COKK (OKT%WJCTK7GMMGUK (OKT(HGPFK (OKT(HGPFK\jFG6G[[KF$DFNJCNKO(HGPFK (OKT¼G[JK6NG[OCP(HGPFK (OKTGHGPFK\jFG+CNKO(HGPFK (OKTIjP (OKTICPcG½OGUK (PFGTWPK6NG[OCP+C[TK%G[ (PUGTEK (UCF(HGPFK (UMK$NK3C½C&CFFGUK (UMK<GPK&COKK%jNK+QEC0GUEKFK (UOC+CP»O (UOCºDTGV+CP»O (UOC6WNVCP6CTC[» (U6G[[KF0GJOGF%CJTK(HGPFK (½¼G[J+jH»\0WUVCHC0WJ[KFFKP(HGPFK ([R ([R0GFTGUGUK ([R0QNNCU» ([RN ([RUWNVCP ([RUWNVCP&COKK ([RUWNVCP7TDGUK ([[WDK ([[WDK5GEGR+CNKHG ([[R\jFG )CVKJ )CVKJcCT½CODC )CVKJ6COCPK[G0GFTGUGUK )CVKJ6WNVCP0GJOGF+CP )CVKJ6WNVCP0GJOGF7TDGUK )CVKJ<CXW\6GNKO&COKK )CVOC0GXJKDG+CP»O )CVOC6WNVCP )CVOC6WNVCP7TDGUK )C\N»ºNCJK7TDGUK )GTJCF3C½C )GTKFWP3C½C7TDGUK )GTTWJ.GVJFj7GMMGUK )GUJCPG&CFFGUK )GVJKcGNGDK&COKK )GVJK[G0HVK(UCF(HGPFK0GFTGUGUK )G[JCOCP'WTCP )G[\KºDTCJKO(HGPFK )G[\K[G5½FK[GUK )G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK )»PF»MN» 213 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 214 )»PF»M\jFGºDTCJKO(HGPFK )KNKDG )KNKDGNK%CMMCN$JOGF$TKH(HGPFK )KNKDGNK0GJOGF(HGPFK )KTW\¼CJ )TGPMºDTCJKO3C½C )[W\CV0GMVGDK *jHWTK(HGPFK *CNCVC *CNCVC+QECU»0GJOGF(HGPFK *CNCVC0GXNGXKJCPGUK *CNCVC5WUWOCV1G\CTGVK *CNCVCN» *CNCVCUCTC[ *CNCVCUCTC[6WNVCPKUK *CNKR'GFG *GD\G *GNGPDGXKºUOCKN(HGPFK *GNKDQNW *NHGO+CVWP.»\5½FK[GUK *NJCPG$UMGTK2MWNW *OTMnºUJCM$¹C *O½c»MOC\» *O½JCPGNK¼G[J$JOGF=K[CGFFKP (HGPFK *O½UW[W *PI{TOG\0CJCNNGUK *\GN0GJOGF *\GN6CPCVNCT$MCFGOKUK +CDKD(HGPFK +CDKDG+CP»O +CDKDG+CVWP +CE»cGNGDK +CE»)CKM +CE».nM&COKK +CE»3C½C +CE»<CJ[C +CE»<WUWH(HGPFK +CE»Q¹NW3C\CT» +CEK.jOKN(HGPFK +CnQXC +jH»\<CJ[C9GJDK(HGPFK +jH»\ +jH»\$JOGF3C½C +jH»\(FKD(HGPFK +jH»\ºDTCJKO(HGPFK +jH»\ºDTCJKO=JFK(HGPFK +jH»\ºOCO +jH»\ºUOCKN(HGPFK +jH»\ºUOCKN6CDKT(HGPFK +jH»\0GJOGF(HGPFK +jH»\0GJOGF3C½C +jH»\2UOCP +jH»\2UOCP(HGPFK +CHK\G+CP»O +CMMCM\jFG0WUVCHC+KNOK(HGPFK +CMM»%G[ +CNGDKcGNGDK +CNGDNK +CNGR +CN»E»NCT.{½M +CNKNC¹C +CNKN(HGPFK +CNKOcGNGDK +CTGOºUMGNGUK +CTRWVNW+jH»\0WUVCHC(HGPFK +CUCJ7CJUKP+KNOK(HGPFK +CUCP$¹C +CUCP%G[ +CUCP%KP$DFUUCOGF +CUCP&CP +CUCP+C½KOKcGNGDK +CUCP+UPK(HGPFK +CUCP+UP3C½C +CUCP1WTK(HGPFK +CUCP3C½C +CUCP5»\C(HGPFK +CUCP7CJUKP+KNOK(HGPFK +CUKD3C½C +j½KO(HGPFK +CVKEG6WNVCP +CVKR\jFG +CVVCV$JOGF(HGPFK +CVVCV$NK(HGPFK +CVVCV+QEC\jFG6G[[KF$JOGF(HGPFK +CVVCV.jOKN(HGPFK +CVVCV/C\fOGT(HGPFK +CVVCV0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP(HGPFK +CVVCV0WUVCHC5jM»O +CVVCV¼GXMGV9CJFGVK +CVVCV9GHC[K +C[CVK\jFG5GKUµNGVKDC0WUVCHC(HGPFK +C[TGFFKP +C\GTHGP(FJGO(HGPFK +C\TGVK+CNKF7TDGUK +C\TGVK0WJCOOGF +GMKO.WVDGFFKP0GMVGDK +GMKODC½»0GJOGF5GHµK(HGPFK +GMKOQ¹NW$NK3C½C +GMKOQ¹NW$NK3C½C6GDKNK +GTUGM +»TMCK¼GTKH&COKK+CVKDK([R6CDTK (HGPFK +KEC\ +KNOK(HGPFK +QEC0CJOWF%CDC +QEC0GJOGF0WTCF(HGPFK +QEC0GJOGF5CUKJ(HGPFK +QEC0GJOGF5CUKO +QEC1CKO(HGPFK +QEC2UOCP(HGPFK +QECfOGT(HGPFK +QEC5CKM(HGPFK +QEC6CFGFFKP(HGPFK +QEC6CNKJ(HGPFK +QECRC½CN»ºDTCJKO'GFG +QEC\jFG +QEC\jFG0GJOGF +QEC\jFG0GJOGF(PXGTK +QTCUCP +WDDK+CVWP7TDGUK +WNWUK(HGPFK +OC½CJ6WNVCP +UCO%G[&COKK +UG[KP$¹C +UG[KP(HGPFK +UG[KP+CDNK +UG[KP+UP(HGPFK +UPK(HGPFK +UP%G[ +\+CNKF ,$DFWNJCOKF ,$JOGF ,ºDTCJKO ,0WUVCHC ,'GTXK½$NK ,0CJOWF ºDPNGOKP0CJOWF.GNOCNºPCP ºDTCJKO$NCCFFKP%G[ ºDTCJKO%G[ ºDTCJKO&GXTK(HGPFK ºDTCJKO(HGPFK ºDTCJKO+CP ºDTCJKO+CPKH(HGPFK ºDTCJKO+CP\jFGNGT ºDTCJKO0VGHGTTKMC 215 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 216 ºDTCJKO3C½C ºDTCJKO6MVK(HGPFK ºDTCJKO7CJKT(HGPFK ºDTCJKO9CJFK(HGPFK ºDTCJKO9CU»M(HGPFK ºDTCJKO=CTKHK ºFTKU.{½M ºFTKU.{½M&CFFGUK ºFTKU.{½McG½OGUK ºJUCP%G[ ,,$DFNJCOKF ,,0CJOWF ,,2UOCP ,,,$JOGF ,,,0WTCF ,,,0WUVCHC ,,,1CRQN[QP ,,,6GNKO ºOCO+CUCP(HGPFK ºOCO\jFG+CVVCV0GJOGF0WUVCHC(HGPFK ºRNKMJjPG ,TCM ºTCP ºUC\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK ºUHCJCPN» ºUJCM$¹C ºUMGPFGT3C½C0CJCNNGUK ºUMGPFGT3C½C0GMVGDK ºUMGPFGT3C½C6»D[CP0GMVGDK ºUMKNKRNK7GMMGUK ºUOCKN(HGPFK ºUOCKN(HGPFK\jFG$DFK(HGPFK ºUOCKN+CMM»%G[ ºUOCKN=JFK(HGPFK ºUOKJCP(UOCJCP6WNVCP ºUVCPDWN ºUVCPDWN.CF»U» ºUVCPDWNNW ,90GJOGF ,90WTCF ,90WUVCHC º\OKT º\PKM º\PKM0GFTGUGUK º\\GV$NK3C½C º\\GV(HGPFK º\\GVNKGN+CE0GJOGF(OKP .CECOWUVCHCRC½C7GMMGUK .CF»,[C\ .CF»\jFG .CH\jFG)G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK .j¹»VJCPG .CJKTG .CJXGEK\jFG .CNGPFGTJjPG .CNGPFGTJjPG&CFFGUK .CNGPFGTJjPG0GMVGDK .jOKN$MFKM .jOKN(HGPFK .CPN»EC.{THG\K .CPWPK6WNVCP6NG[OCP .CR»C¹CU»0CJCNNGUK .CR»E»cG½OGUK .CR»KnK&COKK .CRVCP»'GT[C+CUCP+UP3C½C .CRVCP»'GT[C.C[OCM0WUVCHC3C½C .CTCcGNGDK0GJOGF(HGPFK .CTC+CNKN(HGPFK .CTC0WUVCHC3C½C .CTCCDCN»7GMMGUK .CTCDC½7GMMGUK .CTCIOTM .CTCJKUCT .CTCM»\ .CTCOCPN»$DKF(HGPFK .CTE»DC½» .CT»PCDCFN»+CUCP+UP(HGPFK .CTK[G&COKK .jU»O .jU»O*WDjTK .CU»ORC½C .CUVCOQPW .C½ICTK¼G[JK$DFWNNCJºFTKU .j½KH0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK .C½N» .jVKD\jFG0GJOGF5GHµK(HGPFK .C[UGTKNK'GTXK½$NK5»\C(HGPFK .C[[»O\jFG .C\CUMGT$DFNMCFKT%G[ .C\CUMGT&CµHGTcGNGDK&COKK .C\CUMGT(HGPFK .C\CUMGT0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFK .C\CUMGT0G[[GF\jFG$DFWTTCJOCP (HGPFK .C\CUMGT8DG[FWNNCJ+COFK(HGPFK .GDGEK\jFG0GJOGF9CUHK(HGPFK .GPCP5KHCK .GRGMEKNGT&COKKºOCO»0GJOGF(HGPFK .GTCOGFFKP(HGPFK .GVCPK\jFG .GVCPK\jFG$NK(HGPFK .GVCPK\jFG.GDKTK0WUVCHC(HGPFK .GXCMKD\jFG.C\CUMGT9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK .»DT»U .»DT»UK\jFGºUOCKN+CMM» .»T»O .»T»OK(HGPFKcG½OGUK .»T»OK0GJOGF(HGPFK .»T»OKcG½OGUK .»TM0GTFKXGP0G\CTN»¹» .»TM0GTFKXGPNGT .»U»MN»&COKK .»\6CPC[»K1GHKUG2MWNW .»\$NK\jFG .»\»N0GUEKF .»\»NFG¹KTOGP6QMCM .KTNK .KTRCUK7GMMGUK .QEC+C[CVK\jFG0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK .QEC1K½CPE» .QEC¼WEC .QECOWUVCHCRC½C0GFTGUGUK .QP[C .QP[C(TG¹NK .{UVGPFKN .WFUK\jFG.GVJFCU» .WFUK\jFG¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFK .WOMCR» .WPFW\ .WT½WPEW\jFG .WT½WPEW\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK .WTWnG½OG .nM$[CUQH[C0CJCNNGUK .nMcCXW½ .nM(OKT .nM(OKT(HGPFK7TDGUK .nM([R .nM7QOCM(HGPFK /CµNK$NK(HGPFK 217 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 218 /CµNKcG½OGUK /CµNK0WUVCHC(HGPFK /CµNK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK /CµNK\jFG6G[[KF$DFNDjMK(HGPFK /CNC0WUVCHC3C½C /jTGPFGNK0GJOGF(HGPFK /C\0GJOGF /C\fOGT(HGPFK /C\fOGT9CUHK(HGPFK /GDPK 6Vn%G½KT$¹C /GHMQ½G /QPFTC 0CnMC 0CIQUC 0CJKT\jFG 0CJOWF$MKH(HGPFK 0CJOWF%CDC5»\CK 0CJOWF%G[ 0CJOWF&GNjNGFFKP 0CJOWF'GFG 0CJOWF(HGPFK 0CJOWF1GFKO3C½C7TDGUK 0CJOWF3C½C+COCO» 0CJOWF5CEK(HGPFK 0CNNK\jFG+UTGX.GVJFC 0CPKUC 0GFKPG 0GFTGUGK+CVVCVKP 0GFTGUGVµN+CVVCVKP 0GJOGF$TKH%G[ 0GJOGF$¹C 0GJOGF$TKH(HGPFK 0GJOGF$VCWNNCJ9CJ[K(HGPFK 0GJOGF%CJKT(HGPFK 0GJOGF&CP(HGPFK 0GJOGF&GNjN%G[ 0GJOGF&GOKN(HGPFK 0GJOGFcGNGDK(HGPFK 0GJOGF(HGPFK 0GJOGF(HNCVWP 0GJOGF(OKP 0GJOGF(OKP$V»H(HGPFK 0GJOGF(OKP%G[ 0GJOGF(OKP'GFG 0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK 0GJOGF(OKP.j½KH(HGPFK 0GJOGF(OKP7QMCFK 0GJOGF(OKP7QMCFK(HGPFK 0GJOGF+»H\»(HGPFK 0GJOGF+WNWUK(HGPFK 0GJOGFº\\GV(HGPFK 0GJOGF.CRVCP 0GJOGF.j\»O(HGPFK 0GJOGF/GXPK(HGPFK 0GJOGF0GEKF(HGPFK 0GJOGF1CHµK(HGPFK 0GJOGF1CHK(HGPFK 0GJOGF3CTUC 0GJOGF3C½C 0GJOGF5CUKO(HGPFK 0GJOGF5C½KV(HGPFK 0GJOGF5GEGR(HGPFK 0GJOGF5G½KF(HGPFK 0GJOGF5»\C6CHXGV%G[ 0GJOGF6CKF(HGPFK 0GJOGF6CNKJ(HGPFK 0GJOGF6CNKJ¼GOµK(HGPFK 0GJOGF6CNKO$¹C 0GJOGF6WWF%G[ 0GJOGF¼jMKT5GEjK(HGPFK 0GJOGF¼GMKD3C½C 0GJOGF¼GXMK(HGPFK 0GJOGF7CJKT(HGPFK 0GJOGF7GDTK\K 0GJOGF9CJFGVK(HGPFK 0GJOGF9CUHK(HGPFK 0GJOGF9WUWNK(HGPFK 0GJOGF=CKHK(HGPFK 0GMMG 0GMMG.CF»N»¹» 0GNGM3C½C7QTWPW$NK+C[FCT%G[ 0GNGXK 0GOK½(HGPFK 0GOK½5CUKO(HGPFK 0GP[GN.CUT» 0GTECP 0GTMG\GHGPFK&COKK 0GTMG\GHGPFK7TDGUK 0GT\KHQP0GFTGUGUK 0GT\KHQPNW 0GUKJ0GJOGF3C½C 0GUPGXKJCP0GXNGXK2UOCP'GFG 0GXNjPC&GNjNGFFKP5WOK 0G[FCP&COKKºOCO»2UOCP(HGPFK 0»U»T.TCN»)WCF 0»U»T 0KHVCJK\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK 0KJTK½CJ0GMVGDK 0KJTK½CJ6WNVCP 0KJTK½CJ9CNKFG6WNVCP6GDKNK 0KJTK½CJ9CNKFG6WNVCP7TDGUK 0KOCT6KPCP 0KT$JOGF 0KTºUOCKN%G[ 0KT0WUVCHC%G[ 0KTCJWTºOTCJQT&COKK 0QNNC$½MK&COKK 0QNNCcGNGDK 0QNNC'KNUK\ 0QNNC*TCPK 0QNNC¼GTGH0CJCNNGUK 0QTC 0WJKD(HGPFK 0WJKFFKP(HGPFK 0WJ[KFFKP(HGPFK 0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ%G[ 0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK 0WJUKP\jFG$DFWNNCJ+COFK%G[ 0WJUKP\jFGGU6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ 0WTCF+FGXGPFKIjT 0WTVC\C(HGPFK 0WUC(HGPFK 0WUjJKD0WUVCHC3C½C 0WUNKJKFFKP6KTQ\K 0WUVCHC$¹C 0WUVCHC$¹CcG½OGUK 0WUVCHC'GFG 0WUVCHC(HGPFK 0WUVCHC)G[\K(HGPFK 0WUVCHC+KNOK(HGPFK 0WUVCHCº\\GV(HGPFK 0WUVCHC.VCJK 0WUVCHC1CKNK(HGPFK 0WUVCHC1CM½K(HGPFK 0WUVCHC1K[C\K(HGPFK 0WUVCHC5CM»O8PCP%G[ 0WUVCHC5CM»O(HGPFK 0WUVCHC¼G[JK(HGPFK 0WUVCHC9CUHK(HGPFK 0WUVCHC9CU»H(HGPFK 0WUVCHC9GHC(HGPFK 0WUVCMKO\jFG 0W\»MCK+OC[WP 0µOKP\jFG%WTUCN»6G[[KF+CUKD(HGPFK 0FGTTKU0GJOGF7CJKT(HGPFK 0G[[GF\jFG$DFWTTCJOCP+CVGOK (HGPFK 219 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 220 0G[[GF\jFG$NKcGNGDK 0G\\KP 0G\\KP$D\GJJKD6CNKJ(HGPFK 1CMMC½\jFG 1CM½KFKN9CNKFG6WNVCP 1CNN»0GUEKF 1CUWJK.CTI»%G[ 1C[\GPDC½»$MOQNNCfOGT(HGPFK 1C[\GPDC½»+CNKN'GTXK½0GJOGF'GFG 1C\»T$¹C6QMC¹» 1C\N»0GJOGFcGNGDK 1GEKR)C\»N 1GEOGFFKP2M[C[ 1GHGU\jFG6G[[KFºUOCKN(HGPFK 1GTIKU$JOGF(HGPFK 1GTIKU\jFG 1G½G%G[ 1GXµK\jFG0GJOGF6CNKJ(HGPFK 1GX½GJKTNK'COCVºDTCJKO3C½C 1GX½GJKTNK'COCVºDTCJKO3C½C6GDKNK 1KOGV(HGPFK\jFG 1K½CPEC 1K½CPEC0WUVCHC3C½C&COKK 1K½CPE» 1K½CPE»&COKK 1K½CPE»&GNjN\jFG0WUVCHC 1K½CPE»0CJCNNGUK 1K½CPE»0GMVGRNGTK 1K½CPE»3C½C&COKK 1K½CPE»6G[[KF%G[ &GNjNGFFKP1K\COGFFKP(HGPFK 1WJ(HGPFK\jFG$NK3C½C 1WTK$¹C 1WTK%G[ 1WTK(HGPFK 1WTWNNCJ7KNIGP 1WTWQUOCPK[G&COKK 1WTWQUOCPK[G.VRJCPGUK 2TFW 2TJCPK[G.»½NCU»&COKK 2UOCP%G[ 2UOCP(HGPFK 2UOCP.jOKN(HGPFK 2VCMn»NCT 2VCMn»NCT&COKK fOGT$¹C fOGT(HGPFK fOGT(HGPFK\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK fOGT+WNWUK(HGPFK fOGT9CUHK(HGPFK f\DGM¼»DCPu f\DGMNGT7GMMGUK f\MGPV 3CTKU 3GJNKXCP\jFG 3GRG+QEC 3GTVGX3C½C7TDGUK 3GTVGXPK[CN9CNKFG6WNVCPcG½OGUK 3K[GTNQVK 3K[GTNQVK.CJXGUK 3TGPU$DDCU+CNKO3C½C 3TGPU0GJOGF$NK3C½C 5CDKC.CF»P 5CM»O(HGPFK 5COC\CP(HGPFK 5CUKO(HGPFK 5CUKO0GJOGF(HGPFK 5C½KF(HGPFK 5GECK\jFG(MTGO%G[ 5GEGR+CNKHG 5GKUµN(V»DDC$JOGF(HGPFK 5GKUµN.VVCD$PDGTK0GJOGF(HGPFK 5GUN\jFG(HGPFK 5GUN(HGPFK 5GXCP 5KHCV<C\ICP 5K\G 5QFQUK\jFG 5WOGNK.C\CUMGTK6G[[KF6CKF0GJOGF (HGPFK 5WUnWMNW 5WU[C 5UVGO3C½C 5½FKgUVGM 6CDCPE».QNGMUK[QPW 6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK 6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK0GUEKFK 6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK&COKK 6CFGFFKP(HGPFK 6CFK[G+CNKN(NFGO+CP»O 6CFTC\CO+COK0GJOGF3C½C 6CFTC\CO.CTCOCPK0GJOGF3C½C 6CFTC\CO0WUVCHC3C½C7GMMGUK 6CFTC\CO0WUVCHC5G½KF3C½C 6CFTC\CO5COK0GJOGF3C½C 6CFTC\CO¼GJKF$NK3C½C 6CFTC\CO¼GJKF$NK3C½C.VRJCPGUK 6CFTC\CO7WPWUNW+C[TGFFKP3C½C 6CFTC\CO<KTOKUGMK\cGNGDK\jFG6CKF3C½C 6CFWNNCJ(HGPFK 6CHTCPDQNW 6CNKJ(HGPFK 6COK%G[ 6COK(HGPFK 6COUWP 6COUWPK+CUCP(HGPFK 6CT»9GNK 6GNCPKM0QNNCU» 6GNCPKMNK0WUVCHC(HGPFK 6GNKO(HGPFK 6GNKO+jP 6GNKOK[G&COKK 6GOGPFGTG 6GOGTMCPF 6G[[KF 6G[[KF$DFWNJCNKO+CUKD(HGPFK 6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK 6G[[KF$DFNJCNKO 6G[[KF$JOGF+C½KO(HGPFK 6G[[KF$NK(HGPFK 6G[[KF%WTJCPGFFKP.»N»n 6G[[KF+CUCP+C½KOK 6G[[KF+CUCP1WTK(HGPFK 6G[[KF+UG[KP9GJDK 6G[[KFºDTCJKO(HGPFK 6G[[KF.jU»O*WDjTK(HGPFK 6G[[KF0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK 6G[[KF0GJOGF0»UTK 6G[[KF0GJOGF6CKF 6G[[KF0WUVCHC¼jMKT(HGPFK 6G[[KF2UOCP(HGPFK 6G[[KF6CT»$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK 6G[[KF¼GTKH 6G[[KF¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFK 6G[[KF9CJ[K(HGPFK 6G[[KF9GJDK 6G[[KF<CJ[C(HGPFK 6»FM»(HGPFK 6»TT»$NK(HGPFK 6»TV7GMMG 6KPCP3C½C&COKK 6KXCUK7GMMGUK 6K[jJK$JOGF(HGPFK 6K[CXW½3C½C7TDGUK 6QMWNNW0GJOGF3C½C 6HK\jFG 221 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 222 6WNVCP$DFNC\K\ 6WNVCP$DFNOGEKF 6WNVCP%C[G\KF 6WNVCP%GFK\\COCP 6WNVCP+COKF 6WNVCP,$JOGF 6WNVCP,6GNKO 6WNVCP,6GNKO+CP 6WNVCP,,%C[G\KF 6WNVCP,,6GNKO 6WNVCP,,,$JOGF 6WNVCP,,,0WTCF 6WNVCP,,,0WUVCHC 6WNVCP.GVJFCU» 6WNVCP0CJOWF 6WNVCP0GJOGF5G½CF&CFFGUK 6WNVCP5G½CF 6WNVCP5G½CF7TDGUK 6WNVCP6GNKO&COKK 6WNVCP6GNKO0GMVGDK 6WNVCP6GNKO7TDGUK 6WNVCP6NG[OCP 6WNVCPCJOGF&COKK 6WNVCPCJOGF0G[FCP» 6WWF%G[ 6W[QNEWfOGT$¹C 6W[QNEW\jFG0GJOGF1GEKR(HGPFK 6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC(HGPFK 6W[QNEW\jFG0WUVCHC([[WDK 6W[QNEW\jFG¼G[J+COFWNNCJ0GMVGDK 6NG[OCP(HGPFK 6NG[OCP(HGPFK\jFG 6NG[OCP)CKM(HGPFK 6NG[OCP+KMOGV(HGPFK 6NG[OCPº\\u(HGPFK 6NG[OCP5CEK(HGPFK 6NG[OCP6CDKV%G[ 6NG[OCP¼GXMGV3C½C 6NG[OCPK[G&COKK 6NG[OCPK[G0GFTGUGUK 6VNEG 6VNEG&COKK ¼CJºUOCKN ¼CJ6WNVCP'GTIjJ» ¼CJ6WNVCP6»D[CP0GMVGDK ¼CJ6WNVCP7GMMGUK ¼CKT%jMK ¼CKT+j½KOK ¼CKT.C\CUMGT%jMK(HGPFK ¼CO ¼CON»+jH»\0WJCOOGF5C½KF(HGPFK ¼CON»5C½KF(HGPFK ¼CPK\jFG$VCWNNCJ(HGPFK ¼CV»T\jFG ¼GHKM%G[ ¼GJKF$NK3C½C ¼GJKF¼G[JNKUNjO)G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK ¼GJ\jFG0GJOGF&COKK ¼GJ\jFG0GJOGF7TDGUK ¼GJ\jFG6WNVCP%C[G\KF ¼GJ\jFG6WNVCP.QTMWV ¼GJ\jFGDC½»&COKK ¼GJ\jFGDC½»'CTWµN+CFKUcG½OGUK ¼GMGTRjTG7TDGUK ¼GMKD3C½C ¼GTKH$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK ¼GTKH\jFG ¼GXMGV3C½C ¼GXMK(HGPFK ¼G[FC'GFG ¼G[J$DFjNMCFKT(HGPFK ¼G[J$DFTTCJKO(HGPFK ¼G[J$NK(HGPFK ¼G[J$\K\GT5WHCK(HGPFK ¼G[J$\K\0CJOWF+FCK+COCO» ¼G[J+COFWNNCJ ¼G[J+CUCP)G[\K(HGPFK ¼G[J+UG[KP)CJTGFFKP(HGPFK ¼G[JºDTCJKO'GFG ¼G[JºUJCM(HGPFK ¼G[J0CJOWF&COKK ¼G[J0GEFFFKP(HGPFK ¼G[J0GJOGF(HGPFK ¼G[J0GJOGF(OKP(HGPFK ¼G[J0WJ[KFFKP0GJOGFºUMKNKDK ¼G[J0WTCF'GTICJ» ¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK ¼G[J0WTCF(HGPFK7GMMGUK ¼G[J0WTCFGN%WJCTK ¼G[J0WTCF»1CM½KDGPFK7GMMGUK ¼G[J0WUVCHC9GHC(HGPFK ¼G[J5C½KF(HGPFK ¼G[J6CNKJ ¼G[J6G[[KF0GJOGF9CJ[K(HGPFK ¼G[J6G[[KF1WTGFFKP(HGPFK ¼G[J6G[[KFgUMFjTK$JOGF5CWHK(HGPFK ¼G[J6KPCP(HGPFK ¼G[J6NG[OCP(HGPFK ¼G[J¼EC ¼G[J7CVCT$JOGF(HGPFK ¼G[J9CJ[K(HGPFK ¼G[JK$NK6CPK ¼G[JNNKUNCOºUJCM(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO$DFWNNCJ9CUUjH(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO$VCWNNCJ(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjOcCVCNECN»$NK(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjOcCVCNN»$NK(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO(DW6WWF(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO(UCF(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO+QEC6CµFFFKP(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO.GOCNRC½C\jFG$JOGF(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF(UCF(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF6CFGFFKP(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO0GJOGF¼GTKH(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO0WUVCHC(HGPFK7GMMGUK ¼G[J8½½CMK$NK(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO3KTK\jFG0GJOGF6CJKD (HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO6CnN»$DFNMCFKT(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO6G[[KF)G[\WNNCJ(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO6G[[KF0GJOGF(HGPFK ¼G[JNKUNjO9GNK[[FFKP(HGPFK ¼KHCJCXW\NW6COK%G[ ¼KO½KT'GFG ¼KTC\ ¼MTWNNCJ+CNKHG ¼MT(HGPFK 7CEK\jFG&CHGTcGNGDK 7jE\jFG0GJOGF(HGPFK 7CJKT(HGPFK 7CJKT(HGPFK&COKK 7CJUKP%G[ 7CJUKP(HGPFK 7CKH 7CMUKO0CMUGOK 7C½n»\jFG 7C½M{RT 7CVCTE»M\jFG$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK 7CVCTRC\CTN» 7GDTK\ 7GHUKTK(DWµU6WWF 7GHUKTK\jFG 7GMKTFC¹ 7GXHKM%G[ 7GXMKK1K½CPE»$NK%G[ 7»TJCNC9CNKUK 7KOWTNGPI 7QMCV 7QMCVN»$JOGF(HGPFK 7QMOCMVGRG0G\CTN»¹» 7QRJCPG 7QRJCPG'GHVGTFCT0CJCNNGUK 223 H a t t a t la r E y ü p lü 224 7QRJCPGNK0CJOWF(HGPFK 7QRMCR»0G\CTN»¹» 7QRMCR»6CTC[»0\GUK 7QTCOCP+CUCP$¹C 7QU[CN» 7QU[CN».CF»&GNjN 7Q\MQRCTCP\jFG+jH»\0GJOGF(HGPFK 7TCD\QP 7NDGPVEK0WJKFFKP6QMC¹» 7TMXGºUNjO(UGTNGTK0\GUK 7TME6QMC¹» 7VPE+jH»\<WUWH%G[ 8NW&COKK 8½½CMK\jFG6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK gn¼GJKVNGT.CDTKUVCP» gUMFCT gOOK6KPCP7GMMGUK gOO.GPCP'GTIjJ» gP[G gUMFCT$VKM9CNKFG6WNVCP0GMVGDK gUMFCT$[C\OC&COKK gUMFCTK+CE»'GFG gUMR gUMRN0WUVCHC(HGPFK 9CJFGVK%G[ 9CJFGVK(HGPFK 9CMµCPXKU/VHK(HGPFK 9CMWPNW0GJOGF(HGPFK 9CTCFKP 9CU»H(HGPFK 9CUUCH\jFG 9GHCºFCFKUK 9GHC/KUGUK 9GHC[K0WUVCHC(HGPFK 9GNK[FFKP(HGPFK 9GUKO$DDCU(HGPFK 9G\KT0GJOGF+WT½KF3C½C 9G\KTKC\COºDTCJKO3C½C 9K[CPC <C¹N»Mn»\jFG0GJOGF(OKP3C½C <CJ[C)CJTGFFKP(HGPFK <CJ[C3C½C <CJ[C\jFG7GMMGUK <CMWD$¹C&COKK <CMWD+KPFK <CNQXC <COCM\jFG6CNKJ(HGPFK <CXGFF <CXGFFºUMGNGUK <CXGFF.CDTKUVCP» <CXGFF0CJCNNGUK <CXW\6GNKO&COKK <CXW\6GNKO&CFFGUK <CXW\6WNVCP6GNKO+CP <C\ICP <C\»E» <GFKMWNG <GFKMWNGNK(OKP(HGPFK <GFKMWNGNK6G[[KF$DFWNNCJ(HGPFK <GMnG½O6NG[OCP(HGPFK <GPKMCR»0GXNGXKJCPGUK <GPK½GJKT <GPK½GJKT)GPGTNK¼GTKH(HGPFK <WPCPKUVCP <WPWU3C½C0GFTGUGUK <WUWH(HGPFK <WUWH0WJNKU3C½C&CFFGUK <WUWH3C½C\jFG <WUWH6KPCP(HGPFK <WUWH\jFG <T[½&COKK =CJKTGEK6QMC¹» =CN0CJOWF3C½C&COKK =CN0GJOGF3C½C0GFTGUGUK =GMCK'GFG(HGPFK =G[TGM&COKK =G[TGM6CNKJC6»D[CP0GMVGDK =KIGVXCT =JFKºUOCKN$¹C
Benzer belgeler
Madrid Protokolü - Türk Patent Enstitüsü
DKTOCTMCPÆPXG[CDKTOCTMCVGUEKNDCĩXWTWUWPWPQNOCUÆ\QTWPNWFWT 7NWUNCTCTCUÆOCTMCDCĩXWTWUW7NWUNCTCTCUÆ$×TQŏ[COGPĩGQſUCTCEÆNÆþÆ[NC[CRÆNOCNÆFÆT $CĩXWTW UCJKDK VCTCHÆPFCP 7NWUNCTCTCUÆ...
DetaylıHEMA ENDÜSTRİ YENİ YATIRIMLARA DOYMUYOR
)C\KCPVGR MCOR×U×PFGP /CMKPC /×JGPFKUK QNCTCM OG\WP QNFWMVCP UQPTC [CMNCĩÆM [ÆN -QÁ ITWDWPFC 1VQ[QNXG1VQMCTHKTOCNCTÆPFCÁGĩKVNK IÑTGXNGTFG DWNWPCP [GPK )GPGN /× F×T×O×\ FC...
Detaylı16. Sayı - Hattat Holding
EÆUÆ QNCP HKTOC UGÁKNOKĩ [CRÆNCP IÑT×ĩOGNGT XG ÑP CPNCĩOCNCTÆ VCMKDGP DWI×P DKT QTVCM ÁCNÆĩOC UQPWEWPC XCTÆNOÆĩVÆT
Detaylı